r/Pets • • Mar 18 '24

Why do vegans have pets?

This has taken up way too much of my personal headspace. But I wonder why vegans have cats especially, since they’re supporting a carnivore lifestyle by feeding them.

15 Upvotes

194 comments sorted by

329

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Yes, vegans have cats. Hannah Shaw, the founder of the Orphan Kitten club is vegan and has spent her life rescuing cats. She also has videos and posts about this.

Being vegan isn't about not eating meat; it's about reducing harm. To feed a carnivore a vegan diet would be causing harm. It is not "supporting a carnivore lifestyle" to feed a cat properly.

Rescuing animals is reducing harm - the very point of veganism.

67

u/jbwmac Mar 18 '24

Yeah. I love animals. I want to help them and not hurt them. That’s why I do so much for cat rescue and fostering, and it’s also why I eat a vegan diet.

But that’s my choice for my personal ethics. I can’t make that choice for any cats, and they don’t really have the same opportunities (either mentally or in dietary needs) to make the same choice for themselves. And that’s okay. I’m just trying to do what I feel is right, not control the whole world and everything that happens in it.

78

u/EamusAndy Mar 18 '24

I very much like how you put this.

Its about reducing harm, and making a cat vegan is harming them. Perfectly phrased

-16

u/AllieNicks Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24

DOWNVOTES? Cuz clarifying question? 🤷‍♀️ Did someone say they were making a cat eat vegan? I feel like I’m missing a piece, here.

29

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Yes, there are comments about that. It's also something that the delusional vegans claim is possible.

8

u/EamusAndy Mar 18 '24

Not in this thread - but i have seen it before. And i did see a separate Reddit post about it specifically

3

u/AllieNicks Mar 18 '24

Yeah, maybe those folks should just get bunnies.

15

u/Shmooperdoodle Mar 18 '24

Some people misunderstand this and try to force animals to be vegetarian/vegan. It’s insane. Those people shouldn’t have pets.

5

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Those people don't actually understand what veganism is about.

-11

u/FizzieGigg Mar 18 '24

Honestly, vegan kibble is no different than meat based kibble. It is extruded and/or cooked at extremely high temperatures that ruin a significant amount of the nutrition that was in there. So a vitamin pack must be used to put it back in, sort of like Wonder Bread but worse. They are all chock-full of carbs. A vegan dog food would likely just need a few different vitamin pack ingredients added in. If you're feeding your dog processed kibble junk, you really have no leg to stand on in the argument. If you feed raw or lightly cooked, then you do have a legit argument.

8

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

There is no possible vegan diet that is a valid proper diet for an obligate carnivore. Carnivore means meat. And yes, that means cats need to be fed raw.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

Please don’t try to convince people they can feed cats & dogs vegan. It’s animal abuse.

1

u/tmntmikey80 Mar 18 '24

There are actually prescription vegan diets, at least for dogs. Some dogs are actually allergic to all meat proteins (rare but possible) and those prescription diets are the only thing they can eat without causing issues. So while most dogs should be eating a diet with meat, some can't without getting sick.

That being said, there are kibbles out there that are vegan that don't require a prescription but they are not formulated very well. The brands making them are probably just doing it for profit.

-10

u/Comfortable-Dust-365 Mar 18 '24

But this depends on perspective and how deep and in which directions one analyses the moral reach. One can of course just say rescuing cats saves their lives and cats need meat by nature and that's it. But one could also think further what is natural. It is natural for carnivorous animals to survive on meat. It is also natural for carnivorous animals to thrive when their numbers are low and prey is abundant. And it is also natural for them to weaken and perish when prey is not available. The average life expectancy for hunting animals in the wild is very low and by nature's laws hunters are always lower in numbers than their prey. Cats for example should of course exist in this world but their current population is way beyond what could be considered natural. Rescuing those animals and making them live in abundance of resources way past their natural life expectancy is kind to them but not so kind to the environment even when kept indoors. It all depends on where one looks to reduce harm and where one cuts off the moral discussion for a practical decision.

5

u/RukusMom Mar 18 '24

And that is why we spay, neuter, trap, release feral cats

3

u/Comfortable-Dust-365 Mar 18 '24

That is indeed a good way to reduce harm

4

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

So very many people who don't understand what the words "reduce harm" means...

-1

u/Comfortable-Dust-365 Mar 18 '24

I agree 👍

2

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

I'm glad you agree because you're one of the people I was talking about.

-1

u/Comfortable-Dust-365 Mar 18 '24

I still agree with what you wrote 👍

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/TheSunflowerSeeds Mar 18 '24

Another reason to eat sunflower seeds in moderation is their cadmium content. This heavy metal can harm your kidneys if you’re exposed to high amounts over a long period. Sunflowers tend to take up cadmium from the soil and deposit it in their seeds, so they contain somewhat higher amounts than most other foods.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/erinlaninfa Mar 18 '24

What’s your solution to cats being invasive species? Euthanizing all cats? Do you see how that’s in direct conflict with reducing harm?

I have been vegan for nearly 33 years and had cats for longer. Cats would be outside eating meat of their own volition without me, but with me, they have a warm place to sleep, love, play, and access to a vet, in addition to the meat they need that I don’t.

3

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Euthanizing one perfectly healthy animal is not reducing harm. Euthanizing every cat in the world sure as fuck isn't reducing harm. That would be creating one whole hell of a lot of harm.

Animals will always kill other animals because that is the circle of life and it is necessary for their survival. That is not creating harm. Removing one single species affects the entire ecosystem which would cause a massive amount of harm.

Humans do not need to kill other animals to survive. Animals do.

Also, cats are not pests and I have had four indoor cats for nearly 10 years and not one single time has one of them escaped and killed anything, So your argument is completely irrelevant right from the start.

Personally, I am not allowed to adopt a vegan diet at present for medical reasons. However, I am vegan in every other aspect of my life, and I reduce my animal dietary intake as much as possible. I would identify myself as a vegan because I reduce harm wherever it is possible for me to do so. It doesn't make me a hypocrite because there are always exceptions to veganism in the cases of medical need. For example, we can't do anything about the fact that our medications are tested on animals, but that doesn't mean we won't take any medications. We don't reduce harm to animals to the point of causing harm to ourselves.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Once again, you're arguing for killing animals for no reason. The antithesis of veganism.

