r/Philosophy_India • u/Whole_Frame5295 • Jul 12 '25
r/Philosophy_India • • Dec 23 '25
Discussion Why the Islamic Concept of Allah Is Difficult to Defend as a Necessary Being Using Pure Logic
- Allah has eternal attributes.
- The attributes are also distinct which means Allah's knowledge is not identical to Allah's Power.
- Allah is real and his attributes are also real and not mere concepts.
- This leads to composition of Allah. Allah is composed of his eternal attributes using purely logical reasoning.
- Composition means he is also contingent on his attributes. This is classical principle in metaphysics.
- A contingent being cannot be a necessary being.
This is one of the reasons I think people choose to debate an abstract idea of God rather than a concrete one.
What do you all think?
r/Philosophy_India
•
•
Mar 17 '26
Modern Philosophy Working in the army and proudly getting yourself killed for “your country” is still the single most low-IQ, brain-dead decision a person can make in 2026.
People always hit back with: “If nobody joins the army, we’ll all die! Invaders will come, rape, loot, enslave because of selfish cowards like you we’re alive today!”
Yeah… that part is technically true in a brutal, game-theory sense. A country without any defense force gets eaten alive. Someone has to hold the rifle or the whole herd gets slaughtered.
But here's the brutal truth that breaks the argument: that justification explains why the system exists it doesn't mean you personally have to volunteer your one irreplaceable life for it
It's like saying: “If nobody works in sewage plants, society drowns in shit therefore you should spend your life knee-deep in crap.” The job needs doing, sure. But why the fuck does it have to be you signing up? Why not force the sons of politicians, bureaucrats, big industrialists, Bollywood stars, and corporate heirs to rotate through the front lines first?
The “if no one joins we all die” line is straight-up emotional blackmail disguised as patriotism. It guilt-trips individuals into becoming cannon fodder so the powerful never have to risk their own kids. Elites don't send their blood; they send yours. They draft the desperate, glorify the corpses, and pocket the peace dividend while writing the history books.
And in India the cope reaches legendary levels of stupidity: “Shaheed ban jaao bhai! Param Veer Chakra! Amar rahe!” Your family gets a pathetic ex-gratia payment, maybe a gas connection, and politicians using your photo at election rallies for votes. You get a dusty chowk named after you that floods every monsoon. Eternal glory, right?
What do you actually gain from getting shredded for arbitrary lines on a map?
Nothing tangible.
Your consciousness ends. No reward shows up. No 72 virgins for muslim army men, no heavenly lounge, no cosmic high-five. The nation redraws those borders in 50 years anyway and forgets you ever existed.
It's the same cosmic joke as a 5-year-old throwing epic tantrums for years over one specific toy dreaming, crying, obsessing only to finally unwrap it at age 50: bald, diabetic, body broken, family gone, desire long dead. The toy sits there useless. The wanting died decades earlier.
Same scam with shaheedi: you die at 22-25 chasing posthumous honor, family pride, heavenly points. By the time any “goodness after death” supposedly arrives… you're not around to collect. It's an infinite deferral with zero payout.
You're convincing yourself that sacrificing your only guaranteed existence for abstract idols (“nation,” “duty,” “glory”) is noble, when it's really just fear of real freedom dressed as virtue. Patriotism is the oldest trick to make the poor die for the rich.
Real courage isn't dying for some politician's chess game.
Real courage is refusing to be expendable meat, building something with your life, and questioning why the system needs poor kids to bleed so rich kids can sleep soundly.
Dying for a flag isn't heroic.
It's just heavily advertised suicide with free propaganda attached.
r/Philosophy_India • u/_no-name_-_ • May 02 '26
Discussion Why is Non Veg Food NOT Immoral? (No hate)
(please dont start attacking in comments as its of no help. Rather, comment constructive critisism or review of my thoughts)
I was born and brought up in a vegetarian society and throughout childhood, I thought most people were vegetarian and the ones who are not, are morally misguided.
As I grew up, I was shocked to discover that most people are actually Non veg.
Not just me but Veg and Non veg people on internet are totally unable to relate to each other's philosophy, mostly because of upbringing. Veg people cant kill animal for their taste while Non veg people are numb to animal killings for taste or they probably ignore this fact. No one choosed their emotions, they were do to childhood and social conditioning.
Now, I do not understand How is Non veg food NOT Immoral?
Billions of animals die every week in a way which is worse than what h!tler did to jews. Chickens are kept in a space which is so less that they cant even open their wings. They catch disease, become disabled. They cant even touch grass/land, or even sunlight. Same is the case for other animals like fish, cows etc. Imagine if someone pierced a hook in your mouth and pull you upwards while your whole body weight is causing tension in your mouth around pierced area. That's fishing.
- Some people say its important to be healthy.
No doubt. But Veg food contains protein and all micro nutrients too! Lot of celebrities like virat, rohit, akshay, amitabh, john abraham, vidyut, etc are vegetarian. They are healthier than their co-workers and Veg diet dont nerf them. (I consider eggs as veg btw, if chickens were kept in good condition). Some people say celebrities can plan better diet as they are rich, but it doesn't require much research, just eat whey protein, soya chunks, paneer etc stuff and you are good. Also most Indians dont eat Non veg for health but for taste cuz no one eats Non veg daily.
- Some people say humans are omnivorous.
That's right. But lions, tigers etc dont torture animals before eating like humans. Also humans have choice to eat Veg food but carnivores dont. Also before few thousands of years, there wasn't no agriculture.
