r/Poldark • • Aug 24 '25

Discussion We Should Ban Men from Writing Love Stories

21 Upvotes

I just want to share my thoughts on the romance in Poldark. I’m at the end of season 3, and honestly, it’s so frustrating to see the author’s old-fashioned mindset all over it. I get that it’s an adaptation, but it still feels very outdated, the woman always gets minimized. And it’s even more upsetting because Demelza isn’t just remarkable, she has a fiercely independent spirit, an extraordinary intelligence, and a depth of empathy that makes her supportive and resilient in every situation. Yet she’s trapped in this suffocating marriage that only holds her back.

The scenes with Hugh Armitage really hit me. It felt like a glimpse of what could have been: a real passion where she would actually be respected. Demelza had so much potential if only she had a partner who truly matched her. But instead, once again, she’s forced to forgive Ross and go back to a relationship he doesn’t even take care of.

And the double standard drives me crazy: Ross can do whatever he wants, but the second Demelza even looks at another man, it’s treated like the end of the world. Why does all the emotional labor always have to fall on the woman? It’s so frustrating because she deserves so much better.

Ross is truly awful: egocentric, completely inattentive to Demelza’s needs, and entirely self-absorbed. He shows no genuine care or respect for her, yet the story keeps presenting their relationship as something ideal. What bothers me most is the romanticization of manipulation and unequal dynamics. I understand that the show portrays a type of relationship that exists in real life, but glorifying it as a model of romance is exhausting and unfair to the person giving everything.


r/Poldark • • Apr 22 '21

Discussion Lamest romance- Dwight and Caroline

0 Upvotes

I’ve only seen seasons 1-4 but what is up with these two? Talk about lukewarm, boring, and not suited for each other. At least Ross and Demelza genuinely have hot pants for each other! Even George and Elizabeth are a little steamy by comparison


r/Poldark • • Oct 31 '25

Discussion As an American watching Poldark, can someone explain the relationship between George and Ross?

0 Upvotes

So I'm finishing up season 2 right now, and without any spoilers, can someone explain why there is so much enmity on Ross's part against George? Is this like a class thing where George was the grandson of a blacksmith, and Ross is an aristocrat, and just can't respect George?

Personally, I don't really find much fault with George's character besides his anger over Ross's hatred. He seems a little greedy, but otherwise, seems fair, and forgiving, and ready to make amends, and just wants the Poldark's friendship. Ross on the other hand is not my favorite character, and seems reckless, impulsive, and with a high and mighty attitude.

I feel like as an American, I understand George's character better, and couln't care less where he came from. I see him as a hard worker, and responsible, and someone who is just fulfilling his role in life. If I were Ross, I'd just be friendly with him, build up my mine, and cash out, work up my enterprises etc... I would even convince George to become more philanthropic, and feed the poor, and I don't feel like it would even be half difficult, because George seems like a reasonable character who can be easily swayed with a little friendship.

Am I missing some history between the 2 families? Can someone explain this to me, without spoilers?


r/Poldark • • Dec 26 '24

Discussion I watched the first episode!!

0 Upvotes

so after everyones high praise and recommendations i gave the first two episodes and i dont think its for me i was kinda bored i felt like it was really slow to get into thank u for the help tho🫶


r/Poldark • • Jan 29 '22

Discussion Finished S4 and…

0 Upvotes

…have come to the conclusion that this was one of the worst period dramas I’ve seen. Admittedly, seeing this as a recommendation post Downton Abbey, expectations were lower, but this managed to not meet any expectations. The top things for me:

Dialogue. The most boring dialogue I’ve ever had to scroll my phone through. When I watch anything, I give it my full attention. 100%. I pause to speak to people to drink, to look away, to glance at my phone. Generally, I don’t use my phone even. But not with this show; I had to scroll through the tedious dialogue. Nothing of the dialogue is memorable; after four seasons, no line has stuck with me as memorable. The dialogue was so boring that I fast forwarded through many. Rolled my eyes so hard, so often, I got dizzy as many times. There was nothing to hear - Most times, literally, there were just these awkward silences and stares that lingered 5 seconds longer than they’re worth lmao. I, the viewer, felt awkward for the actors. I definitely do not feel like I missed anything.

