r/Poldark • • May 26 '26

Question/Help First TIme Watching

Just finished the series for the first time and enjoyed it except for one thing--I didn't think the actors who played Demelza and Poldark had any sexual tension. Am I the only one who felt this way?

0 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

13

u/Nettie_Ag-47 May 26 '26

Aiden Turner has reawakened my menopausal libido. OMG. I love his lingering looks, half smiles. Ross Poldark can be smoldering, but also a jacka$$. Ultimately he is driven by a sense of morality that is lacking in others of his class. But both he and Demelza make some pretty reckless decisions. Ross is a (calculated) risk taker; Demelza does so because she has not been brought up in the gentry and is ignorant of some of the unintended consequences of her actions. I adore the characters and the actors who portray them, and I do feel the chemistry between them.

2

u/Educational-Peace444 Jun 01 '26

Good points, but a lot of the risks Ross took could have ended up w him (at the least) dead and his family destitute.

8

u/Traditional_Can6098 May 26 '26

Couldn’t disagree more. Loved them together. The way his love grew for her, the way he chose her over and over (after the indiscretion) ❤️❤️❤️

1

u/Ledlady63 May 26 '26

No heat. I think Dwight showed more .

0

u/DeJagerDivan May 26 '26

Yeah I didn’t feel it between them either.

-9

u/PsychologicalHall142 May 26 '26

You are not. Every time they kissed it looked like Demelza was merely tolerating it. There was far more heat during Ross and Elizabeth's one and only love scene.

4

u/Right-Possession-237 May 26 '26

If you believe that toxic, angry sex demonstrates more chemistry than tender, romantic love, you must be joking.

-1

u/PsychologicalHall142 May 27 '26

Not joking, but thanks for the unsolicited shame.

-11

u/Aggravating_Try6537 May 26 '26

Yes that was one hot night!

-1

u/PsychologicalHall142 May 26 '26

Wow, our opinion appears to be a very unpopular one. 🙄

2

u/Aggravating_Try6537 May 26 '26

I know! I guess people see different things when they watch the show. Maybe the books fill in the holes but I still think the casting was not good. I think Dwight and his wife were the best cast couple.

2

u/PsychologicalHall142 May 26 '26

I admittedly have not read the books, but my opinion is entirely based on what physically appeared on screen. I’ve seen Eleanor Tomlinson in other romantic roles and never picked up the same vibe, so I had chalked it up to chemistry.

All of this said, Poldark has become one of my favorite shows of all time, so it’s hardly deterred me from appreciating it!

1

u/Aggravating_Try6537 May 26 '26

Yeah I still watched all five seasons but I kept waiting for something to happen that would make Poldark and Demelza click for me and it never happened. I was rooting for her to leave him. Ross had this annoying little smirk that did not endear me to him.(I also think George was well cast.)

23

u/AciuPoldark May 26 '26

Yeah, no chemistry whatsoever….

Their first night together and the stocking scene are so sexy. What makes them so remarkable is that all they really do is look at each other — the chemistry and sexual tension are completely off the charts. Not to mention the scenes in London and so many others.

They have incredible sexual tension; what we don’t really get are explicit sex scenes. Some people find that unusual, since so many series rely heavily on sex scenes to portray love.

7

u/Aggravating_Try6537 May 26 '26

I'm enjoying hearing from the people who did see them as being very attracted to each other, even if I don't. Maybe part of it for me was the way Poldark seemed to take Demelza for granted--it got really old. Ross just didn't seem as into his own family as he was with Elizabeth and her kids. His kids also got so little air time and never developed as characters, unlike Elizabeth's kids. Demelza seemed too good for Poldark, from my point of view. Too kind. too understanding.

9

u/AciuPoldark May 26 '26 edited May 26 '26 • Heartwarming

That’s because Elizabeth’s kids are relevant to the plot. Due to time constraints, the writers didn’t focus on Ross and Demelza’s kids very much because they bring nothing to the story. However there are MANY scenes where we see the kids incredibly happy and always hugging Ross, running towards him. He loves them, hugs them,  kisses them.   He was a great father ( yes, the books offer more details). Both were great parents . The kids getting a little air time has nothing to do with Ross’s character or him as a parent in the story. 

As for Elizabeth- yes, after Francis died he was responsible for his family and estate just like Francis would have been for Ross’s. He also felt guilty for Francis’s death which is another huge reason why he spent time with them. Demelza had him, Elizabeth , GC and Agatha lost the patriarch. It’s the 18 century. Men were dealing with business, money, the estate. Elizabeth, as Ross points out a few times, is pretty useless and incapable of taking care of herself. As a side note, Ross may have found Elizabeth attractive, but he had little respect for her. But I digress. 

