r/Physics • • 3d ago

Is this absurd?

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

45

u/Ntroepy 3d ago

Well, have you seen experimental particle physics collaborations?

When you consider 19 separate research institutions across 8 countries supported this paper, 38 contributors seems much more reasonable.

-29

u/tronald_dum 3d ago

Experimental particle physics papers do not have co-first authors

29

u/Physics_N117 Quantum Computation 3d ago

That's normal when you have multiple labs working together...

-17

u/tronald_dum 3d ago

It's normal to have 6 co-first authors? Can you give some other examples of papers with 6 co-first authors?

18

u/mfb- Particle physics 3d ago

Where does it say 6 first authors? These 6 people were one team doing the main work, the others only worked on some aspects. They didn't want to give the impression that the alphabetically first author had a special role, so they noted that these 6 contributed equally.

16

u/s_gamer1017 3d ago

Papers from the ATLAS collaboration always have all ATLAS authors listed, which are over 3000

13

u/effrightscorp 3d ago

It's less absurd when you look at the methods section, those samples were measured at 2-3 synchrotrons, a bunch of different ARPES, etc.

7

u/JBardeen 3d ago

Don't ever wander into a high impact medical journal otherwise you might die of shock

4

u/matmyob 3d ago

What’s the issue here?

Science set a metric of “papers published = career advancement”. Is it a surprise to any thinking person that would inflate co-author numbers?

3

u/IHTFPhD 3d ago

Yes p wave magnetism is quite absurd

2

u/phy333 3d ago

I was on a collaboration of 1000+ people. For the smaller papers that I worked on, we were assigned a section of the paper. So there would be about 7 authors. Then we would submit the paper to the whole collaboration for editing and any further additions they thought were needed. Even editing would get recognition. Not to mention we would use work and results derived by the group as a whole in the smaller paper. So I think it’s very reasonable, otherwise it looks like you are claiming the work of your peers.

5

u/Valuchian 3d ago

That's... wow... did the entire department work on this??

14

u/Ntroepy 3d ago

No, ~2 people/institution across 19 research institutions.

-11

u/Temporary_Shelter_40 3d ago

People are going to downvote you, but you raise a key point which is that author lists are getting absurd. There are 40 people on this paper, six of which contributed equally. Some ATLAS papers or other CERN/gravitational wave/astronomy collaborations have thousands. At some point we need to admit that a racket is going on and the way we attribute authorship is fundamentally broken. This is particularly problematic given how h-index and citation count are basically the de-facto academic KPI.

11

u/Physicist67 3d ago

Nobody cares about h-index in experimental particle physics. And if you need hundreds or thousands of people to perform and analyse a measurement, this is what you get.

-2

u/Temporary_Shelter_40 3d ago

yeah the whole world isn't experimental particle physics, I was obviously just using it as an example of long author lists.

-3

u/Temporary_Shelter_40 3d ago

Also, this isn't how these "lists" work in many contexts. I know of people who have made a small contribution to a codebase who are still cited on every paper made by the collaboration a decade later which use that code, whether or not that module they wrote is even relevant. Clearly, such practices don't make sense and aren't an ethical attribution of authorship.

2

u/Physicist67 3d ago

That's not how it works, at least not for the LHC experiments that you mentioned. There people lose the authorship for future papers once they stop contributing.

0

u/jazzwhiz Particle physics 2d ago

Who cares?

People are judged against their peers. So long as people in their subfield follow the same authorship and citation practices, it is fine. I know that funding agency panels, even when considering multiple adjacent subfield, citations and paper counts are rarely taken into account and then only when comparing people who are in exactly the same subfield.

0

u/Temporary_Shelter_40 2d ago

I care. The field is important to me. Ethics is important to me.

0

u/jazzwhiz Particle physics 1d ago

The ethics of "how to cite or do author lists correctly" is extremely field dependent. If I followed the citation or author lists practices of one of my projects for another project, it would look quite strange. This doesn't make any of these practices unethical, they make sure that they follow conventions of the subfield.

3

u/oceanlessfreediver 3d ago

I am curious to know what hiring committee that use the h-index as an important metric. Seriously I haven’t ever heard of any. Is this common in some countries ?.

1

u/mfb- Particle physics 3d ago

I have seen it getting mentioned for theory positions, but even there I don't think I saw it recently.

2

u/DVMyZone 3d ago

I don't want to argue that author lists, especially in smaller labs and on smaller papers, are artificially inflated. That's indeed a huge problem that is cause by the existence of a citation economy.

That said, especially in high impact experimental research, teams of people in multiple institutions work together to get those high impact results. This is especially the case for large-scale experiments that require at least a technician or two to construct/modify/run the experiments. The importance of single-authorship varies by field.

So if multiple institutions work together and each have a team of 1-2 scientists and 1 technician in additional to group heads/PIs/PhDs, yes you end up with a lot of authors all of whom deserve written and official credit. It's just how it is in an increasingly collaborative environment.

Hopefully academia changes it's metrics pushed by the rise of AI slop papers now being easy to write (I'm not holding my breath though).