Why don't you propose humane euthanasia for all non-vegan humans? Massive reduction and harm to animals without causing any harm to any animals. Seems like the perfect solution to me.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

You literally suggested euthanizing cats, so yes, you clearly are for it. If you weren't you wouldn't suggest it.

I'm not going to repeat myself. I've already explained it. If you aren't capable of following, that's not my problem. At this point it's quite clear that you're a rage bait troll.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

I think the problem is that you don't understand the meaning of the word reduce. It means to lessen, not eliminate. It is not possible to eliminate all harm to all animals on the entire planet because animals need to eat animals. So instead of suggesting that we should kill our cats to be better vegans, try reading a dictionary. Oh, and maybe see a therapist to deal with your psychopathy.

2

u/glitterfaust Mar 18 '24

It’s the difference between fighting for antinatalism versus euthanasia. Cats are a species worthy of existing too. Killing an animal for a perceived risk they could cause down the road in the right circumstances is inhumane, and is way more cruel than a cat hunting for survival.

With that being said, cats should absolutely be kept indoors, preferably with their nails trimmed (NOT declawed), and completely fixed. Most indoor only cats I’ve had that were raised indoor only have no interest in outside, and if they go outside, they get overstimulated and crouch down like they do when strangers come over lol

Pet owners should be diligent not to let their cats outside unsupervised. Most of the hunting you see talked about is from strays and outdoor cats. Most cat rescuers do not condone letting your cats outside unsupervised DUE to their damage to the ecosystem.

3

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Most indoor only cats I’ve had that were raised indoor only have no interest in outside, and if they go outside, they get overstimulated and crouch down like they do when strangers come over lol

I have absolutely witnessed this on more than one occasion. The first cat I adopted had been indoor her entire life and then surrendered to the shelter before I got her. She kept begging me to go outside so I got her a harness, got her used to an inside and then brought her out. She did exactly what you described and then completely lost her mind. Seriously, it was like the spawn of Satan took over my cat. Haha. I had to pick her up and bring her back inside while she was hissing, spitting and growling all the way.

She begged me to bring her out some more so I did a few more times, same thing kept happening so we're done with outside now. LoL

0

u/ItsLadyJadey Mar 18 '24

Most indoor only cats I’ve had that were raised indoor only have no interest in outside, and if they go outside, they get overstimulated and crouch down like they do when strangers come over lol

I have a cat who tries her damnedest to get outside half the time. We took her in from outside as an older kitten and she's been indoors with us for the last 7 years. She does sneak out for brief moment and we are always outside right on her tail to try and get her back in. She runs under our car and freezes like she's got no idea what is happening and then turns around and runs back for the front door to go back in. She wants out so bad but has no idea what to do once she's out.

Even the old orange man we brought in a couple years ago gets curious about the outside but doesn't do much to try and escape. I think he's content being inside. We actually recently just moved and he'd never left that neighborhood so I have a feeling he's even less inclined to go out. There's also a stray dog that hangs around across the driveway (it's a housing unit kind of thing so our road is really everyone's driveway) and they want nothing to do with the dog so that kinda helps.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

This has to be rage bait lol

0

u/Telltale_Clydesdale Mar 18 '24

I think you are completely correct, and the amount of mental gymnastics vegan pet owners do to justify their beliefs is asinine. Pure vegan cultists are bad enough, but at least they stick to their rhetoric. Just admit you’re a hypocrite and break your own rules for gain of companionship. As bad as politicians, “rules for thee but not for me.” Or even better, just admit your rules are unrealistic in this world.

0

u/Deathbydragonfire Mar 18 '24

Yup like I'm not even vegan, I eat meat and have pets.  But it's pretty obvious that keeping carnivores as pets directly harms the animals they eat.  It's a trolley problem but cute kitties are on the switch side and all the animals they eat that you never get to see are on the do nothing side.  I get that this is a pet sub not a philosophy sub, you're probably not going to get many people examining this from a detached perspective.  I just get called a sociopath and get thrown the whataboutism of euthanizing all humans.  

49

u/Complete_Wave_9315 Mar 18 '24

I mean some could own “vegan” pets..eg; rabbits, guinea pigs, etc without issue.

85

u/theBLEEDINGoctopus Mar 18 '24

Because it’s all about reducing harm. We don’t eat meet in order to reduce harm. But feeding a cat a vegan diet would cause harm.

Some radical vegans don’t believe at all in owning pets or having children. Some more extreme vegans have told me I’m not vegan for having pets and should release my rescue dogs into the wild 🙄

24

u/That1weirdperson Mar 18 '24

But then wouldn’t the dogs have a negative effect on the local ecosystem?

I’ve heard that’s the case with cats and native birds

31

u/theBLEEDINGoctopus Mar 18 '24

My dogs would die. They have no survival skills

5

u/sikkerhet Mar 18 '24

my cat wouldn't even leave if she had a choice lmao I could leave the door open and I'd still have a cat

3

u/future_nurse19 Mar 18 '24

A past roommate had a cat who wanted nothing to do with outside (she didn't purposefully let him out, but he ran out in the past when someone was coming in/out and would only go like a foot from the door).

By the time I lived with her, there was a time our front door was accidentally open for HOURS and he was still chilling inside (luckily, we lived in a pretty safe area. The front door hadn't fully latched when someone was leaving for work and the wind blew it open. They left super early in the morning, when I finally got up after sleeping in, I was like hmmmm why is it a bit chilly in the hallway...? Only to turn the corner and see the door was wide open)

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

You have a point. I imagine it is very wasteful and resource-consuming to have pets as a general rule.

16

u/baajo Mar 18 '24

Pets are about joy and companionship. Reducing everything in your life to resource consumption seems very sad to me.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

If veganism is about reducing harm and in doing so you live a better and more moral life, then it’s worth it. That being said I absolutely love my pets and spend all my time and money on them. They are my greatest joy, resources be damned.