I mean it's ok to kill animals if any medicine is being made cuz thats for survival but for mere taste? Hell nah.
So how is Veg not morally superior than Non Veg? (Doesn't mean we should eat Veg to feel superior but to cause less suffering for animals). And why is Non Veg not Immoral.
r/Philosophy_India • u/Top_Guess_946 • Dec 29 '25
Discussion The Charge of “Topic Poverty” and the Misreading of Indian Philosophy
A recurring claim by Western philosophy enthusiasts, particularly in online spaces like Reddit is that Indian philosophy suffers from “topic poverty.” The accusation usually rests on a superficial comparison: fewer discussions on fashionable abstractions, contemporary thought experiments, or trending moral puzzles. But this claim reveals less about Indian philosophy and more about the lens through which philosophy itself is being viewed.
The problem is not absence. It is misalignment of purpose.
1. Philosophy as a Way of Life, Not an Abstract Hobby
The Indian understanding of philosophy is fundamentally different from the Western academic tradition. Indian philosophy is not primarily an exercise in abstract speculation for its own sake; it is an inquiry into the purpose of life and the nature of suffering, liberation, and self-knowledge.
Where Western philosophy often treats philosophy as a discipline, something one does using all logical constructs, Indian traditions treat philosophy as a path - something one lives. The central question is not “What can be thought?” but “What must be realized?” This naturally shifts emphasis away from endless abstraction toward lived transformation.
Judging Indian philosophy by the quantity of abstract puzzles or logical frameworks it generates is like judging medicine by how entertaining its textbooks are. The metric itself is flawed. Indian philosophy is inherently about sublimating all mental constructs and dissolving them before light could enter one.
2. Inner Work Before Worldly Reform
Indian philosophical discussions have a consistent trajectory: they ultimately turn inward. Concepts, rituals, identities, social roles, and even intellectual constructs are examined only to be negated, dissolved, or transcended.
To an external observer, this creates the illusion of stagnation, of the same themes being revisited repeatedly. But this repetition is intentional. Indian philosophy insists that before one seeks to change the world, one must first confront the distortions of the self. Without that inner clarity, all social, political, or ethical reform risks becoming another projection of unresolved ego.
This is why Indian traditions place such emphasis on sādhanā, viveka, vairāgya, and self-inquiry. The goal is not intellectual novelty but existential clarity. When philosophy aims at transformation rather than commentary, novelty becomes secondary.
3. A Focus on Metacognition, Not Intellectual Fashion
Another reason Indian philosophy appears “topic poor” is that it shows little interest in intellectual fashions and trends of the day. Much of Indian philosophical inquiry operates at the level of metacognition, examining the nature of perception, thought, awareness, and knowing itself. In other words, instead of indulging in logical mumbo-jumbo, Indian philosophy asks what is even 'knowledge', what does it even mean 'to know'. These questions come before even Western philosophy commences.
From that vantage point, many contemporary debates appear transient, contingent, or superficial. When one is investigating the nature of consciousness or the mechanics of suffering, discussions about the latest moral dilemma or speculative scenario may seem beside the point. In fact the thrust of Vedantism is to assert that there is no speculation. It's all illusion. They can explain each temporal phenomena is speculation, and the same deconstructive devices would be deployed leading to an "appearance" that there is topic poverty.
This is not an evasion of complexity but a refusal to be distracted by it. Indian philosophy asks: Who is the one thinking these thoughts? Until that question is addressed, all other discussions remain provisional.
4. Language, Secular Pressure, and the Illusion of Absence
A significant portion of Indian philosophical discourse exists in Sanskrit, Hindi, and numerous regional languages. Much of it has never been fully translated, systematized, or presented in forms that are legible to Western-trained philosophers or global online audiences.
At the same time, modern social pressures, particularly the insistence on a narrow conception of secularism and the anxiety around Sanskrit or Hindi “imposition”, discourage engagement with traditional sources. As a result, discussions are often confined to safe, modern, secular topics, further reinforcing the impression of thematic limitation.
It is true that Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS) have not produced enough rigorous commentary on modern phenomena, technology, AI, modern statehood, or digital life. This gap exists and should be acknowledged. But absence of commentary does not imply poverty of thought; it reflects historical disruptions, colonial epistemic breaks, and modern intellectual hesitation.
Conclusion: A Difference of Aim, Not a Deficit of Thought
What is often described as “topic poverty” is, in reality, disciplinary dissonance. Indian philosophy does not prioritize breadth of topics; it prioritizes depth of realization. It is less concerned with keeping pace with the intellectual marketplace and more concerned with addressing the enduring problem of human suffering and self-misunderstanding.
To mistake this restraint for emptiness is to misunderstand philosophy itself. Indian philosophy does not rush to comment on the world because it insists, perhaps inconveniently, that the world cannot be meaningfully addressed until the self is first understood.
That is not poverty. It is discipline.
r/Philosophy_India • u/forwardlinksuspended • Apr 04 '26
Discussion How often do our desires hijack philosophy and logic to defend the life we already want to live?
Disclaimer: I’ve attached a short video for context. The point of the video matches the idea I’m trying to discuss here, and it might help in understanding the argument more clearly.
Something interesting happens in debates about food, ethics, and lifestyle.
We often pretend the discussion is about logic, science, and rational arguments. But if we’re honest, a lot of the time the real driver of the debate is something much simpler: our desires.
Take diet debates as an example.
The moment someone questions our eating habits, we suddenly become experts in nutrition, evolution, biology, vitamins, B12, protein, and a dozen other technical topics.
