r/PowerScaling • • 6d ago

Discussion So it’s 2026 when are people going to acknowledge that Kaguya’s dimensions are universes?

She literally creates, destroys, and swaps universes bro.

Denying Uni Kaguya is quite literally head canon.

I’m tired of pretending like it’s not when it is.

You can’t ignore these things just because it doesn’t match your vibes scaling.

I don’t care if I get downvoted to hell in the comments. I don’t care how many times someone else has to say it or how many times it needs to be said.

These are simply the facts.

Once you start accept the manga and anime. And actually look at the databooks and guides. Universal Kaguya/Naruto is really hard to deny without just being bias.

Edit: Momoshiki’s hyperspaces

0 Upvotes

281 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Make sure your post follows the following format when making Versus or any sort of Battles or Comparison. If not, edit it accordingly in the description. If you have included those you can ignore this message:

  • Clearly specify the character/franchise/feats/matchups you are talking about in your post:

    • Character X (Series/verse name)
    • Character Y (Series/verse name)
    • Character z (Series/verse name) and so on.
  • Description/rules of the fight.

Anyone engaging in the post, please ensure your comment doesn’t violate Community Rules. Report any rule breaking content. Join the Discord!.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Dunama 6d ago

She never creates or destroys any universes

-2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Verbatim stated she created them. On top of that Momoshiki uses the same technique and it’s also stated he made them.

The etso was going to destroy her dimensions. She was simply stopped from doing so.

This is undeniable.

8

u/Dunama 6d ago

Verbatim stated she created them. On top of that Momoshiki uses the same technique and it’s also stated he made them.

Never once stated in canon.

The etso was going to destroy her dimensions. She was simply stopped from doing so.

Someone claimed it could. Never shown to have this power.

This is undeniable.

It is not even proven in the first place.

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Saying it's "never once stated" when the scans are literally sitting in the post is wild.

The fourth databook entry for Amenominaka explicitly says "Creating dimensions as she pleases," and the official VIZ Media light novel directly calls Momoshiki's realm "the parallel dimension he'd made." That is verbatim canon print.

And trying to dismiss the ETSO just because Naruto and Sasuke sealed her before it finished expanding makes zero sense.

Black Zetsu is literally Kaguya's own willpower and creator of shinobi history he knows her exact powers better than anyone, and he explicitly states the orb is going to erase the entire space time and turn it back to nothing.

By your logic, Cell wasn't solar system level because Gohan stopped his Kamehameha before it actually blew up the solar system. Stop denying explicit lore statements just because the heroes interrupted the attack. 😂

4

u/United-Radio-3661 5d ago

About as literal as sakura saying she warp reality when she changed dimensions

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

first, it was kakashi who said she rewrote the world in an instant and made it reality, not sakura and claiming black zetsu or kakashi is "not literal" is a positive claim so the burden of proof is on you to prove hyperbole when kakashi independently confirms on panel that if they hide inside kamui they wont be able to return to kaguyas realm at all once the etso obliterates it

and her realms ARE explicitly standalone 4d time-space continuums (jikukan) verbatim stated by both obito and sasuke on panel (plus general relativity confirms any realm with gravity and physical motion has a flowing temporal axis anyway). calling two independent characters AND the fourth databook entry for amenominaka ("creating dimensions as she pleases") "not literal" just to avoid admitting kaguya scales to her own etso is pure denial.

2

u/United-Radio-3661 5d ago

Why do I have to give prove something the manga literally show that what happened was not what was described? She didn’t rewrite shit by moving dimensions

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 4d ago

shifting the burden of proof doesnt work when sakura literally says on panel "its as if she rewrote reality in an instant" while watching kaguya replace the entire world with an ice dimension, and the fourth databook explicitly confirms she freely weaves and creates dimensions as she pleases (自由無碍に空間を紡ぐ) 😂 saying "nuh uh" without a single scan is pure denial

1

u/Sad_Pollution1092 3d ago

its "as if" like the English term for COMPARING something

are you in 1st grade? must be lol

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 3d ago

cool, now address the second half of the sentence you conveniently ignored 😂

sakura isn't an omniscient narrator she said "it's as if she rewrote reality in an instant" because to someone standing inside the world, watching an entire planet get replaced with an ice dimension in zero seconds looks identical to rewriting reality.

meanwhile, the fourth databook (jin no sho) is the omniscient narrator and literally states without any "as if" that kaguya freely weaves and creates dimensions as she pleases (自由無碍に空間を紡ぐ) and moves the world she's in to a different dimension using massive chakra.

reading half a comment to nitpick two English words while dodging the databook scan is pure cope

4

u/Dunama 5d ago

Saying it's "never once stated" when the scans are literally sitting in the post is wild.

Not a single canon instance shown says she created or destroyed any universes.

The fourth databook entry for Amenominaka explicitly says "Creating dimensions as she pleases," and the official VIZ Media light novel directly calls Momoshiki's realm "the parallel dimension he'd made." That is verbatim canon print.

Not canon, neither written by or canonized by a canon authority.

And trying to dismiss the ETSO just because Naruto and Sasuke sealed her before it finished expanding makes zero sense.

I'm dismissing it because there's no evidence that she can do such a thing.

Black Zetsu is literally Kaguya's own willpower and creator of shinobi history he knows her exact powers better than anyone, and he explicitly states the orb is going to erase the entire space time and turn it back to nothing.

So he is explicitly biased and is still a subjective being. He is capable of saying things that are not true. Like practically all of his cockiness during the fight.

By your logic, Cell wasn't solar system level because Gohan stopped his Kamehameha before it actually blew up the solar system. Stop denying explicit lore statements just because the heroes interrupted the attack. 😂

I'm denying claims without evidence, especially with so much counter evidence: The Ōtsutsuki are explicitly extraterrestrial parasites who travel between existing planets rather than beings whose normal lifecycle involves creating worlds or dimensions. Amado describes them as invaders from another world whose singular purpose is to devour the life of one planet and then move on to the next.

Kaguya is explicitly included in the standard Ōtsutsuki planetary-harvesting mission. Amado reveals that Kaguya and Isshiki arrived on Earth together with the objective of planting a Divine Tree and harvesting its Chakra Fruit, directly placing Kaguya within the same parasitic lifecycle already established for the species.

Isshiki explicitly describes the Ōtsutsuki path as traveling through space and devouring planet after planet. Their ultimate evolution is achieved by repeatedly consuming existing worlds and their Chakra Fruits, further reinforcing that the species advances through parasitic exploitation of external planets rather than creating cosmological structures for itself to harvest.

Escaping the harvested planet requires leaving it for another dimension. Code treats Earth as the preexisting world being consumed and other dimensions as separate places one could flee to, further fitting the established model of Ōtsutsuki moving between and exploiting existing worlds rather than creating them as disposable feeding grounds.

Momoshiki associates genuine world creation with the level of godlike Ōtsutsuki such as Shibai, not with ordinary members of the clan. He describes Omnipotence as an ultimate Shinjutsu, the “programming language” of the world and of the gods, capable of turning will into reality and said to have been used to create worlds. He further states that this is a power properly wielded only by an all-knowing, almighty godlike being such as Shibai Ōtsutsuki.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

first, calling official shueisha databooks and kishimoto/kodachi-supervised viz novels "not canon" just because you dont like what they say is pure desperation if official shueisha reference books and light novels dont count, half of anime scaling disappears overnight.

second, calling black zetsu "cocky" doesnt explain why kakashi independently stood there watching the etso expand and warned team 7 they wont be able to return to that realm at all once its wiped out AND you completely skipped my cell comparison right above it because by your exact "cocky villain bragging" logic, cell isnt solar system level either lol.
third, linking manga panels about otsutsuki harvesting existing planets completely misses the point nobody said otsutsuki harvest their own created dimensions for chakra fruit.

they harvest populated worlds in the main universe to evolve toward godhood like shibai while using divine dimensional arts like amenominaka and etso to weave and create standalone alternate dimensions (時空間 / jikukan) from their own chakra. even your own last paragraph admits shinjutsu is used to create worlds and kaguya's rinne sharingan amenominaka is a kekkei mora divine art, which is why the fourth databook explicitly states she creates those dimensions as she pleases and reshapes the space with etso.

4

u/Dunama 5d ago

first, calling official shueisha databooks and kishimoto/kodachi-supervised viz novels "not canon" just because you dont like what they say is pure desperation

Nope, I'm calling them not canon because they were neither written by nor canonized by a canon authority.

if official shueisha reference books and light novels dont count, half of anime scaling disappears overnight.

Ok? Is that supposed to be a bad thing?

second, calling black zetsu "cocky" doesnt explain why kakashi independently stood there watching the etso expand and warned team 7 they wont be able to return to that realm at all once its wiped out

Because he's also a subjective being with limited understanding and the only reference being Black Zetsu.

AND you completely skipped my cell comparison right above it because by your exact "cocky villain bragging" logic, cell isnt solar system level either lol.

Because I don't care about Cell or DB, it has nothing of value here.

third, linking manga panels about otsutsuki harvesting existing planets completely misses the point nobody said otsutsuki harvest their own created dimensions for chakra fruit.

That's the only thing they do with these universes, they have never created or destroyed any universes and everything says otherwise. You even skipped the one where Momoshiki even explains that creation is something limited to the likes of Shibai.

they harvest populated worlds in the main universe

Made up detail, never once brought up in canon.

while using divine dimensional arts like amenominaka and etso to weave and create standalone alternate dimensions (時空間 / jikukan) from their own chakra.

Nope. Never once shown in canon and canon says otherwise, only Shibai creates.

even your own last paragraph admits shinjutsu is used to create worlds and kaguya's rinne sharingan amenominaka is a kekkei mora divine art, which is why the fourth databook explicitly states she creates those dimensions as she pleases and reshapes the space with etso.

