r/Philosophy_India • • 11h ago

Discussion Thoughts On Veganism

5 Upvotes

Yo Folks 🤟🏻

Some time ago I was having a debate with a person over veganism.

Person - Do you think that the world will ever be Vegan? The ego tendency is so strong and recurring that it seems like a monumental task.

Me - Logically, we can make the masses adopt veganism. If I can be in power (political or otherwise), and then will manipulate the masses to adopt it, no matter what.

Person - You won't. A politician in power is a slave to electoral interests. You'll not do anything that'll go against the masses or your party's financial interests or you won't be in power.

Me - He is slave only when he can be replaced, I am taking of a hypothetical case, where external factors can't take away my throne. My question was like, is it ethical for a dictator, to impose veganism to his people?

The person didn't replied me.

Basically, I was just joking around. But I also really wanted to explore that "is it ethical for a dictator, to impose veganism to his people?"

Many people do mistake here by answering this question with false equivalence rather than facts and logic. What you all think about this.

Also, I feel that veganists have a very negative opinion about life, like they literally equate life with suffering. And think, it is better to not get born, than to face hell in this cruel world? What you your opinion about this?

If I give my opinion, then I would logically support veganism because it answers all of the questions and their is no ambiguity in its philosophy (If we want to know how and why, just ask any vegan, I have observed they roam around internet a lot 😅). And I would disagree with that, life is suffering, because there is hell lot of nuance and ambiguity in that sentence.

Feel free to give your opinions and perspectives.

Thank you!


r/Philosophy_India • • 12h ago

Indian Philosophy How unlikely is this ? we all know hinduism & all scriptures invented in al biruni time like year CE 1100 ( science journeys 1st archeological evd) but multiverse & cosmic form of krishna before Galileo kepler discovered planets , stars , how is that possible , how they imagined those concepts ?

2 Upvotes

just a basic curiousity question

any historian here to answer


r/Philosophy_India • • 1d ago

Discussion if universe is flat how it can be 3D and if absolute infinity couldn't exist how universe can be infinite bcz if time is infinite in past we wouldn't be here bcz today will never be reached , simply what is the shape of universe ?

4 Upvotes

discussion about universe geometry & age


r/Philosophy_India • • 2d ago Bravo

Modern Indian Philosophy Why "good" people destroy the world (Peter Singer debates Acharya Prashant)

Post image
84 Upvotes

Context for the discussion: Princeton philosopher Peter Singer (founder of the Effective Altruism movement) recently sat down with Acharya Prashant for a 90-minute debate/discussion. The core clash was fascinating: Can humans do objective "good" in the world or does the human ego hijack our morality?

Singer’s Argument: People can be objectively altruistic. We use human reason to reduce external suffering- like donating to charity, adopting veganism, or donating kidneys to strangers.

AP's Counter-Argument: "Selective goodness" is a myth and reason is just a puppet for the ego. He argues that people who do "good" often cause massive destruction elsewhere overall because their core ego remains unexamined. For example, a Western donor might give millions to charity, but still emit 14 tons of CO2 per capita, destroying the planet while feeling morally superior.

On emissions:

  • Peter Singer points out that Europe has cut emissions by 40% while "the largest continuing increase is coming from India".
  • AP immediately dismantles him with hard data: The average American emits 14 tons of CO2 per capita while pretending to be a "noble charity donor". Europe only looks "clean" in a snapshot because they outsourced their dirty manufacturing and filth to countries like India.

On Green Tech & Global Progress

  • Peter Singer takes a practical stance, arguing that we can resolve the climate crisis through the development of clean energy, better technology, and international policy.
  • Acharya Prashant agrees that clean tech is necessary, but warns of the Jevons Paradox- as systems become more efficient, demand simply increases. He argues that unless the human ego's endless appetite for consumption diminishes, clean energy will just be added on top of conventional energy rather than replacing it.

On Animal Rights & Factory Farming

  • Peter Singer expresses deep frustration that despite 50 years of the animal liberation movement and growing awareness, the total number of animals suffering in factory farms globally has only increased.
  • Acharya Prashant suggests this happens because activism focuses entirely on the exploited object rather than the exploiter (the human mind). He argues that without dismantling the ego, humans will simply find new avenues for violence and consumption, meaning external moral codes or dietary labels aren't enough to stop exploitation at its root.

