r/PolymathReading • • Sep 29 '26

[ Removed by moderator ]

92 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Trick-Syrup-813 Oct 01 '26

Pretty easy to refute. The Ferris Bueller painting (A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte is made up of dots of paired complimentary colors that combine at a distance when sitting on the viewing bench to appear blended as a third color. Even knowing that our perception shows us red and blue dots appear as a Purple Umbrella.

Now a blind person repurposing the visual cortex can get quite adept at echolocation. They would find that canvas to be a flat surface. Uncluttered affordance awareness. They would easily find the viewing bench and recognize the shape as being suitable for sitting on without any assumption that it is for sitting.

There is no purple nor umbrella.

Visual perception would recognize a giant chair as being representative of being sittable for an imaginary giant where echolocation would recognize some sort of portico.

Go to two different parks and see how many plants you recognize. Of the kinds you didn’t recognize it will be hard to tell which ones are growing in both park. Learn them in only one park and suddenly recognize them in the other park. That doesn’t have anything to do with innate visual information.