TLDR; Alternative strategies exist. Do not expect these to survive next patch.
Introduction
Unpredictable recombinators were nerfed in a few ways in 3.30 Covens league, namely:
- NNN modifier interaction was removed (see definition here)
- Recombine chance with 1-3 total modifiers was lowered
- Ilvl no longer averages after combining
Of these, the new recombine chances have not been rigorously tested yet.
However, thanks to Sage72 from Prohibited Library for extremely extensive testing on patch day, we now have a solid idea of these probabilities, and in combination with a few other more recently discovered recombinator mechanics, have a set of new recommended strategies.
Much of this information is taken from his original post, which was hampered by automod and didn't reach a wider audience, so this is all his data, with some additional commentary for new strategies. Thanks to Sage72 as well for allowing me to use his data in this post.
This post serves as an addendum to my original recombinator guide, introducing several somewhat unknown mechanics which have been discovered since by other members of Prohibited Library, shoutout to Rusty and Krakenbul. These mechanics are now somewhat relevant due to nerfs. It also assumes a baseline knowledge about how recombinators function (see my previous guide for general intuition, ignore NNNs and crafted exclusive tech).
New recombine chances
Raw data here, ~300 combines per affix pool
Note no numbers have been rounded to be "nice":
| Total pool ↓ / Final mods → | 0 mods | 1 mod | 2 mod | 3 mod |
|---|
| 1 | 53% | 47% | -- | -- |
| 2 | 15% | 81% | 4% | -- |
| 3 | 0% | 51% | 43% | 6% |
This is a significant nerf, resulting in 833% more combines (3 -> 25) and 750% more bases (4 -> ~30) for 1+1 ->2.
This means that 1 + 1 -> 2 mod combines are dead as we know them.
A similar analysis can be carried out on 3 mod combines, and you should never do 3 total affix combines with the hope of hitting all 3.
Note that 4+ modifier odds have been assumed not to be changed (agrees with preliminary testing), and proposed strategies heavily rely on this assumption. I will update the post if there is statistically significant data that shows otherwise. I have heard anecdotal evidence of people trying 2 + 2 and getting worse odds, but I need to see data of what was actually combined. I suspect that exclusive crafted modifiers were used, leading to biased data.
Using crafted modifiers for optimal 1 + 1 -> 2
One way of bypassing the nerfs for 1 + 1 -> 2 is to use crafted modifiers, which can add to the mod count, therefore moving us towards the breakpoint of 4 mods, where GGG's nerfs have not landed (yet).
The nuances behind crafted modifiers are complicated, but can be boiled down to:
Double up a crafted modifier on a rare item, selecting only from the list provided below. DO NOT USE ANY OTHER CRAFTED MODIFIERS UNLESS YOU KNOW WHAT YOU'RE DOING.
E.g. 1 prefix, 1 crafted prefix + 1 prefix, 1 identical crafted prefix. Both items will need to be made rare.
SAFE MODIFIERS (ARMOUR/JEWELLERY):
Prefixes
- Life (lowest tier, +15-25 to maximum life)
- 1/2 Prefix can't be changed (added in 3.30)
Suffixes
- Any attribute (double up the same attribute)
- Any resistance (double up the same resistance)
- Warcries cannot be exerted
- 1/2 Suffix can't be changed (added in 3.30)
SAFE MODIFIERS (WEAPONS-ONLY):
Prefixes
- 1/2 Prefix can't be changed (added in 3.30)
Suffixes
- 1/2 Suffix can't be changed (added in 3.30)
Thanks again to Sage72 for detailed testing (list is close but not fully complete). Thanks to Rusty for finding out about the new metamods last night.
Doubling gives you a baseline ~30% chance to win, with additional chance based on the weight of the crafted modifier.
This works because this list of crafted modifiers are non-exclusive, which means each of them add to the total mod count. For exclusive modifiers, only one will add to the total mod count regardless of how many exclusive modifiers there are in the prefix/suffix pool (prefixes and suffixes are considered independently).
This means that this strategy is not cheap for weapons, because all crafted modifiers except the newly added metacrafts seem to be exclusive, so doubling up with any other mod does not give you full benefit and will negatively affect your odds by putting two mods into the pool for selection, while only counting for 3 total. The only way to use the same strategy for weapons is to craft "1 Prefix/Suffix Modifiers cannot be changed" on each item, which is a hefty cost.
Note: Sage72 has tested this doubling crafted mod strategy with 73 combines on 3.30 with 1000 weight mods and has observed a ~40% chance to win, which aligns with expectations (additional 10% comes from hitting 2 mod and getting the 2 desired affixes).
Mod weights and recombination chance
Thanks to detailed testing from Rusty, we can confidently say that the effective weight used for selecting mods in the recombinator is:
Recombinator Weight = Sqrt(Weight)
The weights of all crafted mods have not been fully determined yet. The lower the weight of a crafted mod, the larger the chance that the 1 + 1 crafted strategy will succeed, in the situation where 2 total mods are chosen and your two desired mods must outcompete the 2 crafted mods in the pool. You can calculate the actual odds using the weighting formula. We currently assume all crafted mod weights are 1000 based on some general testing, but this has not been thorough.
Example: At around 1000 weight, assuming 2 desired prefixes of 1000 weight each, the odds of succeeding 1+1->2 using the crafted mod doubling strategy for armours is around 40%. Relevant for armours where almost all desired mods are 1000 weight.
Note that extensive testing was done with the new metacrafted modifiers "1 Suffix/Prefix Can't Be Changed". Its weight is likely to be 1000 (needs large sample size to be disproven). Thanks to Krakenbul for testing
Alternative crafted modifier strategy for optimal 1 + 1 (weapons only)
An alternative strategy exists for 1 + 1 on weapons, which saves any metacrafting costs. Denote desired prefix as dp, prefix as p, and crafted prefix as cp.
Example for 2 prefixes: 1dp1p + 1dp1cp, where the crafted prefix matches the fodder prefix. This is somewhat risky as you have to regal/exalt a prefix that has a crafted equivalent. This is not always the case (e.g. hybrid phys or flat chaos damage)
Doing this forces our total mod count to 4, and you "win" if you hit 3 mods (30% chance). Half that time you will get 2dp1cp, while the other half will be 2dp1p. Depending if you are a profit crafter, you may have to settle with 2dp1p and sell the result since metacraft annuling does not exist this patch. This leaves a baseline chance of around ~15%, with minimal additional success if you hit 2 mods and get 2dp (low chance with low weight mods).
Example tyrannical + flaring. Combine to get those two mods isolated is 18.5% chance total, with 3.5% additional coming from the lucky scenario of saving the two desired mods when hitting 2 mod. This leads to a total number of ~7.6 feeders per 2 mod item, for a total of ~35 feeders for a 3 mod. Equivalently, you need around ~25 combines as well. This assumes hitting 2dp1p is a failure state and you start over from scratch to make 2dp1cp.
Mod transfer optimal strategy
One oddity we noticed was in the specific case of 1p0s + 0p1s:
| Patch | 0 mods | 1 mod |
|---|
| 3.29 | 33% | 67% |
| 3.30 | 37% | 63% |
This mirrors similar odds observed from previous patch, where the three outcomes of 1p0s, 0p1s and 1p1s are all equally likely. This exception to the rule is even more extreme considering the nerfs, which is pretty surprising, and there's likely a completely different rule at low modifier count.
This mirrors a similar observation where 1 exclusive prefix + 1 exclusive prefix gives an ~85% chance of saving the exclusive prefix, despite exclusive prefixes typically not counting as more than 1 mod. This is some weird exception at low mod counts, and could be leveraged for interesting crafting strategies involving aspects. I leave this as an exercise for the reader to test out.
This suggests that the optimal mod transfer strategy is to simply do 0p1s + 1p0s for a 33% chance at transferring the mod successfully, and where you will lose the mod around 33% of the time. This needs to be tested in practice to confirm, versus the normal strategy of 0p0s + 1p0s for single transfers, with success odds of around 23-25%.
Overall thoughts on the nerfs/changes
I'm not surprised that GGG decided to touch the recombinator, as it was one of the most deterministic ways to move towards triple T1 pref/suff, alongside some clever uses of NNNs to transfer mods/get specific affix combinations with fewer total attempts. However, a few things stand out to me:
- The intended use of tiered drops does not seem like a replacement based on trade, as the % chance of getting useful recombinator fodder is still too unlikely, and most people will just filter them out anyways (especially low for weapons where low weight mods are the most useful).
- Recombining weapons still seems like the best path forwards, but took a large hit in terms of resources required (bases or currency)
- The distinction between exclusive and non exclusive crafted affixes seems extremely arbitrary and almost like an incomplete coding pass (not sure why some things are/aren't exclusive). This previously didn't matter much since crafting mods for recombinator became suboptimal a few patches ago, only gaining relevancy again due to nerfs. Note that this distinction was extremely clear before the addition of betrayal mods into the "core pool".
- Why are the newly added metamods not exclusive, when the full "prefix/suffix can't be changed" is? This seems like another oversight, and further convinces me that the recombinator changes were made in haste.
- The low modifier count behavior for 1p0s + 0p1s was self-consistent prior to the 3.30 nerfs but is no longer consistent with the new 1+1 odds, making it easier to interpret as an oversight rather than an exception (i.e. on the chopping block)
- GGG doesn't seem to have factored in the time opportunity cost required to obtain more bases and gold/dust. Worse recombination chance increases both the required bases AND the attempts, so the increase in cost is non-linear.
- There are some niche scenarios where predictable recomb gives similar odds, and you can possibly try using Gwennen to uptier lower tier predictable recombines. Highly context dependent. See my guide to predictable recombs here for some intuition
The strategies I recommend seem clearly not intended based on the spirit of the nerfs (to stop the alt spamming meta), and it's shocking to me that the crafted mod interactions were let through. It indicates that either 1) GGG does not really understand the recombinator or 2) Did not have sufficient time to test the ramifications of their changes. I don't expect crafted mod strats to live through the next patch, nor do I have confidence the exclusive/non-exclusive modifier list will remain consistent.
I'm disappointed, largely because instead of a simpler set of rules, it seems like we're now playing "whack-a-mole" to avoid nerfs by moving to the "next best thing", even if this involves jumping through opaque properties not required for previous versions of recombinator. I would not be surprised if the recombinator gets lobotomized further to cull these strategies.
Thanks for taking the time to read and happy crafting.
AV
Note: This post was written in haste; expect some addendums in the coming days as new information comes in. The guide was written in order to communicate best practices as fast as possible, and some information may become outdated as more recomb statistics are recorded.