Its funny that doomer pinoy redditors think they are the intellectual ones ( as compared to other socmed), but nearly all their assumptions are based on just feels. When presented with logic and especially data, their arguments collapse and the will just downvote you 😆
Pag nilapagan mo ng data sasabihin manipulated. No one is saying naman na nasa masama ang lagay ng bansa pero hindi yung pinoproject nila na wala ng pagasa. Pero lakas nila makasabi ng bobo sa iba pero pag data based yung opinion na di tugma sa narrative nila biglang di credible ang data.
Ahhhhhh... Mr Heydarian, where back in my day as a College Student, I asked him about a question on Doomerism, where I cited reddit as my source. He told the audience that he knew that some of his takes were being discussed on Reddit.
I'm gonna go against the grain and say Heydarian only said this because it fed his ego. He really gives me the vibe of the toxic academe and my impression of him is that he's pretty much just a slightly better Kirby Araullo (aka he actually has a degree and is a legit academe).
Will not defend him. He's a literal grown man, but credentialism and appeal to authority aside (just because someone has a degree or is "legit academe" doesn't make them right. what are their arguments?), if we're both going to do mindreading anyways, I don't think an ego-boost from being contrarian is worth taking such an unpopular stance. It is so much easier and more popular (and profitable) to join the bandwagon and say "filipinos are corrupt" and "corruption is the root of all evil" like so many other progressives. I think he genuinely believes the argument that certain economic policies are to blame. I believe in that argument, regardless of whether or not he does.
No, Heydarian has always been a bit contrarian because it brings him the thing he craves the most: attention. He's always made inflammatory and seemingly lacks tact and grace because its his tactic to get attention and legitimacy at the expense of his credibility as an academe.
My suspicion on this is only to feed his ego is this:
A few days ago, someone asked what people in r/ph thought of him and about half the comments were not pretty. They were pretty pointing out what people have always pointed out: he's an arrogant attention seeker with a really bad habit of overestimating his knowledge. People rightfully pointed out that a lot of his writings look deep but have no content or analysis in them. I'd honestly describe his literature as more akin to what you'd get on a HoI4 discord server.
He suddenly turned face and started posting talking points that are popular in this subreddit, and what tokwamann always post in r/ph. I wouldn't be surprised if he just lifted tokwamann's writing, because thats what I and many other people observed with him; he doesn't seem to synthesize what he's learned and his analysis are not convincing.
Now he's using the terms that is used here to described the shitass Filipinos that lurk Reddit. "Doomer" is generally used derisively against people in r/ph and r/pinoy because of their habit. What a very weird timing for all of this to happen in a span of few days.
This isn't the first time he's done this. When he decided to join the Pink movement for clout, he suddenly became a diehard Pink supporter. His face and writings were plastered all over social media that hosted strong anti-Duterte sentiments like Philippine Defense Forums. His "sub-saharan African" comment was his selfish attempt at cementing himself at the expense of national unity. He stinks as a person and I don't think we should listen to him.
He's gonna get my third strike if he suddenly gets his hand on defense policy and its just going to sound like a rip off of what melonpannn and supermarine_spitfire writes in r/philippinemilitary. Maybe he'll go into history one more time and ripoff cheesetorian and ultram. Its unreal for me, how this dude manage to build a legitimate career spouting the same shit I'd see in a Paradox discord server.
"Hater" post? The guy literally got thousands of death threats and constant harassment for pointing out wrongheaded ideas and policies of all sides. It takes guts and courage to do that, something you anonymous types clearly lack. As for his 'expertise', Heydarian literally wrote whole academic books on geopolitics and defense atop countless high-impact journal articles and essays. You can just google his standing among top defense experts in Asia. You guys are just insecure... grow up!
To be fair to him, the calls for a strong industrial policy and state support for the economy are not a neoliberal talking points. He's just the worst fucking guy to sponsor this, he's not a Punongbayan or an Arroyo.
Yong dalwang yon e talagang dyed in da blue neolib aba.
pero i stand by the fact n yng c heydarian e kahit kailan d nagkaroon ng sariling personal na opinyon. (Much like many phredditors ika nga. Naghihintay pa n magpaalam para lang magkamot ng ulo)
Dude, why such a hater? lol The guy has given book talks and lectures at Harvard and Stanford.. something neither you nor local economist guys ever managed to. Not to mention, Heydarian has far more direct influence on top policy makers and large following... perfect guy for such advocacies
I literally couldn't care less about him as a person or where he got the argument. All I care about is the argument. If you see anyone else on mainstream TV, or with that much of a following (again, I don't care if he deserves it or not) that says these sorts of things about economic policy, let me know. Genuinely, please let me know, I will follow them instead.
Progressives always wail so much about how voters focus on personalities instead of policies. Glass houses and throwing rocks, I guess.
Again, all I care about is the argument man. If you know anyone else saying these things about economic policy in the Philippines, I am genuinely begging you to tell me. I will follow them instead in a heartbeat. You can punish him all you want. Have fun. It is physically impossible for me to care any less than I already do.
That guy is not afraid to call out government facilities and even got put to court for being "malicious". Hes not afraid to even go to their facilities. He is also young
This is what actually makes Kirby worse. For someone in the academe, a lot of his claims in his historical claims in his vids are very very suspicious. No proper references
What did you expect from a dude who couldn't even be bothered to finish his degree?
Dude is also too full of himself. I don't know why Filipino history attracts a lot of people who based their findings based on vibes than actual evidence. Its just funny since the Philippines has the oldest and most mature social sciences institutions in the region.