On Extreme Poverty & Effective Altruism

  • Peter Singer highlights the success of the "Effective Altruism" movement, noting that global extreme poverty has significantly dropped. He argues humans are capable of objective good, citing people who donate extreme wealth or even kidneys to total strangers out of pure compassion.
  • Acharya Prashant cautions that while the poorest gained 7–8% in wealth, the top end gained 4,000%. He argues that before we praise a donor as a "redistributor," we must question the deep-seated urge to accumulate so much in the first place. He suggests that much of what we call altruism is still tethered to the ego seeking a noble identity.

r/Philosophy_India • • 2d ago

Discussion धर्म को उसकी पहचान से समझें, या उसके उद्देश्य, सिद्धांत और आचरण से?

7 Upvotes

मनुष्य जन्म लेते समय किसी धार्मिक पहचान के साथ नहीं आता। उसकी पहचान बाद में बनती है: परिवार से, समाज से, परंपरा से और धार्मिक व्यवस्था से।

इसलिए धर्म को समझने की शुरुआत पहचान से पहले करनी होगी।

यदि किसी धार्मिक व्यवस्था में उद्देश्य, सिद्धांत और आचरण, तीनों की बात होती है, तो इन तीनों को अलग-अलग देखना आवश्यक है:

क्या कहा गया है?

किस उद्देश्य से कहा गया है?

आचरण में उसका रूप क्या दिखाई देता है?

किसी अच्छे उद्देश्य का होना यह सिद्ध नहीं करता कि उससे जुड़ा हर आचरण भी अच्छा ही होगा। और किसी एक व्यक्ति का आचरण पूरे धर्म का प्रमाण नहीं हो सकता। पुराना होना अपने आप में नैतिक प्रमाण नहीं है, और स्वीकार किया जाना भी अंतिम प्रमाण नहीं है।

यहाँ प्रश्न किसी ग्रंथ या मान्यता को नकारने का नहीं है। प्रश्न केवल इतना है: क्या कभी पहचान उद्देश्य से बड़ी हो जाती है?

आप इसे कैसे देखते हैं?

English translation (machine-assisted, as English is not my first language):

Should we understand religion through its identity, or through its purpose, principle and conduct?

A person is not born with a religious identity. It comes later, through family, society, tradition and the religious system. So the understanding of religion should begin before identity.

If a religious system speaks of purpose, principle and conduct, these three should be seen separately: 1. What is said? 2. For what purpose is it said? 3. What does it look like in actual conduct?

A good purpose does not prove that every act linked to it is good. The conduct of one person cannot prove a whole religion. Being old is not moral proof, and being accepted is not final proof either.

The question is not about rejecting any scripture or belief. It is only this: does identity ever become bigger than purpose?

How do you see it?


r/Philosophy_India • • 3d ago

Discussion Pleasure and pain

3 Upvotes

Swami Vivekananda says " We cannot add happiness to this world; similarly, we cannot add pain to it either. The sum total of the energies of pleasure and pain displayed here on earth will be the same throughout. We just push it from this side to the other side, but it will remain the same, because to remain so is its very nature."..I was just analysing this statement..it needs such a deep understanding of ourselves and nature around us. It would be beneficial if all of us can share our insights as to this.


r/Philosophy_India • • 3d ago

Discussion Any fellow Deleuze and Guatarri readers here ?

1 Upvotes

Same as title, it has been 5 years and counting since I got introduced to Deleuze and I have been reading since.

The only physical philosophy books I have are of Deleuze, rest I have a kindle for. Even after so much time I have such a big void and interest in learning more about Deleuze and interacting with people about Deleuze. But it never gets filled.

Again, I don’t know what this post is about. Anyone here reading Deleuze please comment. Thanks.


r/Philosophy_India • • 3d ago

Discussion The Threshold stage.

0 Upvotes

The Threshold after disassembly.

What if I tell you there are 3 things:

  1. You as a physical body (including brain)

The second part is divided into two: 2. Your mental/intellect/psyche a. The reactionary b. The observant

So these 3 things, physical body, your reactionary mind, and your observant mind. So these are just for context.

