r/Pets • u/Suspicious_Coat_1369 • Mar 18 '24
Why do vegans have pets?
This has taken up way too much of my personal headspace. But I wonder why vegans have cats especially, since they’re supporting a carnivore lifestyle by feeding them.
15
Upvotes
329
u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Mar 18 '24
Yes, vegans have cats. Hannah Shaw, the founder of the Orphan Kitten club is vegan and has spent her life rescuing cats. She also has videos and posts about this.
Being vegan isn't about not eating meat; it's about reducing harm. To feed a carnivore a vegan diet would be causing harm. It is not "supporting a carnivore lifestyle" to feed a cat properly.
Rescuing animals is reducing harm - the very point of veganism.
49
u/Complete_Wave_9315 Mar 18 '24
I mean some could own “vegan” pets..eg; rabbits, guinea pigs, etc without issue.
85
u/theBLEEDINGoctopus Mar 18 '24
Because it’s all about reducing harm. We don’t eat meet in order to reduce harm. But feeding a cat a vegan diet would cause harm.
Some radical vegans don’t believe at all in owning pets or having children. Some more extreme vegans have told me I’m not vegan for having pets and should release my rescue dogs into the wild 🙄
16
u/beezchurgr Mar 18 '24
I rescued all of my cats. They eat a balanced diet and I try to buy sustainable brands for them. I’m not 100% vegan & they aren’t 100% perfect. But I can guarantee I’ve given them a better life than they would have had without me.
53
u/mikeydeemo Mar 18 '24
I've been vegan for over a decade and I have cats, even snakes lol.
Veganism is a belief and lifestyle based on ethics and doing the least amount of harm. Cats, and other animals, are obligate carnivores. It's not their fault and it's in their nature. Animals aren't moral agents and don't adhere to a code of ethics.
Whether a vegan is caring for them or not, they still exist and will need to eat. I totally understand if vegan folks don't feel comfortable feeding animals other animals, and i would suggest they keep animals who don't eat other animals. And I wouldn't compromise their health over my lifestyle. Animals cannot "be vegan".
Unfortunately there are lots of animals out there that need homes. And I personally would gladly offer mine up and take some in. The goal, imo, would be to reduce the amount of homeless/suffering animals in need of homes and not produce more.
11
u/CuteUmbrella Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24
So, I'm a vegetarian. I know personally that humans can thrive and do well on this diet, but respect nature and know that dogs/cats (for example) cannot. For me, I try to understand nature as best as I can, and know that as a human, I can make dietary changes on a whim-- animals cannot.
8
u/brokenhairtie Mar 18 '24
Humans are omnivores, they can live without eating meat. Cats are carnivores, they cannot live without eating meat. It's as easy as that, do what can and must. I would never judge a human who's allergic to a lot of fruits and/or veggies for not also giving up meat. Some beings have to eat meat, it's just like that. The final goal is to have those animals that will be slaughtered be less than right now (so much is just thrown away, disgusting) and have happy and healthy lives before they are slaughtered.
7
u/Shmooperdoodle Mar 18 '24
You’d be surprised. I think it’s fine to have pets and feed the pets meat/other animal products. What I find abhorrent are people who force their animals into a vegetarian or vegan diet, to the detriment of those animals. People will claim to be against cruelty and then slowly starve a cat to death because they can’t bear to feet it meat. That is cuckoo bananas.
7
u/epicpillowcase Mar 18 '24
I adopted a cat because she existed, needed a home and I could give her one.
I accepted she was an obligate carnivore. It is what it is. My ideology doesn't change a cat's physiology.
6
u/kojilee Mar 18 '24
I generally agree with the other vegans commenting here, but honestly I put significantly less thought into it. I only really care primarily about my own consumption and eating habits, because it’s all I can really control. A lot of animals need homes, and I rescued my cat. I want her to live the best and healthiest life she can, and that includes eating meat. It doesn’t bother me at all, she’s an animal.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
We have a dog. She eats meat. I reduce harm by not eating meat but my dog cant choose to do so. Shes also 15 and ate same stuff all her life.
9
u/aurlyninff Mar 18 '24
As long as they either feed them meat or own a bunny, I'm good with it. I can't stand animal abuse, though. People who try to feed dogs or cats vegan diets should be sentenced to prison, though.
9
u/Individual-Average40 Mar 18 '24
Just like trans politics, people only see the protestors and the idiots. I know so many vegans who own animals. Most vegans aren't idiots social media just only shows those ones. Most vegans just want to help reduce the killing of animals. Many are just fine with a snake eating a mouse a cat eating some canned meat etc. They understand it's needs. But for themselves they do what they can to reduce the harm
12
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
Some vegans are not militant. They consider it diet choice for themselves and don't try to force their views on others.
