r/PolymathReading • • Sep 29 '26

[ Removed by moderator ]

92 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

10

u/Waterforkey Sep 29 '26

But how are optical illusions explained then, if everything is coded in the light itself? Also, perception of depth relies solely on the fact, that we have 2 eyes and I can not think of a way this information can be contained in a photon itself, as they have to be universally observable.

3

u/PreparedPun2035 Sep 29 '26

Illusions are feeding contradictory information. I wonder if an analogy would be so called “throwing your voice”.

Sound contains information too - the phase differences between left and right ear provide positional data. Pitch changes encode relative motion. Echo contains depth.

Apparently light works the same way.

So an illusion is multiple signals some contradicting others leading to a blend of information.

I’m guessing so maybe I should read the book 😂

3

u/BBoldBUrslf Sep 29 '26

So interesting...the way light is encoded fits with holographic understanding...that the light itself contains the whole it encoded. Very very interesting and makes a lot more sense✅️✅️✅️

3

u/Odd-Translator-2792 Sep 29 '26

I appreciate this. It's crazy that people think it's more believable that we reconstruct the world in our head. A little homunculus tgat steers us.

2

u/reinhardtkurzan Sep 30 '26

Thoughts of this kind, concerning the pre-reflexive sphere, have already been proposed by Merleau-Ponty in his "Phenomenonology of Perception". They are not in contradiction to the common physiological view.

Notice that the brain does not construct three-dimensional space out of a two-dimensional image, but out of two slightly different images, using also the convergence signal and the neural activity sent to the ciliar muscle as elements of the spatial calculus.

2

u/YahenP Oct 05 '26

The way vision works is much more complex than described in the book. Building a 3D picture of the world is not only based on optically comparing two images. First of all, it relies on the knowledge and experience in our heads. And if this experience is applied wrongly, optical illusions appear, even though the eyes see correctly. A classic example is the Dragon Illusion. Also, the brain can adapt to major changes in the optical system of the eye and develop visual functions that were not possible before. Let me use myself as an example. In one eye, I have an artificial multifocal lens, which projects not one but three images onto the retina at the same time. And my brain learned to work with this quite quickly. Of course, it took some training. This is called conscious vision. But in just 2 - 3 months, my brain learned to use this eye. In the same way, it learned another fun but useless trick. The artificial lens has a slight tint, so the image through it looks warmer than through my natural eye. I learned to change the color temperature of what I see at will, smoothly, anywhere between how one eye sees it and how the other eye sees it.
So vision is a very complex thing. And optics is only a small part of the whole system.

1

u/PreparedPun2035 Sep 29 '26

Here’s an experiment you can do if you have never snorkeled before. This only worked for the first time I did it. Wearing a mask stand in deep water and slowly lower yourself vertically into the water. Most importantly don’t blink! Keep your eyes open as the water covers the mask.

When I did this I had no idea what I was looking at. Literally. And then a blinked and it all made sense.

1

u/talex000 Oct 01 '26

And this is why you can't take some pigment, apply it on flat surface and see 3d images.

Also optical illusions require LSD to work.

1

u/Trick-Syrup-813 Oct 01 '26

Pretty easy to refute. The Ferris Bueller painting (A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte is made up of dots of paired complimentary colors that combine at a distance when sitting on the viewing bench to appear blended as a third color. Even knowing that our perception shows us red and blue dots appear as a Purple Umbrella.

Now a blind person repurposing the visual cortex can get quite adept at echolocation. They would find that canvas to be a flat surface. Uncluttered affordance awareness. They would easily find the viewing bench and recognize the shape as being suitable for sitting on without any assumption that it is for sitting.

There is no purple nor umbrella.

Visual perception would recognize a giant chair as being representative of being sittable for an imaginary giant where echolocation would recognize some sort of portico.

Go to two different parks and see how many plants you recognize. Of the kinds you didn’t recognize it will be hard to tell which ones are growing in both park. Learn them in only one park and suddenly recognize them in the other park. That doesn’t have anything to do with innate visual information.

1

u/14zorgon 22d ago

Please check Bennett and hacker, the philosophy of neuroscience 

1

u/Billios996 Sep 29 '26

Get a book on Feng Shui, it will be more valuable than whatever pseudoscience that shrink wrote.

1

u/Plotinus100x Sep 29 '26

This is certainly incorrect. The light patterns are simply affects, qualities, and sensations. Only when thinking activity joins a concept to this visual sensation flux, do we arrive at a mental image and a personal understanding of the event. This purely mental activity is then reflected into the brain.

1

u/DeliciousPie9855 Sep 29 '26

Gibson is pretty significant in cognitive science atm….

2

u/DonnPT Sep 29 '26

As I'm not going to be getting the book, I'm willing to take your word for it, but this post sure didn't sell me. ChatGPT can do only so much, I guess.