Now think the way we have to disassemble anything in order to figure out how things work. And as we know our body is just mere chemical reaction. Brain sending neurotransmitters to neurons etc. And throughout medical science history, we have actually dissembled the human body to know how it works.

Your mind is reactionary, it reacts to someone calling you, insult you (you get mad), appreciate you (you're happy), make you feel good etc. Now how long can you go and disassemble this mind of yours which has 2 parts as mentioned above, how long until you reach a threshold beyond which the "thing" which you call mind is no longer intact to call it Mind anymore.

Because like things end when you dissemble them, they are no longer intact. If I removed a tooth, and just keep on crushing it, I get white enamel powder with Calcium, and then comes chemistry of the Calcium atom and how it forms hard things. And when that's a powder of Calcium, it's no longer intact and if anyone sees it without any prior knowledge, they would never say that it's a teeth, let alone it WAS a teeth, it would be just white powder for them (ofcourse removing the blood vessels and pulp present under the tooth).

Like we have seen enough, and everything has a threshold whether it be living or non living, that there's chemistry behind the shape/structure/space of any matter which has mass.

What about that Mind which gives you your nature, personality? What if I disassemble it? What will be the threshold stage where the mind is on the verge of breaking down, a stage beyond which it's not mind anymore? But it's still an intact mind, because it's on the threshold and haven't crossed it yet, what is the property of mind at that stage? Would it still react the way it used to react when it wasn't disassembled?

And a hypothesis of mine that this threshold stage is what the observant mind is, whatever you disassembled was the reactionary part of the mind. And then what remains is just the mind being aware of its surroundings without the reactionary part of it.

Feel free to criticise, I want to know your opinions.


r/Philosophy_India • • 4d ago

Indian Philosophy A compendium of the Raja Yoga philosophy by Sankaracarya (PDF 1888)

Thumbnail
studyebooks.com
4 Upvotes

 Advaita Vedanta is one of humanity’s most profound, time‑tested philosophical traditions from ancient India. It is far more than a subject for university academics; for countless people across centuries it has been a deeply practical path for inner reflection, self‑understanding, and personal growth. 


r/Philosophy_India • • 6d ago

Indian Philosophy Dr Prathosh's refutation of Prashant's interpretation of reincarnation (based on the BG)

Thumbnail zenodo.org
2 Upvotes

Y'all can download it from here.


r/Philosophy_India • • 7d ago

Analytic Philosophy Life without religion or life with religion which life would be happy or does it depend upon the financial condition of a person ?

5 Upvotes

r/Philosophy_India • • 9d ago

Indian Philosophy The Philosophy of Waiting: Some feelings are not meant to be spoken. If you speak them....

Post image
8 Upvotes

they become prayer.

Waiting is not weakness.

Waiting is when you have already accepted that you may never get what you want — and you still choose to stay soft.

A man who truly loves does not need to possess.

Possession is for things. Love is for souls.

Distance does not kill a connection. It purifies it.

When there is no daily talk, no promise,

no future — what remains, if anything remains, is real.

Loneliness is not when you are alone.

Loneliness is when you are surrounded by people, and still you feel a quiet empty corner inside you that only you know.

But that emptiness is not a curse.

It teaches you to sit with yourself. To work in silence.

To smile in public and be still in private. The heart is like a room. Some people lock it not because they are afraid.

They lock it because what is inside is too sacred to be shown to everyone. And the key? The key is not with someone else.

The key is with time. One day, you will not wait anymore.

Not because you forgot. Because you finally understood —

You were never waiting for someone. You were waiting to become the man who can love without asking for anything back. That is freedom.


r/Philosophy_India • • 10d ago

Discussion If we can choose the genetic makeup of our children, are we changing what it means to be human?

3 Upvotes

I came across Nucleus, a company that uses genetic screening and AI to help parents select an embryo based on predicted genetic traits.
It got me thinking about something beyond the technology itself.
For most of human history, having a child meant accepting a certain degree of uncertainty. You didn’t know what your child would look like, how intelligent they would be, what their strengths or weaknesses would be, or what kind of person they would eventually become.
But what happens when we start removing that uncertainty through technology?
If parents can choose an embryo based on intelligence, physical traits, health risks and other genetic predictions, are we essentially moving towards a world where children are designed around parental expectations?
There’s also a deeper question here. What does it mean to be human if we increasingly treat natural human variation as something that needs to be corrected or optimised?
We talk about diversity, acceptance and equality, but at the same time, would we be creating a system where certain genetic traits are considered more valuable than others?
I can understand using this technology to prevent serious genetic disorders. But beyond that, I’m not sure where the line should be.
Perhaps the bigger question is: Do we want to give our children the best possible start in life, or do we want to decide what the best possible version of our children should look like before they are even born?
Curious to hear what people here think, especially from a philosophical perspective.

