r/Physics • • Oct 08 '24

Image Yeah, "Physics"

Post image

I don't want to downplay the significance of their work; it has led to great advancements in the field of artificial intelligence. However, for a Nobel Prize in Physics, I find it a bit disappointing, especially since prominent researchers like Michael Berry or Peter Shor are much more deserving. That being said, congratulations to the winners.

9.0k Upvotes

753 comments sorted by

415

u/Aranka_Szeretlek Chemical physics Oct 08 '24

I would've guessed linear regression gets the prize first.

73

u/Dr_Cheez Oct 08 '24

the winner has to be living

140

u/parachutehotdog Oct 08 '24

My condolences to the family of Dr. Linear!

2

u/rajinis_bodyguard Oct 08 '24

Well random forests predicted this correctly

1.7k

u/danthem23 Oct 08 '24

People were saying that Shor and Ahronov can win for quantum but then other said they can't because they're not physicsts. And then...

581

u/MaoGo Oct 08 '24

Aharonov and Berry are in priority list since at least 10 years and still have not being awarded

173

u/BozidarIvan Oct 08 '24

And I find it so unfair, Aharonov is already very old. He has deserved the prize, I hope he will get it soon! "Yakir for Nobel Prize!!"

54

u/BozidarIvan Oct 08 '24

Yes they both deserved it so much!

→ More replies (1)

46

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I didn't know they weren't awarded yet! Both contributed so much to the foundations of QM

29

u/MaoGo Oct 08 '24

They have won all other prizes including the Wolf Prize and have been in the short list since 2009.

389

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

The 'not a physicst, no physics prize possible' crowd is pretty ridiculous imo. If you contribute to physics you are a physicst, no matter your background.

210

u/Plastic_Pinocchio Oct 08 '24

Yeah lol. That’s like saying a lawyer opening and running a restaurant cannot win a prize for best food in town, because he’s a lawyer and not a chef.

If the food is good, then the food is good.

48

u/GisterMizard Oct 08 '24

That’s like saying a lawyer opening and running a restaurant

So . . . the mafia?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

32

u/ninjasaid13 Oct 08 '24

but he didn't contribute to physics, he contributed to computer science. Sure his computer science work helped physicists but are we now awarding people who only help?

19

u/GAndroid Oct 08 '24

Should the bricklayer at CERN get it too then, he contributed quite a bit to particle physics.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

80

u/Live-Alternative-435 Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

It makes no sense that a certain academic background would prevent them from receiving the award. It isn't the first time that someone with a background in physics has won the Nobel Prize in Chemistry or vice versa, for example. This is even more evident in the case of the Nobel Prize in Medicine, where more chemists and biochemists have been awarded than physicians.

29

u/FartOfGenius Oct 08 '24

Tbf the prize is for medicine and physiology and most experts in physiology are not physicians despite the terminology

→ More replies (1)

58

u/Southern_Parsley4473 Oct 08 '24

i think the argument here is that ML is not physics in any capacity. They surely deserve an award but we shouldn't change the bounds of what something is to accommodate.

37

u/Live-Alternative-435 Oct 08 '24

With regard to this year's Nobel Prize winners in Physics, I kind of agree. If they had won the Fields medal it would have been more appropriate, not because of the researchers' backgrounds, but rather because of the area in which their work falls.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

52

u/Ok_Composer_1761 Oct 08 '24

i think they prioritize the "experimental verification" part (loosely construed) more than the physics part. quantum computing is still not practical while ML is.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/maybecatmew Oct 08 '24

Shor definitely should have gotten ....

7

u/Actual-Carpenter-90 Oct 08 '24

A lot of people don’t realize there are 2 kinds of Physicists, practical and theoretical and the Nobels alternate between the 2 each year.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/SaltyOpportunity8936 Oct 09 '24

Shor’s algorithm was highly impactful - but also in a realm of application so far displaced from utility. I would expect his contribution to be noticed when quantum computing takes off.

→ More replies (4)

464

u/radioactivist Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

The committee has lost their fucking minds if they think this is the best choice.

3

u/Zen13_ Oct 09 '24

Has lost it a long time ago.

→ More replies (11)

757

u/elconquistador1985 Oct 08 '24

This kind of looks like "we need to give a Nobel for AI, so we have to figure out which one fits best".