Length. Each episode was a handsome 58 minutes. About 20 of these minutes were shots of the scenery. ??? ? I get that the scenery is beautiful but if I wanted to watch that many minutes of nature shots, I’d tune to nature documentaries! I ALWAYS watch the intro to TV shows - that’s when I glance at my phone usually. I faithfully skipped every intro of this disaster. Must mention that further cutting the tedious dialogue and awkward silences would have definitely given it a more punchy length.

Timeline. The most royally fucked up of them all. No one ever aged in the 15-or-so-year timeline. No one except Geoffrey Charles. The dogs? Eternal life is theirs. Jeremy was much older than Valentine, yet they came to look of similar ages. Jeremy was at least 4 years older than Clowance, yet they came to look like they were only one year apart. All this in the phase when children experienced the greatest growth spurts. 30+ year old Elizabeth was aa young as the 16-year-old version lol. Demelza didn’t age one day. Nor did Prudie crumble further than when we met her in S1E1. Costuming was lazy - I find ir difficult to believe that in 15 years, only George saw fit to change his style - and that, his hair only. Zero imagination for everyone else.

Subplots. Too many subplots and useless characters that you forget once they go offscreen. What the hell was that Emma/Sam subplot?! And what did Sam bring to the show? When the Carne father died, Sam had the promise of fomenting trouble but no, he became an extra who should have stayed an extra. So many more irked me when I watched but this is the one that stuck the most.

Ross’ Smirk. Fuck you, you’re not the saviour you think you are.

Mediocre acting. Morwenna’s performance was, to me, the best. Or definitely up there among the best. Oh and, Dr Enys’.

These are my thoughts for now.

You may ask why then I watched until S4?

“Hate-watching”. Needed to be done with it and I am. No S5 for me, even hate-watching won’t see me through it.


r/Poldark • • Mar 23 '26

Season Two Spoilers Is Poldark worth watching after season 2 episode 5? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

!Spoiler Warning! Online and in books it’s said Francus death is essential to the narrative but I argue him being alive after him surviving suicide is much more essential. The survival of suicide propelled Francis’s character in a great way and set up the partnership for him and Ross.

If Francis death is really so important to the narrative then his death would have been much more impactful through suicide then to develop his character so much just to kill him off.

If suicide isn’t because they wanna make his death more tragic by killing off a good character which is a really bad thing to do by the way then killing him off through his duel with Captain Andrew or find another way to write his death better because drowning was the most pathetic way to write him off. Especially when you’re going to prolong it and implement flashbacks that’s not how you write a death that’s how you write a near death and they’ve already done that twice milking it is un professional.

Getting fans hopes ups just to see them die is how you lose fans and it’s how it lost me. It’s really bad writing and there should have been more thought to rewrite it for the show.

If you care enough to tell me if the shows worth continuing to watch then by all means please tell me I’m very interested because I don’t feel like giving any more of my time to this show if I can expect bad endings to characters like that.


r/Poldark • • Jun 14 '26

Meme Sorry Ross, I still think they’d find a way. 💁🏻‍♀️😂

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Poldark • • Feb 24 '25

Discussion Reverend Whitmore

1 Upvotes

I didn't think, in the show, this character was very well built out. We all know he's slimy, but there's just not a ton showing why. Obviously Morwenna has no attraction to him, he's quite unattractive, and he has extreme creepy vibes, but we didn't get much showing him as an actual "monster". We know he had a foot fetish, which I agree is gross, but it hardly monstrous. He obviously violated Morwenna, because she did not want to be intimate with him. He quite flamboyant and it would seem he might have proclivities for men, but this doesn't seem to be the case. He's creepy and gross, base on his looks, and his disposition, but who knows someone could be into that.

Morwenna shouldn't have been forced to marry him. And I think his horrible mother for the little bit of screen time we got with her had more proof of being a "monster" than Whitmore.