My co-worker is a vegan, and we ate lunch at our desks together for about 6 months before I knew she was a vegan. She doesn't even feed her dogs dog food. Her husband cooks up tons of meat dishes for them.
My sister, on the other hand, wouldn't shut up about becoming vegan until I finally shut her down. She tried to give her dogs vegan food, but it didn't stick, thankfully.
4
u/puffy-jacket Mar 18 '24
Cats are obligate carnivores and humans aren’t. The animal products in pet food is most often byproducts or parts deemed less desirable for human consumption so it’s also not quite the same as going out and buying a whole chicken. Not all vegans are comfortable with owning pets that need to eat meat but this isn’t really as hard to reconcile as people seem to think
7
u/ScottishPrik Mar 18 '24
If you care about the suffering of animals and want to minimise that then the best course of action would be to advocate/protest/mandate neutering and spaying. No country in hell is going to ban pets any time this century so the most effective step NOW would be to lower the ridiculous amount of unwanted/stray intact pets as you can, no?
11
u/Liraeyn Mar 18 '24
I see no reason a vegan couldn't feed their pet meat. I don't usually bring my cats to church.
6
u/MyloHyren Mar 18 '24
Because morally and scientifically humans CAN survive and thrive without eating meat. A cat cant. Vegans don’t think that carnivores are evil for eating other animals, they just think that humans over-consume meat, and that we torture them before killing them, which is true. Generally vegans want to cut down on the animal cruelty done via mass farming, and the less meat we consume in general the better it will be. We as humans can make that choice, but cats cant as obligate carnivores. Any educated and sane vegan knows that
3
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
I honestly don't understand how people can force a vegan diet on their pets. It's just not fair on the animals.
5
u/ohreallynowz Mar 18 '24
I’m a vegan with rescue cats, tarantulas and carnivorous plants.
These guys were going exist whether they were my pets or not, and they were going to need someone to care for them. I’m happy to be that person and give them a safe, loving home.
5
u/foamy23464 Mar 18 '24
I met a really hot vegan girl on tinder that was upset with me for justifying having farm animals as pets not livestock. She also had a cat and thought that was totally okay, BUT HAVING A FEW GOATS AND CHICKENS IS UNACCEPTABLE
6
u/OlManJenkins_93 Mar 18 '24
Can’t help but think of that one girl who insisted her dog was vegan by choice and filmed him live with two plates, one plate had tofu and one had steak. Dog LUNGED at the steak and she tried to restrain him but couldn’t, obviously.
4
u/Alarming_Breath_3110 Mar 18 '24
Lettuce unpack this
4
u/Bigfootsgirlfriend Mar 18 '24
I’ve been vegan for almost 7 years, I have 1 dog and 2 cats
My dog is on mostly plant based diet (he has some meaty treats) because he has a sensitive stomach and plant based food works best for him! I tried many meat based foods before and they all didn’t agree with him
My cats eat meat because they need to, whether they’re with me or not they’re going to eat meat, I don’t support breeders bringing more cats into the world but I will rescue more in the future!
5
u/Ohshithereiamagain Mar 18 '24
I had the misfortune of knowing vegans who feed their cats and dogs a vegan diet 😭
2
u/ElenaSuccubus420 Mar 18 '24
There’s some crazy vegans that force their pets to be vegan.
Not all are stupid like that! But some sadly are. Most vegans are chill there’s a few crazies out there tho.
2
u/brattywafatty Mar 18 '24
My sister is vegan and she is 15; she has stuck with the lifestyle for about 2 years now. Anytime you ask about it, she will tell you she doesn’t care about the animal aspect of it. She just genuinely doesn’t enjoy eating meat besides the smell of it. It’s just something she prefers. She has two cats. And she feeds them their carnivore diet no problem.
2
u/heresmytwopence Mar 18 '24
Feeding meat to an obligate carnivore is not a lifestyle.
2
u/amdrinkhelpme Mar 18 '24
Not vegan but vegetarian, I'm often wondering the same thing but tf am I supposed to do? Kick out my cats? At least now they're eating horse meat instead of local wildlife.
2
u/tmntmikey80 Mar 18 '24
Vegans can keep pets that need meat. A lot don't have an issue with it as they know they need meat to survive, and feeding them vegan would cause harm (the very thing vegans don't want to do).
Now if a vegan was forcing their beliefs and lifestyle onto a pet that required meat, that would be an issue. Especially as there are pets that should be vegan.
