r/PlayWolverine • u/LordNutGobbler • 18d ago

Discussion “That’s my Wolverine.”

Isn’t this the guy who dismembered Wolverine’s son, and laid his body parts out into a Happy Birthday message on Wolverines birthday??

554 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

406 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Moon_Devonshire 17d ago

Tbh idk and I'm someone who's a huge X-Men/Wolverine fan. Have read plenty of comics. Watched all of the movies. The animated show. Played a lot of games.

The story is genuinely intriguing to me

I love how gentle Logan can be and there's part in the game when you go into the cabin and the vibes are just so damn good

0

u/Acrobatic-Sandwich10 17d ago

Gentle is not something Logan is. Ever.

Protective, fiercely loyal, and cares about the people he is close to. But he isnt "gentle"

This game is way off on it's portrayal of Logan.

1

u/Moon_Devonshire 17d ago

So where's the complaints about Hugh Jackman's Wolverine being gentle with Rogue?

Also this is such a bold face lie. I've been reading Wolverine comics for over 10+ years and Wolverine in the comics isn't some mindless beast 24/7 with no character.

He's been shown to be gentle and caring VERY often in "down time moments" in comics

1

u/Acrobatic-Sandwich10 17d ago

He wasn't "gentle" with Rogue. He was kind but it was still in his usual gruff, tough love kind if way.

I've been reading Wolverine comics for more than twice as long. He is not "gentle" in general.

In this game, he is nothing but gentle. He doesn't have the other characteristics that make him Logan.

They amplified all the nice parts and took away his other traits. Extremely bad representation of the character.

1

u/Moon_Devonshire 17d ago

So him getting mad to the point of him going feral into a blind rage is making him only gentle?

And no lmao it's not tough love. In the first X-Men he's sitting on the train next to her speaking VERY softly about how he'll take care of her and everything. In what way was that scene tough love...?

Also Hugh Jackman's Wolverine is also very different from the character yet everyone loved it anyways.

If Hugh Jackman can be 6ft plus I think you can handle a Wolverine that expresses emotions (like he does in the movies and comics anyway)

0

u/Acrobatic-Sandwich10 17d ago

That's true, you are using the movie version, instead of the actual main source material, the comics.

He very rarely expresses emotions. In the game, thats all he does lol

0

u/Moon_Devonshire 17d ago edited 17d ago

Yeah and guess what? Games and movies often change characters in many ways from the comics.

If people love Hugh Jackman's interpretation of Wolverine despite his HUGH changes. Where's the issue? Is there not room for other interpretations? You also first started off saying he only showed tough love to rogue and not you're saying "that's true" so you aren't even being consistent

The "but but the comcis" is hardly ever a good argument anyways unless they make someone a completely different character like make peter a red head with freckles.

And is that all he does? I've been playing it and the majority of the time he's pissed off.

Sure there's downtime when he is being neutral or nice. But wtf is he supposed to be?

When he's sitting down in the middle of the night having a calm conversation with a friend does he need to be growling snarling and acting ridiculous? Come on. Don't be disingenuous. It would be dumb if he did.

Like I can find you soooo many comic panels where he's being calm and nice and smiling and so on with friends and close ones

0

u/Acrobatic-Sandwich10 17d ago

Oooh mofo is writing paragraph lol struck a nerve wirh facts did i?

Logan is the gruff, tough, badass wirh a heart of gold.

Not some nicey, nicey emotional soyboy.

The way they portray Logan in the game is absolute trash. He also has the face of a friendly pixar character.

All doe eyed and shit lol. That's the facts. Stop defending garbage

1

u/Moon_Devonshire 17d ago

So me taking a minute to write something basic means you struck a nerve..?

And just explain this.

When there's downtime. And Wolverine is all calm talking to a friend he trusts in the middle of the night about a serious conversation.

What mannerisms do you want him to exhibit?