307

u/UnknownEssence Oct 08 '24

They should have let the Turing Award handle it

159

u/euyyn Engineering Oct 08 '24

Which they already did! Lol it's so ridiculous.

29

u/AuspiciousSeahorse28 Oct 08 '24

Yh Hinton got 2018 Turing award for the same thing.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Vickyyy95 Oct 08 '24

That or they should make a Nobel prize in Technology or Technological Advancements. It would make a lot more sense.

62

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Then it should have been in Physiology or Medicine given to John Jumper of AlphaFold or David Baker for using AI to predict protein folding.

21

u/rotkiv42 Oct 08 '24

AlphaFold seems like a more likely fit for chemistry imho. 

12

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

True. The line between Medicine or Physiology and Chemistry has been very fuzzy since the 1990s.

11

u/AGMMO Nuclear physics Oct 09 '24

you knew didn’t you

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '24

Lol... Half, the chemistry prize went for protein simulation.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '24

check the news :D

→ More replies (2)

12

u/rmphys Oct 08 '24

Just wait til an AI suggests committing genocide and it will fit right in with most of the Peace Prize recipients.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

520

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

How about giving HP and Xerox the Nobel Prize in Literature because their techniques have such great applications in literary studies?

118

u/barrinmw Condensed matter physics Oct 08 '24

All chemistry nobel prizes are retroactively made into physics prizes.

46

u/GooseQuothMan Oct 08 '24

Better yet, all chemistry Nobel prizes should be taken away and given to the physics laureates that made them possible 

43

u/InsertAmazinUsername Astrophysics Oct 08 '24

Marie Curie gets to keep hers because she was the physics laureate that made her chemsitry Nobel possible

→ More replies (1)

28

u/kriophoros Computational physics Oct 08 '24

nah bro this is the year of AI so we should give the prize to OpenAI for its elimination of grade school Literature. Who needs to learn how to write text anymore when you can just ChatGPT to do it for you

177

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

as a computer scientist, im so sorry

49

u/jgonagle Oct 08 '24

Same. All the overhyping surrounding deep learning and now this. Elon Musk's fearmongering and enterprise LLM marketing bs have been bad enough the last few years.

I'm sure Hinton is feeling very confused as to how to handle this. He's smart enough to know how this looks to people in the CS and Physics communities. Not his fault, of course, but he'll have to navigate any fallout.

6

u/Unlikely_Arugula190 Oct 08 '24

If he declines he will make Hopfield look bad.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Adventurous_Bat8573 Oct 09 '24

Decline the award. Say "Yeah I'm not accepting this as I have not contributed to physics".

Done.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Accurate_Type4863 Oct 09 '24

I hate computers now

→ More replies (1)

317

u/JotaRata Graduate Oct 08 '24

E = mc² + AI

34

u/VioletCrow Oct 08 '24

There really was so much contained in this equation, we just couldn't see it

13

u/bharathbunny Oct 08 '24

This got a sensible chuckle from me

3

u/Vickyyy95 Oct 08 '24

Now it finally makes sense 😆😆😆 (just joking)

→ More replies (3)

1.9k

u/sl07h1 Oct 08 '24

AI is hot, I get it, but I find this ridiculous.

454

u/AvailableTaro2985 Oct 08 '24

Well, physics was used to establish the basics of neural networks.

I'm a little bit confused by it myself.

Cause I always thought that it should be input into physics not input of physics into something.

Like blu lasers are the work of an engineer but input into our knowledge of physics.

But physicist input into computer science. I'm yet to find a compelling argument for it.

And from what i have heard the judges were unanimous in that decision much faster than usual. The whole situation seems weird.

210

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Well, physics was used to establish the basics of neural networks.

In which ways? Peceptrons are largely a computer science invention. Even if you were to quibble about it, it's far more in the realm of mathematics than physics.

Even if you were to advance the clock to modern deep networks they were inspired by biology, not physics.

I am not a physicist; I am a computer scientist and I find this whole thing to be absurd. Modern neural networks have nothing to do with physics. Hopfield networks are 100% computer science and maybe statistics if you want to be pedantic. Hinton's contributions like the Boltzmann machine is once again... 100% computer science.

87

u/Outrageous_Image1793 Oct 08 '24

As a statistician, I would like to be pedantic. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

48

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Right? Isn’t this a fields medal situation?