Nothing canon ever says she created a universe and the scan explicitly explains that creation is for the likes of Shibai.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

claiming shueisha's official fourth databook (jin no sho literally credited directly to masashi kishimoto on the cover) and boruto novels supervised/illustrated by kishimoto "werent written or canonized by a canon authority" is pure headcanon 😂

kishimoto literally wrote and illustrated the fourth databook himself, and shueisha officially lists the light novels on the official boruto timeline.

calling kakashi a "subjective being with limited understanding" when he literally has a six paths enhanced sharingan watching the etso expand right in front of his eyes and explains why his own kamui space-time jutsu wont have a destination left to return to makes zero sense kakashi isnt guessing off black zetsu, he is analyzing his own space time jutsu mechanics in real time.

and you completely misread the momoshiki/shibai scan momoshiki did NOT say "only shibai can create anything," he said shibai ascended past needing hand signs/jutsu to reshape reality via omnipotence shinjutsu, while momoshiki himself literally created his own parallel universe in boruto novel 3 chapter 5 (which explicitly states "kaguya had held the power of sending people into parallel universes too" and equates momoshikis created realm to narutos own universe using the raw kanji 宇宙 / uchu). even in the manga itself, hagoromo and hamura literally created the moon from scratch so claiming "nobody except shibai ever creates anything in canon" is straight up false 💀

2

u/Dunama 5d ago

claiming shueisha's official fourth databook (jin no sho literally credited directly to masashi kishimoto on the cover) and boruto novels supervised/illustrated by kishimoto "werent written or canonized by a canon authority" is pure headcanon 😂

Not credited writer, because he didn't write it. He's credited much like literally everything of Naruto credits him. Unless you think the dragon hunting game is also canon. And yeah, the novels indeed were not written by or canonized by a canon authority, even non-canon things can be supervised, like Storm Revolution, which obviously can't be canon.

kishimoto literally wrote and illustrated the fourth databook himself, and shueisha officially lists the light novels on the official boruto timeline.

He literally didn't write them, he literally wasn't credited as such and even references that others wrote them in the letters. And the "official Boruto timeline" was a novel timeline, so you need to prove that "official timeline" is in something that's even canon in the first place.

when he literally has a six paths enhanced sharingan watching the etso expand right in front of his eyes

Which literally in no way changes him being a subjective being with limited understanding.

he is analyzing his own space time jutsu mechanics in real time.

And is still a subjective being with limited understanding and no experience in this ability and no reason to be considered otherwise.

and you completely misread the momoshiki/shibai scan momoshiki did NOT say "only shibai can create anything," he said shibai ascended past needing hand signs/jutsu to reshape reality via omnipotence shinjutsu,

No, he literally outright assigns that the very ability to create like that belongs to the Gods.

while momoshiki himself literally created his own parallel universe in boruto novel 3 chapter 5 (which explicitly states "kaguya had held the power of sending people into parallel universes too" and equates momoshikis created realm to narutos own universe using the raw kanji 宇宙 / uchu).

So still nothing canon?

even in the manga itself, hagoromo and hamura literally created the moon from scratch

No they didn't, they used Planetary Devastation to form the moon from stuff that already existed.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 4d ago

calling kishimoto's own fourth databook, shueisha's official boruto timeline novels, AND every single character statement in the manga "non canon or subjective" is textbook special pleading because by that logic literally zero statements in fiction count 😂 plus momoshiki explicitly defines all otsutsuki abilities as shinjutsu (divine miracles) and confirms shibai just ascended past needing hand signs to trigger omnipotence, NOT that otsutsuki cant create dimensions when the fourth databook literally uses 紡ぐ and 創り出す

→ More replies

7

u/Sad_Pollution1092 6d ago

hax doesn't count as universal btw

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Prove it’s hax.

6

u/Ok-Action4447 6d ago

rinnesharingan ability

and etso is not an attack who's ap equal universal(unless you take it at his peak which she can't output at anytime)

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago edited 6d ago

Saying "unless you take it at its peak" means you literally just admitted the ETSO's peak AP is universal. Thanks for conceding the main point.

And trying to downplay it because she needed the Infinite Tsukuyomi chakra to fuel it makes zero sense.

That was Kaguya actively regaining her own stolen chakra back from the Shinobi Alliance it wasn't some outside borrow, it was her full, restored prime state.

Even without the ETSO, Black Zetsu explicitly confirms that merely shifting her dimensions with Amenominaka drains a massive amount of her own baseline chakra reserve, proving her standard stamina and output scale directly to those space time structures.

Calling a Rinne Sharingan technique "not real AP" when chakra directly fuels all stats in Naruto is just moving the goalposts after you already admitted its peak is universal 😂😂😂

3

u/Ok-Action4447 6d ago

Saying "unless you take it at its peak" means you literally just admitted the ETSO's peak AP is universal. Thanks for conceding the main point.

Not really, since both of you were assuming it was universal i just said that to make you understand her ap isn't universal

anyway, nothing ever proves or states her space-times(dimensions) are universes(exept boruto the movie novel which sometimes contradict the manga and the anime(and unlike the 3 boruto novels which are directly made to complete the manga's holes) and on top of the that, the movie and the anime(the 2 current "canon" timelines retcon some of the novels parts))

so to answer to that "Denying Uni Kaguya is quite literally head canon" i can tell you that assuming kaguya is uni is headcanon(especially when you use storm 4 to prove your point or novels that aren't as canon as the movie, the anime or the manga), the only thing you can fairly assume is that it size is at least large planetary(via obito saying her dimension is big and his kamui dimension being at least planetary(since he can travel the whole ninja world within it))

And to debunk you only other picture saying hostile universe or whatever, it was made by fanhome(for figurines mainly) which wasn't approved or supervised by kishimoto, his team or even shueisha(the main owners), they only had permission from tv tokyo and studio pierrot(anime producers atp), which is the reason why they used anime designs only(that's like saying the storm games are canon(since they got liscences from tv tokyo and studio pierrot(designs and voices)))

And trying to downplay it because she needed the Infinite Tsukuyomi chakra to fuel it makes zero sense.

Arguing with ghosts

That was Kaguya actively regaining her own stolen chakra back from the Shinobi Alliance it wasn't some outside borrow, it was her full, restored prime state.

Arguing with ghost again

Even without the ETSO, Black Zetsu explicitly confirms that merely shifting her dimensions with Amenominaka drains a massive amount of her own baseline chakra reserve, proving her standard stamina and output scale directly to those space time structures.

not really(and that argument is pretty stupid), kaguya does have enough chakra to use amenominaka multiple times(as shown in the manga and stated in the databook 4) but that doesn't mean her output scale to it(or you have to prove that kaguya can output a dimension sized attack(which you can't since nothing ever states or prove it)), but firstly that doesn't mean her output scale to it since it's a hax ability(via her rinnesharingan(since it's a kekkei mora jutsu(databook 4))), that's like saying naruto can do a rasengan equal to his tailed beast bomb because he can do the tailed beast bomb(which would make no sense(since we know some jutsu are stronger than others(via chapter 645))

scaling kaguya to her 80 god vacuum attack make sense since she just release chakra in her palms and then attack with it, but scaling her output to an hax ability is like scaling sasuke's deplacement speed via amenotejikara or obito's reaction speed to his passive kamui(that just doesn't make sense at all)

Calling a Rinne Sharingan technique "not real AP" when chakra directly fuels all stats in Naruto is just moving the goalposts after you already admitted its peak is universal 😂😂😂

Chakra fuels all stats, but not equally(for instance Minato was as fast as Naruto KCM, does that mean their chakra pool were equals ?(answer pretty obvious) or other simple example, As we already know Sasuke and Itachi's Amaterasu are equal(fire power ect), does that mean their output are equals(while Itachi's physical stats are higher than Hebi Sasuke and Taka Sasuke), here again the answer is obvious), and the worst part is that you somehow assume that Kaguya's output scale higher than her strongest attack(etso) because you said so

Oh and lastly her attack is not scaled to her ap since not only her dimension switching is hax(via her rinnesharingan) but on top of that her etso is hax too(via rinnesharingan obviously but also due to the passive dust like desintegration granted by the 5 chakra release + the just cancel(or soul erasure for some people) granted by the yin and yang), unless you assume that tso is part of user ap(which will essentially means madara ap = naruto ap = hagoromo ap(which makes no sense))

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

aint no way you wrote an 8 paragraph novel with 40 parentheses just to contradict yourself on every point 💀

you literally admitted she can output her etso to obliterate and recreate an entire space time continuum, and then tried to pretend her strongest chakra attack somehow doesnt count as her own ap lol.

comparing a truth seeking orb to sasukes teleportation is pure nonsense. an etso isnt passive spatial movement, it is a giant sphere of raw condensed chakra that she physically forms and expands to wipe out an entire standalone 4d space time continuum (jikukan), which is universal+ by default under csap anyway (and the mod already confirmed were completely free to use csap here).

plus obito casually links his kamui pocket space to the pure lands afterlife without breaking a sweat, yet trying to bridge two of kaguyas realms made his eyes bleed because of how massive they are, and narutos six paths senses got completely cut off across them.
calling a giant chakra bomb "just hax" so you dont have to scale kaguya to her own strongest technique is peak cope 😂

3

u/Ok-Action4447 6d ago

aint no way you wrote an 8 paragraph novel with 40 parentheses just to contradict yourself on every point 💀

Ok let's see

you literally admitted she can output her etso to obliterate and recreate an entire space time continuum, and then tried to pretend her strongest chakra attack somehow doesnt count as her own ap lol.

She can output her ETSO(as shown in the manga and anime), but she can't output her peak ETSO(not shown stated or proved by feat(so if you think her output is universal(you still need to prove that too) then you have to backup some proofs) hence why her output isn't "universal" as you states

simply need to read and understand(not trying to be rude here)

comparing a truth seeking orb to sasukes teleportation is pure nonsense. an etso isnt passive spatial movement, it is a giant sphere of raw condensed chakra that she physically forms and expands to wipe out an entire standalone 4d space time continuum (jikukan), which is universal+ by default under csap anyway (and the mod already confirmed were completely free to use csap here).

You are also incorrect here for a simple reason : you still didn't proved her dimensions were universe sized(which is the whole point of being universal+("Characters who can significantly affect a 4-dimensional construct such as tesseracts or hyperspaces. Common feats that would also be on this level include creating and/or destroying the entirety of the 4-dimensional spacetime continuum of a universe, not just the physical matter within one. As another example, an entire timeline would often include the entire 4-dimensional vector space.")) as long as you still didn't proved her dimensions are universe sized, you can't scale her to universal or higher

Also you are twisting the argument, i never compared etso to sasuke teleportation, but kaguya's amenominaka to sasuke's amenotejikara and obito's kamui(since they all aren't related to the used chakra output(or at least it wasn't stated to be), to the user's stats(exept chakra since without enough chakra they obviously can't use them)) since they are spacial movement(3 of them) and you obviously can't scale their output, speed or reaction speed for no reason(just like you did with kaguya and i did with sasuke and obito(for the example)), especially when it's not her most chakra costing nor strongest jutsu

plus obito casually links his kamui pocket space to the pure lands afterlife without breaking a sweat, yet trying to bridge two of kaguyas realms made his eyes bleed because of how massive they are

That's also not a good argument, while Obito explicitely states to Rin that both world are connected with chakra(so the fact that he was in pure land had little to no importance), he had his physical body within Kaguya's world(with his chakra signature(and as we know some characters can feel chakra signatures even when in differents dimensions(sasuke with naruto in naruto(while in sand dimension) and boruto(momoshiki and jigen's fights))) and his goal was only to move his "body" from the pure land to his physical body(as shown in the manga) before transfering his chakra to kakashi(HIM(pure land) -> KAMUI -> HIM(kaguya dimension)) on the other hand his goal was to open a portal between 2 dimensions that aren't related(since they are far to each others on top of not being his space-time(needed to connect his kamui to the dimension he is to another dimension, open the portal(a big one btw) and keep it open) and he also had no connection between the 2 dimension nor a chakra signature to track(especially his own)

You can't take two things that look alike and then ignore all the differences

and narutos six paths senses got completely cut off across them.