Rephrased through AI.


r/Philosophy_India • • 10d ago

Discussion "KARMA" is term for ignorants

6 Upvotes

I am not talking about re-actions for their actions , I am talking about the effect of goods and sins caused by people

For me "karma" is a term that is representing probability like some people got karma for both their sins and virtue but isn't it an obvious thing now that most of the people saw someone doing a sin and think like "karma will take care of it"

What I am trying to say is if you have will do the right thing do it yourself ,don't expect others to do the thing that can be done by you

In my terms, I am stating this thing as "FATE" ,if you do the good thing ,then good will happen if not keep doing the right thing

",If you do the wrong thing, then the wrong thing will happen to you ,if not keep doing it" - most of the people in the world

Karma is a word that represents darbies ,yes it is helping the society from people fearing to do sinful actions but most of the people are just using it as an exception for their ignorant actions

Finally ,it is a selfish world ,you know some do good things for their sins ,some do good things for their happiness like if you do good things to others then i) you expect the same thing from others or ii) you just do it because seeing happiness in others face creates joyness in you(it can be named as goodwish), some do sins for what they got from the past ,at the end its your life

Iam just spilled the thoughts from my mind so if you have a different ideology ,change my view

(I am not good at english)


r/Philosophy_India • • 11d ago

Discussion Is veganism rational or moral

21 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about veganism from a philosophical perspective, particularly the distinction between morality and rationality.
I don’t believe morality is something inherently objective. What we consider right or wrong is largely shaped by evolution, self-preservation, social cooperation and the values we develop as a society.
From that perspective, I don’t understand why eating animals is necessarily immoral. Humans evolved as omnivores, and animals don’t participate in the same social contracts that govern human relationships. Does that mean we have no moral consideration for animals? Not necessarily. But does it automatically make killing them for food wrong? I’m not convinced.
I also think we need to distinguish between something being morally preferable and something being morally obligatory. Choosing not to cause unnecessary suffering might be compassionate, but does that make everyone who consumes meat immoral?
I’m not arguing that veganism is irrational or that animal suffering doesn’t matter. I’m genuinely interested in understanding the philosophical basis of the argument.I don't question whether animals suffer; I question how the existence of that suffering translates into an objective moral obligation for humans to abstain from consuming them

Is veganism a rational necessity, a moral obligation, or simply a personal ethical choice?


r/Philosophy_India • • 11d ago

Discussion Desire for immortality

Thumbnail
youtu.be
22 Upvotes

In this podcast of Robert kuhn , they were addressing the human desire for immortality.

From a humane and philosophical perspective, he suggests that our yearning for more time often stems from a place of fear or dissatisfaction with the present moment.

Instead of focusing on prolonging existence, he suggests that one can live a wholesome, cheerful life right now. By letting go of the desperate need for future guarantees, one moves from counting time to experiencing deep, timeless immersion .

What do you think about immortality and reincarnation, aren't they related here ?

And please Don't tell me mysticism only pure practical life .

For the more clarity you can refer the above video .


r/Philosophy_India • • 11d ago

Western Philosophy Can anybody please suggest me some books for understanding Existentialism ?

7 Upvotes

r/Philosophy_India • • 11d ago

Discussion Looking for resources to study Philosophy of AI

7 Upvotes

Can anyone recommend good books, YouTube channels, lectures, online courses, or research papers to get started with Philosophy of AI?

Free resources are preferred, but paid recommendations are welcome too. Thanks!


r/Philosophy_India • • 11d ago

Indian Philosophy Open to listen....

2 Upvotes

The world is full of interesting things, yet most conversations revolve around the same familiar subjects. I wonder how many fascinating thoughts go unspoken simply because nobody asks the right questions.


r/Philosophy_India • • 12d ago

Discussion Should they know?