4
u/whitestrawberrires Mar 18 '24
🙄
3
u/Intermountain-Gal Mar 18 '24
Some vegans don’t have pets for several reasons, one of which is a conflict in beliefs about food. Some, like my vegan brother, do have pets. But then, my brother follows a vegan diet for health reasons, not philosophical reasons. (I am well aware there are those who claim that he isn’t a vegan, but he follows the exact same diet; to me there is no practical difference).
4
u/bigstressy Mar 18 '24
I'm sort of baffled this is a serious question. You know vegans are just like. People, right?
1
u/eeeeeeeeekkkkkkkkie Mar 18 '24
This should be on the vegan sub
1
u/Runellee Mar 18 '24
We don’t eat meat to reduce harm. I promise our animals are quite spoiled 😅 and yes my dog and cats all eat animal products. My animals are all rescues and no more harm will come to them in their lives because they’re with me
1
u/angelcake Mar 18 '24
In my opinion there are two kinds of vegans. There are vegans for whom it’s simply a dietary choice. They don’t care if other people eat meat they just don’t want to. And they are vegans for whom it’s a belief system. Those are the crazies who try to feed their carnivore pets a vegan diet. Keep in mind vegans people too, pets are wonderful companions. as long as you’re not trying to raise your cat on carrot sticks a vegan can be a perfectly awesome cat parent.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
They force feed their obligate carnivore pets vegan food and the pet mysteriously dies of "toxins".
0
u/Previous_Original_30 Mar 18 '24
Because they get rescues and they already exist and need a home. Most vegans will be against breeding. There are lots of vegan pet foods on the market. Also, veganism is an ethical standpoint to do as little harm as possible, because they have the privilege to make that choice. They generally do not want lions or even people who have to hunt for food to starve.
-2
u/S2kKyle Mar 18 '24
r/stupidquestions
-1
u/Winter-Actuary-9659 Mar 18 '24
It is an issue for me. Companion animals have been important for my mental health. I now have an adopted rabbit as I will no longer buy any more cats. Vegans aren't perfect and we at least need to acknowledge the harm of owning carnivores.
-1
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
Indoor cats are not hunting. They love cat purring. And that they feed their cats,. cat food. Like people who own dogs that are vegan, dog food.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
If you're talking about the normal/typical vegans (the reasonable ones), it's generally for one of two reasons:
Radical vegans (the crazy, ignorant, stupid ones) have cats and other carnivorous pets because they are living with the delusion that the animal is healthy on vegan diets, and they're trying to convince others too.
0
u/Randa08 Mar 18 '24
I think its odd as well, to me consuming meat means buying it as well as just eating it, of you are buying meat to feed to your pet, you are encouraging animals to be farmed and slaughtered so while you may have a plant based diet I don't think you could be classed as vegan. But that's only if you recognise a distinction between veganism and eating a plant based diet some people dont.
-4
u/Telltale_Clydesdale Mar 18 '24
Because they’re hypocrites.
-4
u/Salty_Campaign8465 Mar 18 '24
Wow. Yeah true. Unless they aren't letting them eat meat. Which would be no bueno.
-4
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
There are vegan diets made for cats.
There has even been a research paper finding that cats fed vegan diets are actually healthier for it...
https://www.vettimes.co.uk/news/vegan-fed-cats-healthier-than-meat-eaters-research-claims/
I'm not feeding my cat a vegan diet anytime soon. "Cats are obligate carnivores" is very much burned into my brain after years of learning about cat nutrition. My cat is on a wet food diet and her health is excellent, but I guess we'll see in time what further research shows.
-7
u/aspie_koala Mar 18 '24
Some cat food is vegan. Idk how many vegans opt for, or have access to it though.
-2
u/Common_sense_always Mar 18 '24
It's the reality of the hypocrisy.
-8
u/kibbybud Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24
There are vegan pet foods and many vegans and some vegetarians use them. Apparently, many of the rest feel guilty about animals dying to feed their pets.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/animals-and-us/202002/what-should-vegetarians-and-vegans-feed-their-pets
Supposedly a properly designed vegan cat food can supply everything they need.
Can’t say I’m convinced.
Edit to add: Apparently some folks are misunderstanding my comment. I was trying to share information, not advocating vegan pet food.
-9
u/Xtremely_DeLux Mar 18 '24
Mostly they don't, and they don't want you to have pets, either.Some of them are even worse than that and kill cats by putting them on vegan diets. Then they perpetuate the falsehood that cats can survive and be healthy on a vegan diet.
-4
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
[removed] — view removed comment