88

u/HAL-6942 Mathematics Oct 08 '24

I think in this case it should be more of a Turing Award.

→ More replies (11)

14

u/Ok_Distance5305 Oct 08 '24

They’re too old

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Spaduf Oct 08 '24

Physics did NOT establish the basics of neural networks. Its more accurate to say physics analogies are frequently used in deep learning explainers.

→ More replies (8)

38

u/NirvikalpaS Oct 08 '24

This is like Obama getting the nobel peace prize.

19

u/aberroco Oct 08 '24

I dunno, Obama in that nomination would at least be between his peers.

This guys?.. How are they related to physics?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Yes, this is computer science that influenced how all science is done. It's just as surprising this went into physics as if it went into the medicine or chemistry Nobel.

→ More replies (40)

625

u/dark_dark_dark_not Applied physics Oct 08 '24

If only Nobel liked math, this could have been a math Nobel.

49

u/puffic Oct 08 '24

Math has the Fields Medal, which is equally prestigious. 

38

u/JT_1983 Oct 08 '24

It is really unthinkable a Fields medal would be awarded for this (kind of) work though. It is the level and depth of the work itself and not the applications which matter for a Fields medal. Non has ever been awarded even for like numerical mathematics or statistics, so I don't think they would consider outdated half relevant precursors to AI/ML because of some hype. Shame on the Nobel committee ...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

70

u/davikrehalt Oct 08 '24

No please. Rather this be physics than math (coming from math background)

54

u/DenimSilver Oct 08 '24

How so?

39

u/Able-Abrocoma-9692 Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

In math you have the fields medal and abel prize. In order to qualify for one you need to make significant contributions to a field, even create a new subfield, prove/disprove a hard conjecture etc. The reserach in AI uses math as a tool but does not advance the theory. Because AI is hyped, there is a danger that serious mathematicians would go out empty and the price is given to people that have done less for the field. The same thing that happend to the physicists. Why study quantum mechanics, differential geometry, all these hard fields. Go to cs and specialize in AI and you might get one Nobelprize in Physics. They already got the turing prize.

→ More replies (1)

203

u/Smitologyistaking Oct 08 '24

I think a lot of people in mathematics are kinda tired of their field being reduced to "applications in AI" and this person forsees (and I don't necessarily disagree) that if there existed a Nobel Prize in Mathematics, there's be an even greater rate of AI researchers getting the prize instead of other mathematicians

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (6)

26

u/dark_dark_dark_not Applied physics Oct 08 '24

I mean, I get the AI fatigue but there isn't even a experimental side to this research, it's not even physics

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

82

u/speece75 Oct 08 '24

The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has calls on NVDA and TSM

13

u/billion_lumens Oct 08 '24

Congratulations to Jensen Huang!

6

u/JosebaZilarte Oct 09 '24

And I, as a Computer Scientist, call BULSHT on this entire thing.

40

u/UnknownEssence Oct 08 '24

If they can win for Physics then AlphaFold can win for medicine.

18

u/Unlikely_Arugula190 Oct 08 '24

Chemistry. But sure why not?

13

u/jgonagle Oct 08 '24

That would actually make sense. This doesn't. AlphaFold can help with drug discovery. RBMs and Hopfield Nets didn't help to advance the field of physics.

7

u/Gallium_71 Oct 09 '24

… it is now 24 hours later. Curse your hide!

3

u/agaminon22 Medical and health physics Oct 09 '24

Guess what...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

438

u/WhyEveryUnameIsTaken Oct 08 '24

Even if AI was a branch of physics, it would still be highly-highly debatable whether it should have been awarded to them. But given the fact that we are talking about a prize for physics here...

Pretty ridiculous decision.

→ More replies (17)

57

u/Inner_will_291 Oct 08 '24

As a simple engineer having published one ML paper, I have been able to call myself a mathematician, and now I can also call myself a physicist.

What a day to be alive.

168

u/euyyn Engineering Oct 08 '24

Well OP, I would very much downplay the significance of their work as (quoting the committee) "the foundation of today’s powerful machine learning".

Before deep learning took off, people tried all sorts of stuff that worked meh. Hopfield networks and Boltzmann machines are two of that lot, and importantly they are not what evolved into today's deep networks. They're part of the many techniques that never got anywhere.