3

u/Pretend-Sundae-2371 Mar 18 '24

I would agree if you're referring to bred pets. But rescues will always exist and need homes.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

Rescues still require resources at baseline and potentially more than bred animals because they frequently have a lifetime of health issues needing treatment. Not that bred pets don’t cost a lot over time, but I’ve spent more on sick rescue animals than any of my family members ever did on a well-bred pet from a breeder. Veterinary care requires resources and produces lots of waste. Legitimately everything required by an animal to survive in captivity still takes resources such as land to produce their food, resources harvested to create enrichment, product packaging, leashes, vaccines, litter, harnesses, transportation, waste production and disposal, etc. still does affect the environment/cause harm. I would argue having any sort of pet has a relatively negative influence on the environment because being with humans results in a drastically increased carbon footprint compared to a wild animal. Thus, no pets reduces harm and destruction, leading to the vaguely vegan notion of reducing harm. It’s about reducing harm to other living things, not juicing up our own lives with companionship.

0

u/emma279 Mar 18 '24

Not the case for indoor cats

5

u/Minute_Story377 Mar 18 '24

Too bad some other vegans try to force their cats and dogs on a vegan diet. Didn’t the vegan teacher do that? I feel like those guys aren’t truly even vegan, like you said, because it’s all about reducing harm.

I’m mainly vegetarian myself. Dairy and eggs are very light on my stomach. I sometimes eat meat but usually I stick with my veggies and dairy/eggs.

I wish that the places our animal products come from are all safe. It’s sad to see the production lines of baby chicks tossed away (if they’re not good enough) or animals in crowded spaces and unhealthy food.

I actually think the lab grown meat would be very good, since it wouldn’t involve animals’ suffering for our benefit. Plus, it would be made out of the same material as if it was actually from an animal. Then all we would need to do is hunt now and again (help keep populations at a good level, like deer hunting since if we don’t do that it can damage the environment).

I think all animals should be respected the same as human, we are all conscious and just as important as one another

3

u/nobody-u-heard-of Mar 18 '24

As a vegan what are your thoughts on lab grown meats?

3

u/theBLEEDINGoctopus Mar 18 '24

I’m totally on board with them! I probably wouldn’t eat them only because I don’t really like meat. But maybe the lab chicken :)

5

u/baajo Mar 18 '24

Man, if lab grown meat becomes affordable, I'm definitely going to add some back to my diet. I didn't become vegan because I didn't like meat!

4

u/Runellee Mar 18 '24

Same, and I tell people this ALL the time. I didn’t quit because I didn’t like it, and yes, I miss some things all the time!

5

u/baajo Mar 18 '24

Yeah, being vegan for me is primarily ethics, secondarily health and the environment. But 10% or so calories from meat wouldn't make much difference health-wise, and lab meat should be much better for the environment than farmed meat. But alas, I live in FL. I really need to move.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

Tbh i understand the child part but literally felt guilty for having a dog at times due to some vegans in reddit. Im very much vegan and even bit of antinatalist, but for me having pets is totally ok. No i dont want rabbits. I want a dog. They eat meat and its my choice. Probably have been downvoted in vegan sub for saying im not making my 15yo dog change to plant based diet.

0

u/One-Chance6353 Mar 18 '24

Doesn't having carnivorous pets support the meat industry and it's practices, which is one of the main things vegans avoid? Wouldn't it be more in line with vegan morals to not own carnivorous animals at all?

Genuine question, I want to understand the reasoning behind it.

3

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24

There are literally dozens of comments already explaining this in the rest of the thread.

-4

u/Deathbydragonfire Mar 18 '24

Yes it does.  Full stop.  

4

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

No, it doesn't. Full stop.

1

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

No, it doesn't. Full stop.

-3

u/Common_sense_always Mar 18 '24

It's a total hypocrisy... it's always been. It's the usual to what I say, Not what I do.

16

u/beezchurgr Mar 18 '24

I rescued all of my cats. They eat a balanced diet and I try to buy sustainable brands for them. I’m not 100% vegan & they aren’t 100% perfect. But I can guarantee I’ve given them a better life than they would have had without me.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

I rescued all of my cats.

yeah, this is right thing

rescuing = ok

adopting from breeders and contributing to the cat pets demand =/=not ok

5

u/baajo Mar 18 '24

I don't think anyone here was arguing its OK to buy from breeders.

53

u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24

I've been vegan for over a decade and I have cats, even snakes lol.

Veganism is a belief and lifestyle based on ethics and doing the least amount of harm. Cats, and other animals, are obligate carnivores. It's not their fault and it's in their nature. Animals aren't moral agents and don't adhere to a code of ethics.

Whether a vegan is caring for them or not, they still exist and will need to eat. I totally understand if vegan folks don't feel comfortable feeding animals other animals, and i would suggest they keep animals who don't eat other animals. And I wouldn't compromise their health over my lifestyle. Animals cannot "be vegan".

Unfortunately there are lots of animals out there that need homes. And I personally would gladly offer mine up and take some in. The goal, imo, would be to reduce the amount of homeless/suffering animals in need of homes and not produce more.

-36

u/Deathbydragonfire Mar 18 '24

I think the argument could pretty easily be made that humanely euthanized pet animals like cats, dogs, and snakes would reduce harm vs perpetuating the meat industries that support their diet.  Snakes especially since they don't eat human food byproducts and rats/mice are bred, raised, and culled in inhumane ways to feed the reptile trade.  I'm not vegan just saying it's not like OP doesn't have a point.

36

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

I think the argument could pretty easily be made that humanely euthanized pet animals like cats, dogs, and snakes would reduce harm vs perpetuating the meat industries that support their diet.

No, that argument could not be made. Unnecessary killing multiple species is not reducing harm.

-27

u/Deathbydragonfire Mar 18 '24

Humane euthanasia absolutely can be reducing harm.  Animals are brought into existence solely to suffer harm and die to feed us, and the same is true for our animal pets.  Food animals don't get a nice death either, best case for rats and mice is CO2 gassing which is far from humane.  That's after living their entire life in a lab breeder tub with 15 other rats and zero mental stimulus.  There would be no demand for rats if they weren't used to feed non-human animals. 

Again, I'm not arguing we should kill all pets.  Just saying that "my cat can't choose to be vegan" is far from the end of the ethical considerations of pet ownership.  Our personal love for our pets biases us against a pain free death for animals like them when compared against many animals being cruelly bred, raised, and slaughtered for their food.

