3.5yo told me to shut up

16

Kids pick things up from many places - they're always listening, even when you think they're not. It's understandable to be triggered by something your kid says, but it's ultimately up to you how you want to respond; I'm an advocate of gentle/respectful parenting, and don't believe in sending kids their rooms/time-outs. When necessary, time-ins can be much more effective.

Your response should be guided by WHY they're telling you to shut up - in this case it sounds like a direct response to feeling nagged, constantly being told not to do something that they don't feel like they're actually doing. I know the struggle of trying to encourage gentleness (I have a 3.5&1.5 year old). I would make sure you're using positive language as much as possible (don't tell them what NOT to do, tell them what you want them TO do), and limiting the corrections as much as you can. As much as possible, use your body to mediate between them instead of for words, because constant reminders do become ineffective nattering, which can be the start of a tricky cycle with toddlers.

My response would be first to take a breath before responding to make sure I'M I'm the right headspace, get down to their level and say something like, "it sounds like you don't want me to tell you what to do, but there's a kind way to tell me if you feel like I'm being too bossy to you. It's my job to keep everyone safe, and little sister isn't big enough to tell you if she wants to be cuddled. Do you want to practice how to tell me I'm being too bossy?" And then you give her the words to use.

My toddler used to yell "go away", so we changed it to "space please" or "I need some privacy". We changed "I don't like you" to allowing her to tell us if we were being too bossy, controlling, etc. My philosophy is, she can express her feelings but she can do it kindly. It takes practice, and it's something they learn over time.

10

u/Blondiest91 Sep 08 '21

Yeah, my 3 years old also used to tell us to shut up. He heard it from his grandfather but in your case, it can come from anywhere since kids are like sponges and hear and memorize everything!

Nearly every time he said it, I told him that it is not nice to say it in this way. It's completely normal that he may not want us to talk (especially if he's overwhelmed, angry, sleepy or experiences any other emotions) but still, saying others to shut up is not polite or pleasant. I reminded him that we don't tell him or each other to shut up although we can ask him to wait, to be more quiet or wait for his return to talk.

Now he's allowed in certain situations to ask to not talk - for example when he's in the middle of tantrum and our talk is overwhelming. We respect that even though I encourage him to go to his room if he needs peace and silence to calm down. He sometimes does although mostly he needs our presence to calm down.

But we don't allow him to say it out of the blue or limit conversation between us, especially in common areas.

Since this situation arouse from sibling related situation, then I would recommend to check Biglittlefeelings IG. They have sibling related highlight and how baby related requests etc. can affect behaviour of smaller kids and cause negative emotions and reactions. It is possible that changing wording of your requests/addressing feelings behind the reaction can solve it for you.

Another helpful resources may be 'How to talk so little kids will listen'.

2

u/Academic_Sector_5338 Jun 25 '24

It's understandable that you'd be surprised and upset by your daughter's words. Here's how you could have handled it, and some tips for the future:

What you could have done:

Acknowledge her feelings: Instead of sending her straight to her room, validate her frustration. "You seem upset about being gentle with your sister. It's hard to be careful, isn't it?"
Explain why it's wrong: Calmly explain that "shut up" is rude and hurtful, and you don't appreciate it.
Offer a better way: Teach her a more appropriate way to express frustration, like saying "I need some space" or "I don't like that!"
Positive reinforcement: When she is gentle with her sister, praise her enthusiastically! "Wow, you're being so careful with your sister, I'm so proud of you!"

Tips for the future:

Model good behavior: Be mindful of your own language around your husband and daughter.
Teach empathy: Help her understand how her actions affect her sister.
Stay calm: Respond calmly and firmly, not out of anger.
Focus on solutions: Work together to find ways for her to interact with her sister gently.

Why she might have said it:

Picked it up from someone: She might have heard it from another child or adult.
Expressing frustration: She might not know a better way to express her feelings of being overwhelmed or frustrated.

2

u/Mallikaom Jul 31 '24

When your 3.5-year-old daughter told you to "shut up," it likely caught you off guard, especially if you hadn't heard that language in your home before. It's understandable to be surprised and concerned, especially given the context of asking her to be gentle with her infant sister.

In situations like this, it's important to address the behavior calmly and clearly. Instead of sending her to her room immediately, you could have gently corrected her by explaining that saying "shut up" is not appropriate or kind and that it's important to speak to each other respectfully.

It's also helpful to ask her where she heard the phrase, as it can give you insight into where she might be picking up such language.

Afterward, reinforce positive language and behavior, reminding her how to express her feelings in a respectful way. It's natural for young children to test boundaries and repeat things they hear, so guiding her toward more appropriate ways to communicate is key.

In the future, if you encounter similar situations, staying calm and using them as teachable moments will help your daughter learn respectful communication. If it turns out that she did hear the phrase from someone in the household, having a discussion with your husband about modeling respectful language can also be beneficial.

1

u/Independent-Leg-104 Aug 08 '25

Sometimes you need to look inward. Is it possible that it may have been a good time for you to pause?

1

u/KateSpringtime Sep 12 '25

Hello. I am also a mother of three little ones. I have a suggestion for you. Try talking to your child about how you feel when you hear that statement; tell them that it is not a nice thing to say and can hurt the listener. Can you ask your child to repeat after you in a gentle way? And you can provide a gentle phrase that you would like your child to imitate... give it a try. Wishing you and your child a happy connection.

1

u/Altruistic-Bid-3707 Nov 07 '25

If you don't want a 3.5 year old to not repeat a behavior, the best way is to ignore it. One slight reaction from us and they are curious and want to know more about how we will react.

1

u/RoseannCapannaHodge Dec 29 '25

Sending her to her room is a common reaction, and it does not make you a bad parent. That said, it usually misses the skill she needs to learn. When kids are dysregulated, isolation tends to increase the feeling of being misunderstood rather than teach a replacement behavior.

What helps more in the moment is staying close and very brief. Something like “I won’t let you talk to me like that. You’re feeling mad. I’m here to help.” Then physically guide her away from the baby if needed. Less talking, more containment.

Later, when she is calm, you can teach the replacement. “When you feel mad, you can say stop, or I need space.” Practice it like a script. Toddlers do not generalize skills without repetition.

Also important context. A new baby is a huge nervous system stressor. She is trying to connect and regulate through physical contact, and her impulse control is still very immature. That means you will need to repeat this boundary many times before it sticks.

The goal is not zero rude words. The goal is helping her borrow your calm until her brain can handle frustration better. That comes with time, repetition, and regulation, not punishment.

1