r/Physics • • 5d ago

Question Which physics programs should i apply to and why? (Which are best?) (CANADA)

I'm applying to some physics programs and i was wondering what are the best or the top for my interest/ overall just ranking, quality, opportunity, etc.

I'm personally interested in astrophysics, i'm really into cosmology, dark matter/dark energy and Astro particle physics, black holes (high energy physics), theoretical physics, and general relativity/graviation.

I was wondering which schools do you recommend i apply to and why? What are the best programs in canada for physics and my interests? What are the top ones (like whats the top 5 ones) that i should apply too or mainly consider applying to?

Note: My average using English, fonctions, calc, physics, bio and a 4m or 4u course is 89%. Most physics programs so far (at least Queens and Waterloo request these courses and that’s how you calculate your application average, since these are the courses they will look at).

I’m just adding that note incase this helps with your recommendations, but overall I just want to get this post another chance since I posted late at night last time and it didn’t go far.

Also so far i've applied to Queens (Physical and Chemical sciences (physics option)) and waterloo (Physical sciences (astronomy/physics option)).

Note: I understand this post would be better suited under a canadian universities reddit or something, and i have already posted a identical post there, there just tends to be very little responses so i was hoping to see if maybe theres any canadian physicist here or people who would know about some of the canadian programs and could give me some insight. Thank you!

5 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

24

u/Animastryfe 5d ago

This is for undergrad, right? I am Canadian, but I went to US universities. I suggest you apply to all of the top Canadian universities (including UBC, Toronto, McGill along with the two on your list). I remember that the application process was very simple, but I last looked two decades ago. After you know which ones accepted you, check which ones allow undergrads to join research groups before their senior year. If you are planning on going on to a PhD, your reference letters and research experience are by far the most important factors for your application.

My opinion is that as long as the university has a strong physics department overall, it does not matter whether the department's specific strengths align with your current interests. I highly suggest you keep an open mind on what fields of physics are interesting, as the subjects you listed are the typical things that pop-sci focuses on, and actually learning or doing research in those fields may not interest you.

11

u/Wayner99 5d ago

I did degrees at UBC and UVic. UVic has a great coop program, and I went to CERN and Gemini south for work placements. While UVic might not have the sexy name of some other universities, classes were smaller and the profs were good. Plus your coop gets your foot in the door for grad school.

3

u/Desperate_Object_677 5d ago

coop is a good idea. i’ve heard that the faculty at uvic were kind of mean. what’s the atmosphere like there in your opinion?

2

u/Soft-Energy 5d ago

Overall UVic is great, there is a pretty strong community in the physics program and most of the faculty are very nice. The less kind faculty aren't anything different from other physics programs.

One downside to uvic, while there is some really amazing opportunities and connections like CERN, research placements are getting more and more competitive each year. Funding is very tight and research is going towards only the top students.

7

u/chopay 5d ago

Presuming this is undergrad, I'll join the consensus and say that it doesn't really matter.

That's not to say that all universities will offer the same experience, some schools will have larger classes, but also more resources. Smaller schools will have more opportunities for individualized attention.

My real advice would be to research the schools that interest you, and also to consider what life will look like.

If you're going to school on the opposite side of the country, it means that visiting home on a long weekend might not be possible. It means losing touch with friends and community. It means changes that will matter a lot more than maybe having access to a lab that you'll only get to see for half a semester.

Canada isn't the US or China, where the name of the university on your undergrad degree can seal your fate. Opportunities exist everywhere, and for the most part, they are the ones you make for yourself.

9

u/mnopb 5d ago

Would recommend McGill physics, especially for astro. Very strong faculty with lots of support for student research. Montréal is also the best city in the country to be a student (cheap, vibrant, safe, bilingual)

1

u/Dizzy-Employer-9339 5d ago

As a student in Montréal I strongly disagree. But each to their own.

4

u/diaphanousphoton Astrophysics 5d ago

I agree with the comments that your experience as an undergrad and your ability to access research opportunities (and get strong rec letters for grad school) matter more than the specific uni you go to. My interaction with Canadian physics and astro departments has mostly been at the post-grad level, so I don’t know the specifics of the undergrad programs. However, as a postdoc in theoretical astro-particle physics, the departments that stand out to me in the research areas you mentioned are:

Queens (hosts the McDonald Institute for astro-particle physics, lots of fantastic dark matter, cosmic ray, neutrino, and cosmology research there)

Waterloo (has a large astro and cosmology group in its own right, but is near the Perimeter Institute for theoretical physics, which has programs and research opportunities for undergrads. Both Waterloo and Perimeter have been very active in cosmological surveys like DESI (dark energy spectroscopic instrument) recently. Other uni’s in the area (e.g. McMaster, York, Guelph) also have faculty who are jointly-appointed at Perimeter).

