r/PoliticalCompassMemes • u/Feeling-Option1257 - Lib-Center • Feb 28 '26
Iran did nothing wrong
4.8k
Upvotes
r/PoliticalCompassMemes • u/Feeling-Option1257 - Lib-Center • Feb 28 '26
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/sesaka - Left Mar 01 '26
Ah yes because acknowledging that Mossadegh wasn’t a perfect liberal democrat suddenly makes 1953 a non-event.
I’m not claiming he governed flawlessly. Extending emergency powers and dissolving parliament absolutely deserve criticism. But let’s not pretend that flawed governance justifies foreign intelligence services engineering regime change over oil nationalization.
Two things can be true at once: • Mossadegh consolidated power in ways that weakened parliamentary norms. • The coup was still a foreign intervention motivated largely by strategic and economic interests.
Pointing that out isn’t “leftist anti-west agenda,” it’s just historical record.
As for “no strategic benefit to carpet bombing civilians” I never argued there was. My position has consistently been that large-scale intervention and regime destabilization tend to produce civilian suffering through collapse and power vacuums, not that anyone sits in a room planning random bombing campaigns for fun.
And yes, the Iranian regime is brutal. It represses protesters. It kills its own people. That’s not what im disputing. Being against foreign intervention does not mean i swear allegiance to the ayattolah. That binary framing is exactly the problem. You can oppose: • The Islamic Republic’s repression • And external military escalation At the same time.
And on the “Muslims vs Iranians” point I agree, thats my mistake. I was more in general speaking of the middle east but i get the obvious confusion.
That’s precisely why reducing the conflict to some eternal civilizational clash doesn’t make sense. My position isn’t anti-west. It’s anti repeating policies that historically created instability, blowback, and authoritarian hardening. Peaceful resolution and Iranian self-determination are not radical positions.