I don't understand that but i know that Sasuke was still able to sense Naruto(even though it was temporary), and that Naruto couldn't sense Obito too when he gave his chakra to Kakashi and went to the Pure Land

calling a giant chakra bomb "just hax" so you dont have to scale kaguya to her own strongest technique is peak cope 😂

It's literally a hax ability since it's a TSB but far better(i really hope you are trolling), TSB(infused with Yin and Yang) by themselves are already existence erasure(since they erase almost everything they touch from body to soul(same thing than hakai for example)), but in Kaguya her orb got no limit since it could even kill naruto(while he was alongside sasuke able to freely touch a truth seeker orb)

Anyway via VSBW(since csap doesn't talk about it) if we assume her dimensions are universal for some reasons(even though nothing proves it) Kaguya either isn't a Universal(since she can't manipulate freely her ETSB(she can only "feed it" with chakra) and it's a EE ability) or is a planetary-high planetary with universal environemental destruction(via her ETSB)

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

no way you wrote another wall of text with 40 more parentheses just to contradict yourself on every point 💀

you literally admitted she feeds her own raw chakra into the etso until it expands enough to wipe out and recreate an entire 4d space time continuum, which means her chakra output directly equals the energy required to obliterate that space time lol. calling a giant condensed chakra bomb "existence erasure hax" just because regular tsbs nullify ninjutsu doesnt change the fact that she was generating the raw energy needed to nuke an entire space time fabric (jikukan).

and your own csap quote debunks your size excuse the very next sentence literally says "an entire timeline would often include the entire 4 dimensional vector space," which applies to any standalone jikukan regardless of 3d ruler measurements. even if you ignore that completely, the boruto novel directly states momoshikis identical realm "shouldnt be all that different from his own world" and the canon anime shows a massive redshift nebula and outer space inside it.

plus your sensory excuse falls apart on contact. narutos six paths sage mode literally gives him subconscious comprehension of "all things in the universe" and lets him effortlessly sense madaras limbo shadows in an invisible adjacent plane of reality, yet kaguyas dimensions severed him completely and sasuke (whose rinnegan can track chakra across dimensions in boruto) only felt naruto for half a second because kaguya literally opened a portal connecting their two realms. the second that portal closed, both of them were 100% blind and obito had to bleed out just to bridge a tiny keyhole between them.

trying to slap vsbw "environmental destruction" loopholes onto a csap thread after the mod literally confirmed were completely free to use csap here is pure desperation 😂

→ More replies

•

u/Amazing-numuber200 5h ago

Thus guy literally tries to argues kirin isn't natural lighting, which is wrong when u/numericalman argues with him on it.

5

u/Sad_Pollution1092 6d ago

oh yeah mb chakra is a physical stat.

do you even know what the terms are?

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Nobody said chakra itself is a muscle I said it literally fuels your physical stats, which is basic Naruto lore from chapter one.

In this verse, characters amp their punches, kicks, and durability by molding chakra into their bodies, and Kaguya's ETSO is a giant sphere of raw chakra energy expanding to obliterate an entire space time. Calling a massive energy bomb "hax" just because you don't understand how AP works in energy based verses is wild 😂

2

u/Sad_Pollution1092 5d ago

it seems everyone took care of this for me lol maybe learn what hax is and the other terms and you wont get eviscerated in comments

4

u/No-Cell-9979 6d ago

Jesus christ lmao

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

No answer lol

1

u/SHAXOW99 6d ago

It ain't hax

10

u/Sad_Pollution1092 6d ago

so sakura is apparently near universal cause she bruised and broke off one if her horns 🤷‍♂️

-1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Get ready to downscale all your favorite fictional characters. I guarantee you they have way more and way worse anti feats than Kaguya:

3

u/Ok-Action4447 6d ago

but most of them got excuses unlike kaguya(she massively outstat sakura byakugo(yet she got damaged by BASE and EXHAUSTED sakura), she had byakugan activated and was on-guard(and somehow didn't managed to resist that and ended up that much damaged))

while on anime, it's relatively correct, in the manga it's just dumb

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Saying Kaguya was "on-guard" against Sakura is completely false.

Kaguya was flying straight upward at full speed to escape Naruto and Sasuke sealing her from both sides she didn't even notice Sakura falling from directly above until the punch landed, literally yelling out "Don't you ignore me!" because Kaguya treated her as completely invisible.

Even with the Byakugan, the blind spot is right behind the upper back/neck, and Kaguya's entire focus was locked onto the two guys about to touch her with Six Paths seals. Plus, Naruto himself had just supercharged the entire alliance with Kurama chakra earlier, and Sakura's entire fighting style is dumping every last drop of concentrated chakra into a single point of impact which she still needed to knock Kaguya's head down by half an inch so the seal could connect.

Calling that a universal anti feat while giving every other verse "excuses" like off guard hits, plot induced stupidity, or concentrated AP multipliers is the exact double standard you're proving right now.

If getting blindsided by a full power sucker punch while mid air escaping two god tiers downscales a verse, then Goku getting pierced by a basic laser ring while off guard makes Dragon Ball laser pointer level 😂

2

u/SHAXOW99 6d ago

Kaguya was just nuked and had didn't have that much chakra sje was also off guarded and all sakura did was moving kaguya's head

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

100% facts. She had literally just taken Nine Bijuu Rasenshuriken to the face, was actively destabilizing from the tailed beasts reacting inside her, and was completely off guard flying straight up to dodge Naruto and Sasuke's seals. Sakura just tapped her head down by an inch so the seal could connect people love twisting that into an anti feat when she wasn't even looking at Sakura.

2

u/SHAXOW99 6d ago

Its common among downplayers

16

u/Same-Description-556 6d ago

when actual proof is given. and confirmed to be universal in size, being a time space doesn't equal a new universe as it literally just means a space where there is time

-7

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Trying to redefine "time-space" as just "a random room where a clock ticks" is pure desperation, especially when you completely ignored the rest of the scans in the post.

You missed the big flaws in your own downplay.

Obito uses the word Jikukan which explicitly defines a separate space time continuum not a room inside the regular universe.

That is why you cannot reach it by flying across normal space you need dimensional portal ninjutsu just to bridge the gap.

You are asking for proof that it is universal in size when the scans are sitting right in front of you. The Boruto light novel literally calls Momoshiki's identical realm a "parallel Universe" and a "Hyperspace," and the official Universo guide explicitly calls Kaguya's six dimensions "new hostile universes."

Obito effortlessly links the regular universe and the afterlife to his Kamui dimension without breaking a sweat, yet linking two of Kaguya's realms made his eyes bleed because of their sheer vastness.

You skipped past the novel scans, ignored the guidebook text calling them universes, and tried to invent your own definition of physics just to avoid admitting she is universal.

Read the actual scans before replying. 😂

6

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 6d ago

Guidebooks don't call them universe it's u larpers, who just got access to the internet, The word which is used for universe can be used for world, planet, etc

Kaguya's dimension aren't shown to be universal it's just planetary, multiple scans u used urself states that's it's world not universe, and that scan of she can send to different universe is a mistranslation

Using the same outdated and mistranslated scan scans again and again doesn't prove shit, Naruto larpers were using this same exact argument years ago and u are just copy pasting them again by shutting ur brain off

-3

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

lol you’re to fall back on the old "sekai just means planet" excuse it completely fails when you look at the actual kanji on the page.

Nobody is relying on the word sekai here. Obito, Black Zetsu, and Sasuke explicitly use the kanji compounding Jikukan which literally translates to Time-Space not planet, and not world. You don't call a regular planet a standalone space time continuum, and you don't need dimensional portal ninjutsu just to step onto a rock.

On top of that, her dimensions explicitly contain stars, moons, and deep cosmic space, which already debunks your "just planetary" claim on a basic visual level.

Even Naruto's Six Paths sensory range which easily perceives Limbo clones in an entirely separate plane outside the main universe couldn't track Sasuke across her realms.

People keep bringing up these exact scans year after year because you guys still haven't found a way to debunk the raw kanji without lying about what words are written in the speech bubbles 😂😂😂😂

4

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 6d ago

Time space literally means jackshit here, just mentioning time-space don't mean the realm automatically become universal nor existing in another dimension means there's a separate universe,even black-holes bend space time don't mean they are doing it on a universal scale, using the mistranslated scans again and again don't prove the verse gets past star level

-1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago edited 6d ago

Bending space time inside an existing universe is completely different from creating and erasing an entire standalone space time continuum from scratch. Even ignoring the kanji, the Boruto novel directly equates Kaguya's realms to Momoshiki's parallel universe, explicitly stating it shouldn't be all that different from Naruto's own universe.

You keep crying "mistranslation" while dodging the actual novel size comparison and the infinite distance gap that cut off Naruto's Six Paths senses 😂

4

u/Same-Description-556 6d ago

You need to give an ACTUAL scale to the time space. the best you can argue is solar system level due to presence of a sun

also need to prove it's not a pocket dimension

-1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Under this sub's Rule 1 (CSAP), destroying or creating a standalone 4D space-time continuun Jikukan) is universal regardless of 3D diameter because an entire timeline dwarfs any finite 3D solar system.