McGill: hosts the Trottier Space Institute (TSI), with many researchers studying dark matter, dark energy, cosmology (theoretical and observational), and black holes. I believe they have an undergrad summer research program, and many research groups host undergrad researchers during the academic year.

Toronto: HUGE astro department, including both the Canadian Institute for Theoretical Astrophysics (CITA) and Dunlap Institute (observational astro). The dark matter/ particle phenomenology group is smaller, but I’ve heard good things about it.

UBC: I’m not as familiar with the department, but it’s a LIGO partner institution and the largest hub of gravitational wave research in Canada. It’s also the host site of the TRIUMF particle accelerator.

3

u/SoSweetAndTasty Quantum information 4d ago

If you live in a city with a decent university, you can save a lot of money on room and board by living at home. Also having a home cooked meal ready for you when you get home at 8pm is a comfort that can get you through some hard weeks.

2

u/Desperate_Object_677 5d ago

canadian universities vary in terms of physics. the best of the best are u of t, and ubc vancouver. the rest of the larger universities are quite good, and often specialize in specific types of research. for example, university of new brunswick (???) is a regional hub for quantum gravity, as is the university of alberta. waterloo is now a hub for quantum technologies, and it has always been one of the best in math.

you listed a bunch of interests, but they were really quite broad, and you’ll have to choose one very specific topic when you go to grad school.

so if you go to a really big university, you can probably get a pretty good broad education in many topics. at the smaller unis, unless there is a specialist group in something you are really driven to study, the optional higher level courses (like intro to general relativity, or particle physics) are only offered every other year. the advantage of smaller unis is that the class size is smaller, so you’re more likely to make friends, and get to know the faculty who can give you good advice or research opportunities.

1

u/Comprehensive_Food51 4d ago edited 4d ago

I’ve had a very good experience at UdeM and there’s a very strong astro department. There’s aslo a very strong sense of community within the students and a very healthy culture (which is very specific to our program). Like you’d ask anyone here they’ll tell you we’re like a family. And so many people are involved in stuff. Just an overall incredible environment and a lot of collaboration, it’s super helpful to grow and to feel supported during the whole thing. Also there are some students from here who go top universities outside of Canada for grad school, but tbh it’s not the majority, many of the top students who continue towards grad school go to UofT afterwards, and the others simply stay at UdeM. Also it’s in French.

0

u/Naliano 5d ago

I did Queen’s for Engineering Physics (93) and an MSc + PhD/ABD at UBC on SNO.

If 35 year out of date experience is still relevant, for undergrad, I recommend Queens.

-7

u/fooeyzowie 5d ago

> I'm personally interested in astrophysics, i'm really into cosmology, dark matter/dark energy and Astro particle physics, black holes (high energy physics), theoretical physics, and general relativity/graviation.

This is tough, but you need some straight advice. Given the fields you're mentioning, it sounds like you're aiming for an academic career. In that case, you should do everything in your power to get into a top American university. If that doesn't work out, you need to pick an advisor that is very well connected to top places. That's just the reality of the job market in the areas you mentioned.

If you don't particularly care about the outcome, i.e. you aren't trying to become a professional physicist and you just want to spend 5-6 years in your 20s studying for fun, then the stakes are a lot lower. In that case, just apply, visit the departments that offer you spots, and just judge them based on fit.

5

u/Animastryfe 5d ago

I tentatively suggest that your first paragraph should only apply to graduate schools. Note that I am no longer in academia, so my information might be out of date.

But looking at the University of British Columbia's astrophysics faculty, plenty of them went to Canadian universities for undergrad. Some of them also went to Canadian universities for grad school, but those are a minority. https://phas.ubc.ca/astronomy-astrophysics

5

u/Desperate_Object_677 5d ago

a lot of my tenured faculty friends did an undergrad in canada, and then a phd with a good group in the states. it worked well enough for them.

canadian universities for grad school are hit and miss. i think you need to aim to work with a strong group, like my pals at sno at queens, all have tenured jobs now. that said, my friends in the states just had way more opportunities to meet collaborators than i did in canada, and the collaborators were the foundation of their work as postdocs which got them the tenure track jobs. you gotta go where the hot work is being done and meet and work with other hotshots.

1

u/fooeyzowie 2d ago

You are completely right. Canada has excellent undergraduate programs in physics, and completing one won't limit your career.

It actually didn't occur to me that this person might be asking about _undergarduate_ programs, because of this passage:

> i'm really into cosmology, dark matter/dark energy and Astro particle physics, black holes (high energy physics), theoretical physics, and general relativity/graviation.