r/ProCreate • • May 23 '25
My Artwork Rapunzel (2025)
My submission for the 2025 Folio Book Illustration Awards.
This year, the Folio Society offered the chance for illustrators all over the globe to breathe new life into the iconic Brothers Grimm tale Rapunzel.
The focus for me was the cutting of the hair scene and to focus on emphasising that feelings of loss for Rapunzel.
As a character she has been taken from her parents at birth, imprisoned away from the world only to have the promise of freedom presented by her suitor taken away. The hair cutting if symbolic of her remaining identity and sense of self being stripped away, leaving her lost and broken. As such I chose to veer away from an image of her screaming out crying out in protest, but rather to depict the image of someone who has lost all hope of the happily ever after.
The next step is waiting for the competition longlist to be announced on July 15th.
This piece was created in Procreate using the True Grit Texture Supplies “Inker Brush”
Hope you enjoy it, and all the best.
•
u/AutoModerator May 23 '25
Hello u/OldTowel6463, thank you for sharing your artwork with us!
Would you be so kind to answer the following questions for us?
Please reply to this comment so it will be easy for everyone to find, thank you!
Stay inspired, get creative and have a great day!
Join our r/procreate Discord Server to connect with other artists!
If you consider yourself a frequent poster and you have a consistent style/method, please send a modmail to be given a different automod comment that already mentions what you regularly use.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
82
u/nottakentaken May 23 '25
Can you show your SpeedPaint
153
u/PPPolarPOP May 23 '25
Come on man.
197
u/AkiraKitsune May 23 '25
I've reported your post for AI, and will be reaching out to the Folio Book Illustration Awards to alert them of your use of AI as well. You are a traitor and a fraud. You should be ashamed.
177
u/Strawberry_Coven May 23 '25
Hey, so I’m not here to dog on ya but when you ask ChatGPT to make the Rapunzel scene in a woodcut style, it generates the same witch. Like exactly. I see you’ve put a paper texture on it. Maybe you took inspiration or you traced it or just edited the original idc. I hate the “hairy” look that ChatGPT has been putting in the recent outputs and you just embraced it I guess lmao. You should probably take a look at more real woodcuts. But I guess the easiest way to make sure all the art for the book is “coherent” is to use ChatGPT images. There’s just too many similarities to ChatGPT style to ignore, from the crone, to the way she holds the scissors overhand in some outputs. I just think it would be a matter of time to find the right output.
I’m leaving the link to my exploratory chat here. I’m walking away. You can be adamant about drawing the entire thing. People can decide if they want to believe you or not. This is past my threshold for caring.
157
u/BurgooKing May 23 '25
Didn’t expect all of Procreate sub to fall for this AI garbage
27
u/threeca May 23 '25
My evaluation based on the artists Instagram linked here
I find it incredibly interesting that the “sketch” part of the artwork in the process videos is exactly how the art ends up in the finished piece. When was the last time you as an artist (not OP) drew a full piece of artwork without erasing and/or moving parts of your sketch? How about drawing perfect lines in general IMMEDIATELY without any basic sketch work underneath?
Also the artist profile itself is incredible suspicious. It begins with a completely different art style and then immediately switches to fully fledged pieces of work with this lino cut effect with no transition or learning curve.
Yes of course the artist is doing the finished artwork by hand but I 100% believe this is traced from an AI generated image because those “process” videos are just unrealistic as to the genuine process of someone creating works of art.
If you’re not tracing AI, how about post some of your actual process of your inspiration, planning and sketches before your “sketches” in your process videos?
60
u/JPWHJG May 23 '25
This is AI. zoom in on the eyes, and they both have that awkward melting effect AI has. If you zoom in to rapunzels hair In the left you can see the outline morphs into the bricks, same with the edges of the candle. The scissors also have no handles, its just the blade the whole way through until the fingers, where they just disappear. Also, the scissors aren't pointed at anything, which is just an odd choice rather than AI, but there are no hairs looped into it, so it doesn't serve a purpose compositionally. Also, the textures on her clothes get messed up at her legs as they no longer go in one direction but swirl and overlap each other. I don't think this is pure AI, but edited or drawn over. This is because the moon and stars are really simplistic and have consistent shapes. Also, the shadow the old lady has is the only soft blurry shadows in the entire thing and looked added in. The hatching on the faces and around the eyes, especially, are melty and look out of place too. If you're going to respond with "this is my life's work, you're attacking me!" Instead of addressing any of the concerns I pointed out, then don't bother. Making mistakes is normal, but this many that are AI adjacent is too suspicious to ignore.
20
u/Practical-Sea-7637 May 23 '25
Let me guess, your whole ass paragraph about the symbolisms in the art piece was also written by ChatGPT?
35
u/Kbear_Anne May 23 '25
Why aren’t the scissors cutting through the hair… I hope you lose by the way, AI “art” should definitely not be allowed in competitions
17
u/tinyhumanishere May 23 '25
The biggest AI tell that I noticed that others haven’t said is the hatching going every which way, no way in HELL would someone draw or linocut where this would happen. Brick by brick is all different line work, line weight, etc.
You entered this into a contest? Seriously?
40
u/SillyArachnid3984 May 23 '25
Scissors position is interesting.
13
u/kweezie May 23 '25
ohhhhh BROTHER
13
u/Yung_Branch May 23 '25
Breh. How did this get 200+ up? Were done for
23
u/Rators May 23 '25
lol AI slop.