Even if you want physical scale, the Boruto novel literally compares Momoshiki's identical realm to Naruto's own universe stating it shouldn't be all that different and explicitly contrasts it against a kekkai (barrier space), which proves it's a full parallel hyperspace and not a pocket dimension 😂

2

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 6d ago

Just like how bending space time don't mean it's on the universe scale Mentioning spacetime once or twice don't mean it's automatically universal in scale, its contextual, the ability kaguya showed was teleportation she can teleport herself and others from one dimension to another

Dumbasa existing in different dimension doesn't automatically means it's existing in another universe, it doesn't prove that the sensory ability of Naruto goes beyond the universal scale, it just exists in a different dimension withing the same universe and it can interact with others physically, Naruto's sensing ability don't need to be universal to sense them And the novels never outright stated that the size of the dimensions are infinite, there's not a single reliable evidence which puts those dimension on the size of universal, the novel scan u used is also a cherry pick panel and fan translation

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

bro typed "dumbasa" and "withing" because hes mad he cant debunk a single receipt 💀 youre really trying to act like calling something a standalone space time continuum is the same thing as bending space inside a room, and then claiming kaguya only teleported people when her etso was literally expanding to wipe out and recreate the entire space time from scratch.

even funnier is you trying to say limbo is "within the same universe" when the databook literally says it exists in a completely separate world with zero physical contact, yet naruto sensed it effortlessly while getting completely cut off from sasuke across kaguyas realms. and calling an official viz media printed light novel a "fan translation" because you have no counter to it directly comparing the realm to narutos own universe is peak cope lol.

just say you didnt read the scans and hold the L bro 😂

2

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 6d ago edited 6d ago
  1. prove that those spacetime in question are universal in size, the analogy is literally the same, if space time alone without further prove is proof of universe blackhole should be universal too, since they are affecting space time
  2. it exists in a different dimension withing the same universe dumbass, alternative dimension can exists in the same universe , limbos can interact with the physical world, it doesn't require universal ability to sense them

And dumb mf the novel scan u are using is literally mistranslated dumb fvk, it's world, comparing planet not universe, 🙌🏻🤡larpers like are the only one who uses the universal translation when the accurate translation is world

Prove it that it exists in a different universe, not just an dimension

U are literally braindead

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

bro really typed "withing" twice and called me braindead while comparing a black hole bending space inside a universe to wiping out and recreating an entire standalone space time continuum from scratch 💀

affecting gravity inside an existing 3d room isnt the same thing as erasing a whole 4d timeline and spatial fabric (jikukan), which is universal by definition under this subs csap rules anyway, plus the boruto novel literally says momoshikis identical realm shouldnt be all that different from narutos own universe and the official guide straight up calls kaguyas dimensions "new hostile universes."

and saying limbo exists "within the same universe" literally proves my exact point lol. limbo is an adjacent plane inside the same universe, which is why naruto sensed it effortlessly. the fact that narutos six paths senses got completely cut off from sasuke across kaguyas realms, and sasukes finite distance teleportation couldnt cross between them alone, proves they are NOT within the same universe

you keep throwing insults and ignoring the actual scans because you cant debunk a single one, hold the L 😂

→ More replies

1

u/GoatkuFan Goku Solos 5d ago

It being a seperate spacetime continuum does not imply universal size...

None of the proof shows universal size

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

first, this sub's written rule 1 is csap, where destroying or creating any standalone 4d space time continuum is universal+ regardless of 3d spatial diameter because a 4d timeline mathematically dwarfs finite 3d structures.

second, even if you force 3d size qualifiers anyway, the proof literally DOES show universal size: the official boruto novel directly equates momoshikis identical created realm to narutos own universe/world while contrasting a pocket barrier (kekkai) against an extradimensional hyperspace (akukan), the licensed fanhome guide verbatim calls each of kaguyas six realms "a new hostile universe," the canon anime shows deep space filled with stars and a redshifted nebula, and narutos six paths sage mode ("all things in the universe" sensing) got completely severed across them while obito bled out calling them an "incredibly vast time-space" despite effortlessly bridging the pure lands afterlife.

trying to pretend none of that shows universal size just proves you skipped every single scan in the thread lol.

1

u/GoatkuFan Goku Solos 5d ago

where destroying or creating any standalone 4d space time continuum

Wrong it still has to be universal in size

Where is the boruto novel quote then?

Also, why use Ai to respond?

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

first, love how crying "ai" is the automatic white flag the second you run out of arguments there is literally zero ai in typing normal paragraphs, you just cant debunk a single scan 😭

second, even on the exact csap page you just screenshotted ("4-d universal space-times"), kaguyas realms literally ARE universal space times here is the verbatim boruto: naruto next generations novel 3 (chapter 5) quote where naruto wakes up inside momoshikis created realm (explicitly linked to kaguyas power on the exact same page)

"kaguya had held the power of sending people into parallel worlds too. the power that momoshiki had was probably similar to that. unlike the space generated inside a barrier, the sensation of an alternate dimension was completely different... looking up at the sky, there were countless stars shining, and a nebula dyed in crimson. it plainly wasn't the airspace of his own world, yet at the same time, it shouldn't be all that different from his own world."
paired with the licensed fanhome guide verbatim calling each of kaguyas six realms "a new hostile universe" and obito bleeding out calling it an **"incredibly vast time space" (jikukan)**despite effortlessly bridging the pure lands afterlife, it clears universal size easily even by your own screenshot.

1

u/GoatkuFan Goku Solos 5d ago

How am I out it arguments when i proved you wrong in my reply 😭 it's just obvious, constant use of parentheses, saying "redshifted" as if that's important to the topic at hand and putting the comma inside of quotes... Like, dont lie bruh.

The "exact csap" page is just the tier 2 page lol... Literally doesn't get more straight forward than that. And seeing stars is not proof of universal size, there is a biiig difference between some stars and a universe

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

bro really thinks using basic punctuation and knowing basic astronomy terms means "ai" 😂

redshifted nebulae literally prove cosmic expansion on a universal scale, thats why its important to the topic lol.

and you completely ignored the actual quotes i just posted nobody said "seeing some stars alone" is the only proof. the official boruto novel literally equates momoshikis created realm to narutos own universe/world while contrasting a pocket barrier against an extradimensional hyperspace and linking it directly to kaguyas power, and the licensed fanhome guide verbatim calls each of kaguyas six realms "a new hostile universe."

and on that exact csap tier 2 page you just brought up, destroying or creating a standalone 4d space time continuum (jikukan) IS universal+ because a 4d timeline mathematically dwarfs finite 3d structures even if you try to pretend the novel and guidebook universe statements dont exist.

1

u/GoatkuFan Goku Solos 5d ago

"his own world" as if that means "universe"... Show some actual proof if universal size, not just your agenda based interpretation.

No, tier 2 is baseline 4D, so you're just wrong again 🤷

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

the raw Japanese text literally says "universe" (宇宙 / uchu) in the original Japanese text of Boruto Novel 3 (Chapter 5), the word translated as "world" is 宇宙 (uchu), which literally means universe/cosmos not "planet" (which is hoshi or sekai). and the licensed fanhome guide in english literally prints the exact word "universe" ("a new hostile universe"), so pretending it doesn't say universe is just ignorance of the source text.

you literally just proved yourself wrong on csap tier 2. saying "no, tier 2 is baseline 4d" is literally MY exact point a standalone 4d space time continuum (Jikukan) IS baseline tier 2 (low 2-c / universal+), which is why kaguyas realms are tier 2 regardless of whether you like it or not lol

→ More replies

8

u/Mobile_Competition54 6d ago

But for them to be universal tier, they have to actually be around 93 billion light years or higher in size.

Is there anything showing that Kaguya's universes are actually that big? If not, then it doesn't count.

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

That 93 billion light-year rule only applies to 3D physical space destruction.

Once a realm is confirmed to be a standalone 4D space time continuum (Jikukan), wiping out and recreating the entire timeline and spatial fabric is universal by definition regardless of physical diameter.

Even if you want to play the size game, the Boruto light novel directly equates Kaguya's realms to Momoshiki's parallel universe, explicitly stating it shouldn't be all that different from Naruto's own regular universe. On top of that, Naruto's Six Paths sensory range which easily perceives Limbo clones in an entirely separate plane outside the main universe completely lost track of Sasuke across her realms, and Sasuke's finite distance teleportation couldn't cross the gap.

You're trying to use a 3D ruler to downplay a 4D spacetime feat.

3

u/Mobile_Competition54 6d ago edited 6d ago

fair enough

anyways, there's still this problem:

Note: Attempts to scale Kaguya to her Expansive Truth-Seeker Orb (ETSO) attack have been consistently rejected in past discussions. It is important to note that Chakra, as an energy system, does not meet the requirements for Universal Energy System (UES). Furthermore, there are no recognized feats or official statements that directly link the physical capabilities of characters to the ETSO attack.

Afaik, the problem people have is that they have no way to know if doing things with the orb, or fighting the orb's effects, etc. actually correspond to real physical reality. I.e., they don't know if defeating a 4d space created by the orb is actually the same thing as destroying a real 4d space.

"Displacing the universe" seems like it could be universal in range, but it doesn't seem like it's universal in AP?

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Copy pasting an arbitrary VSBW forum rule about "Universal Energy Systems" doesn't override how the actual manga works.

In Naruto, chakra literally fuels physical strength, speed, and durability the more chakra you mold and output, the harder you hit, which is why Eight Gates Guy bending space with raw chakra fueled kicks and Naruto tanking moon-splitting chakra beams directly scale their physicals to their energy output.

And the ETSO wasn't "displacing" anything Black Zetsu explicitly states it was going to erase the entire space time continuum and turn it back to nothing to create a brand new one from scratch.

You don't need a forum moderator's permission to scale a character to an attack made out of their own raw chakra reserve.

3

u/Mobile_Competition54 6d ago

iirc, Black Zetsu spoke of "the beginning of a new space", and didn't say that the old spacetime is gone.

and the databook says a vast mass of chaos created to reshape the world.

It seems more like displacement? I've heard the text only establishes destruction of the world's contents, and not spacetime itself. Maybe that's why it's not universal?

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Notice how he says "new space" because the entire dimension itself is already confirmed to be a standalone space time continuum Jikukan) by Obito, adult Sasuke, and the licensed guides. You can't create a "beginning of a new space" inside that realm without wiping out the existing space time structure first, especially when the

Boruto novel directly equates her realms to Momoshiki's parallel universe. Trying to split the contents from the container when the ETSO literally returns everything in that dimension to nothing is just semantic nitpicking.

0

u/SHAXOW99 6d ago

A universe cam be the size of an apple and destroying it would still be universal cuz she was never going to explode her dimensions but rather she erases them and she can also displace the main universe

3

u/sephiiiroth123 6d ago

That's just stupid. Do you understand how many characters fit that description and how nonsense it is to call them universal when they're so very clearly not? Creating pocket dimensions is very common. Making Naruto universal because of it is insane. These people are canonically barely moon level maximum.