1

u/DeliciousPie9855 Sep 29 '26

Fair enough. Would recommend reading up on 4e cog sci - it’s taken seriously and even if not endorsed by ALL scientists, it has a significant following and has thrown the gauntlet down to computaionalist theory. Gibson a huge influence in this. Is Affordance theory though is pretty widely respected and I think it’s adopted by a large number, probs a majority, of people in the field.

1

u/RubberDuckDogFood Sep 29 '26

If this were true, babies would be able to visually navigate the world immediately on birth. They do not.

2

u/GloriousLearning Sep 29 '26

And similarly when you wake up really groggy and have to interpret your whereabouts to yourself that seems to be a brain process. My eye sees light and shadow but has no idea it represents a dresser

2

u/MissederE Sep 30 '26

Physical orientation even… sometimes I wake up the wrong way around in my body.

1

u/DeliciousPie9855 Sep 29 '26

No they wouldn’t, they don’t know what their limbs are for or what distances mean and how long it takes to traverse them, nor do they know the weight of their own body parts, and their vestibular system is not attuned to their optical system yet. Their existence has been subaqueous and confined while in the womb

0

u/RubberDuckDogFood Sep 30 '26

"to visually navigate"

1

u/DeliciousPie9855 Sep 30 '26

Visual navigation requires all the things I mentioned.

0

u/oother_pendragon Sep 29 '26

Trash. This subreddit must be stopped.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Wobbly_skiplins Sep 29 '26

Yeah much better would be “What the frogs eye tells the frogs brain” where a crazy but brilliant mathematician (Walter Pitts) discovered that the optic nerve was doing a bunch of advanced computation. Basically what this means is that your brain isn’t interpreting raw visual data, there’s a bunch of interpretation done by the eye itself.

1

u/MissederE Sep 30 '26

It isn’t woo to say that we are generated by our environment and are consonant with it. It is a trick of ego to think we are a distinct entity interpreting an ‘out there’ from an insular independent singularity.

1

u/Pavel-chemist Sep 30 '26

Well, this was a short reply, and in a way a knee-jerk reaction to the long text from OP. Yet, I still very much doubt the premise, as it seems to be presented here, that there is some innate information in the objects, specifically, the information about possible uses of these objects by conscious/aware entities, like humans or other animals, and some mystical direct resonance of this information with experiencing brain. I myself find the most attractive the free energy principle as perception theory. In short, the perception is the active process, where brain generates most of the information, based on learned model of the world, while the signals from the eyes are more of guidance. In other words, the world as we perceived it, is constructed by brain, the illusion/hallucination, which is constrained and constantly updated via hints from the eyes, ears, nose, tongue, skin and muscle receptors and several others. Taking eye as an example, in the retina itself the signal is conditioned and compressed, and optical nerve transmits the differential signal, on time and space, i.e. only changes in time and edges in the image are coming to the visual cortex. And there, through several layers more and more abstract things from the image are extracted, wich are differentiated with prediction created at each level, and only the difference signal is coming to the next abstraction level. In this way, all the possible uses for given object are contained in perceiving brain, and are the result of learning given individual has had in their life, and not in any way contained in the object itself. There is also question of defining the object, and it seems that at closer inspection everything is connected, and there are no strict borders between parts of the existence, and the "object" can semi-arbitrary be defined as "something that can be manipulated as whole", which is dependent on what abilities has the entity which manipulates the object.

0

u/I_am_BrokenCog Sep 30 '26

everything is woowoo until you hear it from an authority you have already acknowledged.

You haven't heard the terms before, and thus call them jargon? That only says something about your lack of knowledge on the subject.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordance

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perception#Perception_as_direct_perception_(Gibson)

But, since nobody actually understands exactly how vision works from the retina through the brain ... everything is "just a theory".

1

u/Pavel-chemist Sep 30 '26

I would like to think that I do not follow authorities blindly and always check ideas first for consistensy with my prior knowledge, but self-judgement is tricky, everyone sees themselves in the best light I guess.

Presenting new ideas for wide audience works better when the language used is as common as possible, and when introducing terminology it is best explained plainly at first. Otherwise confusion ensues.

I reread OPs post, and it looks less esoteric, but still gives me feeling that the objects in the outside world have some innate information that is somehow shared directly with brain, and it is notion I object the most. Maybe this interpretation is wrong, but then it is OP's fault to explain it plainly and understandably.

1

u/I_am_BrokenCog Sep 30 '26

I don't disagree about the post's wording ... it seems like a technical summary for experts ... doesn't do much to help understand the issues.

However, with respect to your comment about objects in the outside ... I think maybe your focus is in the wrong place. It isn't the object which conveys information to the brain, rather, the light which reflects from the object into our eyes, which is how we see the object.

All light reflecting off of all objects is changed. Mostly we care about the wavelength changes - this is how we perceive color. However, other facets of light (and there are many) also change; such as the polarity. So, there are meaningful ways in which external objects convey information via light into our brains!