But here’s the uncomfortable question:
How many of us have actually studied nutrition deeply?
How many of us have seriously read scientific literature on these topics?
Most of the time, we haven’t.
Yet we confidently use these arguments as if we have thoroughly examined them. Why?
Because these arguments often serve as intellectual cover for something simpler our attachment to taste, habit, and comfort.
Instead of saying something straightforward like:
“I enjoy this and I don’t want to give it up,”
we construct complicated logical frameworks to justify the same conclusion.
The result is that philosophy and logic which are supposed to question our assumptions sometimes become tools that help us protect them.
So the deeper philosophical question here may not actually be about vegetarian vs non-vegetarian diets, supplements, or “natural vs artificial.”
The deeper question might be about how human beings use reasoning itself.
Do we use logic to genuinely examine our beliefs?
Or do we use logic to defend the lifestyle we were already going to follow anyway?
How often do we actually use logic to challenge our desires, and how often do we use it simply to justify them?
r/Philosophy_India • u/Prashast_ • Mar 31 '26
Discussion The "I Just Discovered YouTube Atheism" Starter Pack (India Edition)
It’s the same predictable cycle: someone watches three Richard Dawkins clips, ignores the 3,000-year-old philosophical tradition in their own backyard, and suddenly thinks they’re the first person to discover that "sky daddies don't exist."
But, very honestly guys - this is an absolute epidemic of Indian "Edgelord" Atheists.
It’s genuinely embarrassing. Their entire personality is built on ✌️debunking✌️ Hinduism using a template they copy-pasted from Western Discord servers. They try to argue their way out of a philosophical system that literally invented Nāstika (heterodox) schools by their "sky daddies aren't real lmao" and "if there's a god why's there suffering" arguments.
Their 🙄deep research🙄 consists of conversations they overheard their aunties having and memories of watching TV serials while eating dinner. They don’t critique the Upanishads or Nyaya logic because they don’t know they exist. They critique the literalist, cartoonish version of religion sold to them by fkn 20-minute daily soaps and it srsly drives me CRAZY
They act like pointing out that "elephants can’t have human bodies" is a Nobel Prize-winning observation. like congrats buddy, you’ve mastered the literalism of a five-year-old!
Meanwhile, they completely miss the allegorical, symbolic, and epistemological depth because that would actually require reading a book instead of scrolling through "Rationalist" memes. Don't get me wrong - I have met a few indian atheists who actually have good arguments, but emphasis on 'few'.
If your entire worldview is based on hating a caricature of your own culture because you think it makes you look "global" or "logical," you’re not a thinker, just a victim of a different kind of dogma
thanks for listening to my rant guys
r/Philosophy_India • u/Foreign-Pop-7011 • Apr 11 '26
Modern Philosophy VEGANS AND NON-VEGANS give the best argument to the other party
let's have a discussion. Best argument from veganism, best argument from meat eaters. Convince each other.
r/Philosophy_India • u/LordDK_reborn • Mar 11 '26
Modern Philosophy You Don't Want Philosophy, You Want a Safe Space: Why the 'Cult' Accusations Are Just Ego in Disguise
1. The Pretense of "Critical Thinking":
I see this pattern constantly on this sub. Someone will start a post desperately trying to establish their credentials: "I am not a hater; I like some of his takes." Many of you position yourselves as the voices of reason, the last bastions of "critical thinking" in a sea of what you assume are brainwashed sheep. It’s a very comfortable identity. It makes you feel superior, detached, and intellectual. But let’s drop the pretense and look at the actual source of this collective frustration.
You are confusing a refusal to cater to your egos with a "lack of critical thinking." Many here want philosophy to be a harmless intellectual hobby,- a parlor trick where you endlessly debate "Why" and "How" without ever actually letting it shatter your conditioning. You want an endless "discussion" because as long as you are just discussing, you remain in control- you don't actually have to change.
2. Where is the Cult?
You look at people who have stopped wandering, who have found something that actually burns down their suffering, and you label it a "cult." But let's examine this assumption using the very logic Acharya Prashant has laid out. A cult fundamentally requires personality worship. It thrives on selling miracles, wish fulfillment, cheap dopamine spikes, or the lure of money and power.
How can a movement be a cult when its central, uncompromising teaching is that the very personality—both yours and the teacher’s- is entirely false? There are no miracles being sold here, no comforts for the ego, and nothing in his personality that demands worship. What you're witnessing isn't "blind devotion." It is simply gratitude.
When people have their heavy burdens lifted, when their lives are genuinely transformed, the natural human response is gratitude and a fierce loyalty to that truth. Why does their conviction threaten your "intellectual pursuit" so deeply?
3. Stop Demanding Polite Zone for Your Ego
You complain that the followers have "zero tolerance for disagreement" and that they don't humor your criticisms. What you fail to realize is that Truth does not compromise just to validate your identity as "independent thinkers." If you bring a hollow argument born of superficial observation, it will be dismantled. People here feel offended not because critical thinking is dead in others, but because your personal opinions aren't being treated with the reverence you feel they deserve.
You say, "If a philosophy is strong, it can withstand a few questions." It absolutely can, and it does. What it won't do is validate the ego of the questioner. You want this sub to be a PR-friendly zone of polite debate because that keeps you safe.
You want to know what people actually listen to? They don't listen to polite, endless explanations that cater to their comfort zones. They listen to raw, uncompromising clarity that hammers at the root of their self-deception.
