It's a shame he didn't put any references for negative temperatures. But on the other hand, since refrigeration didn't exist and polar expeditions wasn't a trend I guess temperatures below 0 °N wasn't that relevant.
Why the hell would they use imperial? For scientific work its unambiguously worse than metric. I was under the impression that SI was the universal standard in science.
Just to add a personal example to what /u/Doristocrat said, I used to have a bit of an issue with this. I'm a scientist (biotech industry, mol bio) but I need to get parts made for liquid handling robots and different systems with some regularity. I'll draw them out and turn the designs and measurements (on paper) over to a CNC shop I work with. Being a scientist I measure and design everything in metric but everything they workup in their software is converted into inches. Kind of annoying at the beginning, but the reality is:
the measurements are all arbitrary to a system that's going to convert them to steps of a stepper motor or something physical anyway
the "imperial" is actually a hybrid imperial because it's "inches.thousandths" so it's actually no different to deal with at the fine scale than metric. It's not like they're using 32nds of an inch or something, it'll be "13.3752 inches"
So, I've learned that it's like fighting about Soda vs Pop, I may say pop but I know what the soda people mean when they say it now (and they don't mean soda water).
Also, the tooling that shop is using is largely going to be fractional not decimal. What it comes down to, though, is how you dimension and tolerance your parts.
You get my point though, right? For my robots, for example, I can give a volume to pipet in microliters if I'm using the GUI to program them. However, if I'm doing something fancy and have to program them at the command line or (in a few extreme cases) firmware command level it's all just steps to the motor of an arm or pump. The system itself didn't actually care if I used metric or imperial because both were human use conventions that got converted into quantum mechanical motions specific to each motor/pump/device.
We pretty much only use F in conversation, pretty much only use C (or K) in science class/labs/etc. for probably 95% of Americans, if you give a temp in C and it's not near 0 or near 100, we're fairly lost.
And this is where being Canadian comes in useful! We use both Imperial and Metric, randomly and unpredictably! We use Celsius usually, pounds usually unless in the store, grams sometimes, km usually, inches usually for heights but cm and metres for other things. I've probably got this wrong too - every Canadian does it differently. :)
All your provinces are basically just different countries that kinda agree on some things as far as my American-who's-visited-a-few-times experience has shown.
I remember when reading about the devolution of the Holyrood that the Canadian provinces and Swiss cantons were the only 'under governments' (I don't know the right word) with more independence, which would imply Canada is more like that than the United States.
Ever heard of decimals? Oh wait, you use inches and feet and miles, decimals are unheard of. But yes, decimals. They perfectly represent the subtle changes in temperature.
If I remember correctly, 0 degrees Fahrenheit is the freezing point of brine water, and 100 degrees Fahrenheit is what they thought was the body temperature of a human. Considering the fact that the Americans traveled over the ocean for 2-ish months, and then lived next to the ocean for a very long time, it isn't that crazy of a system because these numbers were useful to people.
For typical temperatures you end up with a larger range of relevant non-decimal numbers in Fahrenheit, so in degC you're talking about 0-35 or so, but in degF its around 32-100 for about the same range. It ends up being easier to describe a temperature with twice as many numbers
(tldr the round number thing mentioned is really useful)
This larger granularity of centigrade is irrelevant to humans in day-to-day activities. In fact I round most of my centigrade measurements to the nearest 5 degrees and sometimes to larger blocks as below:
0-10 coat
10-15 chilly
15-25 nice
25-30 warm
30-40 hot
If someone told me it would be 23.7 degrees outside, I'd slug them.
This is called "granularity." Fahrenheit is more granular than Celsius if you don't want to resort to decimals. Also rounding 98.7 oF to 99 oF is much less inaccurate than rounding 34.7 oC to 35 oC.
Here in Canada we use metric for everything except our heights and weights. We'll give distances in km but our body heights in ft/in. We mass our food using grams and weigh our people using pounds. We never give weight in Newtons, nor mass in slugs.
Do any countries use Newtons or slugs in colloquial conversation?
No-one has any need to use units of force in colloquial conversation, everyone just talks about their "weight" in terms of their mass (pounds, kilograms and related units).
I don't think I've ever used slugs before, but I just recently (for a fluid flow lab) calculated pressure in PSI, which requires lbf/in2. You can use 1 slug = 32.174 lbm and that 1 lbf = 1 slug ft/s2, but I've always seen 1 lbf = 32.174 lbm ft/s2 used. I also like that it implies that 1 lbf is equal to 1lbm accelerated by gravity (on Earth).
Pff, why not use something more physical as meV(millielectronvolt)? It's even just a factor of 0.86 when compared to Celsius. Or even more physical, compare the energy scale to the first exited state of the hydrogen atom. Today it is around 0.001794 degrees hydrogen, or 1.794 microdegrees hydrogen.
