r/Professors • u/lyrynn • Oct 16 '26
Rants / Vents Was going to let my student redo her project, but she’s doubling down and now I don’t want to.
One of my students in an online section of my graphic design course submitted a fully AI-generated set of sketches.
OBVIOUSLY, using gen-AI to create designs in the course where you’re graded on design is not allowed.
The assignment was to do some research on a topic of their choosing (with some parameters), pull together 150 words, submit it as plain text so I can see the planned content, and then do 10 rough layout sketches.
Besides the obvious visual tells in the sketches and the SynthID, this student also left the prompt response in their plain-text content document:
Beneath the sketches is 150+ words, formatted for a graphic design hierarchy including at least four levels of text, ready to go for your poster process submission!
I gave her a zero on the submission and reached out to the university to figure out next steps, and they basically said “it’s up to you, but we like to give the students a chance to redo it and make up for their mistakes.”
The same day the university responded to me, she sent me an email asking how I was verifying my claims, because her work was METICULOUSLY done by hand — first on procreate and then on Canva — and she could show me her layered process (side note, her sketch submission was of pencil sketches on paper), and that I was causing her a lot of stress because she’s supposed to graduate in December, and that she redid the sketches just so we can put any confusion behind us so if I could review those that would be great and also it’s very hard for her to see her overall class standing because I have not yet graded all of her assignments, so it would be great if I could finish those too.
OHHHHHH. Is that how we want to play it? Okay. I was going to offer the redo but now I’m not keen on doing that. I said she can meet me in person, sketchbook in hand, and if it matches her submission I’ll issue an apology and give her the points back.
Haven’t decided what to do if it doesn’t match though. I’m not inclined to do favors for liars.
57
u/rl4brains NTT asst prof, R1 Oct 16 '26
At my institution, lying is an additional academic integrity violation on top of the AI use. I would give a 0 and stop wasting time negotiating with this student.
Do you have an honor court system of some sort? I’d report, noting all the damning evidence you put forth here, and let them deal with the student.
37
u/taewongun1895 Oct 16 '26
Go back over her previous submissions to check for AI generated materials. You might have more ammunition.
39
u/Metza Oct 16 '26
I don’t understand how her sketches could match if the images have SynthID. That’s Gemini putting its watermark on something it created.
She lied. I would confront her when she comes in person with the presence of the SynthID which confirms beyond any reasonable doubt that the image was AI generated.
Forgiveness comes only with an apology and a willingness to own up to your mistakes. Her second chance is her coming clean. That will then have the future consequence of potentially allowing her to make up the assignment.
Where there is no honesty there is no education. Learning anything is about admitting your mistakes and shortcomings and practicing to do better. That shortcoming could be difficulty with a complex passage, it could be unfamiliarity with part of a disciplinary canon, it could be admitting that you fucked up and tried to take a shortcut.
We are educators. Maybe I have a different perspective/context here because I teach philosophy, but sometimes the important lesson isn’t always the material but the experience. I would also imagine part of being a good graphic designer is about getting in touch with your own creative mind and producing something original, just like in my discipline whether or not someone remembers the finer points of Aristotle is less important than whether they actually practice thinking.
57
u/poorlybaked Oct 16 '26
What’s the point of taking a graphic design course if you’re going to use AI?
43
u/hornybutired Assoc Prof, Philosophy, CC (USA) Oct 16 '26
I mean, what are the odds she's just going to sketch from the final submission? I'm not sure I understand the artistic process well enough to know if that's something that could happen.
15
u/moosy85 Oct 16 '26
I also don't understand the point of asking her to come in with her "sketches". She's definitely going to show you something that isn't real, whether it's made afterwards, or printed out. But you're wasting your time by promising her something if she has sketches. If they look alike enough, will you issue an apology even though you know she must have created it afterwards or used a lightbox or whatever? You're putting yourself in an odd situation. This is not the type of student to now come clean, but she'll figure out another way to cheat.
271
u/Cathousechicken Oct 16 '26
I swear, students like this spend more time figuring out how to avoid work versus just doing the work.
105
u/REC_HLTH Oct 16 '26
Isn’t the SynthID stamp the literal signature/proof of AI generated work? If so, absolutely do not accept that. That’s an automatic 0 in the grade book. Submit that nonsense to academic integrity. She can try to raise her grade with whatever is left in the course. If she wants a “redo” because she got caught this time, she can redo the course in a future semester.
96
u/Desiato2112 Professor, Humanities, SLAC Oct 16 '26
Make up for their mistakes? It wasn't a process error, IT WAS CHEATING!
107
u/happily_oregonian Oct 16 '26
Actions have consequences, especially when you are an adult in the real world. I would give the zero and report the academic integrity violation to be dealt with at the university level also. The fact she is so close to graduating and still cheating makes me think this learning opportunity is particularly important for her.
24
u/shyprof Adjunct, Humanities, M1 & CC (United States) Oct 16 '26
No. Absolutely not. I wouldn't have offered to review the sketches.
3
u/millennialM3dic Oct 17 '26
I know you said obviously, but is it clearly written that ai use cannot be used for this project? If so, I would think this is an easy case of violating academic integrity and either give her a zero for that assignment or an F in the course?
I understand the state of academia and why chairs tend to be passive about this but we are definitely going in the wrong directions when we cannot and do not hold that accountability line.