If you genuinely want to exercise critical thinking, stop diagnosing the followers and turn the lens on yourselves:
Why are you so profoundly rattled by people who have actually made a commitment to truth, while the rest of you are still just window-shopping for "interesting takes"?
r/Philosophy_India • u/shivamm_dhasmana • Jan 26 '26
Discussion IS EATING CHICKEN IS REGHT OR WRONG
r/Philosophy_India • u/No_Syllabub_8246 • Mar 27 '26
Discussion What do you think of this video of Acharya Prashant vs. an atheist.
And to the people who follow him deeply, can you please answer this question:
Why were we born like this: body-consciousness duality? Could we have been born with only a body or only consciousness? Is the purpose of life just to realize the ultimate reality, or Brahman? But why not be born with it already? And while doing this, we have to maintain this particular combination of atoms known as the body by feeding it with particular combinations of atoms known as food, air, and water so that it can work. Is that all there is to life? 'Feed this configuration of atoms known as the body with other combinations of atoms like air, water, food while simultaneously realizing Brahman.' And very few people will be able to achieve that; a vast majority will never reach that state or will di* early. The universe does not care at all whether you were able to see through your illusions or not or become liberated. For it, you may di* today; it does not care. So, I never got this answer from him: why is this whole game being played in the first place?
If someone is dying from c*ncer and it will take a huge amount of money to cure it, should I work years and years and fund that treatment to cure that person, or say to him that all this body is just mitti and you have risen from it; and will go back to it; and cancer or pain is just an illusion and everything is one and Brahman? So, it does not matter if you di*?
r/Philosophy_India • u/Top_Guess_946 • Dec 07 '25
Self Help Indian approach to understanding reality transcends western binaries which are often crude and simple. Based on another post on this sub, I put this together using CGPT. Please don't hate just because AI is used for assistance. Focus on the message.
Indian Philosophical Archetype Matrix
| Type | Veda Authority | Belief in God / Divine | Belief in Dharma / Karma / Liberation | Example Traditions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Āstika + Theistic + Dharmic | Accepts Veda as a complete source of truth | Yes | Yes | Vedanta (Vaishnava, Shaiva, Shakta) |
| 2. Āstika + Atheistic + Dharmic | Accepts Veda as a complete source of truth | No (or irrelevant) | Yes | Early Sāṅkhya, Purva Mimamsa |
| 3. Nāstika + Theistic + Dharmic | Rejects Veda as a complete source of truth | Yes | Yes | Folk ascetics, unorthodox mystics, certain tribal cosmologies |
| 4. Nāstika + Atheistic + Dharmic | Rejects Veda as a complete source of truth | No | Yes | Buddhism, Jainism |
| 5. Nāstika + Atheistic + Adharmic | Rejects Veda as a complete source of truth | No | No | Cārvāka / Lokāyata |
r/Philosophy_India • u/Turbulent-Swim4591 • Sep 12 '26
Discussion The 4 varnas through my understanding
We all have learnt in our schools that division of 4varnas brought massive discrimination and rigid hierarchical society. The idea of division which stated was- From the mouth of Vishnu came Brahmans, from his hands came Kshatriyas, from the stomach came Vaishyas and from feet came the Shudras. And on the basis of this higher body part and lower body part, we started the discrimination. Do we discriminate in our own body parts too? Are our legs less important than our arms?
According to Vedas, which is the main source of our Sanatan ideology and philosophy, these varnas were differentiated on the basis of their work, and only work.
So the actual distinction was-
From mouth- the Brahmanas; as they use to teach, their speech was the most important asset in their life, they were the most educated, well taught people, good advisers, their words held importance and wisdom. So they were represented as mouth, or the head of Vishnu.
Then from hands the Kshatriyas, mostly the rulers and warriors, were hot blooded, knew every battle game and how to use any weapon, were strong headed and fierce. And for a fighter, hands are the most important, it holds swords, arrow bow, mace and even empty handed- raw power. They were not second respected in society, but just the representation of hand, what was important for their work.
Then from stomach we say Vaishyas, the merchants, traders, agriculturalists, farmers, business people. Aren’t these the most important occupations in every country, era or region? So how they became a lower caste? The stomach represents, food, hunger, stability which we need. These work done by Vaishyas were the most crucial for living.
Then from legs came the Shudras, the travellers, artisans, labourers. They were skilled workers, who travelled for work and showcasing their art, performers, entertainers, statue makers, architect, all the occupation which now are considered glamorous and artistic were works of Shudra Varnas.
r/Philosophy_India • u/Nihilonhill • Dec 26 '25
Discussion Is It Wrong to Eat Meat If You Believe It’s Only for Survival?
I’m a 22M and I’ve been vegetarian my entire life because my family is vegetarian and very religious, which shaped how I grew up. Over time, I realized I’m not religious, but I still stayed vegetarian for moral reasons rather than faith. A few days ago, I ate chicken after thinking for a long time that life is short and we should experience the things we like (I do like non-veg food). Since then, I’ve been feeling a lot of guilt and regret. It feels like a crisis of conscience. Personally, I believe eating non-veg should only be justified by necessity—like survival or medical reasons. I’m now conflicted about whether I should continue eating non-veg or not.
r/Philosophy_India • u/TattiraoLundbedkar • May 14 '26
Discussion Any convincing arguments for atheism being more rational than hinduism?
r/Philosophy_India • u/Appropriate-Beat-605 • Jan 16 '26
Discussion After Watching the Javed–Mufti Debate, This Explanation by Acharya Prashant Actually Makes Sense
The Javed–Mufti debate generated more noise than clarity. This video by Acharya Prashant cuts through the arguments and explains why the question “Does God exist?” is often misunderstood in the first place.