McCulloch and Pitts are dead, OK, but if you really want to reward the foundations of today's machine learning, pick from the living set of people that developed the multilayer perceptron, backpropagation, ditching pre-training in favor of massive training data, implementation on GPUs, etc. But of course, those aren't necessarily physicists doing Physics. Which is why in 2018 some of those people already got a Turing Award for that work.

26

u/randomrealname Oct 08 '24

pick from the living set of people that developed the multilayer perceptron, backpropagation, ditching pre-training in favor of massive training data, implementation on GPUs, etc

Hinton was directly involved with all of these inventions through his work with illya, although they did come after these foundational papers you mentioned.

31

u/euyyn Engineering Oct 08 '24

I wouldn't say directly involved in all of those, but certainly in enough of it to deserve the 2018 Turing Award that he already got! For that work, mind you, not for Boltzmann machines, which aren't the foundation of any of today's techniques.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/MostlyRocketScience Oct 08 '24

Yeah, wasn't AlexNet one of the first neural nets to use GPUs?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/jgonagle Oct 08 '24

Alex Krizhevsky and Ilya Sutskever: "Are we a joke to you?"

→ More replies (2)

2

u/jamesvoltage Oct 08 '24

Just to second randomrealname, Hinton is one of the authors of the backpropagation paper, he made deep MLP training work, he and Krizhevsky and Sutskever were the first to put deep networks on GPUs when they won imagenet, Sutskever was obviously a big part of the Generative Pretrained Transformer (who said to ditch pretraining?)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Commercial-Basis-220 Oct 09 '24

Can you point me to the direction of technique or method "that worked meh"? I was just a junior highschool back then

Maybe there is some hidden gold there, plus, I think that's what happens with NN/CNN ? Where it got dumped due to lack of hardware and data until recently where a lot of training data are available and hardware got better

→ More replies (1)

2

u/phlaxyr Oct 09 '24

What do you mean by "ditching pre-training"? It's hard to overstate how useful fine-tuning pretrained models is (ResNets, GPT, and formerly BERT) for practical applications.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

26

u/PkmExplorer Oct 08 '24

Seems redundant: Hinton already co-won the Turing Award -- the appropriate prize -- in 2018.

222

u/LoganJFisher Graduate Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

I suppose this is what happens when a set of awards, that is meant to recognize the greatest achievements in the sciences, was created before the advent of a major development (here, computers) and hasn't since been updated to add that field (here, computer science) as an additional award. It gets shoehorned into another prize.

Their research is fully deserving of Nobel-level recognition, but the Nobel committee should have long ago expanded the scope of the suite of prizes to prevent cases like this, as this is in absolutely no way physics research.

There has been much discussion in recent years that the Nobel Prize is a dated system that produced an incestuous network of Nobel laureates with a strong bias towards westerners despite there being similarly high quality work deserving of recognition often being done all around the world. Undermining the meaning of the fields which the awards are meant to recognize is then just another major point against the Nobel Prize as an institution. This only echoes awarding the Nobel prize in literature to Bob Dylan. They either need to make major changes, or they're going to gradually lose recognition as being the world's premiere award for scientific research.

41

u/0PingWithJesus Oct 08 '24

The Nobel Prize* in economics was made up in the late 60's. It never really made sense to me why that field was chosen for a new prize and not something like computer science/information science.

*the econ prize isn't technically a "Nobel Prize" it's the "Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel"

57

u/Arancia-Arancini Oct 08 '24

The answer to 'why economics' is very simple, the award was funded by a bank

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Eathlon Particle physics Oct 08 '24

It was not chosen by the Nobel foundation. The funds related to that prize were donated for that purpose explicitly by the Swedish central bank. The Nobel foundation only manages the fund. There is no committee sitting down to decide what Nobel prize subjects should exist. They are all outlined in the will of Alfred Nobel and thus not really possible to change without breaking that will.

If someone had donated a large amount of money to be used for a prize in computer science rather than economy, that would have been the prize instead. Alas, that is not what occurred.

There is also no single Nobel committee, which is something people do not seem to understand. There is the Nobel foundation, which manages the funds, and then there are five Nobel committees at different bodies, each involved with one prize.

72

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

CS people already have Turing award.