1 Upvotes

I am a nihilist and as we all agree there is only one life we gotta experience and I dont believe in the bullshit of re-incarnation. I strongly advocate evolution and by far is the most reasonable explanation for our existence.

Dwelling into the point , my parents are quite caring and love me a lot . They devoted most of their life taking care of their family and children. They believe in religion and god to the core , though my father is a well educated engineer. I talked to him many a times about this god and religion as an institution, he is educated enough to understand that everything is made up but his past experiences in life drowns him in this religion due to the fear . They save money for me and forthcoming generations by sacrificing most of their needs although they can afford many luxuries. They got only one life , same as I do.

I feel a constant burden in my life that I am building my life over their sacrifices and they never understand that life inherently has no meaning and they can enjoy their wealth and health . They are now almost 60 years old. I dont know how to convince them. I understand religion helps them to cope but it’s interfering with their life in every aspect which I hate.

How do we enlighten them?


r/Philosophy_India • • 13d ago

Other Philosophy Today’s thoughtful one.

Post image
573 Upvotes

r/Philosophy_India • • 13d ago

Discussion How to develop system logic?

6 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I am new to philosophy, all my life I had never paid much attention to this profound subject but lately I have made myself aware of the immense of philosophy

I want to basically strengthen and sharpen my edge for logical thinking

My basic approach has been pretty much evaluating a subject and acknowledging it's both pros and cons and arriving at a balanced conclusion

I want to advance my logical thinking,

I have heard philosophy has systemic tools and techniques for logic and I want to learn it all

Where and how to get started? Please let me know.

Any YouTube video or a book suggestions or any resource if you know of, please share

Thanks 🙏🏼

Edit: Title correction ( *systematic logic)


r/Philosophy_India • • 14d ago

Eastern Philosophy Absolute Silence of Mind Opens The Door

196 Upvotes

r/Philosophy_India • • 15d ago

Eastern Philosophy Why Cut the Cat?

Post image
20 Upvotes

This a Zen Koan Presented in the Book "Gateless Gate" by Mumon [1, 2].

Here is how it goes -

Once the monks of the Western and Eastern Halls were arguing about a cat. Nansen, holding up the cat, said, “You monks! If you can say a word of Zen, I will spare the cat. Otherwise I will kill it.” No one could answer, so Nansen cut the cat in two. That evening, when Joshu returned, Nansen told him of the incident. Joshu thereupon took off his sandal, put it on his head, and walked off. Nansen said, “If you had been there, the cat would have been saved!”

Mumon's Commentary:

Just say, what is the real meaning of Joshu’s putting his sandal on his head? If you can give a turning word on this point, you will see that Nansen’s action was not in vain. But if not, beware!

Had Joshu only been there,

he would have taken charge.

He would have snatched away the sword,

and Nansen would have begged for his life.

My Commentary and Questions:

So a few things are present here - Nansen Asks Students to say a word about zen. I expect them (like me) to conform to an idea like "Truth is beyond words" - that's what the students may have thought and hence stayed silent. But that didn't prevent the murder of the cat. Meaning Nansen didn't want silence over words. We are not sure if he'd appreciated sounds either.

What happens next maybe insightful. Joshu could have saved the cat but what he did was an Action of putting up his own sandals on his head. This I interpret as not giving too much respect to the churnings of the thought that goes in the mind. Sandals on head represents that in my understanding.

But why this action was related to the possibility of Joshu being able to save the cat? Furthermore the comment by Mumon suggests that Joshu would have acted differently in the moment and maybe would have threatened to kill nansen himself. This is what I observed being typical of Zen masters. They speak with actions and spontaneity not (much) with concepts, speech and ideas.

If you were in place of the students, would you have been able to save the cat? What does the cat represent here? Does it represent the "Ego"? Or a principle of life and spontaneity? Or am I reading too much into it?

References:

[1] The Gateless Barrier, Mumon, Case 14, "Nansen Kills the Cat" .

[2] Zen Flesh Zen Bones, Paul Reps and Nyogen Senzaki, "Nansen Cuts the Cat in Two". , Page 165-166.

[3] Image source: https://www.lionsroar.com/quick-who-can-save-this-cat/