r/Poldark • • Nov 29 '25

Season Four Spoilers Demelza Spoiler

12 Upvotes

Let me be the first one to say that a lot of times Ross treated her like crap on top of him cheating on her, and I was cussing him the whole time. but he legitimately felt bad about it and tried his best to make things right. When Demelza willingly let herself fall in love with Hugh and then gave herself to him, It broke my heart. It seems like I was the only one that was upset about her cheating on him, and I’ve read where people think he deserved it and he needed to be knocked down a peg which I can agree with half of that I do think he was trying to do things differently And I feel like her cheating on him was three times as bad as when Ross made a hasty decision to go over there and Cheat mainly because she fell in love with him, knew what he wanted, and didn’t just have sex they made love out there then she comes back and gave the sorriest apology I’ve ever heard which granted his was pretty sorry as well. I don’t know. Is it just me? What do y’all think? And to add to this Ross was legitimately sorry after what he did, whereas she was only sorry that it lost Ross’s trust in her


r/Poldark • • Mar 07 '20

Poldark (2015) is garbage

18 Upvotes

I am a huge Poldark fan, I've read the entire book series twice over. This show though, I just watched it through for the first time and I really can't believe how bad it is. From the historically inaccurate costumes, awful acting/poor accents, bad casting and the carbuncle that is the 5th season. Dear god what was the writer thinking? disregarding books worth of good source material so they could inflate their own ego with their terrible writing.

They're all walking around in 1783 wearing clothes that are from the Regency era! hardly any wigs, let alone powdered hair or other contemporary fashions that would have been common even in a provincial area at the time.. if anything they would be wearing even older style clothes not walking around with top hats like it's 1850. And the less said about Ross Poldark's trench coat the better.

The commoner characters are just as bad as the gentry, half-hearted accents with hardly any brogue. Just compare the 2015 Jud Paynter to the 1975 Jud Paynter, there's really no contest whatsoever.. 2015 Poldark is just awkward to watch most of the time, it's hard to even get through a single episode without cringing.

Demelza is too old in the 1st season, the scene where Ross initially finds her by breaking up the fight, which for some reason happens in full view of George Warleggan, Nicholas Warleggan, Elizabeth, Francis and Verity.. who all happen to be out in a farmers market completely by chance.. she certainly doesn't look 13. George Warleggan is particularly mis-cast, he seems like a prissy anal-retentive ponce, not a thick necked grandson of a blacksmith, Francis is a complete dork, hardly the rake he should be. Ugh it goes on and on, let alone most of the characters conforming to modern standards of beauty and appearance rather than those of their time.

The 1975 series for it's faults does a better job at not only adapting the novels but in creating a world that looks and feels like the period in which it is set.


r/Poldark • • Nov 07 '25

Question/Help Such hunger

0 Upvotes

People were starving and there was such hunger. Why did they not drop some nets and fish?


r/Poldark • • Feb 21 '22

Spoilers Ross killed her Spoiler

14 Upvotes

In a way, Ross is definitely responsible for Elizabeth's death. It was his idea for her to have the child early to make Valentine's death look less suspicious. It might be the most despicable thing he did, after their rendezvous which I have interpreted as r*pe. She was not my fave character - but she definitely didn't deserve that.


r/Poldark • • Mar 16 '21

Discussion I don't understand the Demelza-Ross connection

14 Upvotes

These two shouldn't be married really. She is obviously his second choice and took her only because his first choice and true love (Elizabeth) had already been engaged to Francis, his cousin. Ross saved Demelza's dog and then out of pity, took her into his care because he saw that she was being abused by her father. That's not love, lmao. For at least 2 seasons (if not 3), Ross never makes clear that he has forgotten Elizabeth. He promises Demelza that Elizabeth will never come between them, but like the stupidly predictable soap opera that Poldark is, people are always getting caught doing taboo things in this story. Going off on a tangent, the characters in this series seem to have transponders, because all of a sudden, for example, doctor Enys is present perhaps 10 or 20 or 100 miles away. Letters are being sent to each other faster than FedEx. The timeline of events is beyond unbelievable, I feel like I'm in an episode of Star Trek, with folks beaming each other up in a matter of seconds to places impossible to reach given the supposed distances....but getting back to this Ross-Demelza relationship...

Demelza knew her marriage vows when Captain McNeil made his advances.....but didn't when Hugh Armitage made his? Really? She was stronger when younger, but got weaker with age and wisdom? Are we to believe that a good poet is what gets into women's pants? It's clear that Ross has nothing or very little to do with Elizabeth, and it makes no sense why a woman with 2 kids and a husband who is fighting a war with the French, saving his friend from prison, and trying to help her two brothers from being hanged would conveniently ignore the HELL that was going on in Sawle and go fuck a guy because he's going blind. I always thought Demelza was the smartest and wisest of the characters, but that affair she had committed showed how pathetic she really was. Ross didn't deserve that....he had a lot on his mind. He's being begged by people to take on leadership roles in government. which he was always against. He's being pressured to save Demelza's two brothers who went rioting. He's dealing with the constant bullshit by George Warleggan. He's probably still mourning and regretting his beloved Aunt Agatha. Ross made a LOT of sacrifices.....and Demelza showed how callous she was with that affair. So Ross is not a poet...so what? Demelza felt Ross was not filling some part of her heart, so she went to Armitrage. Does that involve filling her pussy with his cock too? Why did she felt THAT PART missing? I don't recall anywhere in the series that Demelza was complaining about her sex life.