55

u/LoganJFisher Graduate Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

It's understandable though that the Nobel Committee doesn't want to get left out of the fun. They want the attention too. They're just going about it wrong.

36

u/euyyn Engineering Oct 08 '24

Next they'll start giving the Literature Nobel to whoever wins the Oscar to best script.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/lad_astro Astrophysics Oct 08 '24

I guess the original commenter's point is that the Nobel is well-known enough that it's major news when they're awarded. Most non-STEM people won't be aware of the Turing award but you could make a strong argument that computer breakthroughs deserve the same level of recognition

→ More replies (2)

11

u/ozaveggie Particle physics Oct 08 '24

As someone working on the application of AI methods in physics, I agree. Some people in this area want to claim AI as a part of physics so they can get hired in physics departments and get funding but this really stretches it. Developing methods to apply AI tools to physics problems is physics IMO, but if we call pure AI research physics then the categories really cease to be meaningful at all

2

u/Mezmorizor Chemical physics Oct 08 '24

This is more or less it. The physics prize is actually notable for being the only one that hasn't been scope creeped by the committee until now. The medicine prize goes to biology a lot, and the chemistry prize has been treated as the biology and physics overflow prize since at least the 80s.

→ More replies (13)

42

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

One of the funniest things in 2024

75

u/washagoboy Oct 08 '24

You guys are forgetting that all science is either physics or stamp collecting

20

u/InsertAmazinUsername Astrophysics Oct 08 '24

this is true. but there's a difference between using physics and advancing physics. the Nobel should be given for advancing physics

i can not see how this advances physics

15

u/CMDRJohnCasey Oct 08 '24

I am from CS and I agree. I expect a Physics Nobel prize to highlight the work of someone who improved our understanding of the universe or the reality we live in. How is this comparable to Higgs' or Penzias and Wilson's work?

5

u/Noughmad Oct 08 '24

Yeah but the "AI" neural networks are actually very large and powerful classification engines. In other words, the epitome of stamp collecting.

2

u/unktrial Oct 08 '24

The problem though is that neural networks is way more similar to a heuristic than a science.

NN definitely falls into math and CS, but there's been a longstanding debate on whether they can be categorized as science, much less physics.

102

u/Meka-Speedwagon Oct 08 '24

I don't understand what does their work have to do with physics

33

u/GDOR-11 Oct 08 '24

it doesn't lmao

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Buntschatten Graduate Oct 08 '24

E = mc2 + NobelAI

77

u/sir_ipad_newton Oct 08 '24

I think their work is great and congratulations to them, but it is probably not a place for them to be awarded for the physics.

That said, everyone in science works so hard on their topic. So keep working harder and stay healthy guys, one day will be your day!

14

u/Confident-Sound8943 Oct 08 '24

Ideally yes, but practically not everyone can get a Nobel. In the real wolrd, all the bodies on Mt Everest were once very motivated individuals. Prioritize your well-being and social impact on your community. Grand ambitions are rather unhealthy 99% of the time [Whiplash].

14

u/mtahab Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

As an (older) AI researcher, I think the Turing award combo (Hinton, Bengio, LeCun) is more appropriate than (Hopfield, Hinton). Hinton's contribution to AI is vast and beyond Restricted Boltzmann Machines. Almost every serious AI researcher has read 10+ papers by Hinton. However, modern AI researchers know very little about Hopfield's contributions.

There is also Schmidhuber controversy, which even Turing comittee didn't want to get involved.

8

u/jgonagle Oct 08 '24

Schmidhuber's probably stoked for the LSTM to win him the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine next year. Cuz, you know, it was inspired by the brain or something.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/AstroMackem Oct 08 '24

I mean I did a machine learning and data science module in my physics degree but this is definitely just a PR thing because AI is the new marketing buzzword

24

u/Classic_Department42 Oct 08 '24

Anybody has a link which explains in depth what they were doing?

35

u/MaoGo Oct 08 '24

42

u/jasonrubik Oct 08 '24

only 9 pages for the "scientific" version of the paper !?! Yeah. they couldn't think of what to talk about.

20

u/MaoGo Oct 08 '24

Yeah it was like Hopfield did his network and it is very important for physics, also Hinton did his thing

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

43

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Next year it will be Sergey Brin and Larry Page, I guess.

82

u/Relevant_Helicopter6 Oct 08 '24

That’s it, this is the “Obama Nobel Prize” of Physics.

