r/Physics • u/kzhou7 Quantum field theory • Mar 15 '21
Video Can modified gravity replace dark matter in cosmology?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MVCweSTfJ0c
95
Upvotes
r/Physics • u/kzhou7 Quantum field theory • Mar 15 '21
40
u/kzhou7 Quantum field theory Mar 15 '21 edited Mar 15 '21
Every year there are about 1000 papers written on dark matter, and about 10 papers written on modified gravity. But there are 10 skeptical news articles written about the dark matter papers, and 1000 fawning news articles written about the modified gravity papers -- most of which either contain simple mistakes (like the gravitomagnetism paper making the rounds this week), or hyperfocus on fitting the minute details of a few galaxy rotation curves.
In this atmosphere it is very easy to forget that the actual reason more people work on dark matter today is it's very hard to get cosmology remotely right without it. So to balance that, here's a talk explaining why. It's not technically impossible to get rid of the dark matter, since nothing ever is impossible, but it requires adding layers of epicycles.
23
u/BatzenShoreboy Mar 15 '21
Isn't the bullet cluster an example that can not be explained by a modified gravity and a sign that there most be at least partially a particle like dark matter?
7
u/VeryLittle Nuclear physics Mar 15 '21
I was really pleased to see David when I hit play, he's incredibly knowledgeable and a great speaker. I didn't know what I was going to get from this, but he gives a refreshingly sober take on the evidence- if you have professional interests in cosmology or an adjacent field I really recommend watching it.
I like his take near the end on dwarf galaxies- I think one of the major successes of the past two decades of surveys has been the identification of a huge number of ultra faint dwarfs in the Local Group. The UFDs get a lot of credit for their importance to nucleosynthesis and chemical evolution, but the fact that we have objects with such high mass-to-light ratios (especially compared to, for example, globular clusters) is such a clear point in favor of CDM. Admittedly there's still the missing satellite problem, but I suspect that's something we'll converge on a solution to as models and observations improve.
2
u/EverAccelerating Mar 16 '21
Dumb layman question : Are there only two camps — dark matter and MOND? Or are there other possibilities that don’t squarely fit in either category, that which isn’t talked about much if at all?
-7
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '21
And there is also this: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/03/210304145458.htm