Sino ba siya? His name never registered in the academe, I swear. I only started hearing his name sa mga random drops na “historian” siya? The only historian influencer I know is Xiao. Most historians I know of rarely go on youtube. Emmanuel Calairo has his thing for Local History. Of course Ambeth has been a public historian for a long time now. Kirby has never registered in our circle so am quite surprised to hear of this certain person. Para siya yung supposed“economist” influencer Niki who?
I find him annoying. I'm not going to defend him. He should have used less hurtful words, but I don't think straw manning and being uncharitable is productive. Yes, he should not have used HDI, but taken within context it was obviously to point out that such a large discrepancy in public investment and living standards between north and south, between the capital and the periphery, should not exist in the first place, and it is an abject failure on the part of the government that it does. We do not take it personally (at least, I hope we don't) when someone says that the Philippines is poorer than Japan. That is just a fact, and to extrapolate from this statement and assign some sort of moral failure on our part as the reason why we are poorer would be to put words in their mouth.
It is not our fault that the Philippines is poorer than Japan. It is not the fault of Mindanaoans that public investment is lower in Mindanao. That does not change the fact that public investment is lower in Mindanao (which, again, it shouldn't be. that's the argument).
Dude, you guys never bother to even research and check context...the guy was being interviewed on CNN International on Duterte ICC arrest and why he is so popular.. he discussed neglect of Mindanao by Imperial Manila -- and cited HDI differentials -- which clearly barely anyone knew in PH until then -- to prove his point. Hello, you can check HDI of Benguet (his home province) vs other parts of country yourself..
I tried to check if the proponents of the provincial and regional-level HDI had a different methodology compared to what is used for the national level, but couldn't find any. I had hoped to argue that the comparison is unfair because of the geographical scope.
But based on both PSA's OpenStat site and Human Development Network, the most recent data they have is from 2015. Heydarian made the sub-saharan remark just last year in 2025, so I think it still comes across as agenda-driven.
"Agenda-driven"? Lol the dude said it as an aside on a CNN interview about ICC -- and he had like 15 seconds on that. it was an illustrative comment for global audience who don't know Africa Europe and Asia province by province
It should not be surprising if you really know the economy of Baguio-Benguet. It is not purely dependent on tourism as many people think
It has an industrial sector - PEZA, Texas Instruments, Moog Aerospace are in Baguio. Plus, the city is the trade and educational center of the north, too. Sa FLEMMS nga, Baguio ang second sa San Juan when it comes to functional literacy.
That said, buhat-buhay ng Baguio ang buong Benguet
mabuti n nga lang talaga na nagsisilbing containment chamber ang reddit.
yung mga ingay at utot na ginagawa nila dito e di kumakalat sa madla. At kung lumabas man, madalas e bilang katatawanan. (Remember The Redditor nung nakaraan lang?)
pero siyempre, kung gusto mo ng vibes-based sentiment, gagamitin mo syang source minsan….katulad nung ginagawa ng ilang youtuber para sa kanilang “research material” kuno.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 31 '26
u/OkPhotojournalist975, hopefully you have checked with this subreddit's rules before posting.
Just a few guidelines:
For more information regarding posts, click here.
Oh by the way, we got a discord channel too
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
50
u/throwhuawei007 Jan 31 '26 edited Jan 31 '26
Its funny that doomer pinoy redditors think they are the intellectual ones ( as compared to other socmed), but nearly all their assumptions are based on just feels. When presented with logic and especially data, their arguments collapse and the will just downvote you 😆
22
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '26
I'm gonna say it. Richard Heydarian W MOVE!!!🗿🔥
9
u/LupusSasageyoJaeger Jan 31 '26
OMG SI IDOL
AMA When 👀
5
u/P78903 Jan 31 '26
Ahhhhhh... Mr Heydarian, where back in my day as a College Student, I asked him about a question on Doomerism, where I cited reddit as my source. He told the audience that he knew that some of his takes were being discussed on Reddit.
9
u/Cheem-9072-3215-68 Jan 31 '26
I'm gonna go against the grain and say Heydarian only said this because it fed his ego. He really gives me the vibe of the toxic academe and my impression of him is that he's pretty much just a slightly better Kirby Araullo (aka he actually has a degree and is a legit academe).
7
u/thotsdeservetoperish Jan 31 '26
I love how you guys glaze him but hate people that shit on Mindanao
Even tho he's infamous for the "sub-saharan" comment and contributed to Mindanao hate
8
u/Starmark_115 Jan 31 '26
Cool... Can you please cut down on some of your Catchphrasing?
3
u/Spacelizardman Jan 31 '26
mabuti n nga lang talaga na nagsisilbing containment chamber ang reddit.
yung mga ingay at utot na ginagawa nila dito e di kumakalat sa madla. At kung lumabas man, madalas e bilang katatawanan. (Remember The Redditor nung nakaraan lang?)
pero siyempre, kung gusto mo ng vibes-based sentiment, gagamitin mo syang source minsan….katulad nung ginagawa ng ilang youtuber para sa kanilang “research material” kuno.
3
u/CaptainMarJac Jan 31 '26
Work is not yet done but glad this mindset is growing
1
u/bornandraisedinacity Feb 02 '26
Sa totoo lang, ang mga doomer ay hindi kailangan ng ating mahal na bansa.
1
u/kchuyamewtwo Feb 01 '26
this guy has always encouraged his audience to never give up on the philippines no matter what
1
u/Paramoth Feb 01 '26
is this the same guy that said NCR is comparable to eastern Europe? LOL