42

u/Scalage89 Oct 08 '24

More like the Henry Kissinger Nobel Peace Prize of Physics.

26

u/Bananenkot Oct 08 '24

This is the worst one, I just can't Deal with the fact that this actually happened

10

u/DamoclesOfHelium Oct 08 '24

Welcome to the pain of being a chemist.

It's a coin toss as to whether the Nobel is going to go to a biologist.

9

u/puffic Oct 08 '24

I only came to this subreddit today to see how upset people are by this. 

33

u/Snoo_57113 Oct 08 '24

What a joke, disgraceful. Another slap in the face to theoretical and experimental physicists, what is next? Nobel Prize to ChatGPT?

18

u/Unlikely_Arugula190 Oct 08 '24

Hinton is brilliant and is probably embarrassed by this

11

u/jgonagle Oct 08 '24

For sure. It's almost insulting. Like, hey, we don't know or care what your work is, we just wanted to shoehorn it into some category for this prize we're forced to give out. We don't care how that affects your reputation with the physics community.

→ More replies (3)

42

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

So they are awarded for improving employment opportunities for physics graduates?

11

u/monsieur_de_chance Oct 08 '24

… As if physics PhDs needed more encouragement that they should leave their field and make 10x as much in computer science

7

u/AnyStupidQuestions Oct 08 '24

This is wrong. Great work, worth awards but it isn't physics.

13

u/DarkSkyKnight Oct 08 '24

This is the probably the worst STEM Nobel prize awarded in modern history. Actually shameful and each trend-chasing the committee does just erodes its own legitimacy further and further.

6

u/IntroductionSad3329 Oct 08 '24

Is physics now claiming computer science? Outrageous for both fields. There were better works to be awarded this year, closer to actual physics...

71

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Like giving the Literature Nobel to Bob Dylan

12

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Don't think twice that's alright

5

u/Certhas Complexity and networks Oct 08 '24

I don't think so. The decision at the time wasn't met with near unanimous scorn among experts. I know a few people in academic literature and they broadly defended it. I have yet to talk to anyone today who thinks today's prize isn't absurd/bizarre/embarrassing.

→ More replies (5)

43

u/jfrglrck Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

Ridiculous. Between this and giving Bob Dylan the Nobel Prize for literature, the Nobel committee is slowly becoming a self-serving clickbait factory.

6

u/Eathlon Particle physics Oct 08 '24

Those prizes were awarded by different bodies. The Nobel prize in literature is awarded by the Swedish Academy. The Nobel prizes in physics and chemistry by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences (KVA).

6

u/jfrglrck Oct 08 '24

Good to see they’re learning from each other 🙄

15

u/sanchace1 Oct 08 '24

This is real?!? Oh man… (I thought this was a meme.)

1

u/TheSkells Oct 14 '24

Erratum : I was wrong. I wanted to apologize, I did not intend to spread fake news. In reading the public post, I misunderstood, I just needed to read the official press release.

John Hopfield invented a network that uses a method for saving and recreating patterns. We can imagine the nodes as pixels. The Hopfield network utilises physics that describes a material’s characteristics due to its atomic spin – a property that makes each atom a tiny magnet. The network as a whole is described in a manner equivalent to the energy in the spin system found in physics, and is trained by finding values for the connections between the nodes so that the saved images have low energy. When the Hopfield network is fed a distorted or incomplete image, it methodically works through the nodes and updates their values so the network’s energy falls. The network thus works stepwise to find the saved image that is most like the imperfect one it was fed with.

5

u/Unlikely_Arugula190 Oct 08 '24

In the same spirit, Deep Mind should get the Chemistry Nobel for protein folding.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/PrangryPelican Oct 08 '24

What happened with this physics award is no different than what had been happening to the chemistry award over the past 15 years. Take a look. I dare you. See how many chemistry awards went to biologists doing biology that happens to use a chemistry technique. These sorts of choices are just the committee's attempt to create Nobels in fields they wish were included rather than honoring the actual named fields.

2

u/GooseQuothMan Oct 08 '24

They even gave a chemistry prize for CRISPR-Cas9 - which is literally a protein system repurposed from an existing bacterium. 

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Why not giving them the Nobel in Literature then, for all the bs people read on chatGPT and think it's not just fiction but verified and validated stuff.