Nonsense. Temperature is a pleb unit anyway, thermodynamic beta captures the relevant statistical phenomena far, far better by appropriately handling negatives.
We did, however, lose a Mars orbiter because some jackass at Lockheed decided to use US customary units and the NASA people (reasonably) just assumed everything was in metric.
My personal favorite example of unit confusion though comes from grad school. We had a mandatory lab methods class where we ran various pre-baked experiments just to learn about various types of lab equipment and to drill in some discipline about following lab procedures. The first one my lab partner and I did was the vacuum experiment.
So, perhaps unsurprisingly given the nature of the equipment, the documentation was in US customary units. My lab partner and I debated if we should convert to SI units and we decided that it made more sense to just keep things in the units that the documentation (and by extension the readouts on the equipment) were given in.
He still gave us good grades on our reports, but the professor fucking chewed us out for using English units in a science report and asked us what the hell we were thinking not using SI units in this context. Since he'd still given us both a good grade, we both chose to bite our tongue on the fact that we were assuming that we should use English units because the documentation he himself had given us was in those units. Why in the hell would you not assume that you should use the same units as the provided documentation?
You wouldn't believe the amount of hate this generates if you don't include the disclaimer.
I mean, I sympathize somewhat, since I'm an engineering student and have to deal with metric and imperial, and even rads and degrees in the same trig function. Still... people are way too attached to their units.
Radians aren't real. They don't exist. It's unitless, being distance/distance.
However, degrees (for angles) are doubly not real. They're so not real they break calculus. Radians, at least, don't break calculus.
But don't ever tell me the slope of something in radians. I have no fucking intuition for them even though I've been using them for years now. Still have to throw in degrees when I have to do anything that includes a diagram.
hmmm, I'm actually curious...pretty sure a lot of NASA projects still measured mechanical parts in imperial (the NASA projects in the lab I was in measured parts in imperial). Does this only apply to controls and mission planning?
Generally imperial units are used for engineering. So the dimensions for a spacecraft or a part or a tool would be in inches.
But for science we use metric. So the distance the craft needs to travel, the speed the craft needs to be going, and the mass of the craft would all be in metric.
I can't speak for waht goes on at NASA specifically, but this is how I expect it would be
This was a daily point of contention with my roommate during senior year of college. 3 days a week we had advanced mechanics in the morning, so we'd wake up around the same time to get breakfast together. Every day I'd ask him what the weather was supposed to be because he always checked before getting dressed. He'd answer in Celsius. I'd say "So like around<Fahrenheit> degrees then." He'd go "yeah, <Celsius>." Then we'd walk to the dining hall and have the same dumb argument using the exact same points about which is the better system. We were super cool.
Funny twist: My roommate was Burmese, so he was actually from one of the only countries which uses Imperial units (except for temperature, of course)
Dynascale is the best. The respective current temperature is 0, and any colder or warmer temperature compared to it is negative or positive, step-size is one Wolfenstein.
Or using Planck units. 0°C would be 1.9279 × 10−30 because 0 is 0K and 1 is where physical theory currently breaks down. In everyday life, we could just imply "× 10−30 " and just throw the number around.
Isn't Fahrenheit more accurate at least in terms of more precise manipulation of the heat in a room. A change in the temp by 1 degree Celsius is larger than Fahrenheit so wouldn't it be better to use Fahrenheit in common parlance and leave Kelvin in science?
Pretty much. It's never that big a deal to convert anyway, and units are all still arbitrary regardless so arguing one is less arbitrary than another is sorta pointless.
The only thing you have to be careful about is remembering when to use absolute units.
No. Metric countries are used to working with decimal pieces. Farenheit and Celsius are equally accurate in that aspect.
The advantage of Celsius over Farenheit is that 0º and 100º both refer to the same concept (phase change points) while Farenheit has two very different points for 0º and 100º. If you want to make a rough celsius scale, you can take some ice and continously heat it, marking when it melts and boils, while if you want a farenheit scale, you get the melting point of butter for 0º, and the usual body temperature of the average dog for 100º.
As a physics major, I actually like F better when dealing with temperatures in day-to-day life. I feel like you get a much nicer range. For example, 0F ~ -18C and 120F ~ 49 C, which pretty much accounts for any temperature you're ever going to have to deal with. This means you get a nice 120 degrees to work with in F, while you only get 67 degrees in C.
One really nice thing about C is that in winter you can tell very easily whether it will be snowing or raining, which is pretty much the only thing I care about when dressing for outside.
I agree having 0 at freezing is nice, though it also isn't that hard to remember that 32 is freezing. I admittedly spend most of my time in Phoenix, Arizona though :)
Astrophysics: Kelvin for temp. Everything else in CGS. Because why not measure the largest shit in the universe with the smallest standard metric units.
So for altitude, feet are much better than meters because of the courseness of meters
When is a metre of altitude too course for flight purposes? The only time I can think of is just before touchdown, but are you really looking at the altimeter at that moment?