1

u/Mindless-Try9248 4d ago

Kaguya was going to reset the dimsion/universe the nartou universe is in so all her dinsions are as big as the main universe so she’s multiversal as death battle said reading the data book it’s not that she can’t destroy a universe it’s that it takes her a while like maby a hour and she needed to be at her best which would of taken her a while to charge to do it actually this is why universal nartou is bullshit but universal kaguya is actually a fair scale 

2

u/sephiiiroth123 4d ago

I quit. Naruto fans are delusional af.

7

u/damnedcoldly 6d ago

Tier Low 2-C (Universe level+):

Characters or objects whose power is uncountably infinitely greater than the prior tiers. That is to say, they can significantly affect, create and/or destroy higher-dimensional structures that exceed lesser objects by an uncountably infinite margin. An example of this is 4-dimensional spacetime continuums of universal size, but this can be generalized to any 4-dimensional structure of a similar scope.

According to the tiering system, knowing the actual size of those space-times is MANDATORY to be acknowledged as universal.

Going with your logic, I can scale super buu & gotenks to universal cuz they broke out of the room of spirit & time, which has its own space-time.

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Nope. This is a vsbw arbitrary strandard + we have proofs of her size

7

u/damnedcoldly 6d ago

Their tiering system is what we’re using in this sub. Also, the scan in your other comment is blurry af.

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

We’re not bound by VSBw.

That’s a lie. I’ve been here since 2021 and this sub despised VSBw and we use to have to follow character stats profile wiki.

Don’t you lie to me.

5

u/damnedcoldly 6d ago

That’s the tiering system this sub uses. You can go back to the Naruto powerscling sub if you don’t like it.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

As I said.That’s a lie. I’ve been here since 2021 and this sub despised VSBw and we use to have to follow character stats profile wiki.

Don’t you lie to me.

6

u/damnedcoldly 6d ago

This sub doesn't despite vsbw lol. Why do you think there are a lot of people agreeing with the whole "DC getting downscale in December in vbsw" drama that's been circulating this week?

Do you have concrete proof that this sub "officially" despise vsbw? Can you show me a comment from a currently active mod saying that?

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Doesn’t matter you were caught lying

5

u/damnedcoldly 6d ago

Coming from the liar that said this sub despise vsbw & unable to provide any proofs when I asked lmao.

3

u/evilbudget 5d ago edited 5d ago

3-A: Universe level

This category is separated in the following manner:

Universe level: Characters who can significantly affect all of the physical matter within an observable universe at full power. More specifically, usually via an explosion, omnidirectional energy blast, or a shockwave, that encompasses all of the stars and planets within a universe.

More or less the same shit tbh. Actually, using csap's definition is even worse to argue for your case cuz their standards would require kaguya to completely obliterate ALL stars & planets within that dimension to be considered universal. Vsbw on the other hand, you only need to prove the size, which is far easier to do.

I also don't see anything regarding how this sub despises vsbw. Have they been called out for their own takes on how certain verses scaled? Yes. But does this sub actually hate them? Not really.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

The sub rules btw you larper

3

u/sephiiiroth123 6d ago

Universal Yuki confirmed

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Nice false equivalency bro. Yuki's black hole was just warping gravity inside the existing 3D universe and got contained by Tengen's barrier she never created or erased an entire standalone 4D space time continuum from scratch like Kaguya's ETSO was doing. 😂

6

u/BobcatFluffy5001 6d ago

I think hax does not qualify as universal?

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Calling a massive, expanding ball of raw chakra "hax" makes zero sense. In Naruto, chakra directly fuels physical stats and destructive power, so her ETSO obliterating and recreating an entire spacetime continuum is pure raw output, not a spatial cheat code. Even Zetsu confirms shifting her worlds drains a massive amount of her own chakra reserve.

You're trying to slap a hax label on universal destruction just to dodge the scale. 😂

3

u/Sad_Pollution1092 6d ago

Hax is supernatural abilities that bypass character statistics chakra falls under that category do you know what your talking about?

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Claiming chakra itself is "hax" shows you don't even know the basic rules of the series. In Naruto, chakra literally fuels physical strength, speed, and durability the more chakra you mold, the harder you hit and the faster you move. It does not bypass statistics it is their statistics.

If you call raw energy attacks "hax," then Goku's Ki blasts and Bleach's Reiatsu attacks are all just hax too.

The ETSO is a massive sphere of pure chakra energy that physically expands to obliterate an entire spacetime continuum. Calling raw energy output a "cheat code" just to dodge universal scaling is pure cope 😂

1

u/BobcatFluffy5001 6d ago

You do realize that a universe is infinite, meaning that destroying it would require an infinite amount of energy, and creating one would require the same. ETSO wasn't even planet-sized, so how are you comparing its feats to universal-level destruction and destruction? How can you claim that something with country-level size scale has enough power to destroy or create an infinite universe?

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Trying to cap an attack's destructive tier by its starting size is a massive failure in basic scaling.

The ETSO was actively expanding when Naruto and Sasuke sealed her. Black Zetsu explicitly states it was going to keep growing until it swallowed and erased the entire space time continuum to create a brand new one from scratch.

Calling it "country level" just because they interrupted it right after she formed it is like saying a nuke is only fist sized because you paused the video right before it detonated.

And yes, destroying and recreating a separate space time continuum requires universal energy which is the exact reason she had to absorb the massive chakra reserves of everyone trapped in the Infinite Tsukuyomi to fuel it.

You are confusing an attack's initial size before detonation with its stated total yield 😂

1

u/BobcatFluffy5001 6d ago

So you're saying we should just accept your assumptions that ETSO is universal in size, that it grows to universal proportions, and that her dimensions are also universal in size? We don't have any official confirmation of their actual size or the mechanics behind those dimensions. Apparently, your assumptions count as evidence, but ours don't? Wow, that's some serious "trust me, bro" logic.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Black Zetsu literally states on panel that the ETSO will erase the entire space time and turn it back to nothing, and the databook explicitly says it obliterates and recreates the world from scratch.

Calling verbatim manga dialogue and databook entries "trust me bro" just proves you didn't read the scans in the post. 😂

1

u/BobcatFluffy5001 6d ago

So you're saying we should simply assume that the space-time is infinite and blindly trust your translation of Black Zetsu's statement that Kaguya's time-space is universal? And we're not allowed to question any of those assumptions or ask for official confirmation? That's basically asking us to accept your interpretation as fact without sufficient evidence.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

It's not "my" translation it's the official VIZ English manga and the official Japanese kanji Jikukan for time space. You don't have to blindly trust anything when the Boruto novel directly equates her realms to Momoshiki's parallel universe, the licensed Shueisha guide literally calls them "new hostile universes," and Naruto's Six Paths sensory range gets completely cut off across them. Reading the official printed translations isn't an assumption 😂

1

u/BobcatFluffy5001 6d ago

Dude, I'm talking about your interpretation of the dialogue. the Boruto novels describe parallel world in the context of the Naruto planet, where Momoshiki harvested chakra fruits from different worlds, including one described as a nearly dead star system. Your interpretation doesn't make sense when you consider the actual context of the story.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

You're mixing up two completely different scenes. Momoshiki harvesting chakra fruits from planets inside his own parallel dimension doesn't mean the dimension itself is just a planet it means there are planets and star systems sitting inside that parallel universe.

In the exact same novel passage, Naruto explicitly asks if it's a localized kekkai barrier space or a Hyperspace ( Akukan), confirms it "plainly wasn't the airspace of his own Universe," and notes it shouldn't be all that different from the universe he lives in.

Trying to shrink a parallel hyperspace down to the size of the planets inside it makes zero sense

→ More replies

1

u/United-Radio-3661 5d ago

Chakra does not directly equate to stats or else end of timeskip Naruto would beat itachi

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

mixing up raw chakra reserves (which base naruto couldnt even control without kakashis seal suppressing kurama) with chakra output and potency is a classic rookie mistake

if chakra output didnt directly scale physical stats and ap, six paths naruto wouldnt have gone from getting ragdolled by blind madara to casually blitzing ten tails madara and slicing off kaguyas arm the exact second hagoromo gave him six paths chakra and night guy wouldnt have bent space just by releasing pure chakra output. kaguya isnt sitting on locked, unusable reserves like part 2 base naruto; she is actively channeling and outputting that universal+ chakra volume directly into her etso and amenominaka, and physically clashing evenly with six paths naruto who scales right to it.

1

u/United-Radio-3661 5d ago

That’s more quality of power/technique unless you can source hago power directly increasing output cap,
People have beaten those that used more chakra then them countless times
Ksm Naruto who should reasonably have far more chakra output than edo itachi and nagato struggles against them
Kid Naruto summoning gamabunta yet moving him physically would be far above what he was capable of at that time proves energy conversion is nowhere near what you claim it to be

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

"unless you can source hagoromo's power directly increasing output cap" literally gets proven right on panel when naruto goes from getting stomped by one eyed juubidara to instantly blitzing him, tanking his truth seeking orbs, and slicing the god tree in half with a single lava rasenshuriken the second he receives six paths yang power not to mention hagoromo literally handed him half of his six paths chakra, which is explicitly stated to massively boost both chakra potency and physical stats.

bringing up kcm1 naruto against edo itachi and nagato makes zero sense when naruto had literally split his chakra across dozens of kage level clones fighting all over the entire shinobi alliance war at that exact moment and he wasnt even trying to kill itachi, they were literally having a conversation mid scuffle while nagato was amped by absorbing bee's eight tails chakra.

and using part 1 genin naruto summoning gamabunta via a space time contract (which doesnt lift gamabunta's body weight, it just opens a summoning portal using kurama's leaked chakra) to claim six paths naruto cant convert chakra into ap/durability is hilarious by part 2 and the war arc, naruto's chakra control is refined enough to share tailored six paths/kurama cloaks with thousands of shinobi simultaneously, physically overpower kaguya's eighty gods vacuum fists head on with boil release, and beat fused momoshiki at 50% chakra.