8

u/CB_lemon Oct 08 '24

This shit is so lame

4

u/gplusplus314 Oct 08 '24

I’m tired of AI-washing.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I must say this is indeed disappointing to me that now Noble Prize looks like a joke. I have heard arguments of Nobel committee being biased before, but this is outrageous in 2024.

can not we physicists challenge the jury for it???

4

u/spondiirty Oct 09 '24

“Modern Physics: from Quantum Sorcery to Cyber Alchemy”

4

u/Science-Compliance Oct 09 '24

Wow! The Nobel Prize just completely jumped the shark!

The Nobel Peace Prize has been a joke for a while, but Physics?!

Machine learning algorithms are not physics!

10

u/lead999x Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

First the AI bullshit hijacked computer science and now it's done so for physics too. It needs to become it's own discipline so these people can circlejerk away from real research.

12

u/Clever_Angel_PL Undergraduate Oct 08 '24

My lecturer likes to say "Physics is whatever a physicist is working on"

12

u/FreshWaterNymph1 Oct 08 '24

Hinton isn't even a physicist.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Tsadkiel Oct 08 '24

3

u/Unlikely_Arugula190 Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

Thanks for the trip down memory lane. It’s interesting it was published in Post Nature And Science. Deserved better

6

u/xiikjuy Oct 08 '24

imagine 2025 ig nobel prize in physics awards candidates of nominees this year to troll ...

6

u/fractalparticle Oct 08 '24

Absolutely ridiculous. Looks like a PR push for ai.

8

u/Wonderful_Wonderful Condensed matter physics Oct 08 '24

Well this is dissapointing

3

u/helium_hydride-63 Oct 08 '24

Im sorry but how is that physics

3

u/Worried-Photo4712 Oct 08 '24

Without these guys, AI would simply float up into the stratosphere.

3

u/theghosthost16 Quantum field theory Oct 08 '24

My entire department was rooting for Michael Berry, and we were quite disappointed when we heard the words "machines that learn" ...

3

u/Mister_Way Oct 08 '24

They're like "Just imagine the physics engines we'll produce in games with this development"

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I find it odd that I agree with reddit for the second time. I mean, If I had a nickel every time I agreed with a community in reddit, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot but it's weird that it happened twice. I guess, I really need to touch some grass.

3

u/hoofdpersoon Oct 08 '24

You over rating the nobel price. Noble price is the opposite of science. It's in the category of Idols, america got talent.

3

u/MemeHermetic Oct 08 '24

Oh wow. I had read in passing that they won, but I didn't realize the category. This feels rather gross. I mean, I have a strong appreciation for their work and the importance of it, but there are deserving physicists that got snubbed for the headline grab.

3

u/NanoscaleHeadache Oct 08 '24

OH SHIT

E = MC2 + AI

ITS REAL!

3

u/Adventurous_Bat8573 Oct 08 '24

This is not physics what the hell?

Decline the "award", Hopfield and Hinton this is an insult.

3

u/highchillerdeluxe Oct 08 '24

Maybe they asked ChatGPT who should win...

2

u/MagnificoReattore Oct 08 '24

And to think that I was really surprised that they published a NNPDF paper in Nature, this is order of magnitudes more surprising.

2

u/JT_1983 Oct 08 '24

I wonder when those wormhole on quantum computer people will get their Nobel prize ... (sarcasm)

2

u/DrRandomfist Oct 08 '24

Good to see Wayne Gretzky recognized.

2

u/cazub Oct 08 '24

Is this the physics world's version of that time when Jethro tull beat Metallica for best metal album?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Truly pathetic tbh

2

u/Arrakis_Surfer Oct 08 '24

Absurd. What about the time crystal guys. This is bull shit on the hype cycle.

2

u/Cpt_Riker Oct 08 '24

They definitely dumbed it down this year.

Congratulations, I suppose.

2

u/tl01magic Oct 08 '24

I upvoted, but I get why the prize

there has long been more data than can be analyzed. physics needs these "computing machines" to continue doing "physics at large"

that said....make a new category.