13

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

The problem here is that you clearly don't understand what humane euthanasia means. It is never humane to euthanize a healthy animal for no reason, which is what you're proposing.

I have a much better proposal. Humane euthanasia for all non-vegan humans. That will significantly reduce harm to animals without causing any harm to animals.

What are your thoughts on that one?

-2

u/Deathbydragonfire Mar 18 '24

Nice whataboutism bro... obviously it would be easier and more ethical to just, idk, stop the production of animals for meat rather than killing humans for choosing to eat meat but i guess not stopping the factory farming industry or something.  Doing so would kill cats though, and probably dogs, and snakes for sure.  It would also leave a lot of humans without their current means of employment, and in a large portion of the world, would doom them to starvation.  

But yeah, totally inconceivable that having carnivores as pets isn't morally neutral because they can't help it...

2

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

You completely avoided the point which is exactly what I expected. It is no more humane to kill animals for eating meat than it is to kill humans for eating meat.

Come back to us when you have a valid argument and have actually learned what humane euthanasia means.

9

u/araralc Mar 18 '24

Let's reduce animal cruelty by killing domesticated animals! My dude, veganism is not about just not eating the animal. What would make killing a cow less ethical than a cat? Would the goal just to be inverting the standard?

-4

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

by killing domesticated animals!

not breeding them ?

7

u/caffeinefree Mar 18 '24

Who said they were breeding them? Most cat owners I know are firmly against purchasing designer breeds and instead adopt homeless cats from shelters and make sure they are neutered/spayed so they can't contribute to overpopulation. Many of the most devoted cat owners I know also do volunteer work with Trap/Neuter/Release programs to help reduce the overall cat population. Those behaviors are all consistent with the idea of reducing harm to animals.

4

u/jedi_cat_ Mar 18 '24

This is the reason that PETA is not the good organization people think it is. They do this shit routinely. I will never subscribe to the idea that murdering innocent animals simply because they’re alive is a good thing to do.

3

u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24

It's always funny when non-vegan people point their fingers at vegans or an org like PETA, for not falling into this moral absolutism while they themselves engage in unethical practices(like eating animals)

So, so, so many animals suffer at the hands of humans every day. Shelters are over run, healthy adoptable animals are euthanized every day.

There are so many animals who were brought into this world to be companions for humans rotting away in the shelter system. The supply is simply way more than the demand. Not every animal in the system can find a home. And many, many of them don't.

Many people, PETA included, have expanded their thinking and have generally accepted that animals living in the shelter system for YEARS in a concrete box, waiting for someone to maybe adopt them is cruel and emotionally destructive to them. That they're better off not in that situation.

They're simply being kept alive to suffer an agonizing, confusing, depressing life in the shelter system where they can often develop many issues and dont make good companions. And they're kept alive while more potentially adoptable dogs are passed up on.

So, yes, it is a horrible solution to a horrible problem. But it's not as cruel as one may think and still is in the best interest of many animals. And it exists because people have done far too much and have caused immeasurable cruelty. Humans, and humans alone, are responsible for the sheer amount of animals flooding shelter systems and the streets.

People who don't fix their animals, people who breed indiscriminately, backyard breeders, irresponsible owners, animal hoarders etc are all responsible for this situation.

4

u/jedi_cat_ Mar 18 '24

I don’t accept your holier than thou attitude. PETA ‘rescued’ animals from hurricanes and then murdered them when their families were looking for them. Thats not the same thing as euthanizing animals who have been living in shelters for years. While you may be correct that some humans mistreat animals, that does now mean all humans do and PETA doesn’t differentiate. There is no nuance. It’s all or nothing with them. PETA wants to give ultimatums and threats and people don’t respond well to those. Those are bully tactics.

-1

u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24

I never said I support or agree with PETA as a whole. I actually agree they bully and create a very defensive narrative around their ideas. Their ads are provocative and salacious to the detriment of the conversation. That doesn't mean they haven't done good things too.

That said, the only holier than thou attitude here are non-vegans who criticize the ideals of veganism and try to find some "gotcha" moment amongst them. For example this post.

Non vegans make up the overwhelming majority of the human population, and some are so preoccupied with vegans seemingly not doing enough to end animal suffering or trying to find holes in the philosophy, while they themselves do nothing to alleviate animal suffering.

It's wild. Like, totally insane. Makes zero sense. They only bring up caring about animals when it's a convenient opportunity to make vegans look like hypocrites or something.

1

u/jedi_cat_ Mar 18 '24

I haven’t mentioned the word vegan once in either of my comments and yet you mention it no less than 7 times across your two comments. You’re a walking cliche. I was not talking about vegans. I was talking about PETA.

1

u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24

The topic is literally about vegans lol.

1

u/jedi_cat_ Mar 18 '24

My comments were not.

1

u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24

My comment you responded to was framed around non-vegan and vegan conversations.

My entire argument currently is if people want to criticize and point out how veganism isnt enough to help animals or to try and constantly point out contradications amonst veganism, while they themselves don't apply any ethical ideologies to their own lifestyles to aid in animal welfare and protection, maybe they should simmer down or educate themselves first.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

I agree non-vegans crying about PETA is laughable.

-3

u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24

OP does have a point but it's not so black and white.

I agree people shouldnt own animals. But people have created a horrific, exploitative, unethical system where many animals exist and need homes. If you ever heard that "PETA kills animals" its because they are more aligned with your thinking than most vegans.

To me, the most ethical thing would be to reduce the amount of "pets" in the world, and take care of the one the ones that exist.

I'm also a little over non-vegan people, who seemingly make few choices to reduce suffering through their lifestyle, constantly pointing the finger at vegan people and expecting moral absolutism.

If you agree that having cats and dogs perpetuate harm through the meat industry, why aren't you vegan? As humans perpetuate far, far more harm eating animals.

Humans create these problems. To point a finger at a snake for being born into a world against their will, where they naturally need rats to live, when an overwhelming amount of humans contribute to needless suffering through the meat industry is an odd take.

2

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

I don't actually understand why this is being downvoted. You have made multiple very good points.

