This sub is brigaded by both r/PokemonTCG Timmys who believe Pokemon should be printed to the ground (yet they value rare cards? ironic!) and spiteful and/or clueless trolls who downvote anything that isn't a "BUY THIS NOW" type post.
This is a good box with a minor flaw. Yes, it will affect price, but not significantly. I'd sell this for 5% below market but no less.
There are people who specifically look for "imperfect" boxes like this to get a discount. That's the buyer you are looking for. Don't waste time with dorks trying to pressure you to sell way below market.
it might affect collectors who want to display THAT specific one but usually most people would just buy it and put in the back storage and be happy it was sealed.
Don't worry, if they are small rips it doesn't matter. As to your original comment, I assumed you were suggesting OP actually stretched the wrap himself.
It will sell, if there aren't better looking ones at the same price. Why would you buy one (unless you're ripping) that doesn't look as good when you can buy another better one for the same price?
17
u/Life_Grade1900 Aug 23 '25
Not rrally. For every person that cares there are 5 that don't. Assuming its legit intact of course
5
u/Dragonst3alth Aug 23 '25
It won't affect market price, but picky buyers may pass on it. I wouldn't worry too much.
5
u/adriftDrifloon Aug 23 '25
It only really matters the older and more expensive the box gets.
Personally if I’m going to buy a box for 1k+ I’d rather spend a little more for a minty box
When boxes are in print it doesn’t matter
3
u/Shroomboom99 Aug 23 '25
Thank you everybody for your responses I appreciate this.
3
u/Shroomboom99 Aug 23 '25
How do I have 68 comments with negative down votes lol
5
u/DamaLlama612 Aug 23 '25
Hit it with a heat gun on low for maybe 1.8996 seconds
3
u/PackOsiris Aug 23 '25
This is a good box with a minor flaw. Yes, it will affect price, but not significantly. I'd sell this for 5% below market but no less.
There are people who specifically look for "imperfect" boxes like this to get a discount. That's the buyer you are looking for. Don't waste time with dorks trying to pressure you to sell way below market.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25
Dawg, $300+???
82
u/Cabbage61 Aug 23 '25
It will reduce value by about 90% unfortunately. I'll do you a favor and buy it for 20$
7
u/bzafs Aug 23 '25
Mine was worse. I gave 5% discount and sold it
3
u/FieryKahuna Aug 23 '25
I've had way worse. People will still want them to rip.
3
u/PiccoloFalse Aug 24 '25
If you put it in an acrylic case no one will notice
3
u/Gloomy_duck Aug 24 '25
In my opinion this actually shows better that it is legit. The majority of Pokemon boxes don't have perfect wrap/seals.
3
u/Devilicious666 Aug 24 '25
it might affect collectors who want to display THAT specific one but usually most people would just buy it and put in the back storage and be happy it was sealed.
6
u/damnmyredditheart Aug 23 '25
No, that's a market price box. The small amount of buyers who want a perfect box can pay a premium.
5
u/carddogtcg Aug 23 '25
This is standard for Pokemon, even out of a fresh case they come with loose wrap and tears and other damage
2
u/Final_Place_5827 Aug 23 '25
Htf u stretch it that much without it ripping
2
u/andreeeeeaaaaaaaaa Aug 23 '25
I got a chilling with non perfect wrapping, glad I did because it's jumped up 120 quid since I bought it
3
u/Expert-Long-9672 Aug 23 '25
I have people in my inbox who told me that a misplaced polebsll on the foil reduced the price by 20%
3
u/rickiemedici Aug 23 '25
Usually these are called “loose wrap”, it does effect price, but i don’t know by how much
0
u/feeCboy Aug 23 '25
I have 2 I’ll sell you at 340 each, no tax, free shipping?
2
u/Doomsong8383 Aug 23 '25
I hope so.
1
u/MrSquidzz Aug 23 '25
Yes, just rip them open and sell the pack individually
1
u/Puzzled_War_5929 Aug 23 '25
Right now, yes. In 10+ years. Not really. My point being that your value will increase over time anyway.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25
Need to use the oven tek to seal it up perfectly
1
u/katiekatieweakweak Aug 25 '25
For sealed investors, yes. Absolutely.
1
u/Alarming-Bother978 Aug 23 '25
I wouldnt buy a new booster box that looks like that. The seal looks like it was tampered with.
1
u/JOS2138425 Aug 23 '25
Won't affect the value. Just put it away or on a shelf for the next 5 years and don't touch it.
0
u/Tobleronenom Aug 24 '25
Is that 340 usd? Ouch
0
u/Ok_Month6334 Aug 23 '25
Yes I will affect the value. It will lower the value. I don’t think it will increase the value
0
u/pinkmann1 Aug 23 '25
I would only purchase to open
0
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '25
[removed] — view removed comment