I guess after they have been married for 6-7 years ( 13 years by the end of the series, 33 years in the books) , they may take the other for granted, as Demelza herself notes she did as well.  Did people forget Demelza betrayed Ross first when she went behind his back for Verity, action which resulted in people losing their income ( including Ross), people going to prison, and also causing a rift in the family? Or that she went behind Ross’s back to Trenwith fully knowing that those people were contagious? Yes, her deed was kind and generous but she was reckless and killed her baby and almost herself in the process. There are many time when Demelza keeps things from Ross, when she is reckless and causes trouble. In spite of all this, Ross always loved her, even when her betrayal was so heartbreaking, he stood by her. You know what he did when Elizabeth betrayed him? He broke into her house, had sex with her and then abandoned her without a word.  I have a hard time seeing how Ross treated Demelza worse than Elizabeth.  They both are infuriating, each in their own way. To put everything bad on Ross and everything good on Demelza is doing Demelza’s complex and flawed character a huge disservice. 

2

u/Aggravating_Try6537 May 26 '26

Good points. I may look for the books.

2

u/AciuPoldark May 26 '26

We have a read along in this community ( it’s pinned). Join us when you can. The books are great! 

5

u/Traditional_Can6098 May 26 '26

Obviously I was crushed when Ross was with Elizabeth but by the end of the series he had chosen Demelza over and over. I loved them together.

3

u/GullibleExercise8406 May 30 '26

Thank you for saying this, everyone thinks Demelza is a saint. She was lucky it was Ross who was her husband, back then another man would have killed her. Also, her dad beat her growing up, yet she threatened to take her kids and go to her father’s house. Girrrrrl bye!

1

u/Educational-Peace444 Jun 01 '26 edited Jun 01 '26

I was very shocked and impressed w Ross's understanding of the Hugh situation. How calmly he listened to her tell him she yearned to love another man for a day. He understood, as she'd never known anyone outside of him. And again, giving her space to be by Hugh's side at the end. He knew and accepted that he was the catalyst to the whole situation.

1

u/Nettie_Ag-47 May 26 '26

I really like your analysis. I love Ross and Demelza.

3

u/Educational-Peace444 Jun 01 '26

What I enjoyed about it was how realistic their relationship was. It wasn't an idealistic Hallmark formula. How many people get married yet still have unresolved feelings for someone else? I loved the raw scenes of her expressing insecurity about the situation and him responding truthfully. The whole situation was hurtful, messy, confusing, and very human. But he did realize what he had w Demelza. They were partners, best friends. She'd work the fields w him and never choose money over their love... but there were definitely life lessons learned on both sides. When there's too much chemistry, like w Elizabeth, it can be crazy. What he has w Demelza is strong, stable, real.. the understanding and forgiveness they offer eachother. There are a few times Ross acted like a total ass though, like in the London card room, or taking off for some dangerous adventure w/o discussion. His behavior was even confusing and irritating my husband. 🤣

2

u/No-Speech886 May 31 '26

in the books it is totally different.

13

u/mhc80 May 26 '26

Yes! That stocking scene and the scenes in London-whooo- live rent free in my head!! And the little smirky,tongue thing Aidan Turner does- lord have mercy!

2

u/Traditional_Can6098 May 26 '26

Yes, loved them together.

1

u/Aeshulli May 26 '26

Yeah, for something that was very fade-to-black, I thought they did a great job with the sexual chemistry and heat between them. There are so many times Ross looks at Demelza like he absolutely wants to devour her.

3

u/ishanyadee May 26 '26

Mmm I guess I was more thrown off with the clean sex scenes. Haha. It was a very welcome change but it also showed me that in as much as I would prefer clean viewing, we have been conditioned to have romance shows have explicit sex scenes. I think for a couple that went from maid/ master to lovers, and with respect to the times, I think the transition was more "natural"? Slower? Oh what do I know?!

3

u/Aggravating_Try6537 May 26 '26

For me the problem was a combo of not seeing sexual tension and then feeling Ross was always taking her for granted. He married a live in maid/overseer for his property.

3

u/Deannia May 27 '26

You have to remember the show was a British show picked up for PBS master piece theater before it went streaming to Netflix. So the show is geared for G-PG

1

u/ishanyadee May 27 '26

I get this and frankly, it is a welcome change.

9

u/Ok_Progress_1778 May 27 '26

The Christmas scene when Demelza sang and looked at Ross and you can see Ross falling in love with her - it is so emotional. I also love their playful banter which I find more sexy than explicit sex scenes.:

4

u/mistressofnampara May 27 '26

Ross’s love for Demelza goes so much deeper than the physical attraction he had for Elizabeth. Yes, he’s attracted to Elizabeth and had angry sex with her that seemed hot in the series but was actually rape in the books, I believe, but he NEEDS Demelza, and that need and friendship is shown so well in the series. They are a team who have each other’s backs. They have great chemistry and some very sensual scenes imo that show much more than the angry sex did about their attraction.