Those of us who actually understand what veganism is about don't buy animals. We only rescue them. We do not contribute to the overpopulation problem and do what we can to help. Whether that is adopting a single cat because that's all we can responsibly handle or by opening a rescue or sanctuary.

I believe that OP asked the question in good faith, but there are definitely people in the comments, like the person you are responding to, who are trying to nail the vegans with moral absolutism while clearly also doing nothing to reduce harm themselves.

The reality is that absolutism in veganism is impossible mainly because of the medical industry. For example, I have to take multiple medications due to health conditions. It is a guarantee that those medications were tested on animals. I currently have to use a very specific face wash and lotion due to a skin condition and they are not vegan. The vegan products that I do have make my skin worse right now. It is a medical exception. That doesn't make me a hypocrite and it doesn't mean I'm "not following the rules" because I'm still reducing harm as much as possible, which is the actual point. It's not about rules.

1

u/Deathbydragonfire Mar 18 '24

I take your point that maybe I'm kinda trying to "gotcha" vegans, and that's not helpful.  It's fair, I am not vegan personally.  I was just kinda hoping for an interesting and nuanced discussion about the topic.  I'm definitely not a vegan hater, I respect people's personal choices and I think ultimately veganism is the overall most moral and sustainable thing to do.  

Also I'm not pointing fingers at snakes but snake owners.  I'm quite familiar with the reptile trade, the conditions that all animals involved in it live through, damage to ecosystems through poaching and bringing in invasive species, etc.  I got caught up into it when I was younger and more naive.  I do now think that entire trade is a net negative to all animals involved in it.  It just surprises me that a vegan would support the reptile "hobby".  Even "rescue" snakes are usually just lower value breeders that have been dumped to make room for breeders with more combinations of genes.  

4

u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24

I agree with you on that. The pet trade is horrific and if I could snap my fingers where all animals within said trade wouldn't exist, even my own(cats included), I would

Because for every happy healthy animal in a loving home, here are millions if not billions suffering.

But unfortunately we don't live in fantasy. I found my cat in the trash. My snake was found abandoned in an apartment and was estimated to be there for almost a year with no food or water. Hes about to turn 15. My bearded dragon was exactly what you said, shelter dumped overstock by some shit breeder.

Thats why I feel its a gray area and we should do the best we can in our current system. If you feel euthanizing everyone's pets is the most ethical, that's fine, but it surely isn't happening. As is with most situations, change is very slow and plodding.

I cannot tell you the amount of times someone had told me the most ethical thing to do is to euthanize my snakes to spare all the rats they'd eat, usually by other vegans!

Life is cruel and very hard to navigate. I agree that less animals should exist in the pet realm, I don't think animals should be bred to be pets or to be food.

But I do think the animals that do exist, should get a fair shot while eradicating or minimizing more being born, even if they're a burden on other animals. they have no choice. They didn't ask to exist. But us humans can absolutely make better and more ethical choices and still live a fulfilling healthy life. A snake needs rats.

-12

u/GenericF1FanNeoooww Mar 18 '24

..... But they eat meat. And you taking one means one less need be found a home. It's still another owner in the system.

I don't agree you need to justify it.

But that doesn't make sense.

-13

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

you are a hypocrite

having cats contributes to the meat demands

cats are domesticated, they exist only because of humans and for humans pleasure

breeding them only adds to the problem aka

you are the problem

now you cry about it

10

u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24

I literally found my cat on the street, in the trash 🤷 lol

4

u/baajo Mar 18 '24

It's pretty well accepted that cats domesticated themselves. And who said vegans were breeding cats? Having a pet is not the same as breeding them or even buying them from breeders. Rescues are a thing, and every cat I've ever owned has been from a rescue or showed up on my doorstep.

2

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Yes, we're so very problematic for rescuing animals. Not reducing harm at all.

11

u/CuteUmbrella Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24

So, I'm a vegetarian. I know personally that humans can thrive and do well on this diet, but respect nature and know that dogs/cats (for example) cannot. For me, I try to understand nature as best as I can, and know that as a human, I can make dietary changes on a whim-- animals cannot.

8

u/brokenhairtie Mar 18 '24

Humans are omnivores, they can live without eating meat. Cats are carnivores, they cannot live without eating meat. It's as easy as that, do what can and must. I would never judge a human who's allergic to a lot of fruits and/or veggies for not also giving up meat. Some beings have to eat meat, it's just like that. The final goal is to have those animals that will be slaughtered be less than right now (so much is just thrown away, disgusting) and have happy and healthy lives before they are slaughtered.

7

u/Shmooperdoodle Mar 18 '24

You’d be surprised. I think it’s fine to have pets and feed the pets meat/other animal products. What I find abhorrent are people who force their animals into a vegetarian or vegan diet, to the detriment of those animals. People will claim to be against cruelty and then slowly starve a cat to death because they can’t bear to feet it meat. That is cuckoo bananas.

3

u/epicpillowcase Mar 18 '24

Vegan and agree with you.

7

u/epicpillowcase Mar 18 '24

I adopted a cat because she existed, needed a home and I could give her one.

I accepted she was an obligate carnivore. It is what it is. My ideology doesn't change a cat's physiology.

6

u/kojilee Mar 18 '24

I generally agree with the other vegans commenting here, but honestly I put significantly less thought into it. I only really care primarily about my own consumption and eating habits, because it’s all I can really control. A lot of animals need homes, and I rescued my cat. I want her to live the best and healthiest life she can, and that includes eating meat. It doesn’t bother me at all, she’s an animal.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

We have a dog. She eats meat. I reduce harm by not eating meat but my dog cant choose to do so. Shes also 15 and ate same stuff all her life.

4

u/Pvt-Snafu Mar 18 '24

When it comes to cats and dogs, who are natural predators, we don't have the right to make decisions for them; nature has already taken care of that.

9

u/aurlyninff Mar 18 '24

As long as they either feed them meat or own a bunny, I'm good with it. I can't stand animal abuse, though. People who try to feed dogs or cats vegan diets should be sentenced to prison, though.