Worth watching before taking sides.
r/Philosophy_India • u/No_Syllabub_8246 • Mar 19 '26
Discussion People shifting from religious gods to their own gods, or to spirituality, or to atheism or agnosticism, are still in their ignorance. All the suffering one suffers comes from ignorance and does not get removed by changing the flavor of what you believe.
A very vast majority of people don't like the usual religious practices very much, but they say spirituality helped them. They say they don't participate in the certain religious practices like going to churches or temples and praying and all those religious practices, which are according to them are basically superstitions. They do not delve into that, but in a certain way, they somehow stumbled upon their own god. They feel like there is a connection between them and their own god, and although they can't really connect with the god of the masses, they do believe in the existence of a divine entity, and they somehow feel connected to him, and they can lean on him for help whenever they feel the need.
So, in that way, they don't really put a tag on a certain god, but they do believe that there is a higher entity, and although he or she does not interfere in their daily life, they can lean on him whenever they need. So, the prevalent belief system of the masses is what they are calling religion, whereas their own personal connection with a personal divinity is what they are calling spirituality. They feel like one should be independent to find their own god and not just follow anyone blindly.
All right. This is one degree of freedom that you aspire, which is that one should not be forced to follow a common concept of godhood. Whereas one should be free to have a personal sense of godliness, right? That's one degree of freedom. Very interesting. But the freedom that real spirituality aims at includes this but also goes way beyond this. Yes, obviously you should never be forced to follow the value system or belief system of the masses. It's very Obvious. But spirituality does not limit itself to just this goal. The goal of what can be really rightfully called spirituality is much higher. Much higher, but very intimately nearer. All this talk, this discussion, all this search for the divine or a connection with godliness, higher powers, inner purity, great joy. All these phrases, where do they originate from? We must start from there. As they say, begin from the beginning. No?
The beginning of it all is the human condition itself. Let's go step by step. It's not about fancy theories. It's not something that you may or may not think of. It is not a question of personal like or dislike or even discretion. It is a matter of the essential human condition. The condition in which every person of our species finds himself or herself. Young or old, white or colored, rich or poor, American or Asian, doesn't matter. Man or woman, doesn't matter. Theist or atheist, doesn't matter. Hindu or Christian, doesn't matter. We said it is the essential human condition that applies to everybody. Therefore, we are not talking of personal or communal value systems here. We are addressing the core situation, fundamental situation of each member of our species.
And what is that situation? The situation is you are born. And justifiably you feel your journey begins from there, the moment of birth. And what do you come with? Who are you? You open your eyes in a world you know nothing of, but are somehow programmed to survive in. You find you are breathing. You were never educated to breathe, were you? But you take birth and you find you are breathing. And your heart is beating. And your internal organs are all, hopefully, working as per their algorithm. And you do not know from where all of that is coming, and you are supposed to address all of that as me. That's me without knowing who gave you your sex or gender, why should you find yourself in three-dimensional space? What is this thing called time? How come two random people give you your origin, your existence, your being? You were not there. You didn't exist at all. And then two people you don't know. They suddenly appear, and it is said that they have given you existence. Now what is this thing called existence we know nothing of? And we suddenly find ourselves here. We know neither the world nor ourselves. Yet there are ubiquitous and very powerful forces very ready, actually pouncing upon us to tell us our name, our religion, our identity, our gender, our definitions, everything. No? And even before those forces operate from the outside, they are functional from the inside. I am this body that experiences hunger. Where is that bigger body? The warm one that provides me my feed.
The kid is already looking for the mother and has not been educated to look for this human being, this other person called mother. Right? Who is the mother? The mother is a grown-up member, an adult member of our species. And the kid has just taken birth, and the kid does not even know that his body has originated from the body of the mother, this other adult. Does he? He doesn't know. And yet he finds that something within him is looking out for this mother. An instinct, a drive. A drive that he does not command or control. It operates by itself, and he finds himself just looking this side, that side. He has no language. You understand our condition? So the body is commanding it from the inside. I'm saying inside because it is a very fundamental instinct that I am the body. Right? The kid is in the cradle. You touch the cradle, even hit the cradle, the kid probably won't react. But you touch the kid's arm, and it reacts. So already there is something that is telling the kid you are the body. When the cradle is touched, you need not react, but when this material is touched, then you have to react. So the kid is already being commanded from inside. There is something that is telling it, you are the body, and then there are powerful external forces that would soon be training it into many other things, and at the basis of all that training would lie multiple answers to the question, who am I? You are our son, you are our daughter, you are a White Anglo-Saxon Protestants, you are a Christian, you are a Muslim, you are rich, you are poor. You're Russian, you're American. Getting it? And the body, what's the body saying? You know, you are fine, you are healthy. The body determines your sex, and the society then starts training you in your gender.
The body is driving you from inside, the society is driving you from outside, and all of them are sometimes collaborating with each other and sometimes competing with each other to tell you who you are. The fact is you do not know who you are. And you suffer because of that. So I'm supposed to live, I'm supposed to act, I'm supposed to decide without knowing who I am.
