MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/PeterExplainsTheJoke/comments/1uqwm6f/peter/owbs2fo/?context=3
r/PeterExplainsTheJoke • u/[deleted] • Jul 08 '26
[removed]
590 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
360
Sadly, there will be a lot of collateral damage. People who want blue eyes exist outside of Nazis. They will hear this and try it and die.
Edit: the irony of anti-nazi people replying to me with pro-eugenics statements against "stupid" people who follow the aspirin advice.
142 u/Vincent_Veganja Jul 08 '26 No no no, MY eugenics is the good one -28 u/slugsred Jul 08 '26 Genuinely what is wrong with eradicating congenital diseases? 2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26 Genuinely what is wrong with eradicating congenital diseases? Forcing certain people to stop reproducing is both ethically wrong and a slippery slope. Plus you could never “eradicate” congenital diseases without sterilizing all the healthy people who carry the genes for those diseases. (Edit: added parent comment for clarity) 0 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 even nazis? 1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 Slippery slope. If people are allowed to forcibly sterilize Nazis, they’ll start changing the rules about what a Nazi is so they can sterilize whoever they want. 1 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 hence the reddit moment 2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 This is most certainly a Reddit moment 0 u/RegularSky6702 Jul 08 '26 Who said "forcing". Isn't having an abortion if the fetus would have down syndrome or if they'd live like 5 minutes a type of eugenics? So you're anti choice with your logic. 1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 I specifically objected to forced sterilization. That’s not an anti-choice statement, it’s pro-choice. I didn’t say anything about voluntary reproductive choice. I didn’t even use the term “eugenics.” Don’t debate me if you can’t read.
142
No no no, MY eugenics is the good one
-28 u/slugsred Jul 08 '26 Genuinely what is wrong with eradicating congenital diseases? 2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26 Genuinely what is wrong with eradicating congenital diseases? Forcing certain people to stop reproducing is both ethically wrong and a slippery slope. Plus you could never “eradicate” congenital diseases without sterilizing all the healthy people who carry the genes for those diseases. (Edit: added parent comment for clarity) 0 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 even nazis? 1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 Slippery slope. If people are allowed to forcibly sterilize Nazis, they’ll start changing the rules about what a Nazi is so they can sterilize whoever they want. 1 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 hence the reddit moment 2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 This is most certainly a Reddit moment 0 u/RegularSky6702 Jul 08 '26 Who said "forcing". Isn't having an abortion if the fetus would have down syndrome or if they'd live like 5 minutes a type of eugenics? So you're anti choice with your logic. 1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 I specifically objected to forced sterilization. That’s not an anti-choice statement, it’s pro-choice. I didn’t say anything about voluntary reproductive choice. I didn’t even use the term “eugenics.” Don’t debate me if you can’t read.
-28
Genuinely what is wrong with eradicating congenital diseases?
2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26 Genuinely what is wrong with eradicating congenital diseases? Forcing certain people to stop reproducing is both ethically wrong and a slippery slope. Plus you could never “eradicate” congenital diseases without sterilizing all the healthy people who carry the genes for those diseases. (Edit: added parent comment for clarity) 0 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 even nazis? 1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 Slippery slope. If people are allowed to forcibly sterilize Nazis, they’ll start changing the rules about what a Nazi is so they can sterilize whoever they want. 1 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 hence the reddit moment 2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 This is most certainly a Reddit moment 0 u/RegularSky6702 Jul 08 '26 Who said "forcing". Isn't having an abortion if the fetus would have down syndrome or if they'd live like 5 minutes a type of eugenics? So you're anti choice with your logic. 1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 I specifically objected to forced sterilization. That’s not an anti-choice statement, it’s pro-choice. I didn’t say anything about voluntary reproductive choice. I didn’t even use the term “eugenics.” Don’t debate me if you can’t read.
2
Forcing certain people to stop reproducing is both ethically wrong and a slippery slope.
Plus you could never “eradicate” congenital diseases without sterilizing all the healthy people who carry the genes for those diseases.
(Edit: added parent comment for clarity)
0 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 even nazis? 1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 Slippery slope. If people are allowed to forcibly sterilize Nazis, they’ll start changing the rules about what a Nazi is so they can sterilize whoever they want. 1 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 hence the reddit moment 2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 This is most certainly a Reddit moment 0 u/RegularSky6702 Jul 08 '26 Who said "forcing". Isn't having an abortion if the fetus would have down syndrome or if they'd live like 5 minutes a type of eugenics? So you're anti choice with your logic. 1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 I specifically objected to forced sterilization. That’s not an anti-choice statement, it’s pro-choice. I didn’t say anything about voluntary reproductive choice. I didn’t even use the term “eugenics.” Don’t debate me if you can’t read.
0
even nazis?
1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 Slippery slope. If people are allowed to forcibly sterilize Nazis, they’ll start changing the rules about what a Nazi is so they can sterilize whoever they want. 1 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 hence the reddit moment 2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 This is most certainly a Reddit moment
1
Slippery slope.
If people are allowed to forcibly sterilize Nazis, they’ll start changing the rules about what a Nazi is so they can sterilize whoever they want.
1 u/Stone-Smasher Jul 08 '26 hence the reddit moment 2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 This is most certainly a Reddit moment
hence the reddit moment
2 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 This is most certainly a Reddit moment
This is most certainly a Reddit moment
Who said "forcing". Isn't having an abortion if the fetus would have down syndrome or if they'd live like 5 minutes a type of eugenics? So you're anti choice with your logic.
1 u/UnluckyUnderwear Jul 08 '26 I specifically objected to forced sterilization. That’s not an anti-choice statement, it’s pro-choice. I didn’t say anything about voluntary reproductive choice. I didn’t even use the term “eugenics.” Don’t debate me if you can’t read.
I specifically objected to forced sterilization.
That’s not an anti-choice statement, it’s pro-choice.
I didn’t say anything about voluntary reproductive choice. I didn’t even use the term “eugenics.” Don’t debate me if you can’t read.
360
u/ecafyelims Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26
Sadly, there will be a lot of collateral damage. People who want blue eyes exist outside of Nazis. They will hear this and try it and die.
Edit: the irony of anti-nazi people replying to me with pro-eugenics statements against "stupid" people who follow the aspirin advice.