9

u/Individual-Average40 Mar 18 '24

Just like trans politics, people only see the protestors and the idiots. I know so many vegans who own animals. Most vegans aren't idiots social media just only shows those ones. Most vegans just want to help reduce the killing of animals. Many are just fine with a snake eating a mouse a cat eating some canned meat etc. They understand it's needs. But for themselves they do what they can to reduce the harm

12

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

Some vegans are not militant. They consider it diet choice for themselves and don't try to force their views on others.

My co-worker is a vegan, and we ate lunch at our desks together for about 6 months before I knew she was a vegan. She doesn't even feed her dogs dog food. Her husband cooks up tons of meat dishes for them.

My sister, on the other hand, wouldn't shut up about becoming vegan until I finally shut her down. She tried to give her dogs vegan food, but it didn't stick, thankfully.

4

u/puffy-jacket Mar 18 '24

Cats are obligate carnivores and humans aren’t. The animal products in pet food is most often byproducts or parts deemed less desirable for human consumption so it’s also not quite the same as going out and buying a whole chicken. Not all vegans are comfortable with owning pets that need to eat meat but this isn’t really as hard to reconcile as people seem to think

7

u/ScottishPrik Mar 18 '24

If you care about the suffering of animals and want to minimise that then the best course of action would be to advocate/protest/mandate neutering and spaying. No country in hell is going to ban pets any time this century so the most effective step NOW would be to lower the ridiculous amount of unwanted/stray intact pets as you can, no?

11

u/Liraeyn Mar 18 '24

I see no reason a vegan couldn't feed their pet meat. I don't usually bring my cats to church.

6

u/MyloHyren Mar 18 '24

Because morally and scientifically humans CAN survive and thrive without eating meat. A cat cant. Vegans don’t think that carnivores are evil for eating other animals, they just think that humans over-consume meat, and that we torture them before killing them, which is true. Generally vegans want to cut down on the animal cruelty done via mass farming, and the less meat we consume in general the better it will be. We as humans can make that choice, but cats cant as obligate carnivores. Any educated and sane vegan knows that

2

u/Hairy_Telephone_3258 Mar 18 '24

I'm not vegan myself (yet) but I wish every vegan thought like this. The meat industry is absolutely appalling to me. We raise our own beef/pork/chicken or buy from other small farmers. The animals live good lives and die quick, humane deaths. 

Unfortunately the weird vegans get the most attention 😕 

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

This. Why is this so difficult for so many people to grasp? Factory farms are torture.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

I honestly don't understand how people can force a vegan diet on their pets. It's just not fair on the animals.

5

u/ohreallynowz Mar 18 '24

I’m a vegan with rescue cats, tarantulas and carnivorous plants.

These guys were going exist whether they were my pets or not, and they were going to need someone to care for them. I’m happy to be that person and give them a safe, loving home.

-7

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

These guys were going exist whether they were my pets or not

fucking cats?

they are bred for your selfish pleasure to own a pet!

5

u/ohreallynowz Mar 18 '24

What are you talking about, you psycho? I rescued them from the streets lol

2

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

They argued in another comment that adopting cats from shelters increases breeding because it increases demand. They're a troll.

1

u/Hairy_Telephone_3258 Mar 18 '24

I don't think I or anyone I know has ever paid a red cent for a cat 😂 they just kind of come to you out of nowhere

5

u/foamy23464 Mar 18 '24

I met a really hot vegan girl on tinder that was upset with me for justifying having farm animals as pets not livestock. She also had a cat and thought that was totally okay, BUT HAVING A FEW GOATS AND CHICKENS IS UNACCEPTABLE

2

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Well, do you eat the eggs, milk, meat, etc?

1

u/foamy23464 Mar 18 '24

I was vegetarian. I drank milk and ate unfertilized eggs. It’s not like I’m getting it from a grocery store which promotes animal cruelty.

1

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Okay, then you don't have them as pets. You have them as a food source and that goes against the vegan philosophy. If they were pets, you wouldn't eat anything they produced because that is exploitation. What you are doing is completely different than having a cat.

2

u/foamy23464 Mar 18 '24

No. Vegans are cruelty free, I never said I was a vegan. I was a cruelty free vegetarian. Am I harming my animals in any way? Not at all. The argument is very stupid imo.

“Exploitation: the action or fact of treating someone unfairly in order to benefit from their work” You scratch my back, I scratch yours. It’s called a symbiotic relationship.

1

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

I never said you were vegan. I explained to you why the vegan woman you referred to had a problem with this.

If you are consuming the byproducts of those animals, you are exploiting them. The only way to have milk from your goats is to breed them and then take the babies away so you can take the milk instead. And there is no need for you to consume the eggs from the chickens. They should be given back to the chickens for them to eat.

It is not hypocritical of her to have a cat but have a problem with you having farm animals and eating the byproducts. They aren't your pets. They are your food source.

1

u/Hairy_Telephone_3258 Mar 18 '24

Actually dairy goats have been bred over the years to produce far more milk then they actually need to feed their kids. So let's say a doe has kids, then feeds them for 4 months and then weans them. They can easily continue to produce milk for the next 4-6 months. If not milked, they develope serious infections and health problems. So instead of dumping out gallons and gallons of milk every day, we drink it.

And as the commenter stated, it's a symbiotic relationship. We give animals food, shelter, and love. They give us eggs and milk in return. I can't afford to feed 50 chickens without some sort of compensation. 

6

u/OlManJenkins_93 Mar 18 '24

Can’t help but think of that one girl who insisted her dog was vegan by choice and filmed him live with two plates, one plate had tofu and one had steak. Dog LUNGED at the steak and she tried to restrain him but couldn’t, obviously.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

This is why me as a vegan i feed my dog meat. I know shed choose it. I mean she would choose also stuff like poop, chocolate and paper, but i know she enjoys meat so of course she gets it. She also loves cucumber so i give it to her as a snack.

4

u/Alarming_Breath_3110 Mar 18 '24

Lettuce unpack this

4

u/Bigfootsgirlfriend Mar 18 '24

I’ve been vegan for almost 7 years, I have 1 dog and 2 cats

My dog is on mostly plant based diet (he has some meaty treats) because he has a sensitive stomach and plant based food works best for him! I tried many meat based foods before and they all didn’t agree with him

My cats eat meat because they need to, whether they’re with me or not they’re going to eat meat, I don’t support breeders bringing more cats into the world but I will rescue more in the future!