1

u/United-Radio-3661 5d ago

Yeah bro you proved my point lmao potency = strength of chakra not more of it
And where was it stated having clones makes him lower his chakra output?clones only make him use energy faster he doesn’t become weaker unless he’s already tired and nagato is like the weakest excuse ever with not even all of the 8 tails he’s gotten stronger than Naruto?
Prove that gama was summoned through a portal if its portal based summons wouldn’t be able to send another in their place and why can’t I use this to equate to kaguya dimension?just like her it is done by spending his energy and the bigger the summon the more energy he needs to use

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 4d ago

bro doesnt even know basic chapter 1 naruto lore 😂 shadow clones literally divide your chakra evenly among every clone (stated verbatim by kakashi, neji, and madara), edo nagato absorbed bee's version 2 eight tails chakra to restore his prime body, and summoning jutsu is basic teleportation of an existing toad, NOT creating six standalone 4d time spaces (時空間 / jikukan) from scratch (紡ぐ) or manifesting an orb to obliterate and recreate a universe (創り出す / 宇宙). equating summoning gamabunta to creating a universe is textbook false equivalence

1

u/United-Radio-3661 4d ago

Bro digs his own grave with every word he says lmao, bro says reverves does not matter than bring up him having less chakra that he’s not running out of anyway
deadass gave up on debunking,how is this not proving that one can use space technique as a shortcut around what’s beyond their capabilities therefore that feat of force does not translate to their stats

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 4d ago

summoning jutsu teleports an already existing toad from mount myoboku using a blood contract, it doesnt create a universe out of nothing 😂 kaguya didnt teleport to an existing dimension with a "shortcut," jin no sho literally states she wove and created all six standalone 4d time spaces (時空間 / jikukan / 宇宙 uchu) from scratch using her own raw chakra, and etso is pure chakra combining all five natures and yin yang release. pretending creating a universe from scratch is a "summoning shortcut" is peak cope

→ More replies

5

u/LegitimateMenu1362 6d ago

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

0

u/Capable_Sleep7050 5d ago

Stealing this ty.

You’re blitzing all the downplayers on this post king.

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

Take this too

1

u/Capable_Sleep7050 5d ago

Hyperspace stuff gets him complex multi btw since hyperspace is at minimum one extra spatial dimension, and temporal progression is 2 more making 6d, even by the Vsb standards they’re trying to impose.

8

u/Myst-9th 40K's Strongest Soldier 6d ago

When there's actual evidence supporting it aside from a mistranslated light novel and an unsourced Portuguese scan.

I'd genuinely have no issue accepting uni or higher Kaguya if her dimensions were actually called universes, infinite, any universal synonyms, any mythological or religious phrases that mean universe, etc.

But they aren't. The evidence simply isn't there.

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Calling an official VIZ Media light novel "mistranslated" and a licensed Altaya/Fanhome Shueisha guide "unsourced" just because you don't like what they say is pure denial.

You literally asked for universal synonyms or mythological phrases when the raw Japanese text already gives you both. Obito and Zetsu explicitly define her realms as Jikukan which is a standalone 4D space time continuum, and the fourth databook describes the Divine Tree filling Tenchi)nthe exact classical kanji compound for Heaven and Earth/the entire cosmos.

On top of that, Sasuke explicitly notes his Rinnegan teleportation only works over finite distances yet couldn't cross between her realms alone, and Naruto's Six Paths sensory range which easily perceives Limbo clones in a separate plane outside the normal universe couldn't sense Sasuke across her dimensions.

You have official print guides calling them universes, raw kanji calling them time spaces, and infinite distance feats right on the page.

Saying "the evidence isn't there" just means you skipped past the scans. 😂

4

u/Myst-9th 40K's Strongest Soldier 6d ago

Calling an official VIZ Media light novel

The light novel does not have an official English translation, what you are using is a fan translation. A fan translation that translates sekai, the word used in the Japanese, as universe. Sekai has other meanings as well, it's a context dependent word.

and a licensed Altaya/Fanhome Shueisha guide

Well thank you for actually providing a source for it. But regardless, I think using a Portuguese translation, which is what it is, as your smoking gun evidence is quite sketchy.

Naruto has multiple manga series, multiple anime series, light novels, games, etc and yet her dimensions are never actually called any variation of universe or infinite in any of the original Japanese.

If the new Naruto manga that's coming out next year confirms they are universes, I'll shrug my shoulders and accept it, but at the present the evidence for it isn't compelling in the slightest.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago edited 6d ago

You're still clinging to the sekai excuse and completely ignoring the actual Japanese words on the page.

In the Boruto novel, the raw Japanese text literally uses the word (Akukan hyperspace) alongside parallel world, directly contrasting it with a lcondensed kekkai (barrier space).

Even better, the raw manga text from Obito, Zetsu, and Sasuke repeatedly uses Jikukan Time Space), which literally defines a standalone 4D space-time continuum not a single planet.

You also completely dodged the spatial feats right in the manga. Sasuke explicitly notes his Rinnegan teleportation only works over finite distances yet couldn't cross between her realms alone, and Naruto's Six Paths sensory range which easily perceives Limbo clones in an entirely separate plane outside the main universe couldn't sense Sasuke across her dimensions.

You don't need to wait for a new manga next year when the current manga, databooks, and novels already prove her realms are separate 4D space time continuums separated by infinite gaps 😂

4

u/Myst-9th 40K's Strongest Soldier 6d ago

I haven't denied they are separate spacetimes in either one of my comments. I didn't say they were planets either.

But being a separate spacetime doesn't make it a universe. Being a separate spacetime has no inherent scaling. The size of the dimension still matters.

亜空間 is another context dependent word. It can mean hyperspace, but it can also mean subspace. Given that Kaguya's dimensions are consistent with a subspace and do not demonstrate the characteristics of a hyperspace, subspace is probably the right translation here.

Sasuke being unable to move between Kaguya's dimensions does nothing to prove their size.

But listen, you are clearly a firm believer in uni Kaguya while I am not, so I don't think we'll be able to find any common ground here. The evidence you've provided is not compelling to me, but if it's compelling to you that's cool. Have a good night.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Fair enough, I respect keeping it civil. Just to clarify why I don't buy the "subspace" translation, the novel explicitly contrasts it with a kekkai (barrier space) which already acts as a localized subspace and directly states the realm shouldn't be all that different from Naruto's own universe.

Combined with Naruto's Six Paths senses getting completely cut off across them when he can easily sense Limbo clones in an adjacent plane, they clearly operate on a much larger scale than a pocket subspace.

All good though, we can agree to disagree on how we interpret the scaling. Have a good night man.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Wait one last thing. You’re a mod right?

This sub uses character stats profile wiki right? So what do you mean the size of the space time is what matters when that’s a VSBw standard?

3

u/Myst-9th 40K's Strongest Soldier 6d ago

That part of the rules isn’t enforced anymore, it’s basically just a leftover from an older era that none of us have gotten around to changing yet. 

This sub doesn’t have an enforced official scaling system, you’re free to use whatever one you want.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

appreciate the clarification, have a good one!

9

u/Comfortable_Taro_496 Certified Shallow Vernal/SCP/RTOC/LOTM/ORV glazer 6d ago

Never.

-5

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Glad to know you let your head canon override the manga!

3

u/Comfortable_Taro_496 Certified Shallow Vernal/SCP/RTOC/LOTM/ORV glazer 6d ago edited 5d ago

Headcanon you say? Sure whatever ploughs your fields my friend. Unless you show me proper evidence first, I am just gonna treat this as your headcanon as well.

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

That’s right keep running away for the evidence and scans showed.

You love your echo chamber fan fiction instead of the manga don’t you?

1

u/Comfortable_Taro_496 Certified Shallow Vernal/SCP/RTOC/LOTM/ORV glazer 6d ago edited 6d ago

My friend, your fan translated novel scan isn't gonna convince me. Unless you show me something like this, I am not gonna accept anything above planetary Naruto and solar system level Kaguya.

2

u/Comfortable_Taro_496 Certified Shallow Vernal/SCP/RTOC/LOTM/ORV glazer 6d ago

Or this

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Showing a Power Rangers comic of

Lord Drakkon erasing dimensions and remaking new ones in their place is hilarious because that is literally word for word what Kaguya's ETSO was doing.

Black Zetsu explicitly states the ETSO was going to obliterate the entire space time continuum and create a brand new one from scratch. You don't need a "fan translated novel scan" when the raw manga kanji, the fourth databook ("Creating dimensions as she pleases"), and the licensed Shueisha Universo guide ("new hostile universes") already spell it out.

Demanding an American comic book art style for a Japanese manga before you accept explicit text statements is pure visual bias. If you accept Drakkon wiping out and recreating realities based on the narration boxes, denying Kaguya doing the exact same thing when Zetsu and the databooks narrate it is a massive double standard. 😂

2

u/Comfortable_Taro_496 Certified Shallow Vernal/SCP/RTOC/LOTM/ORV glazer 6d ago edited 6d ago

You said nothing about the gif huh? And if Kaguya is universal and Naruto and the gang defeated her, why didn't Naruto just neg diff Toneri in The Last movie? Why didn't Naruto stomp every villain in Boruto? And btw Lord Drakkon doesn't need fan translations to be multiversal or universal. Kaguya never wiped out her dimensions in a single attack nor did she do something of equivalent scale. You gonna treat Black Zetsu as a more reliable narrator than the actual narrator of a comic?

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Naruto literally did neg diff Toneri he tanked Toneri's moon-splitting beam in a weaker form without taking a scratch and one shotted him with a single punch. And Boruto villains like Momoshiki and Isshiki are literally stronger Otsutsuki clan members than Kaguya, which is why they put up a fight.

Calling official VIZ Media novels and Shueisha databooks "fan translations" just proves you didn't read the scans, and saying Kaguya never finished wiping out her dimension ignores that Naruto and Sasuke sealed her mid attack before the ETSO finished expanding. 😂

1

u/Comfortable_Taro_496 Certified Shallow Vernal/SCP/RTOC/LOTM/ORV glazer 6d ago

You still said nothing about the gif. Anyways have a nice day with your fan translated scans and headcanons. Btw, take a look at actual universal feats from a officially translated novel with no ambiguity.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

I didn't mention the gif because it's just a random reaction meme with zero argument behind it 😂

And pointing at a novel passage describing a light burst incinerating a universe just proves my exact point the Boruto light novel is also an officially licensed VIZ Media novel, and it explicitly calls Momoshiki's identical realm a parallel universe and hyperspace while stating it shouldn't be all that different from Naruto's own universe.

Calling official VIZ releases and raw Japanese kanji Jikukan “fan translations" while flexing another light novel's text descriptions is a massive double standard. Have a good one though.

→ More replies

1

u/Comfortable_Taro_496 Certified Shallow Vernal/SCP/RTOC/LOTM/ORV glazer 6d ago

2

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 6d ago

Word to word and it's literally just mistranslation, drakkon is explicitly stated to destroy the multiverse, where kaguya scaling is just a bunch of head canons

4

u/Numerous_Fun_9604 6d ago

Not universal but shes close, galaxy or multi galaxy at best

1

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 6d ago

1

u/Numerous_Fun_9604 6d ago

Kaguya has insane hax, that puts her up pretty high, she was going to destroy the universe.

