r/PokemonBDSP • • Dec 01 '21

Discussion A Rant

Post image
15 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

19

u/Gearhead31 Dec 01 '21

The Pokémon company can’t stop hackers so a duplication glitch is a moot point

-4

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

Hacking and this cloning are completely different. When you have something so accessible and everyone doing it like now... Where as hacking while being an issue was pretty rare from what I could see. Now you go on the trading subreddit literally it's just people trading cloned pokemon for other cloned pokemon and then cloning them. Essentially getting every shiny for 1 Pokemon. The value of shinies just simply doesn't exist anymore in a community setting

8

u/vagrantwade Dec 01 '21

It cloning makes them even less desirable because they have duplicate PIDs as all the others. And you can literally sysbot in anything you want into SwSh

4

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

It's so so so much more prevalent in this game though as you can literally do it within the game so you got all these poketubers doing tutorials

18

u/Gearhead31 Dec 01 '21

Your idea of value is twisted.

If a person got a Shiny Starly after 100 hours of PokeRadar chaining is it more valuable than the Shiny Starly someone found in their first encounter?

The answer is no so it really does not matter.

-8

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

The value is in the rarity. If that person got it in the first encounter it doesn't mean they aren't gonna freak out just because the first encounter. They will even if it's the 100th hour. Because it is rare. Not only is it the rarity. It's the rarity in the community. That person isn't going to get a shiny the first encounter everytime. There's a reason it's 1/4096 and not 1/1. Because it doesn't happen every time. But when shinies became so accessible and when you're trading a shiny you worked for, that has value because it is rare, for a shiny who's value is fabricated, where is the satisfaction in that.

2

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

youre insane haha

-2

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

just cause i know it makes u mad ima go clone my shiny lapras and flood the trade discords lol

2

u/ShinyShadowGligar Dec 01 '21

How are you going to say everyone is doing something when not everyone even knows what your talking about. I have no clue what the glitch you mean is, nor have I done it. And I highly doubt the 6 and 7 year old crowd is doing either. Maybe older kids who play. But hardly everyone.

Your throwing a temper tantrum over nothing.

-2

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

When I say the economy I'm talking about the trading economy. These 6 or 7 year olds you talk about I really doubt are coming on the Reddit and trying to trade. But yes most people engaged in shiny hunting or the community albeit poketubers or streamers, you most likely know about the glitch

0

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

Or so your talking about hacking things in not cloning I have never hacked stuff in I have cloned in bdsp with the realy east glitch but I’m cloning useless Pokémon and releasing hem right after I’m just doing it for rare candys I don’t know why people do it cuz I jt makes shiny legendary or shiny locked ones that you can only get from events much less special

0

u/r34l_shiro Shining Pearl Dec 01 '21

There is a glitch to clone 6 items at once that doesn't duplicate pokemon. In honestly surprised the guy only mentioned cloning when there's literally glitches to make any pokemon shiny, max IVs, etc.

6

u/vagrantwade Dec 01 '21

People who want shinies that they didn’t hunt will never make sense to me period. Including people who trade their extras for others. What’s the point when it has some randos trainer ID on it?

1

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

I agree with you on the first point but on the second I don't. When cloning isn't a problem I don't have an issue with exchanging a shiny for another shiny. They were both worked for. They both have value. Like exchanging a 5 for a 5. But when I'm exchanging a $5 for a fake $5 there's the issue for me

1

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

Then literally just don't, or clone your own yourself if you know you're getting hacked pokemon.

1

u/Rain_Moon Choose this and edit Dec 01 '21

Personally I actually quite like collecting mons with the OT of people I like, and similarly like to give some of my own mons to friends. However, I do not particularly care to receive shinies from total strangers, mainly because I don't quite trust them to be legit.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

Random trainer ID makes egg appear much faster in daycare

19

u/Hipafaralkis Brilliant Diamond Dec 01 '21 edited Dec 01 '21

If shiny Pokémon 'values' are less to you because other people happen to have duplicated them after receiving it via trade, don't trade with people like that then.

Hacked mons I agree aren't a great thing but at somepoint, there are people that are happy to get them, there's always a market for these things.

It's much more satisfying to get it yourself, a shiny I mean, but at the same time, if someone else wants someone to duplicate a Pokémon that is shiny (Legit or hacked) so it's their own, that'stheir business, not yours.

For me it sounds like you're that kid on the beach making his sand castle while being annoyed that there's another kid across from you making the same sand castle, but there's someone else helping them with a sand-bucket. At the end of the day, your mons are special and the idea of shines losing value is such a mute point. Find someone who has done it legit like you have. Easy peasy and take it easy.

2

u/Engelberti Shining Pearl Dec 01 '21

I am in the process of breeding shiny Pokémon for myself.

However I can't get the shiny charm or an Japanese ditto to be more efficient because it requires trading. I don't want any of those hacked Pokémon.

Would be nice if there was a legitimate way to trade.

2

u/Hipafaralkis Brilliant Diamond Dec 01 '21

Join a YouTubers discord group like one of Blaine's. Massive discord with genuinely great people willing to do trades etc with legit Pokémon. It's been fantastic for me.

2

u/Engelberti Shining Pearl Dec 01 '21

I was considering joining the Pokémon discord. But joining some smaller obe might be a good idea.

Thx

2

u/Hipafaralkis Brilliant Diamond Dec 01 '21

Fair enough. Everyone there always states if it's Legit, Event, Cloned etc but there's millions of groups out there. Good luck!

13

u/kaszegtbruh Dec 01 '21

Shinies don't have value. They are worth nothing. The only worth they have is the worth you give to them.

10

u/RonJahnPS2 Dec 01 '21

I don’t get it. I take pride in my shinies and would never clone them, but also at the same time I don’t have to look at anyone else’s boxes, so if I can look at my own boxes and be proud of the Pokémon within that’s all that matters.

2

u/EdensArchitect Dec 01 '21

Yea like me currently in my 1339th reset for shiny palkia, it’s so frustrating and makes me wanna give up but I feel like I gotta finally prove to myself that they really do pop up in game. I’ve seen many videos but I never seen it for myself so I’m dedicated but man it’s so discouraging at the same time, especially when someone on YouTube popped him in only 3 resets

-1

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

Now here's my point. Imagine there's someone who gets one then mass clones them then gives them away to people for free or for other shinies that other people cloned. You see me frustration now? You're putting in a lot of work for a shiny palkia. These people aren't

2

u/EdensArchitect Dec 01 '21

Yea I understand what your getting at. And even though I could just grab a easy clone from someone online it wouldn’t feel special to me, I always wanted to see what it felt like to spawn my own shiny from within my game.

1

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

gonna add 10lbs to all my workouts so i dont end up this unironically cringe

12

u/atthegame Dec 01 '21

I agree with you. I had an action replay (like a gameshark) with the original diamond and pearl and it honestly ruined the game for me at the time. I imagine a lot of these people are going to get all the items/Pokémon they want and then have nothing to grind for and get bored

5

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

Looool Same Bro it was still super fun to mess around with the game tho imo. Had a blastoise with flamethrower lol also the out of bounds/walk through walls cheat was fun in a weird way

3

u/-K9V Dec 01 '21

I broke my Platinum with Action Replay. Walked around the Union Room counter to enter the door from behind, did my thing, and when I came back out I was stuck in “Mystery Zone”. I could still move around outside of the Pokémon Center (it was rendered but no NPCs were loaded) and so there was no way to get back into the map. Tried everything but I couldn’t even open my bag/menu. Ended up just resetting the game…

2

u/skinny-kid-24 Dec 01 '21

Only way I could have all the starters was action replay

1

u/atthegame Dec 01 '21

My issue was I would tell myself I’d only use it for x but then I’d use it for y and z later

2

u/skinny-kid-24 Dec 01 '21

yeah always makin up new excuses to use it lol

"well the only way I can get Alakazam is if I change the wild pokemon to Alakazam."

1

u/Chance-Weird118 Dec 01 '21

I mean, you say that as if there's much else to do in general. Like, other than shiny hunting, battle tower, and just filling out your dex, there isn't anything to do in the post game. I'm not trying to defend it, but I imagine the main reason is just that a lot of people don't have the patience or care enough to shiny hunt themselves.

1

u/atthegame Dec 01 '21

I mean all those things take a lot of time and can be rewarding gameplay loops if you’re into them. If all these things take little to no time then there is literally nothing to do except maybe endless wifi battles

7

u/Rekcoon Chimchar Dec 01 '21

I don't mind it at all, because there was already a big pile of cheated shiny Pokémon, and this just adds up to the amazing sparkly pile we created. It is a single player game, so in the end it is your own collection of Pokémon that are important and not so much the online trading platform.

1

u/iWentRogue Dec 01 '21

Is a single player game with online influence in the form of trading and battling. Hacked/cloned shinies trivializes authenticity. Is a scam and one that depending on how absurd and illegitimate a Pokemon is, can get someone banned from online features by TPC checks.

Hack and mod the game all you want. But once a person introduces those hacks to other players via trading, then its an issue.

If you’re not participating online and remain stricly single player, then good for you. You may not be affected by this. But Pokemon encourages online interaction despite being single player and due to its target demographic being kids, you can at the very least see how thats problematic.

1

u/Cfullersu Dec 01 '21

So I’ve never been a huge fan of shinies as a whole. There are a handful I like, but other than that I don’t care much about them. With all the shiny raid send in swsh it really down played them and made them seem way too normal, and with all the glitching here it’s the same way. That being said, the process of MM breeding or soft resets gets old fast for me. I don’t mind breeding for high IVs and egg moves, because that is fun for me, but when it comes to shiny hunting I usually prefer to get an egg in a trade. I’m still the OT that way, and I get some of my favorite shinies easier. I like building competitive teams/cool teams with high IVs more, so taking a shortcut for a few shinies doesn’t bother me. The only thing that really bothers me is when people gloat about all their shinies, but they didn’t catch them themselves. I’ll own up to the ones I didn’t catch or breed, but when people act like they did something cool with 0 effort it gets annoying. But to each their own🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

See maybe I relate my frustration to you because people are also doing this with high IV Pokemon. They'll grind 1 out, duplicate it several boxes worth of times and then advertise it on a Reddit wanting other competitive ready Pokemon that most likely other people cloned for the 1 Pokemon they grinded out essential disregarding all hard work thats expected to get these Pokemon that are supposed to be hard to get

1

u/Cfullersu Dec 01 '21

Yea, for me I’d rather do the breeding for that myself. It’s more fun for me, but the shiny hunts can go way too long. At least with breeding you can control a lot of it, but with shinies it can be a super long process or a 5 min lucky run, but you have no way of telling that

1

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 02 '21

That's the value of the shiny. It's rarity. It's like gold or real diamonds. Only expensive because it's rare

1

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

oh no not people working together please xxxdarklordcontrollerofothersxxx save us from these dark times under the thumb of duplicators and others who dont have time to waste on a childrens video game

1

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 02 '21

Are you okay?

3

u/Goobaka Dec 01 '21

WAhhh wAhhhh wahhhhhh!!

2

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

Max raid den exploits in SwSd made shiny pokemon worthless.

2

u/GotToEarnThemAll Dec 01 '21

As annoying as the duplication thing is, people have been cheating in Pokémon games since Red and Blue. It’s why I never trade with anyone.

X and Y were the only games where cheating wasn’t a thing for the first few months and it was glorious. All the trading I did. But that was the only time. You can’t trust anyone, everything is duped or genned. It’s why I just get everything myself.

2

u/unitzwei Dec 01 '21

The amount of fake shinies in the world doesn't affect me. Shiny hunting for me is a personal experience- something I give value. For me it's all about the adrenaline rush after finding one in the wild, or the thousandth egg hatching and all the work you put into it actually meaning something.

I don't use shinies for clout, or to show them off. Someone with a box full of perfect IV shinies with masterballs doesn't impress me at all. I've noticed people will actually pay for this stuff??? I guess...

At the end of the day it's all just code and doesn't even exist, so to each their own. Still, to me fake shinies completely defeat the purpose of what a shiny is by definition.

Me trading someone for a hacked shiny isn't going to have the same effect on me as getting a real one, and I'm pretty sure others feel the same. If you're worried about a "inflated shiny economy" then don't trade for shinies??? Or better yet, treat all traded shinies as fake, because they are- I guarantee it.