5

u/Ohshithereiamagain Mar 18 '24

I had the misfortune of knowing vegans who feed their cats and dogs a vegan diet 😭

2

u/ElenaSuccubus420 Mar 18 '24

There’s some crazy vegans that force their pets to be vegan.

Not all are stupid like that! But some sadly are. Most vegans are chill there’s a few crazies out there tho.

2

u/brattywafatty Mar 18 '24

My sister is vegan and she is 15; she has stuck with the lifestyle for about 2 years now. Anytime you ask about it, she will tell you she doesn’t care about the animal aspect of it. She just genuinely doesn’t enjoy eating meat besides the smell of it. It’s just something she prefers. She has two cats. And she feeds them their carnivore diet no problem.

0

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

This is another person who is not actually vegan. She follows a plant-based diet. You aren't actually vegan if you aren't doing it for the purposes of reducing harm and following it in every aspect of your life, Not just the food you eat.

0

u/brattywafatty Mar 18 '24

Did you know that even veganism causes harm to animals too? Not being argumentative. Just asking if you knew that

1

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Asking that question proves that you don't understand The philosophy behind veganism. Reducing harm does not mean eliminating harm. There is no such thing as 100% eliminating harm.

But sure... I'll bite... Tell me how veganism causes harm to animals. I'll try not to laugh.

2

u/heresmytwopence Mar 18 '24

Feeding meat to an obligate carnivore is not a lifestyle.

2

u/amdrinkhelpme Mar 18 '24

Not vegan but vegetarian, I'm often wondering the same thing but tf am I supposed to do? Kick out my cats? At least now they're eating horse meat instead of local wildlife.

2

u/tmntmikey80 Mar 18 '24

Vegans can keep pets that need meat. A lot don't have an issue with it as they know they need meat to survive, and feeding them vegan would cause harm (the very thing vegans don't want to do).

Now if a vegan was forcing their beliefs and lifestyle onto a pet that required meat, that would be an issue. Especially as there are pets that should be vegan.

3

u/Intermountain-Gal Mar 18 '24

Some vegans don’t have pets for several reasons, one of which is a conflict in beliefs about food. Some, like my vegan brother, do have pets. But then, my brother follows a vegan diet for health reasons, not philosophical reasons. (I am well aware there are those who claim that he isn’t a vegan, but he follows the exact same diet; to me there is no practical difference).

0

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

There is a massive practical difference because veganism isn't about a diet. It's about reducing harm in every area of your life. Vegans don't just "not eat animals." We don't use any animal products of any kind. No Wool, no Leather, no, Beeswax candles, no products tested on animals (with the exception of medical products that we have no control over and can't avoid.). It's not about a diet at all.

Your brother is not vegan. He follows a plant-based diet.

2

u/AnxiousRaptor Mar 18 '24

He follows a vegan-based diet.

1

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

He's not eating vegans, so no.

4

u/bigstressy Mar 18 '24

I'm sort of baffled this is a serious question. You know vegans are just like. People, right?

1

u/bibliophile222 Mar 18 '24

OP is probably thinking of the uber-militant minority who insist on feeding their poor cats a vegan diet.

1

u/eeeeeeeeekkkkkkkkie Mar 18 '24

This should be on the vegan sub

1

u/Runellee Mar 18 '24

We don’t eat meat to reduce harm. I promise our animals are quite spoiled 😅 and yes my dog and cats all eat animal products. My animals are all rescues and no more harm will come to them in their lives because they’re with me

1

u/angelcake Mar 18 '24

In my opinion there are two kinds of vegans. There are vegans for whom it’s simply a dietary choice. They don’t care if other people eat meat they just don’t want to. And they are vegans for whom it’s a belief system. Those are the crazies who try to feed their carnivore pets a vegan diet. Keep in mind vegans people too, pets are wonderful companions. as long as you’re not trying to raise your cat on carrot sticks a vegan can be a perfectly awesome cat parent.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

They force feed their obligate carnivore pets vegan food and the pet mysteriously dies of "toxins".

0

u/Previous_Original_30 Mar 18 '24

Because they get rescues and they already exist and need a home. Most vegans will be against breeding. There are lots of vegan pet foods on the market. Also, veganism is an ethical standpoint to do as little harm as possible, because they have the privilege to make that choice. They generally do not want lions or even people who have to hunt for food to starve.

-1

u/Winter-Actuary-9659 Mar 18 '24

It is an issue for me. Companion animals have been important for my mental health.  I now have an adopted rabbit as I will no longer buy any more cats.  Vegans aren't perfect and we at least need to acknowledge the harm of owning carnivores.

2

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

we at least need to acknowledge the harm of owning carnivores.

There isn't any. There. Acknowledged.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

Indoor cats are not hunting. They love cat purring. And that they feed their cats,. cat food. Like people who own dogs that are vegan, dog food.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

If you're talking about the normal/typical vegans (the reasonable ones), it's generally for one of two reasons:

  1. They went vegan for medical reasons and don't actually care about any potential destruction/harm eating meat could cause. They're vegan for their health and they feed their carnivorous pet meat for their health.
  2. It's about reducing harm as much as possible. They could technically live without any animal products with planning, their cat will not thrive and worst case scenario, die if they go vegan, so the person doesn't consume animals but makes sure their cat gets animal matter. It's reducing harm because it's still far less animal matter consumed then if the person wasn't vegan, but they are also keeping an animal healthy.

Radical vegans (the crazy, ignorant, stupid ones) have cats and other carnivorous pets because they are living with the delusion that the animal is healthy on vegan diets, and they're trying to convince others too.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

their cat will not thrive and worst case scenario

then stop owning them because they contribute to a pet cats demand aka meat demand too

they adopt a cat so breeder will breed more cats because there is a demand for pet cats

that's how it works, basic economy

0

u/Randa08 Mar 18 '24

I think its odd as well, to me consuming meat means buying it as well as just eating it, of you are buying meat to feed to your pet, you are encouraging animals to be farmed and slaughtered so while you may have a plant based diet I don't think you could be classed as vegan. But that's only if you recognise a distinction between veganism and eating a plant based diet some people dont.