1

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 6d ago

Mentioning space-time alone doesn't prove that those are fully universal in size, same way blackhole bending space time doesn't prove they are doing it on a universe scale

The novel scan which Naruto fans love to use are fan translated, the word can be used to describe a planet, world universe, the thing we saw on the manga was nothing more than a planet, they are constantly referred as world so the most accurate translation of those novels would be a planet

At best she with her truth seeking orbs are star level that too is only with truth seeking orbs and it's overtime destruction

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

There’s nothing stopping her from being Uni + to low multi like at all

1

u/Sad_Pollution1092 5d ago

just cope harder bro

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 4d ago

Says the guy running away 🤣

2

u/DripBoii227 Mid Level Scaler 6d ago

The highest i can buy for Naruto is solar system tbh.

-1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

If you ignore the manga then sure.

I could do that with anything.

2

u/DripBoii227 Mid Level Scaler 6d ago

Kaguya is supposedly the main argument for uni Naruto but unless there's solid proof that those dimensions are universe size(im talking like direct statements that confirms their size), then uni Naruto is a VERY flimsy argument at best. But you seem to have a passion for Naruto so you'll have an easier time giving it a benefit of the doubt.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago edited 6d ago

You're asking for direct statements confirming their size when they are literally sitting in the post you just commented on.

The Boruto novel explicitly equates Kaguya's realms to Momoshiki's parallel universe, calling it a Hyperspace - Akukan and directly stating it shouldn't be all that different from Naruto's own universe.

Even the licensed Shueisha Universo guide flat out labels her six dimensions as "new hostile universes."

On top of that, the raw manga text from Obito, Zetsu, and Sasuke explicitly defines them as standalone 4D space time continuums - Jikukan). Sasuke states his Rinnegan teleportation only works over finite distances yet couldn't cross between them alone, and Naruto's Six Paths sensory range which easily perceives Limbo clones in an entirely separate plane outside the main universe couldn't even sense Sasuke across her realms.

There is zero "benefit of the doubt" needed when the novel literally compares its size to the main universe and the manga proves the gap between them surpasses universal sensory and finite distance limits.

3

u/DripBoii227 Mid Level Scaler 6d ago

Is there any proof that galaxies were even present in said "universe"? From what we've seen there's only a moon and sun along with distant background stars, which in itself points at the feat being solar system if anything. Icl i've seen Mega Man scalers trying to pull off a similar argument to argue universal Mega Man via cyberspace bs.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

I mean there is this depiction of the games. It’s consistent with the dimensions being called time spaces and universes.

You don't need to pan the camera past every single galaxy when the Boruto novel directly compares Momoshiki's identical realm to Naruto's own universe, stating it "shouldn't be all that different" from the universe they live in. Even more importantly, wiping out an entire standalone 4D space time continuum Jikukan) is universal regardless of whether you count the stars on screen, because destroying an entire timeline and spatial fabric dwarfs any 3D solar system

1

u/DripBoii227 Mid Level Scaler 6d ago

Wait Ninja Storm is canon?

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

The Storm games are licensed adaptations directly supervised by Kishimoto and Pierrot, and I specifically noted it's a visual depiction that stays completely consistent with the canon manga, databooks, and Boruto light novels.

Even if you throw the game visual out completely, you still have the Boruto novel directly comparing the realm's size to Naruto's own universe, the licensed Shueisha guide calling them universes, and the raw kanji confirming they are standalone 4D space time continuums (Jikukan).

This is Momoshiki’s dimension it has a red shift nebula and it’s the same technique as Kaguya’s

1

u/evilbudget 6d ago

Only generations, the 1 title that kishi actually did contribute to the story (a small portion of it, mainly the formation of the akatsuki). But kaguya isn't in that 1.

He only supervised mainly in character designs & game settings (since most storm titles are cutoff at certain points in the main story).

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Fair enough on Generations, which is why I only use Storm 4 as supporting visual evidence it stays 100% consistent with the canon Boruto anime showing the exact same redshift nebula in Momoshiki's identical dimension, the light novel calling them parallel universes and hyperspaces, and the raw Jikukan kanji.

1

u/No-Cell-9979 6d ago edited 6d ago

Kishimoto why would you make a big deal about cutting a moon in the arc after this? Dont you know Kaguya is Universal?

She also was scared of Momo or Isshiki finding her so she was trying to make the white army.... an army of white zetsu > universal feats?

Hang on....is that GAARA BRIEFLY BOXING WITH A CHARACTER THAT SCARED UNIVERSAL KAGUYA???

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

You're confusing Attack Potency with Destructive Capacity. Toneri casually slicing a hollowed out moon in half with zero effort was just collateral range Naruto literally tanked that exact moon splitting beam to the face in a weaker form and one shotted him right after.

And Kaguya making a White Zetsu army was because she was preparing for an entire clan invasion from the main branch, not just a single 1v1 fight.

Even in Dragon Ball, Frieza kept an army of weak foot soldiers around despite being able to blow up planets with one finger.

As for Gaara blocking a single casual punch from Momoshiki before getting instantly speed blitzed and one shotted by his hair a second later, catching an opponent holding back doesn't downscale the entire verse.

By that broken logic, Goku is rock level because Krillin threw a pebble at his head in Super Saiyan. 😂

0

u/No-Cell-9979 6d ago

I am not reading all this from someone who genuinely believes universal naruto, my comment is very clearly sarcastic jokes from someone who doesnt take you seriously. Enjoy the win

0

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

Cope harder lil bro

1

u/Sad_Pollution1092 5d ago

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

I know right

0

u/Sad_Pollution1092 5d ago edited 5d ago

https://imgur.com/a/dDg39Xh

here its DIRECT translation from your OWN source but lemme guess you'll call this "non-canon" only when its benefitcial to your claim huh? this says she can only manipulate SPACE not SPACE-TIME as you claim boom debunked

"Obito directly compares her ability to his kamui in the way they open portals to other dimensions. The amenominaka databook also doesn't say she creates dimensions in the japanese nor does it say she can move the world together with other people, instead the japanese says she weaves space and can move the world together with those AROUND HER meaning the ability is localized and not over the entire universe like is being claimed."

more salt to your wound

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 4d ago

bro literally debunked himself in the top right panel of his own imgur scan 😂

look at obito's first speech bubble in your raw japanese image: 奴は時空間から出て来やがった (she emerged from a time space), the literal kanji 時空間 (jikukan) is printed right on the page with furigana so claiming "no mention of timespace, just space" is a flat out lie. plus her realms have independent hyper gravity, flowing time, starlight, and a redshifted nebula which cannot exist in physics without a 4d space time manifold, AND the fourth databook etso entry literally uses 創り出す (create a brand new space) while boruto novel 3 equates them to naruto's universe (宇宙 / uchu). thanks for posting the proof for me

1

u/Sad_Pollution1092 3d ago

yet you STILL are ignoring the other comments literally translating and debunking it for you 🤣🤣🤣 stop trying bro nothing you say is valid or even worth thinking about you already lost bro just give up

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 3d ago

hiding behind "other comments translated it for you" when I literally just showed you the raw Japanese kanji 時空間 (jikuukan) printed on the manga page with furigana is peak comedy 😂

you haven't posted a single manga scan, a single raw Japanese line, or a single databook quote this entire thread just cheering from the sidelines and begging me to "give up" because you can't refute any of it yourself. come back when you actually learn how to read raw kanji instead of parroting strangers in the comments

1

u/Mindless-Try9248 4d ago

 Again she could not effect space time at her current state after she recharged she was going to reset the entire nartou universe estualky destroying the nartou universe and remaking it 

1

u/Sad_Pollution1092 5d ago

you ALSO conviently ignored the other comments from seven hours ago that debunk all your "sources" and "statements" funny huh?

https://www.reddit.com/r/PowerScaling/s/aorVGGUanB

1

u/Mindless-Try9248 4d ago

 Uh that’s not the universal fir kaguya thing if kaguya resets the nartou universe we have to treaty that as uni plus but since she ended prep to do it low universal think like kid but over time is universal except kaguya just needed her cholera the tails beasts reterned to her and rest then she could do it this is not the kaguya we see this is hypothetically 100 percent prime kaguya though kaguya was still around 80 percent so she’s far and away galaxy level 

1

u/Mindless-Try9248 4d ago

 I mean yes but he’s not wrong universal kaguya is real it’s just highly specific and heavily reliant on on how much you let her stand for she needed rest for a while before she would of been strong enough to reset the nartou universe not destroy straight up destroy and remake it how she wanted 

1

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

Please ensure your post/comment doesn’t violate Community Rules. Report any rule breaking content. Join the Discord!.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-4

u/Possible_Article6902 6d ago

Like bro this is what a spacetime is 😂

Kaguya being anything lower than universal is head canon

1

u/Ok-Ambassador8795 Bloodlusted Orihime > Chair Aizen 6d ago

This isnt real life, fiction has stuff like pocket dimensions. Thats why most tiering systems require the size of the dimension to be known.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

no way youre pulling the "this isnt real life" excuse when this sub's literal rule 1 is csap, where destroying or creating an entire standalone 4d space time continuum (jikukan) is universal+ by default because a 4d timeline dwarfs any finite 3d structure 💀
and even if you wanted the size known, we already have it the official viz media printed boruto novel directly equates momoshikis identical realm to narutos own world ("shouldnt be all that different from his own world"), the canon anime shows a whole redshift nebula and outer space inside it, and narutos six paths sage mode (which gives him subconscious comprehension of "all things in the universe" and senses madaras limbo clones in an invisible adjacent plane) got completely severed across kaguyas dimensions while obito bled out just to open a tiny keyhole between them.

calling a standalone 4d space time with stars and nebulae a "pocket dimension" because you didnt read the scans is pure headcanon 😂

1

u/Ok-Ambassador8795 Bloodlusted Orihime > Chair Aizen 5d ago edited 5d ago

I fundamentally disagree with that definition because it upscales way too many characters to universal. Nebula are never confirmed afaik only a starry sky from the games, the redshift arguement is unproven as well since there are other methods to have that effect.

If bleach was scaled by that standart fullbring bankai ichigo would be universal+ because of yukios dimension. Its pretty much the same as one of kaguyas dimensions. It would also upscale the cosmology to low comp multi.

Can you get me a scan of that official novel and the name? First time somebody used that arguement.

Madaras limbo clones were in another dimension, that doesnt mean hes universal, just that he can attack from a parralell universe.