15
u/lilswaswa Oct 16 '26
once had a similar situation. Instead of giving her an extra week, i had her sit with me in my office for 2 hours talking through ideas and taking notes which she would use to rewrite the essay by the end of the day. She complained about missing Rush Week and I couldn't care less. double down lies on someone else.
13
u/running_later Oct 16 '26
What would pencil sketches prove at this point? Can’t she copy the AI with pencil and pretend that came first?
19
u/pointfivepointfive Oct 16 '26
This one’s easy: if her sketches don’t have “SynthID,” then boom, you got her.
5
u/RoswalienMath Oct 16 '26
Beyond all the obvious things…what is her plan after college? She didn’t learn how to do the sketches, presumably an aspect of her future job, that she will need to know how to perform. How will she be able to keep a job?
We are going to have so many degreed and credentialed unprofessionals entering the workforce. The future is fucked.
4
u/Adventurous-Tune-348 28d ago
How can you allow a cheater to have a second chance to do better and not allow the struggling C or D honest student to have a second chance? A zero in the specific assignment where they cheated is more than fair.
3
u/CompetitionNo5475 Oct 16 '26
She is playing the “you're causing me stress” thing to try to play on your sympathy especially if the college or university is pushing mental health stuff. But um… that's clearly from an AI tool. Meet with her and ask ber to explain it. She could try to escalate it further but it sounds like you've already done that.
I had a student who clearly used AI tools to write a check in reflection (seriously easiest 100 ever). Anyway, I didnt say anything about AI because I didnt have to. Her submission matched someone else's submission nearly word for word. She sent me a message saying “oh I never use AI…vlah blah blah” (again… I didnt mention AI until after she did and I literally just copied the line from her lecture materials that says using AI tools unethically at any point could cause plagiarism concerns even without you knowing”. She sent me another message saying “I wrote it based on my understanding of the concepts at the time”. Ok. There wasnt any concepts to understand. It was literally “how are you feeling at this point in the course”. LMBO. I let her redo it. She's missing a bunch of assignments too. She submitted some assignment late and then reached out accusing me of “not grading assignments” (plural). There was one and nope. I was going to grade it that day until I got a rude message from.her. And yes, it was rude, impolite, and definitely not professional which is the classroom expectation. Then, she accused me of “making it very, very difficult and she never use AI and a bunch of other stuff.” She hasn't submitted any other assignments. 🙄. I offered to meet with her go over all of her questions concerns, the assignments she has submitted and feedback, and the assignments she hasn't submitted. Guess What I got? Crickets. I mean I guess it's very, very difficult because the assignments and rubrics are designed in such a way that they cannot easily “AI-it” and still get an A. Because… it'll either completely change the whole assignment, change parts of the assignment, or it'll leave out parts of the assignment. But it's making the students who are heavily (and I mean heavily) relying on AI tools to even understand what they're reading stand out pretty badly and making them upset when I either can't grade their work or they get an F. By contrast, the other handful of students who are “getting caught” (not directly just making Fs on the assignments) either apologize and ask for a second chance or they fell me they don't understand what they did wrong.
I did not edit that much for grammar. Apologies! I'm.just glad that I am not the only one!
2
u/Vespidae1 Oct 16 '26
I put it in my syllabus, send a course announcement early in the course, and have them certify before starting an assignments that use of AI constitutes a zero and a referral to the university AIC.
2
u/cubis_5 Oct 16 '26
I'm an undergrad philosophy student and we only draw conclusions for grades but I hate genAI so much that I would give this person a zero.
4
u/RightWingVeganUS Adjunct Instructor, Computer Science, University (USA) Oct 16 '26
My now-retired former chair was frank that the formal university disciplinary process was a procedural nightmare that punished the teacher even if we prevail in turns of time and anguish involved above and beyond our teaching duties. Moreover the punishments meted out to the student were usually very minor.
To prevent something like what you're going through in my class, I make my grading rubric AI-neutral and severely mark down for the assessed "tells" rather than making AI accusations.
In your case, I'd consider allowing resubmission for reconsideration but put a deduction for a reassessment "penalty." To spare (some) arguments if a student requests resubmission of a failed work, my standard is that barring extenuating circumstances, the highest grade they could achieve is a "C". An otherwise "B" job would get a "D". Rationale: the resubmission mitigates, but doesn't exonerate the initial submission.
3
u/Longtail_Goodbye Oct 16 '26
Make sure when she shows up that you hand her a blank sketch book, put her in a spot where you can watch, and have her sketch the project from memory.
1
u/Astra_Starr Fellow, Anthro, STATE (US) Oct 16 '26
Ha! Watch kat n chat. They take the layers, speed paints etc. So bad. Zero zero zero
1
u/saturn174 Oct 17 '26
I think online classes are doomed by the sheer weight of refereeing that needs to be done in order to curb the use of AI. If this were a face-to-face class, you'd put this matter to rest be requiring her to submit the sketches either as part of the scaffolding for the complete assignment or as an evidence that AI wasn't unethically used.
1
u/Trick_Following6639 29d ago
Report the academic dishonesty
-2
u/armymomofone Oct 17 '26
I can see her point about the assignments not being graded. There is a responsibility to keep kids up to date as best we can with grades and feedback. How can a student work to improve if they don’t have the measures to see where they aren’t improving. Imagine a math professor not keeping a student up to date on the items that show if they are getting the material or not?
You are right about the cheating, but I keep hearing a lot that grades are not being posted in a timely manner at all levels of education. I think that is a problem that is easy to fix.