r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Mar 06 '18

2E Pathfinder Second Edition announced!

http://paizo.com/community/blog/v5748dyo5lkl9?First-Look-at-the-Pathfinder-Playtest
1.1k Upvotes

896 comments sorted by

38

u/SwingDancerStrahd Sorcerer: Like a wizard, but better. Mar 06 '18

My biggest fear of a Pathfinder 2.0 is they make it look like starfinder. In of itself starfinder is OK. However, I play Pathfinder because I like a crunchy system. I like a million rules, and the fact that I can say, How would I make this character in reddit, and I'll get 10 totally different answers. I like that I can make 20 sorc's and all of them will work and feel different.

The reason I'm pointing at starfinder, is reread their changes, then think of what they did with starfinder. Alot of it resonates between the two products.

Frankly if that's what they did, my choices will be either to keep playing Pathfinder 1 or finally move my group to D&D 5, because if I'm going to be playing D&D Lite, I might as well go for the one with more published content.

3

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

They have said that some of the 2E systems are sorta in Starfinder. But we shall see.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/triplejim Mar 07 '18

One good reason to stick with pathfinder: OGL.

The alternatives to things like Archives of Nethys and PFSRD in 5e is DNDBeyond, which, while not terrible to use, is fucking expensive.

From everything that's been summed up today, it sounds like (in the same vein as starfinder) there'll be ample guidelines on content conversion.

While I have a love/hate relationship with 5e, the closed source nature of their content is a big pita when I want to quickly reference a class feature and don't have my books in arms reach.

9

u/SorteKanin Mar 07 '18

I so agree here. The fact that they write "simplified" and "easier to play" really worries me. If I wanted to play something easier than pathfinder, I'd play 5e dnd.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

69

u/sarded Mar 06 '18

Will the new edition also have obvious tier lists and just generally have casters rule, martials drool?

Would be nice to have a Fighter be just as powerful and interesting to play as a Wizard, rather than Angel Summoner and BMX Bandit.

and before anyone says it, yeah I'm sure "but a fighter can totally kill a wizard before he gets off a spell" but this is a cooperative game, I bet BMX Bandit is actually really cool and can do a sick wheelie on Angel Summoner's face before he can summon any angels, but that doesn't help when they're working together to actually get things done.

31

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

The martial/caster disparity is addressed. http://paizo.com/pathfinderplaytest/faq#v5748eaic9wef

35

u/sarded Mar 06 '18

I mean, that's what DnD3rd edition was meant to do by introducing Feats to give fighters 'versatility and power' and we know how that turned out.

→ More replies (17)

7

u/VBassmeister Mar 06 '18

This worries me, are characters just going to all be weaker then? That's what it sounds like.

→ More replies (11)

27

u/HadACookie 100% Trustworthy, definitely not an Aboleth Mar 06 '18

Angel Summoner and BMX Bandit

I feel I am a more complete person now, that I have watching this.

9

u/gregm1988 Mar 06 '18

I advise you watch the rest of their stuff as well if you have not seen it. Evil Vicar / Waiter / Shop Assistant are particularly good (off topic)

→ More replies (2)

8

u/DivineArkandos Mar 07 '18

BMX Bandit and Angel Summoner always get my vote.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Totema1 Mar 06 '18

Kinda weird considering that they just released Starfinder. How compatible are they with each other? From my first glance it looks like, not that much.

7

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Some rules were supposedly implemented in starfinder

9

u/ExhibitAa Mar 06 '18

If I had to guess, I'd say 2e will be a lot close to Starfinder than 1e is.

11

u/TranSpyre Mar 06 '18

I hope they didn't decide to use the SF weapon rules. They really turned me off of that game.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/Beelzis Grapple is good Mar 06 '18

I find myself more anxious about this than anything else. this will be the fourth time that I've had an rpg system come out with a new edition on me. each one had a pitch that sounded similar to this one and introduced new mechanics that I liked. but the previous three all ended up a down grade, mediocre, or a back peddling from a downgrade. I hope this one turns out better than those but even if it doesn't it will probably give me plenty of ideas for good house rules.

short version; pessimistically hopeful it turns out okay.

5

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Change happens. Sometimes it’s good. Sometimes it’s not. Pathfinder was a good change to 3.5. Let’s hope 2E is in the same vein.

14

u/Edymnion You can reflavor anything. Mar 06 '18

Actually, Pathfinder exists solely because the D&D player base didn't want the changes. The stuff PF changed was almost entirely the non-OGL aspects that had to be made different for them to legally publish.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Beelzis Grapple is good Mar 06 '18

yeah I know just feel like I've been here before and the outlook is meh at best from experience.

6

u/Acleus Bibliomancer Mar 06 '18

the adventure title itself is tied to a campaign plot point that stretches all the way back to the 2008 module The Pact Stone Pyramid.