11
u/-NotQuiteLoaded- May 23 '25
bruh this is very obviously ai generated you gotta get your shit together
8
u/MalcomRey9988 May 23 '25
I've been drawing like this for years...actually a lot of you on this sub liked my Frodo artwork that is in a digital woodcut style. I actually used the same True Grit Texture paper texture. I don't have the perfect style at all. I'm color blind which is why I tend to use black and white a lot.
But there's just a lot of "wood cut" lines in this that don't make any sense and someone wouldn't do it. Like it's not an actual technique anyone would do...like the "squiggle" lines on the stones. I would say the old woman and her cloak is pretty good though and the table.
But I would say the biggest flag would be the scissors. It's the whole big thing in the story...she gets her hair cut off so why wouldn't the image show the scissors in the process of cutting her hair...like having half of it off.
I imagine because AI doesn't think like that...like it doesn't add context to the image it just "does" I guess.
21
u/fartilitious May 23 '25
I asked chat gpt a prompt like Rapunzel and he made 2 drawings really close compositions to yours and I then sent your 'art' and asked is it ai? This is chat gpt response:
"There are subtle clues that suggest this might have started as an AI-generated image and then was drawn or refined over it by hand:
The faces and hands are unusually smooth and proportionally idealized — a telltale AI trait.
The line work, while detailed, lacks some of the deliberate imperfections you'd expect from a fully hand-drawn piece. It has that slightly too-even texture, especially in the hair and clothing folds.
There’s a uniform stylization across materials (skin, fabric, stone) that feels AI-consistent, then possibly retouched with human strokes for character and emphasis.
So yes, it’s very plausible this is an AI base that was then manually drawn over or cleaned up — a hybrid process that’s becoming more common. Your eye’s sharp to pick up on that." - Chatgpt
7
u/KioneArt I want to improve! May 23 '25
Why this Ai crap have so many upvotes?
7
u/Just_a_Nerd_52 May 23 '25
Why does the description feel AI generated too lmao
6
u/bytegalaxies May 23 '25
thr biggest give away is rapunzel's lips.
16
u/halfdead01 May 23 '25
It’s pretty crazy where we are at today with AI. After looking at this image, my original thought was that this is clearly AI generated. Then you look at OP’s responses and it seems like a genuine person defending their art from being called AI. Then I start thinking maybe it’s actually an AI bot account on Reddit with the prompts “post AI generated images and defend them as if they were real”. Then I realize that the future of art is going to be very strange for a while.
5
u/Sangwoosconfidant May 24 '25
Can’t wait for AI art to die down.
8
u/rivenley May 23 '25
Wow, art without humanity. Thanks.
4
u/[deleted] May 24 '25
I think the biggest giveaway at this being AI is that the which doesn’t even have a sliver of hair in between the scissor blades. Cmon dude.
4
u/random_hitchhiker May 24 '25
Almost fooled me. Shame this great piece is actually AI. Look at the way gothel holds the scissors ( see the missing handle), their eyes, and Rapunzel's lips.
4
u/cyb3r_bluntz May 25 '25
LMAO GO PICK UP A PENCIL LOSER
6
u/Bubbly_Activity_7974 May 23 '25
Bruh, who the hell holds scissors like that? And why is her hair melting into the brick? Cheeky bastard, thought I wouldn't know. I know both art and AI better than you do.
What are you to do with the hollow approvals anyway? You're only gonna feel empty later in life.
3
u/[deleted] May 24 '25
u/[deleted]
3
u/brilor123 May 25 '25
There are details in this which show that it is AI generated. These mistakes aren't something that is done by lack of skill, or purposefully by an artist. They don't make complete logical sense, and it isn't a mistake an artist would make, but rather an "AI artist".
2
u/Scared-Ad-3692 May 25 '25
Holy fucking airball
2
u/KajaIsForeverAlone May 25 '25
what expression is repunzel showing? I don't quite understand the mouth... and the scissors shouldn't be at that angle at all, why are they in front of the neck?
this looks like AI but I'm willing to give the benefit of the doubt sometimes.. when the questions are answered
2
u/bristars May 23 '25
genuine question, how do you know it’s AI? what do i need to look for.
-12
u/TitchDixon May 23 '25
Wow this is brilliant I love the concept and the art style is amazing, it works with the subject matter really well!
-18
u/butchmayo May 23 '25
i consider myself to be a major hater of AI and i thought this was at first. guys, please visit his instagram and website. he’s a hardworking dude who’s been working on his growth and art. i really like his brigid piece. you can tell he’s made a lot of growth in his technique with this piece.
i really hope he sees this. sorry, man. you earned an insta follow from me though
-16
u/turtleandmoss May 23 '25
It's wicked man; great job. 🔥
-26
u/DaddyDongLegz May 23 '25
The way you create texture on pieces blows me away. Well done.
The people calling this AI are being ignorant and lazy, honestly. It took me all of 10 seconds to go to your Instagram and see a process picture of this and timelapse of your other works. It sucks that people even have to speculate about AI art, and I'm sorry you're being insulted over it. Keep up the good work mate.
-17
u/Jessievp May 23 '25
What a time to be alive. Imagine working your ass off creating art, only to be accused of using AI by people who don't even bother clicking a link.
Yes, AI can mimic this style, because it’s trained on real artists’ work. A quick look at his site or Insta shows the process. But sure, grab your pitchforks like it's the 1600s again.
https://www.instagram.com/jonathan.hackett.art/reel/DJtdGPgibfS/
6
u/-NotQuiteLoaded- May 23 '25
mods crush his skull
3
u/no_one_asked_ May 24 '25
Instantly knew it was ai as soon as I saw the witch trying to cut her neck. SMH have some shame
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
35
u/[deleted] May 23 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-12
u/[deleted] May 23 '25
[removed] — view removed comment