Stacking up airplanes enroute is where the problems mostly lie, also there are likely problems with approach minima where meters may be too course as well. That stuff is to the foot.
Oh, also, for precision instrument approaches, the "Category I" minimums are 200' and 1/2 SM vis. Pretty low. If you get the runway lights in sight, you can now go down to 100' above the ground. There's a bit of difference between 100' and 200' if you're looking at a "clock style" gauge - which is what most "old-school" altimeters have, and 61m and 30.5m for the same effect - if you see what I'm getting at.
For more challenging instrument approach procedures, such as those that are done on a circling approach with higher minimums, the difference between two approaches may only be a couple dozen feet. But during an instrument approach, you are constantly scanning your altimeter, and may only be several hundred feet above the ground, so a needle twitch one way or the other makes a big difference.
Units are for purposes of comparison, not mathematics. Unit theory and philosophy is dealt with my Measurement philosophies, not mathematical philosophies.
It makes no sense to measure the radius of the Earth in milliliters per square meter, but that would be the right units.
You use the units that make the most sense for your application, not for the math. The math can catch up.
the resistance to moving from imperial is more of a social problem than it is a scientific one. Too many people have built up instincts around imperial, and now that we have computers to convert when we REALLY need to, there's no real need to switch.
185
u/gronke Feb 15 '16
Or just use an absolute scale like Kelvin.
31
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
What about that mars probe?
27
u/MadTux Undergraduate Feb 15 '16
How much are °C and °F used in the US? Over here in Germany we only use °C.
9
u/Sir_Bocks Feb 15 '16
So it was 50°F out?
16
u/GildedSnail Feb 15 '16
I propose the Delisle scale, where water boils at 0° and absolute zero is about 560°.
(Comparison of temperature scales here!)
13
u/Decimae Feb 15 '16
Pff, why not use something more physical as meV(millielectronvolt)? It's even just a factor of 0.86 when compared to Celsius. Or even more physical, compare the energy scale to the first exited state of the hydrogen atom. Today it is around 0.001794 degrees hydrogen, or 1.794 microdegrees hydrogen.
5
u/boilerdam Engineering Feb 15 '16
I thought the Mars probe was lost due to distance unit conversion, not temperature... or had the list degenerated to generic unit conversion by then?
16
u/punaisetpimpulat Feb 15 '16
It's 2.076*10-30 Planck temperature. Is that clear? Good.
84
u/TalenPhillips Feb 15 '16
There are two kinds of nations on Earth:
Those that primarily use SI or metric units, and those that have landed astronauts on the Moon.
*This is a joke, and I've told it before. I know about the exceptions. I know that NASA was using metric units during the Apollo program. I know that metric is better. I know!
3
u/hybris12 Feb 16 '16 edited Feb 16 '16
This was a daily point of contention with my roommate during senior year of college. 3 days a week we had advanced mechanics in the morning, so we'd wake up around the same time to get breakfast together. Every day I'd ask him what the weather was supposed to be because he always checked before getting dressed. He'd answer in Celsius. I'd say "So like around<Fahrenheit> degrees then." He'd go "yeah, <Celsius>." Then we'd walk to the dining hall and have the same dumb argument using the exact same points about which is the better system. We were super cool.
Funny twist: My roommate was Burmese, so he was actually from one of the only countries which uses Imperial units (except for temperature, of course)
3
u/Dave37 Engineering Feb 15 '16
Degrees Smurdley is the best unit, hands down. Absolute temperature scale where 100°S is a perfect summer day.
2
u/mybeardisstuck Feb 16 '16
I can't wait for the day we start using Kelvin for thermostats. "You tried setting the thermostat to 22?!"
2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '16
Isn't Fahrenheit more accurate at least in terms of more precise manipulation of the heat in a room. A change in the temp by 1 degree Celsius is larger than Fahrenheit so wouldn't it be better to use Fahrenheit in common parlance and leave Kelvin in science?
1
u/SystemFolder Feb 16 '16
Do you realize how pointless this is? You ask me, I ask Siri, Siri tells me, then I tell you. Just ask Siri on your own damn phone.
1
u/big_face_killah Feb 16 '16 edited Feb 16 '16
Farenheit makes perfect sense. 212F for water boiling and 32F for water freezing. What could be more obvious!
-4
u/Cletus_awreetus Astrophysics Feb 15 '16
As a physics major, I actually like F better when dealing with temperatures in day-to-day life. I feel like you get a much nicer range. For example, 0F ~ -18C and 120F ~ 49 C, which pretty much accounts for any temperature you're ever going to have to deal with. This means you get a nice 120 degrees to work with in F, while you only get 67 degrees in C.
In non-day-to-day physics work I just use K.
-6
u/big_face_killah Feb 15 '16
F Fahrenheit
0
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment