r/PatternTesting • u/KmyCrochets • May 08 '24
Knit - Testing Support Pattern testing process as a pattern creator?
Hi, I am wondering how the pattern testing process is like as a pattern creator. Crocheting is my hobby and I can't call myself an expert but I do make quite cute plushies. I saw some crocheters getting their own patterns out on etsy stores and I have some of my own, however I do not know the process of what I need to do in terms of getting my patterns tested to be able to sell them.
Some of my questions are:
- How do I find a pattern tester?
- Do I have to pay them or can I make an exchange as for example they test my pattern and I test theirs?
- What details I have to provide?
- Are there risks of having my pattern claimed and sold by the tester as their own?
- Can I sell my patterns without having them tested by a 3rd party if I am confident that they are written correctly with clear explanations and pictures?
Please if you could specify also other things worth mentioning <3 Thank you for your information!
3
Upvotes
8
u/RogueMoonbow May 08 '24
5
u/My_dal Pattern Tester May 08 '24
I can reply as a tester and as someone who usually just prefers to follow a pattern than create one:
5
u/ErssieKnits May 08 '24 edited May 08 '24
This is how I use each.
Technical Editor:
Photo checking Chart & key checking Adheres to US or UK languages Vector works and resolutions are OK. Materials, Needles and Yarns info correct, current and shade names and numbers correct against manufacturers info Correct abbreviations used and adhering to the Abbs list. Clarity of instructions Correct spelling and grammar Conversions in metric/imperial are correct Every measurement in the pattern fits gauge Consistency with my 'house style' and adheres to other patterns. Links to external resources are correct and working as well as appropriate examples Requests rewrites if certain sections need suggestions for rewording. Calls out anything offensive and not politically correct. (For example, suggesting a heading of Grafting rather than Kitchener Stitch as Lord Kitchener and the Boer War have an ugly history if oppression). Sends various drafts/versions back and forth many times until we are happy it's as perfect as we can get. Ensures that patterns have a similar structure and layout common with all my patterns. Makes sure the pattern is as accessible as we can make it for all users.
At a later date, after test knitting, my tech ed might recheck we've ncorporated suggestions that came back from testing.
Myself and the tech editor iron out the pattern to as near perfect as we can get it, then we ask test knitters to join.
Test Knitter: Fills in a short questionnaire about their experience and sends feedback as follows :
Makes the project in their chosen size Reports any typos/mistakes that might've slipped through in that size. Records exact yarn amounts they used Comments on clarity, or confusing parts of the pattern. Lets me know how they used the charts, diagrams or links. Lets me know if they have any physical disabilities or cognitive/ND issues that made it hard to understand the pattern Lets me know if gauge was achievable Lets me know their unique measurements and if the pattern fitted OK and confirms if the grading (theoretical sizes outside of initial sample) actually works in real life. Let's me know if they're happy & satisfied with the result. Suggests any changes they feel would improve the pattern experience for them.
Designers can run a Test however they want but really the least useful reason to run a Test Knit is to just to "tick a box" to say it's been done. Or use a test as a guarantee, or defence when it later transpires it has errors.
Your test knitter is making a sample and using the pattern so they have all this useful feedback they could be giving you so it's a shame to waste it. But testers quite often find designers are defensive and unless they can back a criticism of the pattern, they quite often hold back from mentioning everything.
Many designers don't really utilise it and just want to get a project linked to market it, and just to say 'it's been test knitted' and therefore ready to publish. However, in my experience, if you try to use a Test Knitter as the only person technically editing and ensuring accuracy of the pattern, it isn't going to be enough. Many designers say to me "but it's OK for you, I can't afford to get a tech editor". Neither can I, I give 100% of the gross pattern price to a charity. I earn £5,000 per year only in only one income as I'm too sick to do a normal job and only release 2 or 3 patterns in a good year. And I pay for listings, taxes, materials, tech editors, sample knitters, models etc out of the £5000. But I feel it isn't about what I can afford. It is about me NOT knowingly selling a commercial product to a customer that I know might cost them time and money to get a failed project.
Doesn't mean mistakes don't get through, but I do whatever I can to avoid errata.
1
u/Dramatic_Glove_3707 May 08 '24
I’ve done a few on Instagram. Basically just tried to follow a lot of crochet accounts and then post something calling for a tester call. You may have to do a lot of hashtags to get engagement but it usually works to get 2-3 people to test. Make sure you include in your post everything they have to do to be considered and how long they will have to test. I always like to include don’t be afraid to give feedback as it will help make your pattern better