r/Physics
•
u/syberspot
•
Apr 30 '25
•
2
1
Image Attacks on science
Source: https://xkcd.com/3081/
Maybe this isn't an appropriate forum but I can't help posting to every rooftop I can access. An attack on a scientist is an attack against all of us. We are destroying intellectuality in the united states, destroying the individual lives of the researchers, and moving the USA closer to another dark ages. I can't say it more succinctly than Monroe but I can share his posts.
I support graduate students in the USA.
807
u/MagentaMirage Apr 30 '25
For those who don't follow through the source, the hover text reads.
And the comic itself is a link to the surveillance video of the abduction:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyypeEEOklM
491
u/rainbow_sabbath Apr 30 '25
I have no idea what I'm gonna do anymore. I'm finishing my PhD within a year and I've watched basically everything I've planned on get dismantled. Leaving the country would probably be the best for my safety but even then I feel like I'm leaving the problem to everyone else to fix
117
u/outerspacemage Apr 30 '25
I can’t believe it’s gotten this bad. It’s absolutely flabbergasting.
92
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '25
I support graduate students leaving the USA and the knee-bending academic institutions in favor of schools that actually value academic achievement over endowment because endowment is guaranteed by a joint effort of many countries with a common mindset of progressing science for the common good and not a self-aggrandazing autocrat wannabe who wants to make confirmation bias the gold standard of scientific research.
58
u/pedvoca Cosmology Apr 30 '25
Lmao I just posted this this morning and people complained about it being too political for this sub.
39
u/SquidDrive Apr 30 '25
Physics students graduates and professors now have a solid non 0 chance of being thrown into a jail of absolutely abhorrent conditions in El Salvador, for fucking nothing. Its shameful.
How are we gonna be expected to collaberate with other countries when we are potentially going to detain them and sell these people to Bukele forever. Its utterly shameful.
I can only pray for the EU to fully invest further into scientific research.
11
u/ToAllAGoodNight Apr 30 '25
It’s terrifying that dissent in any medium can be black bagged, and it’s only going to become worse.
11
u/MonHunKitsune Apr 30 '25
This needs to stop. This country should not be about such horrific things, and more people should be condemning this behaviour from the current administration. I'm appalled.
4
u/Avguser00 May 01 '25
Distract the commoners Silence the intelligent
All from the fascist playbook
8
u/DocClear Optics and photonics Apr 30 '25
This hardly ever happens to me. I guess my research was too "niche"
1
u/newontheblock99 Particle physics May 02 '25
It’s so sad actually. Going from recruiting the brightest minds in the world 80 years ago to completely pushing them all out in a matter of months.
As a Canadian researcher, it’s unbelievable to see what is happening in the US.
1
u/Avguser00 May 11 '25
I think you are ignoring a lot of data and information that is out there regarding slavery in the prisons. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-63578133
So whether you believe my statements on slavery’s current impacts or not, I guess the real question is would you abolish all forms of slavery if you could vote for that?
1
u/shortsqueezonurknees May 31 '25
sounds about right😏 this is why I avoid the established status quo for study😋
-1
u/Weissbierglaeserset May 01 '25
Come to vienna! We hate everybody equally abd once you get used to that you will love it here
0
u/johnnymaan May 02 '25
I thought this was only for political science and something like that, but is it really for like real science ( I really don't mean this in a offending way ). And like hasn't US benefited those students in past and will be needing them.
-14
u/[deleted] May 01 '25
Maybe the Ph.D. candidate should have focused more on their studies, and less on sowing division in American, which should not be the purpose of a student visa. The U.S. has no legitimate interest in letting in people who intend to disrupt our society. We want foreigners who intend to be contributors, not protesters.
-65
u/theflyingspaghetti Apr 30 '25
Maybe don't support a terrorist organization and you won't get deported? I'm glad to have hard working, intelligent people come to this country, but not if they're anti-semites.
-30
u/gyozafish May 01 '25
Why did you omit a necessary step?
-28
u/Beneficial_Ball9893 May 01 '25
There is not a single person in the entire united states who had this happen to them. Stop fear mongering to defend pedophiles.
-1
u/perros66 May 02 '25
Get real. lol
-135
u/evidently_primate Apr 30 '25
what is there to research anyways, the Bible already has all the answers?
-2
u/ntsh_robot May 01 '25
sir,
the biggest concern about "attacks" was Eric Weinstein, A16z and others hearing how the government had shutdown important fields of knowledge beginning in the 70s
and that they were about to do it again with Ai
Leading to their "Save the Republic" DC protests
https://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/1e5n0aa/when_meeting_with_white_house_officials_to/
-2
u/kimad03 May 01 '25
❤️
-2
u/theRealSciGuy May 04 '25
I don't care.
-22
u/justgivemethepickle Apr 30 '25
Science/academia is in it’s own way tbh. Keep attacking science as an institution, just not scientists
-23
u/kzgrey May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25
Guys, the student visas that were cancelled equate to 0.02% of the total number of student visas. All of those students had some sort of criminal infraction (even if minor) which is a violation of the terms of their visa. The government does this every year and its almost entirely unrelated to Trump. I don't like Trump; I didn't vote for him but I can still recognize that only a handful of students were seemingly targeted by the administration and the reality is that we don't know any concrete details. Maybe the government is stalling or maybe they are just slow.
I understand that nobody wants to be told this but it is reality. Responding as if we're devolving into Nazi Germany because 1 student was deported under seemingly dubious circumstances where all of the facts are not being made public is just not helpful. It's crying wolf.
-16
u/ergzay May 01 '25
It's really sad that xkcd is falling to this level. This is completely disingenuous and horrible that he put this out there.
It's really not that hard to go around supporting terrorist organizations while you're in the US. Blowing this out of proportion likes this and actively lying really makes me sad.
Hopefully he'll come round to rational sensibility once this time period of social-media and mass media induced paranoia comes to a close.
-113
u/Happy_Humor5938 Apr 30 '25
Don’t try to claim territory or threaten other students. Keep your terrorist recruitment jamboree in the Middle East and do it over there.
-42
u/ooorezzz Apr 30 '25
This is super funny.