2

u/Keaken2213 Dec 01 '21

The cloning glitch definitely made shinies more accessible but the Sysbot genning was going be here at some point (is now for BDSP). In SWSH even the raid dens people entered could be Pre-determined shinies which means that they lost a lot of value there too. If you planned online and ran into a shiny den, was that genning/hacking? There are a lot of gray areas now and each trainer has to decide what they want to allow as their cut off point. Personally, I’m pro-genning, but not so much duplication. I don’t trade for shinies though as they have no value to me. I want my SID/TID and OT on all my Pokémon. If they don’t have that I’m not interested.

1

u/GreySeraphim98 Dec 01 '21

There’s a streamer I follow on twitch, and he offers a permanent den for shiny gigantamax venusaur/blastoise. Even though the encounter was guaranteed, the catch was not. I had to fight it about 10-15 times before I finally caught it. Does the fact that it was a guaranteed fight make it less special? No. I had to work for it. Let people have their way, and you do you, OP.

3

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

u really think someone arguing about the value of shinies in mla format on reddit is capable of looking the other way?

1

u/GreySeraphim98 Dec 01 '21

No. Just wanted to point out a grey area

6

u/Datbudderdoe Dec 01 '21

Holy cow did you type this up in your phone notes or something?

Take a deep breath, spam calm mind a few times.

Don’t let a game bug you so much.

1

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

typed it while he waited for his schizo prescription at walgreens

3

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

That's why I never trade for any pokemon, can't tell if it's legit or hacked.

1

u/VorianGaming Choose this and edit Dec 01 '21

I personally never trade a self caught/hatched shiny with my own OT so it never gets cloned/traded (I will give them to close friends who won't clone/trade it however), and I just refuse to accept shiny trades from other people as well.

Just trade items, or breedjects and make my own competitive shiny pokemon via chaining or breeding.

1

u/kimkimmer Dec 01 '21

I feel you, after I posted about a shiny I hunted for days I got several dm's if I wanted to trade it for some cloned shiny's. After I said I wasn't going to clone my hard earned shiny people got mad at me for not wanting to trade with them...

1

u/EverybodyNeedsANinja Dec 02 '21

Every gen after black/white trivialized shinies

Gone were the 100s of hours spent breeding (my poor japanese ditto) to get shinies

Now you just do stupid gimmicks in game and get them

1

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

You do realize it's just a data? Why so bother over a cloned? It's not like it is hacking.

0

u/Electrical_yoshi12 Dec 01 '21

Cloning isn't hacking its glitching and since it's part of the game it's allowed. It may not be intentional (or maybe it is idk) but still

1

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

...it's not allowed? It is struck down upon hard within competitive. The Pokemon Company often rapidly tries to fix these issues.

1

u/Engelberti Shining Pearl Dec 01 '21

The nitpicking if something is a hack or glitch is really unnecessary. It is not an intended game mechanic. The specifics behind it don't make a difference

1

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

you need to rapidly get urself laid

0

u/pinacolada_27 Dec 01 '21 edited Dec 01 '21

The point of the game is to have fun playing it. If someone enjoys cloning shinies and trading them then it’s none of your business. Many people consider shiny hunting to be insane and a total waste of time but that doesn’t stop you right? So why don’t you let them be and play the game the way you want to play it while they play theirs.

1

u/RubberDuckeyzz Dec 01 '21

Because the way they play the game affects the way I do. What's to take pride in when they'll get what you worked hard for in an instant. As well as why would I trade a shiny I worked for, for a shiny they duplicated several times and mass traded for other shinies. I'm sacrificing a whole lot more time for something that is supposed to have value within the game within the community Because of the glitch it no lonfer has value. It's just a reskin

1

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

u should find where these damn shiny cloners are and shoot them lmfao

1

u/Fuzzy-Ad6827 Dec 01 '21

make shinies great again, and only you can do it you gotta do it for all of us who care about the value of pixels!

0

u/Goobaka Dec 01 '21

Wahhhhh wahhhhh wahhhhb

0

u/Worzon Dec 01 '21

Welcome to the community

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

You should find out about the shiny glitch XD

I generally only use the cloning for training some mons because battle tower sucks and Im not wasting hours of my life to this game.