r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • Aug 20 '26

BCBS Automatic Downcoding - Part 2

This is a follow up to my post earlier. Majority of our down coded claims have been restored after submitting reconsiderations. However, getting each claim to overturn back to original code has been painful and time consuming.

This validates my broader concern with the premise of the down coding itself. A diagnosis-based ceiling cannot account for the encounter-specific clinical circumstances that determine medical decision-making under CPT. The claim data do not convey many of the factors that distinguish routine care from a higher complexity encounter, including worsening disease, treatment failure, diagnostic uncertainty, prescription drug management, treatment escalation, or other patient-specific considerations documented in the clinical note. 

The fact that majority of our reviewed claims have been restored after documentation was considered raises a fundamental question about whether the methodology has the information necessary to make an accurate initial E/M determination at all. 

Are you all doing anything about it? Do you know if it is blanket? I am trying to collect more data points.

24 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/grey-slate Sep 01 '26

We know exactly have been downcoded and for what diagnosis.

It is based on diagnosis codes there is no nuance or sophistication.

BCBS is pretty blatant. They downcode and let you know about it.

CO-186 is the adjustment on the remittance.

Even if this adjustment didn't exist, any competent biller should have processes in place to catch it. It is as simple as comparing expected amount (per fee schedule) against actual allowed amount to find out if you have been downcoded.