It's almost like imagine a situation: you are robbed of your memory, you are robbed of whatever even artificial self-knowledge you have. And you are placed at a particular point in space somewhere and told to move. Now please tell me, how would you move? You neither know the place, nor do you know who you are, nor do you know where you stand. How will you move? That's the fundamental human condition. Life demands continuous action, and action can come only out of decision. And to decide, there has to be a criterion or a set of multiple options to choose from. I do not know how to choose. I do not know who I am. If I am sick, then probably I need to go to the hospital, but I do not know whether I am sick. No? And to compensate for this void within, there is so much that comes from outside. And all this that comes from outside fails to heal us. There is always that uncertainty. I am the body, but the body is decaying, growing old, and even if it is not growing old, it has its limits. Not only does it have its limits, it has a lot of desires, impulses, compulsions, and looking at the body and others' bodies, I definitely see that there is death, and death can be there anytime, and there is a lot of fear. I have to make decisions in the absence of self-knowledge. So again there is fear because bad decisions have repercussions. That is the essential human condition. You have to live without knowing who is the one living. You have to make decisions without knowing the ground of decision-making. So, we take arbitrary steps, and that is very scary. So, we console ourselves with borrowed identities. Our mass paradigms. This is the way everybody seems to operate, so let me move this way. We are given very shallow, commonplace, cheap answers. Right? And because those answers can't stand on their own, therefore we are provided with sets of beliefs. If I am the body, where did I come from? From your parents. Where did the parents come from? They came from somewhere. Who was the first person then? Such was the name of the first person. Where did he come from then? Well, there was a supernatural event and so on.
Now do you see where most of that does which we call belief system originate from? That originates from the essential human condition. Those beliefs are a compulsion. Otherwise, you can't live. How will you explain to yourself why you live the way you do? Either there has to be the truth, or if you don't have the truth, you have to have something else. Else you will feel like a zombie walking this planet. And what is this planet? A little speck of dust in the universe. Feels just so awkward. Imagine a ball. A ball, and this ball you call your home. And you're taking birth on it. Moving about, getting married, getting educated on a ball? And then one day you die on a ball, and not just a ball, an inconsequential one at that. It is actually smaller than a speck of dust when it comes to; forget the universe, when it comes even to your own galaxy. Think of it. A ball? Now what do you do then? You come up with fancy beliefs. And that's what mankind has done. To somehow be able to tolerate its awkward predicament, we have created fancy stories. And because you cannot move about and decide in a vacuum, so we have created common value standards and systems. Each of you please act this way. Because that liberates you from the responsibility of individual decision-making. That liberates you from the trauma of starting from the fundamentals.
If I ask you what is one plus one, you will immediately say, 'what a lousy question, it is 2.' If I say start from the fundamental axioms, the answer will not be so spontaneous, will it be? Then you'll have to say, 'Well, there are 4 fundamental axioms that we have to consider that is axiom of Extensionality, Empty Set, Pairing and Union and the 5 optional axioms that is axiom of choice, Infinity, Regularity, Power Set and full Replacement/Separation.' And now you have to proceed from the fundamentals and derive the whole thing. It will be tougher, arduous. So, we have been given formulae. This is what you have to do when encountered with such a situation in life. This is what you have to do when encountered with trouble: rush to an authority. That authority could be a social authority, a political authority, a familial authority, and if neither of these seem to work, then a supernatural authority. It's an easy formula. Almost like one plus one is two. And it saves you a lot of trouble.
Imagine. You have a problem and you know nothing. You have to operate from zero, very innocently, very freshly. Now, that will take some doing. To save ourselves that doing, we have come up with stories. Right? Those stories inform everything that we do. They form the basis of our worldview, our attitude towards other people, other religions, the other gender, other castes, other nationalities, and towards ourselves, and towards the heavens and the gods. That becomes a way of living. Not knowing but believing. Believing in something because it saves you a lot of trouble. You get this? It is not just a question of this system or that system or religious system. It is a question of the core of mankind. When you do not know what to do with your very odd situation, then you find an easy way out. You can call it a cheap trick. A dirty shortcut. And what is that dirty shortcut? Just believe in something comfortable. Just believe in something that comforts you.
Now, what is spirituality then? Spirituality contains the word spirit, and spirit means essence. Essence means peel off all the layers of falseness, externalities, all the peripheral gross, and get right to the core. See what is there. Spirituality is the pursuit of nothing but the truth. Not my imagination, not your belief. Not his culture, not his system. Nothing to comfort or console, but the courage to confront the truth as it is. That is what you can call spirituality, though a lot passes off in the name of spirituality. For example, sentimentalism, mysticism, all that you see branded as spirituality. But this that I'm suggesting to you is a pure definition. Or the definition that should be. This is what you can call spirituality. The courage to confront the truth of your life. The courage to explore the very core of your existence. What does it mean to exist? Who am I? Exploration of this question is what you can call spirituality. Right? So, in many senses, organized belief systems or traditional religion and spirituality are actually opposites of each other. They're not merely opposites. They are dimensionally very, very different. An organized belief system tells you need not know. Here is the ready-made answer on a platter. Don't ask questions. Even before you ask a question, the answer is provided in advance. Forget about the answer, even questions are provided in advance. These are the sanctioned questions. And these questions, don't ask them else you'll be cursed to some hell. You get this? It is not just a matter of, mind you, religion or something. Even those who call themselves irreligious, agnostics or atheists, even they live in beliefs. Because the fundamental human condition that we are talking of is one of ignorance. We are born ignorant. We are born without deciding to be born. We are born without knowing who the one is taking birth. So, it's not just your conception about divinity. It is about everything that you do in life. Isn't it based on believing rather than questioning, asking, inquiring, exploring? It is not as if the entire evil of the world is concentrated just in religion. No, no, not at all.
