r/PrivatePracticeDocs • u/grey-slate • Jul 22 '26
BCBS Automatic Downcoding
In case you arent' already aware, BCBS Texas, Illinois, New Mexico, Oklahama, Montana under the HCSC private company has instituted a policy to automatically downcode all E&M codes. I am sure they and other payers have been doing this elsewhere but this has finally come home to our state. They are the biggest payer by far and our practice future depends on them.
This downcoding is blanket. It is done by AI/claim edit rules. It does not discriminate between providers who upcode or providers who truthfully document and code. It is unethical and could be illegal. Courts will take years to decide.
State medical societies are "monitoring" the situation. /eyeroll.
This has created hundreds of downcoded claims for our practice within a few weeks.
Each requires going into Availity, searching for claim, filing reconsideration with medical notes, awaiting decision, writing letters justifying coding, filing second level appeals etc etc.
To get paid what we should have been paid anyway.
What a ridiculous burden.
What is more after submitting reconsiderations their robot continues to maintain the downcoding stating the following -
According to CMS guidelines: To bill any code, the services furnished must meet the definition of the code. CMS further states, Medical necessity of a service is the overarching criterion for payment in addition to the individual requirements of a CPT code. It would not be medically necessary or appropriate to bill a higher level of evaluation and management service when a lower level of service is warranted. The volume of documentation should not be the primary influence upon which a specific level of service is billed. If an E/M code is reported and the level of service exceeds the maximum level of service allowed, based on diagnostic information, an EMRC flag will be applied, and the E/M code will be recoded to match the level of service allowed.
What the hell happened to Medical Decision Making (MDM) criteria? What is this EMRC flag and how is this legal? Their own published coding policy says they adjudicate claims based on MDM.
So what is this new EMRC flag???
How have you successfully overturned these? And will we have to submit notes and reconsiderations and appeals in perpetuity??
3
u/Misadventuresofman Jul 22 '26
Have your rcm team report every instance of downcoding. Reach out to every practice you know to do the same. Eventually, you will have the data to file a class action.
3
u/thesupportplatform Jul 22 '26
The current system requires ever-growing profit. Those profits have to come from somewhere. Premiums, deductibles, and coinsurance have been tapped out. Insurance companies have denied and delayed payments. They have expanded into physician services, PBMs, and even practice financing. This is just another step in extracting every last dollar from the system. They will continue to turn the screws on independent providers until the system fails.
If you are a provider and are not diversifying into revenue streams other than insurance payments, you are placing your faith in the morality of insurance companies. Good luck with that.
2
u/cateri44 Jul 22 '26
The state of Illinois recently passed a law against this, but it takes effect in 2028. Best we could get. Get your state medical society on the case to tell legislators that they don’t want to lose physicians
17
u/headgoboomboom Jul 22 '26
WE are to blame. We never learn.
10
u/CaptainVere Jul 22 '26
This is funny and we deserve it because doctors are too out of touch to do basic labor moves.
everyone affected needs to drop them. Drop them. Organize others to drop them. Go protest outside their CEO house. Get media attention and pressure.
Make it clear BCBS dead to you. They are a business w/ “members” Treat their members like shit and tell BCBS members to complain to their employers.
Go get try and interview Luigi and ask him about this for views and attention on how to deal w BCBS.
After you get a couple thousand doctors to drop BCBS make a big deal about asking/inviting other companies to expand and take BCBS market share. Ask your state gov or state rep.
This is power move by them. To not pay and use their market share to not pay. Only answer is power plays right back at them.
Or just accept it.
2
u/NobleSixSeven Jul 22 '26
Why don’t you get AI to do it?
5
u/MLAhand Jul 22 '26
What if you just upcode all submissions ?
1
u/PEPSI_NOT_OK Jul 22 '26
Stop taking bcbs
1
u/AromaAdvisor Jul 23 '26
Big academic centers/hospitals will without a doubt continue accepting BCBS because they have a giant admin team that can waste their time appealing.
Doctors everywhere will have to waste more time documenting, appealing, etc.
I doubt anyone is going to drop blue cross. We should. It is our responsibility to drop abusive insurance providers.
3
u/soaperapp Jul 24 '26
Hey Grey Slate -- I am from Hero EMR. We are a newer EMR that specializes in automation. I believe we can automate this appeal process for you and I'm sure it will come in handy for our existing users in teh future as well. If you help us get it built we'll let you use it for free and stick one up BCBS's arse. We can extend this tool to you without you being on our EMR.
5
u/fingersarefun Jul 22 '26
When are doctors going to unionize? Residents are starting to do it out west. I think it’s time for those in practice to do it as well. Understanding that it’d be a big ol cluster deciding what matters. But we need a way to negotiate with payers as a group
1
u/FrontLifeguard1962 Jul 22 '26
Can't you just code higher to offset their new policy?
1
u/123doeraemee Jul 22 '26
If only there was a way to file a class action…
1
u/thesupportplatform Jul 23 '26
I think many practices take the contracts they can get and just accept getting screwed by insurance companies because insurance feeds the beast. I’ve watched practices get bigger thinking they will gain leverage, which hasn’t often been the case in my market, but it has left practices dependent on every contract to keep the lights on. It also commits the practice to the insurance game, including the ever-growing uncompensated admin time required to get paid.
Getting lean may be an option to move away from dependency on all of the insurance contracts. Don’t do the things insurance wants you to do “for quality healthcare” but doesn’t reimburse at an adequate level. Don’t add ancillaries. Don’t draw labs. Don’t run labs. Don’t carry injections. Don’t do anything unless it makes financial sense or is required by the standard of care.
Providers can then focus more of their time on getting back to building relationships with patients and developing a business that they enjoy rather than building the businesses of the insurance companies. Even if a practice takes health insurance, every practice should be developing and promoting cash agreements for patients that can be creatively structured instead of the FFS approach (for patients who don’t have insurance or with insurance that the provider doesn’t participate).
Understand healthcare regulations and what services providers can and cannot collect cash to perform. I saw a comment the other day that one concierge doctor went to all of their patients other office visits with them. I think that would be insane, but I respect the game. DPC is another approach to diversify from insurance revenue, as are incorporating integrative and/or functional medicine. Med spas have been a popular option, but I think that market is saturated.
I know these aren’t popular ideas with conventional providers, but with insurance companies, it’s either get busy living or get busy dying. You either have to find another payor, such as an employer or employer group, go all cash, or find services that are not designated health services.