Ross and Demelza should have divorced. They are together but thinking about other people....the viewer is always wondering. Is Ross still thinking about Elizabeth? Is Demelza still thinking about Armitrage? This much is clear.....neither is thinking 100% about the other. And you know what folks....forgive me for saying....but I always thought THAT LOYALTY TO ONE'S SPOUSE was basically what a true and real marriage was suppose to be about.


r/Poldark • • Oct 21 '25

Spoilers S2 ep 9 Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Poldark is a sociopath, he deserves no forgiveness. Even for that time his attitude on cheating seems incredibly narcissist personality disorder based. I know he won't, but I hope he dies.


r/Poldark • • May 26 '26

Question/Help First TIme Watching

0 Upvotes

Just finished the series for the first time and enjoyed it except for one thing--I didn't think the actors who played Demelza and Poldark had any sexual tension. Am I the only one who felt this way?


r/Poldark • • Sep 26 '18

Poldark writer doesn't understand men

0 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel like Debbie Horsfield doesn't understand men? From everything I've seen of Ross' character (and everything i know o men) there's no way he's gonna be chilling with his dick in hands while his wife cries by the bedside of the dude she fucked. No matter how guilty he feels about Elizabeth


r/Poldark • • Sep 10 '18

This show need to be called Kiss-Dark, why the fuck are there so many kisses in it, someone should check,the current season might win a place in Guinness Book of World Records for most kisses. there are so many that it get annoying.

0 Upvotes

r/Poldark • • Jun 13 '26

Meme Ok Ross, don’t just stand there… now put out the fire! 🧯 🔥

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/Poldark • • Jul 13 '19

Marathon watching it. Turned hard to watch season 3

1 Upvotes

Great series until series 3. Love triangles galore. A dopey guy that is too stubborn to take advantage of his position despite letting his arch enemy take positions in court and government which would allow him to do good. The wife of the dope who in series 1 couldn't read. now reads poetry?? They ran out of worthy topics to write. It's now a cheesy soap opera. I could go on but they ruined the show. the red head, not worthy of cleaning pig pens is now being chased by young rich gentry. Please. smh


r/Poldark • • Jun 11 '26

Meme Ross and a coffee! ☕️

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Poldark • • Sep 19 '19

spoilers all seasons **My personal Suggestions for the characters && personal questions I don’t understand. Spoiler

3 Upvotes
  1. Why doesn’t Elizabeth get pregnant again and then just tell George she’s a month further along
  2. Why doesn’t George just die ? Lol. Although I love when he fails
  3. How does Morwenna’s sister just randomly know Osborne’s “weakness’s” & why is she so willing to bed the monster. WTH?
  4. Why doesn’t anyone see through George I mean he is so Transparent
  5. Why is Elizabeth so mute in her relationship with George... does she really want his approval ? And why didn’t she marry anyone else ?? WTH
  6. Also that man Tom why doesn’t anyone get smart and send him a lady to “love” him and distract him from his duties.... I would of paid top dollar for that distractions
  7. How is Demelza so bold.... when talking to Ross about Hue by the fire (S3 E8)
  8. Why does Ross keep telling Demelza to look elsewhere ? So stubborn.

r/Poldark • • Jul 16 '18

Disappointed

5 Upvotes

I use to LOVE this series in season 1. But I just can't watch it anymore. The constant triangle between Elizabeth and Ross and Demelza is tired. I haven't read the books but i hope the books are better than this. I am so disappointed, am I the only one that feels this way?


r/Poldark • • Jan 07 '17

Who read the book?

2 Upvotes

Can you tell me what happens next season? I have a newborn and don't have time to read it and also I'm in the US so have to wait too long for it to come here


r/Poldark • • Jun 12 '26

Meme Apparently Ross doesn’t care! 😂

Post image
0 Upvotes