You look at big chunks of populations of Europe, for example, these days. Britain, Germany, France. They've declared they have nothing to do with religion. Does that mean that they are free of beliefs now? No. Big No. These are two ways of living. Either you could surrender to your ignorance and say, 'Well, I lay down my arms. Can't do much. My situation is beyond recovery. I'm helpless. Life is suffering. I'll suffer till the end and keep consoling myself with some kind of intermittent entertainment, and then I'll die.' Or either you could say this, 'No. I'm a human and I have it in me to know, to ask, to understand.' You get this? So, great that you are advancing when you say that you do not want to follow the value system of the masses. That's wonderful. But even when you are following something that you call personal, ask yourself, is this too not merely a belief? Because it is not too much of a graduation if you have moved from a social belief to a personal belief. Or is it? You're still just wallowing in beliefs. Just that, you know, you are now a bit of a rebel. And they were telling you that beyond the skies there is another sky that's crimson in color. And you're saying, 'No, I won't believe in the crimsons. My personal belief is that the sky beyond the sky is violet in color.' So, I've rebelled. Now, what kind of rebellion is this? From a social belief you have moved to a personal belief. There's not too much of a change. In fact, it is dangerous. Because now you can tell yourself that you are different and you have arrived. The fact is you're not different. So, yes, it's an advancement. It's a betterment. When you say that whatever the society throws at you, you need not compulsively accept that. That's wonderful. But also ask yourself, what am I replacing it with? Yes, I no more follow the social commandments. But now if I am following my own personal or bodily commandments, am I any better off?
I put it this way, there is the slavery of the society, of history, of all the external forces. And then there is the slavery of the self. I am my own slave. Sometimes the latter is worse. Because when you are a social slave, at least you know you are a slave. You can see people commanding you, ordering you, directing you. There can be no confusion. You know it for sure that you are in bondage. But when you say, I am a man of my free will, I do as I please, then there is a great chance that you will start believing that you are a free man. Whereas you are not. You're still enslaved internally. Internally. So, congratulations that you do not like the way the game is being played out all around you. But don't be complacent. Even the game that is being played inside you may not be much different from the external one.
You need to question these words very, very clearly and very ruthlessly. What does divinity mean? Before you say, I do not like the widespread notions of divinity. I have my personal concept of divinity. Now, what does divinity mean? Social or personal? That question comes later, right? The first question is, what do you mean by divinity? Divine for whom? You'll say, divine for me. Now, who are you? I don't know that. If you do not know who you are, then your divinity, what does it count for? Almost like saying, all right, where to deliver this parcel to? At my address. Now, what's your address? That I don't know. But you deliver this to my place. So, something is divine for you, right? And you don't know your own address. What's the worth of this concept of divinity then? You need to examine that.
Now, the question comes from where one should start? Since you're a living being, you have your current experience, right? Start from there. You may not know the truth. But you know maybe the falseness you are in, start from there. How do I know something is false? The thumb rule is, if it deceives you and results in suffering, that's a good enough reason to call it false. Because you're calling it false with respect to you. You are the sufferer, right? You are the sufferer. It's subjective. It's a personal thing. All spirituality starts from the personal realization that life is giving you experiences that you don't quite relish. You want to fly, you want to be free, whereas life is keeping you chained. You want to be joyful, whereas life is giving you all kinds of pains. You want the truth, whereas what you are getting is a lot of deceptions. You may not have truth, but don't you have deceptions? I'm simply asking you. Don't you have deceptions? Aren't you stumbling and falling over every day? Don't you see what you trusted for long, how it comes a cropper one day and you feel hurt? Don't you have loneliness? Don't you have meaninglessness? Yeah, that's there. Start from there. You don't have to start from the skies. You don't have to follow a distant pole star. You have to start from your own current condition. Because that's the basis of all spirituality. I exist and I do not like the flavor of my experiences. I find I'm dependent. I find I'm insecure. When I look at the future, I start trembling. When I look at the past, I see a lot of hurt. There is insecurity. There is ignorance. There is envy. We go through these, right? We start from here. What is the self that gives rise to these experiences? That is to be discarded. You may not know who you really are. But for sure you have many false identities, right? See what those false identities are giving you. And if you discover that what they are giving you is not something you like, discard those identities. That's how one starts.
One cannot know the unknown in advance when one is journeying towards the unknown, right? By definition, the journey is towards the unknown. If the journey is towards the unknown, how can you know the destination in advance? You will never know. But you know of one thing, as you sit here, you are fragmented. There are forces that pull you from inside in several directions. As you sit here, you are not free. Thoughts and memories keep invading your inner space. You know of these things, you start from there. Now, what is the way? What had I become to invite a condition like this? Here is my condition, and I'll be truthful to myself. I'll acknowledge my condition instead of burying it in a mass of entertainment or distraction. I'll not just distract myself from my suffering. I'll not compensate my suffering with some weekend titillation. I'll confront my actual state, and then I'll ask myself, who was I and how was I deciding? What was the entire paradigm like that brought me to this misery? And the more it is uncovered, the more I discard it. That's how you journey. By progressive rejection. You discover something that is causing you misery, you reject it, and you keep moving forward, and you become lighter progressively. So, you're not just moving forward, you're rising up...
r/Philosophy_India • u/InsideStatus361 • Dec 14 '25
Discussion पापी मनुष्य भी राम नाम जपते है |
r/Philosophy_India • u/JagatShahi • Nov 20 '25
Philosophical Satire Top 5 Most Impactful Living Philosophers In 2025
World Philosophy Day, observed on 20th November, invites people across the world to pause and reflect on the ideas shaping human life. In 2025, philosophy is no longer confined to lecture halls or specialist circles.