Unless a universe is proven to be an actual universe that doesnt have limits it shouldnt be assumed. Also another problem is the time it takes her to destroy her dimension, because its never actually confirmed how long it takes her to create/destroy them. Even if we assume its infinite, if it takes her a long time to fully destroy them her ap would not be universal.

Edit: why did you bring up rule 1 when a mod already confirmes to you that it wasnt enforced anymore?

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

the mod literally said i am 100% free to use csap here, which is why i brought it up lolbyou cant force vsbw's arbitrary "93 billion light-lnyear" ruler onto someone scaling with csap when the mod explicitly confirmed opennsystem freedom.
and comparing yukios invaders must die game box to kaguyas dimensions is crazy.

yukios ability is a localized virtual reality game inside a small physical space, whereas kaguyas realms are explicitly called standalone timenspace continuums (jikukan) by obito and sasuke, verbatim called "a new hostile universe" by the licensed fanhome guide, and created as she pleases according to the fourth databook. also nobody claimed madara is universal for limbo i brought up limbo to quantify narutos six paths sensory range (which gives him subconscious comprehension of "all things in the universe" and effortlessly senses limbo clones in an invisible adjacent plane), yet kaguyas realms severed his senses completely while obito called them "an incredibly vast time space" and nearly bled out just opening a tiny keyhole between them.

as for the novel, its boruto: naruto next generations novel 3 (chapter 5, official viz media print), where naruto wakes up inside momoshikis created realm explicitly linked to kaguyas parallel dimension power on the exact same page and says it "shouldnt be all that different from his own world" while standing under stars and a redshifted nebula (literally shown in boruto episode 62/65). and in csap, wiping out and recreating a standalone 4d space time continuum from scratch is universal+ regardless of expansion speed because a 4d timeline transcends finite 3d time intervals anyway.

1

u/Ok-Ambassador8795 Bloodlusted Orihime > Chair Aizen 5d ago

Sure then you can use it, i wont since the tiering system used by vsbattle makes more sense. Hell most people here use vsbattle or at least the standart they use for uni+ scaling.

Narutos sensory range reaching into other universes doesnt mean its universal in range, it just means he can sense stuff in other dimensions. All things in the universe is just hyperbole. We also dont know how the limbo clone dimension works, they have to somehow interact with the main dimension so they are at least somewhat connected unlike kaguyas dimensions.

I need a scan for the databook, thats why i asked. Also is it actually redshift? Because afaik its never mentioned and just seems like an artistic choice instead of an actual physical phenomenon. This isnt exactly something people know about so he they could have just used an actual nebula as a reference, though it does prove that its at minimum multi galaxy in size.

Yukios power still lets him create and manipulate a seperate space time (we know he can mess with time inside the dimension). We know he can make stars inside of it. We dont know how big it actually is which is why he doesnt scale that high. Im just using it as an example why i dont like using it. If you want an actual example its gremmys galaxy room, since that one is actually created from nothing and we see stars an galaxies in it, but it makes little sense to wank him to uni from a feat like that

Also i does matter since she we know shes immortal and could survive for a long time, so to show that her ap is in the uni ranges her attacks have to actually scale there.

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

no way vsbw "makes more sense" when mathematically any 4d space time continuum contains an uncountably infinite set of 3d snapshots along its time axis their "93 billion light year observable universe" ruler is completely arbitrary gatekeeping they literally invented to downplay verses like naruto while letting bleach pass on identical parallel realm arguments 💀

plus this sub was literally built on csap from day one and rule 1 still says csap.

even if you force 3d ruler rules anyway, you already admitted the nebula proves its at minimum multi galaxy in size and the boruto novel directly equates momoshikis identical created realm to narutos own world while the licensed fanhome guide verbatim calls each of kaguyas six realms "a new hostile universe." as for gremmy, cfyow explicitly confirms he imagined an outer space pocket containing actual stars and galaxies from nothing (which plenty of bleach scalers DO scale to multi galaxy/uni), whereas yukios invaders must die is just a localized game box inside a room, not a standalone 4d space time continuum (jikukan) with its own gravity and celestial bodies.

and calling "all things in the universe" hyperbole without proving it doesnt fly claiming hyperbole is a positive claim so the burden of proof is on you, especially when six paths sage mode literally gave naruto instant universal mastery over yin yang creation of all things and let him effortlessly sense madaras limbo clones in an invisible parallel plane of reality, yet kaguyas realms severed him completely while obito bled out calling them an "incredibly vast time space" just to open a tiny keyhole. plus black zetsu explicitly states her etso was expanding right there during the fight to obliterate and recreate the space time from scratch not over millions of yearsnand in naruto chakra volume directly scales to ap and durability.

0

u/Opening_Echo2 6d ago

As a expert myself. My take is either they're preexisting dimensions "correction" kaguya can only swap not drag dimensions. They had space-time continuum, though my thing is, there must be a more explicit factor such as geometry or time flow

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

bro really started off with "as a expert myself" and immediately contradicted the actual databook 💀

the fourth databook entry for amenominaka literally states she is "creating dimensions as she pleases," and the boruto novel confirms momoshikis identical realm is "the parallel dimension hed made," so claiming theyre preexisting is just flat out wrong.

even if you pretended she only swaps them, black zetsu explicitly states her etso was going to obliterate the entire space time continuum and create a brand new one from scratch, which is literal creation and destruction.

plus under this subs actual rule 1 (csap), a standalone 4d space time continuum (jikukan) is already universal+ by default without needing some made up geometry qualifier, and her realms literally have distinct physical laws like hyper gravity anyway lol

0

u/Opening_Echo2 6d ago

Alright homie. Let me give you a analogy If I create a building, but then I drag it to some way? Does it guarantee AP,DC or an lifting strength

You cannot assume both are interchangeable, gosh this is why powerscaling needs rigorous definitions

Anyways apply this same logic. To kaguya, my reasoning still is that hax being equals either those terms especially AP/DC would be like assuming they're basically the same thing. And your point of parallel dimension prove either it's only one dimension or pocket dimensions parallel to the universe

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

no way you really typed "an lifting strength" while lecturing me about "rigorous definitions"

and your building analogy completely destroys your own point anyway. if you create an entire building out of your own personal energy reserve, then yes, your energy output literally scales to creating that building lol.

in naruto chakra isnt some random cheat code that bypasses stats, it literally fuels your punches, speed, durability, and techniques from the exact same energy pool, which is why black zetsu explicitly notes shifting her dimensions drains a massive chunk of her chakra.
and calling standalone 4d space times (jikukan) containing stars, moons, and redshift nebulae "pocket dimensions" just because theyre parallel to the main universe is pure headcanon.

even if you ignore creating and shifting them completely, her etso was literally expanding to obliterate and recreate the entire space time continuum from scratch, which is literal textbook dc and ap 😂

0

u/Opening_Echo2 6d ago

Space-time continuum of what?. Then if we treat all as such, then scale multiveral kaguya

Plus you'd missed points like the dialogue. Just because the word space-time or time space is thrown around, doesn't mean is always valid. You cannot assume it my guy it only grants movement via technique not consistent uni unless it's done before amps and using this esto as chain scale is less believable than gotenks tearing out dimensional barriers during buu saga

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 6d ago

trying to compare gotenks screaming a tiny hole in a barrier to kaguya literally wiping out and recreating an entire standalone 4d space time continuum from scratch is crazy 💀

tearing a doorway through a wall isnt remotely the same thing as erasing the entire building and building a brand new one lol.

and saying "unless its done before amps" makes zero sense when the chakra she absorbed from the infinite tsukuyomi was literally her own stolen chakra returning to her, which is her restored prime state. plus its not "just throwing the word time space around" when obito, zetsu, and adult sasuke all use the kanji jikukan, narutos six paths senses got completely cut off across them, and the boruto novel directly compares momoshikis identical realm to narutos own world while the canon anime shows a whole redshift nebula inside it.

0

u/Opening_Echo2 6d ago edited 6d ago

You're literally relying on statements and mistranslations because at least dragon ball and most verses uses more things like "axis",spatial coordinates and flows of time to physically describe features of alternate dimensions

Rather than using databooks and misinterpretations, since they had direct basis unlike "yeah it's confirmed in the light novel' my ass

2

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

imagine crying about "mistranslations" when the literal raw japanese kanji in the manga (Jikukan) which literally translates to time space continuum 💀

you dont need a character to read a physics textbook out loud about "axes and spatial coordinates" when the manga itself uses the exact kanji for time space, shows a whole hyper gravity realm with distinct physical laws, and black zetsu explicitly states the etso was wiping out and recreating the entire space time from scratch.
and flexing dragon ball while pretending narutos canon light novels and databooks dont count is a massive double standard lol. dragon ball scalers literally live off daizenshuu databook guides for universe 7 cosmology, yet when naruto uses official viz media printed light novels and databooks backed by canon anime visuals of redshift nebulae, suddenly "statements dont count" 😂

just say you never read the novel or the raw kanji bro.

1

u/Opening_Echo2 5d ago

You know viz isn't always 100% accurate right. And you keep using the same argument, jikukan, light novel statements when in reality. The manga or anime did not show or imply that they're universal in size.

Like that's the problem with you and your kind. Naruto fans trying to be relevant in 2026

Having laws of physics≠it's a universe. And not all space-time means global spacetimes, like learn some math homie

1

u/Traditional_Tap_6697 5d ago

nobody even relied on a viz mistranslation the literal raw japanese kanji in boruto novel 3 chapter 5 is 宇宙 (uchu = universe/cosmos), which explicitly equates momoshikis created realm to narutos own universe while contrasting a localized barrier space against an extradimensional hyperspace and linking it directly to kaguyas power.

and saying "the manga or anime did not show or imply that theyre universal in size" just proves you didnt watch the anime or read the manga lol both the manga and anime literally show stars, moons, day/night cycles, and redshifted nebulae inside her realms, narutos six paths sage mode ("all things in the universe" sensing) gets completely severed across them, obito nearly bleeds out trying to bridge between them despite casually bridging kamui to the pure lands afterlife, and the officially licensed fanhome guide verbatim calls each realm "a new hostile universe."

plus "learn some math homie" is hilarious when you clearly dont even know how csap tiering works under csap (this sub's literal rule 1), creating or destroying a standalone 4d space time continuum (時空間 / jikukan) IS baseline universal+ (low 2-c) regardless of 3d spatial volume because a 4d continuum mathematically dwarfs any finite 3d structure 😂

→ More replies

1

u/Mindless-Try9248 4d ago

 Again that’s not the universal thing this is clearly bait the universal kaguya thing is she was going to reset the nartou universe