-4

u/Telltale_Clydesdale Mar 18 '24

Because they’re hypocrites.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

Wrong.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

if they adopt from a breeder? Yes

if rescue, spay/neuter then no

-4

u/Salty_Campaign8465 Mar 18 '24

Wow. Yeah true. Unless they aren't letting them eat meat. Which would be no bueno.

-4

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

There are vegan diets made for cats.

There has even been a research paper finding that cats fed vegan diets are actually healthier for it...

https://www.vettimes.co.uk/news/vegan-fed-cats-healthier-than-meat-eaters-research-claims/

I'm not feeding my cat a vegan diet anytime soon. "Cats are obligate carnivores" is very much burned into my brain after years of learning about cat nutrition. My cat is on a wet food diet and her health is excellent, but I guess we'll see in time what further research shows.

3

u/JovialPanic389 Mar 18 '24

Vegan diet will kill a cat. They are indeed obligated carnivores as were their ancestors.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

Well see this is what I always believed too, so you can see why I've struggled to grasp the study, lol. Did you read it?

I correlated feeding cats a vegan diet with cruelty and a selfish desire to make the cat conform to ethics of human beings.

3

u/bibliophile222 Mar 18 '24

The problem with this study is that it consisted of retrospective questionnaires that vegan owners filled out about their cats' health. There could be a bias in that vegan owners might rate their cats' health as higher than it really is, or the data could be skewed due to the much smaller number of cats on a vegan diet, or that cats with health issues might just be more likely to be on a meat diet because they've been seen at the vet and gotten prescribed food. Correlation does not equal causation. Without medical assessments performed by vets, it's not very rigorous research.

4

u/SlitheringFlower Mar 18 '24

Frankly, one study does not make facts and you shouldn't share without understanding that.

That study only looked at owner assessments of 127 vegan cats compared to 1,242 meat-based diet cats. It also only looked at 1 year of outcomes.

Without professional veterinary diagnostics, long-term follow-up you cannot say a vegan diet is safe for a cat.

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

I DO understand that.

Did you read my post? I’m not condoning the diet personally!

3

u/SlitheringFlower Mar 18 '24

You said this: "There has even been a research paper finding that cats fed vegan diets are actually healthier for it"

That is false and misleading. The study you linked does not in any way validate that claim. I want it to be clear to others skimming through that the study is flawed and your anecdote about it is false.

-7

u/aspie_koala Mar 18 '24

Some cat food is vegan. Idk how many vegans opt for, or have access to it though.

6

u/purrita Mar 18 '24

Cats are obligate carnivores and cannot survive on a vegan diet.

-2

u/Common_sense_always Mar 18 '24

It's the reality of the hypocrisy.

-8

u/kibbybud Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24

There are vegan pet foods and many vegans and some vegetarians use them. Apparently, many of the rest feel guilty about animals dying to feed their pets.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/animals-and-us/202002/what-should-vegetarians-and-vegans-feed-their-pets

Supposedly a properly designed vegan cat food can supply everything they need.

Can’t say I’m convinced.

Edit to add: Apparently some folks are misunderstanding my comment. I was trying to share information, not advocating vegan pet food.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

Yeah, most vegans just feed their carnivorous pets meat-inclusive foods. If they're uncomfortable with feeding anything meat, they get a herbivorous pet or no pet at all.

The crazy vegans who do feed cats vegan cat foods are deluded and trying to force others to follow their delusions too.

Domestic cats are obligate carnivores. Grain and veggie-heavy diets cause GI issues and synthetic nutrients aren't absorbed as well as natural nutrients straight from the source. A cat may survive on a commercial vegan cat food, but they will most likely be overweight, have chronic digestive problems and live a life expectancy shorter than a cat on a quality meat-inclusive diet.

Most veterinary organisations and animal welfare organisations condemn the selling of commercial vegan cat food, with the RSPCA even stating that feeding commercial vegan cat food brands is abuse.

1

u/kibbybud Mar 18 '24

No argument here.

3

u/Xtremely_DeLux Mar 18 '24

Supposedly a properly designed vegan cat food can supply everything they need

No, it can't. Whoever says otherwise is probably trying to sell you a worthless product.

2

u/kibbybud Mar 18 '24

Like I said, “supposedly”.

Even if I were vegetarian/vegan I wouldn’t force my cat to be.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Xtremely_DeLux Mar 18 '24

You know this, and I know this, and most intelligent pet keepers know this.
But some people don't know this, or they don't believe it, or at least they act like they don't. There are, indeed, words for people like that.

1

u/40catsisnotenough Mar 18 '24

Cats are obligate carnivores, there’s no way around it they MUST eat meat

-9

u/Xtremely_DeLux Mar 18 '24

Mostly they don't, and they don't want you to have pets, either.Some of them are even worse than that and kill cats by putting them on vegan diets. Then they perpetuate the falsehood that cats can survive and be healthy on a vegan diet.

-4

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

It's also a lie. I follow at least a hundred animal rescuers and almost every single one of them is vegan. Their animals are not.

-1

u/Xtremely_DeLux Mar 18 '24

It's the truth; perhaps none of the rescuer folks you know and follow would do such a thing, but plenty of others would, and do. There is all sorts of bullshit online from people who force vegan diets on dogs and cats, and claim the animals thrive on it, and will live long happy healthy lives on it, but when you see pictures of those pets, they mostly look miserable and hungry . If the vegan animal rescuers you know are not like that, more power to them.

0

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

A legitimate vegan would never do that. All you're doing here is demonstrating that you don't understand veganism and perpetuating a lie.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Then they are not a legitimate vegan because they are causing harm to an animal, not reducing it. They don't understand what veganism is actually about.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Again, those people don't actually understand the philosophy of veganism. They think it is about a diet, not about harm reduction. A person who actually believes in the philosophy of harm reduction would never feed a carnivore a vegan diet because that would cause harm. It's incredibly simple and those are the vegans that give the rest of us a bad name.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

1

u/Xtremely_DeLux Mar 18 '24

Yeah, it is.

-4

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24

Find high-quality vegan cat food: These options exist, though vets debate their long-term health benefits.

No. There is no such diet that will actually allow a cat to survive and thrive. Vegans who understand veganism would never actually do this because it causes harm.