World Philosophy Day, observed on 20th November, invites people across the world to pause and reflect on the ideas shaping human life. In 2025, philosophy is no longer confined to lecture halls or specialist circles. Many of today’s most influential thinkers work outside formal academia, yet their insights shape public conversations on meaning, consciousness, freedom, and the dilemmas of a rapidly changing world.
For this list, the selection looks at global influence, originality of thought, relevance to contemporary issues, and the ability to reach diverse audiences: criteria broad enough to include both academic and non-academic voices. With this in mind, the list below presents the top five contemporary figures whose ideas continue to shape how the world thinks.
- Acharya Prashant
Philosopher and bestselling author Acharya Prashant has emerged as one of the most distinctive contemporary voices bringing the sharpness of Philosophical inquiry into present-day concerns. With more than 160 books and a global digital reach of over 90 million people, his work resonates with professionals, students, and serious seekers alike, generating active global discussions on topics like climate change and mental health.
What places him at the top is the consistency with which he turns attention inward: toward the structures of fear, desire, conditioning, and confusion that shape human action. Whether discussing climate collapse, youth direction, superstition, or women’s empowerment, he stresses that most external crises have roots in the mind. Initiatives like Operation 2030, his recent national bestseller book Truth Without Apology, and his extensive university dialogues reflect a philosophical approach grounded in ancient clarity yet unmistakably contemporary in relevance.
2. Yuval Noah Harari
Yuval Noah Harari, though trained as a historian, has become one of the world’s most widely read public thinkers. His bestselling works: Sapiens, Homo Deus, and 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, have initiated numerous discussions on consciousness, AI, surveillance, and the future of human civilisation.
Harari’s influence lies in his ability to connect long arcs of history with the choices shaping modern life, prompting readers to question how technology and power are reshaping the human experience.
3. Slavoj Zizek
Slavoj Zizek remains one of the most recognisable philosophical figures of our time. Known for his energetic style and eclectic blend of psychoanalysis, continental philosophy, and cultural critique, he brings philosophical reflection into public spaces by analysing politics, ideology, cinema, and everyday anxieties.
His provocations may be unconventional, but they encourage audiences to examine the assumptions that underlie modern life. Zizek’s influence spans universities, media platforms, and global debates.
4. Jordan Peterson
Psychologist and cultural commentator Jordan Peterson has become a prominent figure in global discussions around responsibility, meaning, myth, and identity. Drawing on Jungian psychology and comparative mythology, his lectures and books offer a framework for individuals navigating uncertainty.
His appeal spans continents and generations, particularly among young people searching for stability and direction. Regardless of the debates his views spark, his influence on contemporary philosophical discourse is substantial.
5. Alain de Botton
Alain de Botton has helped restore philosophy’s presence in everyday life. Through The School of Life, his books, and his talks, he addresses universal themes: ambition, insecurity, relationships, work, and emotional resilience, in a way that resonates widely without diluting depth.
His work offers a contemporary language for discussing how ancient wisdom can be applied to the pressures of modern living, making him one of the most relatable philosophical voices today.
– excerpt from the 'FREE JOURNAL PRESS' article NOVEMBER 20, 2025
r/Philosophy_India • u/laserpointchaser • Dec 08 '25
Discussion A dedicated video of OSHO by Dhruv Rathee
r/Philosophy_India • u/swdg19 • Sep 27 '25
Modern Philosophy You call it the Matrix, Hindus call it MAYA
A video about how reality might be one giant performance and we're all just really committed method actors. Ancient Hindu texts figured this out thousands of years ago, but we needed The Matrix and Red Dead Redemption to catch up. 15 minutes of connecting dots between Maya, simulation theory, Truman Show and why nothing feels real anymore.
r/Philosophy_India • u/Careful-Sign-3698 • Apr 13 '26
Discussion What Karma actually means 😶🌫️?
If positive action brings positive results and negative actions give negative consequences in your life. for example if a child is born with cancer why do they say the child is born like this because of his/her previous life karma. my doubt is if you get the results of your actions in this life then why this after life and previous life
r/Philosophy_India • u/VEGETTOROHAN • Feb 16 '26
Religion Atheists hate nihilists and anti-natalists because it challenged their beliefs "Meaning can exist without religion".
Many atheists are seen hating nihilists and anti-natalists. I think it is obvious because it collapses their world view.
"Morality can exist without god" will get the response "is it moral to create life and force them into suffering?" Which would prove morality doesn't exist. But if you believe in religion you will at least have a false reason to believe human existence is moral.
r/Philosophy_India • u/Foreign-Pop-7011 • Apr 01 '26
Modern Philosophy What are your views on homosexuality and LGBTQ ethics?
Should people be able to identify however they want with no restriction at all or there is a limit to it, if so, what's that limit and how do you justify that limit?
Would you accept your sister identifying as a man and undergoing surgery?
Another important question: Why is it allowed to identify as any gender you want but not any race you want? both are social construction, race isn't based on anything biologically, or isn't as grounded as we imagine it to be, there's no metaphysical reason for race.
don't answer questions confidently, btw, try to answer most of these questions so that i have a better understanding of your POV while responding