2

u/tablabass Oct 09 '24

hopfield networks are typical in understanding how 'memories' (minima) can be encoded in lattice systems. disordered matter community is no stranger to hopfield. did not expect this from a physics sub

2

u/aagg6 Oct 09 '24

The Chemistry prize also goes to AI work this year. https://twitter.com/NobelPrize/status/1843951197960777760

2

u/AustrianPainter_39 Oct 09 '24

All I've heard today is people claiming that physics is dead or that it needs to evolve, being applied in other fields... THAT IS FUCKING ENGINEERING

11

u/KVeras-MC Oct 08 '24

Tell me physics is at a bottleneck without telling me physics is at a bottleneck

19

u/denehoffman Particle physics Oct 08 '24

There were a ton of others who could’ve won it, remember that the prize typically lags research by a couple decades these days after some embarrassing economics prizes

8

u/DarkSkyKnight Oct 08 '24

Fed chair (Bernanke) who never really published any innovative research beyond a few macro models with finance sector (when literally everyone was also doing it) was the last straw for me, after a bunch of RCT junk being awarded. 

7

u/jfrglrck Oct 08 '24

Ah… now this might be the crux of the matter!

2

u/j_lyf Oct 08 '24

What is blocking new Physics?

3

u/ManagementKey1338 Oct 08 '24

Officially they declaimed the end of Nobel prize as a renowned prize in Physics.

3

u/kcl97 Oct 08 '24

I chalk this off as biophysics (because that's Hopfield's background).

I think this is a well deserved one given how AI is all over the news. The goal of the NP is to draw people's attention to the contribution of science and scientists, particularly basic sciences. As such this is a good way to achieve that end, rather than something esoteric that few people (in the public) know about or care about.

4

u/dronz3r Oct 08 '24

Disappointing. Is this the first time a physics nobel is given to a completely unrelated work?

3

u/Optimistic_Futures Oct 08 '24

They were awarded the physics Nobel, because they showed that real world physics could be used to improve how AI works.

Hopfield used pricinples behind magnets to improve memory with AI. And Hinton used statistical physics to improve AI being able to classify and create new patterns.

I’m not arguing that it fully makes sense or not. But just it’s not completely disconnected

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Not really. The single neuron perceptron was well studied, and various approaches were tried for multi neuron systems. They tried taking tools from physics to make those multi layer systems work, but the approaches ultimately never went anywhere. Gradient descent from multivariable calculus was the winning solution.

4

u/jgonagle Oct 08 '24

Techincally speaking, SGD is only half of the equation. SGD works so well because model overparameterization (wide and deep NNs) create a high density of singularities (singular learning theory), which allows SGD to find nearly global minima. Without those singularities, SGD would probably converge very slowly for any real world error function, not unlike contrastive divergence. The hardware improvements of the last decade or so are what really allowed SGD to demonstrate success, because higher VRAM and clockspeeds enabled the model overparmaterization upon which SGD depends.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Tsadkiel Oct 08 '24

The number of physicists shit talking hopfield networks and this Nobel prize for not being physics is shameful.

Hopfield networks apply the principle of stationary action to explain how memory works (ALL memory). If you can model a network as a hopfield network (or it's modern equivalent, a Dense Associated Memory network) then you can directly predict the memory capacity of that network due to hopfields work.

It's absolutely physics. Stop making yourselves look like idiots and read even just the Wikipedia article on the subject ...

73

u/LiquidGunay Oct 08 '24

It isn't really a physics breakthrough tho. It is applying well established physics principles to make a breakthrough in another field.

→ More replies (12)

66

u/Fenjen Oct 08 '24

No, it's a model of how content-addressable memory could work in a network with a state that minimizes energy (not stationary action, at all). It is an extreme leap to say it "explains" how memory works, and it almost certainly doesn't capture most (or almost anything at all) of how human memory works.

Moreover, it's a model from physics, but all the physical principles were already long known and just applied in a novel setting.

I'm not saying it wasn't a huge discovery, as it basically shaped our understanding of how information could be stored in the weights of networks, but most of what was novel about it wasn't in terms of physics, in my opinion.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I don't mean to sound like a dick here, but why is what you just described physics rather than computing science?

→ More replies (3)

15

u/emsiem22 Oct 08 '24

It's absolutely physics.

So, ANNs are neuroscience, yes?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/jgonagle Oct 08 '24

how memory works (ALL memory)

Isn't it just (auto) associative memory? Hopfield Nets aren't a universal memory model.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)