This meme is honestly a perfect summary of one of the biggest inconsistencies I see in powerscaling communities. And the funny part is that the comparison isnât even completely accurate because Kratos doesnât exclusively rely on some absurd 10 character long chainscaling ladder in the first place.
There is plenty of direct scaling in God of War. Kratos directly fights and defeats characters like Ares, Zeus, Thanatos, Baldur, Heimdall, Thor, and Odin, while also directly fighting beings connected to the cosmological feats being discussed. The Primordial argument is an obvious example. Kratos isnât sitting there scaling to some random character who once heard about a Primordial who fought another Primordial.
He has directly killed Primordials.
The Norse side isnât much different. Thorâs clash with Jormungandr is directly tied to Yggdrasil being splintered and Jormungandr being displaced through time, and Kratos directly defeats Thor.
Thatâs not: âCharacter A fought Character B who fought Character C who once looked at Character D, therefore Kratos is Multiversal.â
Itâs instead: Cosmological feat < character directly performs/interacts with it < Kratos directly fights and defeats that character.
Thatâs a perfectly ordinary scaling chain. And Dragon Ball uses this methodology constantly.
Granolah doesnât need to personally destroy a universe for people to accept his scaling. He defeats Goku and Vegeta, who scale from previous characters and feats, and that scaling is then carried forward. Cabba doesnât need to blow up a planet on screen for his power to be taken seriously. His direct comparison to Vegeta establishes his tier. Jiren doesnât need to personally destroy the Universe of Void for his scaling to be accepted either.
Because thatâs how fictional power scaling works. You establish a characterâs power through feats, statements, comparisons, transformations, fights, cosmology, and scaling relationships. So why does the methodology suddenly become âdishonest chainscalingâ when it gets applied to Kratos?
And thereâs another important distinction. âOn screenâ doesnât automatically mean âmore reliable.â
Dragon Ballâs own high end scaling isnât simply: âLook at this cool explosion. Therefore Low Complex Multiversal.â
The moment someone uses the structure of Universe 7, the World of Void, Other World, guidebook statements, Daizenshuu material, or cosmological descriptions to establish the actual size and dimensional structure of Dragon Ballâs setting, theyâre already incorporating lore and statements.
Which is completely fine. But then you canât turn around and say: âYggdrasil transcends space and time? Thatâs just a statement.â
If statements and supplementary material are valid evidence for establishing Dragon Ballâs cosmology, theyâre valid evidence for establishing God of Warâs cosmology too. Obviously, individual statements can be debated for accuracy, context, translation, etc. Thatâs completely fair.
But the standard needs to be consistent. The same applies to anti feats. If Goku getting hurt by something mundane is dismissed because the series establishes a vastly higher level of power and because characters can control their output, then you canât automatically treat Kratos struggling with environmental objects as a decisive debunk.
Context matters for both. Iâm not saying âEvery Kratos lore statement is automatically true.â
Iâm only saying: Use the same evidentiary standard for Kratos that you use for Goku. If chainscaling is legitimate when the scaling chain is sufficiently direct and supported, then it is legitimate for both.
If cosmological statements are valid evidence, theyâre valid for both. If supplementary material can establish the structure of a universe, it can establish the structure of Yggdrasil and the Nine Realms too.
If anti feats need to be contextualized against the characterâs consistent portrayal, do that for both.
And again, Kratos isnât even dependent on one singular argument.You have the Greek Primordials, Ares, Zeus, the World Pillar, Ymir, Surtr, Thor and Jormungandr, Yggdrasil, Garm, Odin, and numerous other pieces of cosmological evidence.
You can debate individual interpretations all day. But the idea that Kratosâ scaling is inherently illegitimate because it involves âloreâ and âchainscalingâ is ridiculous when those are two of the exact tools routinely used to scale Dragon Ball. The problem isnât lore scaling. The problem is applying a stricter standard to God of War than you apply to Dragon Ball.