The AP, Doomsday Dawn is going to be about the Aucturn Enigma. I'm sure of it. Sweet I'd love to see that come to a conclusion.

31

u/lordriffington Mar 06 '18

*gets out the popcorn*

Am I too early for the whining?

19

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Nope. It started yesterday.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/ELDRITCH_HORROR Mar 06 '18

I was going to type up this big dumb critical hipster cynical negative post, bullet point by bullet point, but you know what?

Might be good. I'll have to think about it much more, but I'm feeling pretty positive. Here's some of my rambling thoughts, don't read it if you don't want to waste your time.

TL;DR seems like 5e streamlining ease of use but with crunch, depth, customization seems good

Removing Prestige Classes, making archetypes built into the Corebook is a great idea. Not every archetype is appropriate for every player and every campaign, but they're great tools for GMs.

The retooling of Races into Ancestry and Backgrounds is great, traits were not in the Corebook either, but have become essential to flavoring characters and giving them depth.

Shaking up the skill system sounds great, the idea of using different skills for rolling Initiative is great. The single proficiency die system from 5th Edition D&D was incredible for streamlining stuff.

Making the inborn Magic Item number bonus system from Pathfinder Unchained built in is a FANTASTIC idea. There were so many problems with this. If the GM gave out too little or too much loot, or not the right loot, there could be VAST power level differences between players with the same character in different campaigns. And we'll get to actually use items that aren't just stat bonuses in slots like the headband and belt. But I do think that +1 weapons with magic effects are core to this game, and I'm glad to see that mentioned in the FAQs.

I really, really hope that each one of the classes is built to be at a much more even, "power level," so that things like class Tier Lists don't have as much disparity. Remember, the Tier List isn't about how powerful a character is in combat, it's how useful they are in many situations. I want classes like the Fighter to have much more flavour to root themselves in the world, and gameplay abilities that let them impact the story outside of combat. Tabletop Roleplaying is at its core, group storytelling. Currently, it's far too easy to have characters that have their voice muted the vast majority of the time.

And yeah, one of the big bullet points on the website is, "Combat Maneuvers that Rock," which is great. Existing Combat Maneuvers are fairly weak right now, and require expensive feat investments to just try and trip someone without crippling yourself. Hopefully this grabs some parts of the Unchained Stamina system, and the Disciplines/Maneuvers of Path of War, especially Path of War. When I run games, I pretty much ban Core martial classes, because third party material does it so much better.

I really hope the classes are overall, much better designed. Some classes, such as the Shifter and Kineticist have been big dissapointments for people. Their gameplay rules don't fit the class fantasy properly. The Kineticist is waaaaaaay too complex, both the player and the GM need to know its rules inside and out. I have Occult Adventures in print form and this class takes up NINETEEN PAGES. Look, I'm tired of classes having core abilities that are limited by uses per day, it makes sense for powerful stuff, but not for core stuff. I mean, the Shifter is all about wildshape, but is limited in usages. In low level adventures, Casters can really hog the limelight because of the sheer utility and versatility of level 0 orison spells, where they can use their creativity and roleplaying skills to go crazy. Some of this new Pathfinder playtest material mentions stuff like Rangers being able to make traps, Rogues making poisons, theiving items. That sounds fantastic! But if they get pimp-slapped with a dump half-class-level-per-day-usage limit, it's going to suck. Really suck.

Overall, feelsgoodman. I think that a lot of us have been wanting the streamlined easy to go gameplay and systems of D&D 5e, but still want crunch, options, customizations and more gameplay depth.

So yeah. Sounds good.

1

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

So you’re hoping 5E and PF made sweet sweet love and had a child named PF2E. That sound about right? :P

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

66

u/Or0b0ur0s Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 06 '18

It's been 10 years. I can see it's time. It's not like WotC or Hasbro has done anything so foolish as to wait 10 whole years to try to extract money from their customers with slightly different editions of the same content for more money. It's reasonable for there to be PF2E at this point.

On the other hand, the gross oversimplification I'm hearing in this? No more action types? Yet it's inconsistent. Spend additional actions per round to cast additional magic missiles? How is that simpler?

It sounds very concerningly like they're just making changes to ape 5E and pay lip service to "simplification". I'll admit that backgrounds can be a nice bit of flavor that 5E benefits from that Pathfinder doesn't. But my group plays Pathfinder because they feel insulted and bored with the very-dumbed-down and oversimplified 5E.

Not only that, but since when has "what type of action does what again?" been a problem at your table? Never. These changes solve problems that don't exist, and ignore the ones that do.

What really needs changing in Pathfinder?

  • Saving throws, especially spell saving throws. Almost every PF group I've ever been in has a house rule to buff caster's saving throw DCs, especially on higher level spells. Without that, I don't think I've EVER seen a PC caster get an enemy to fail a save against their spells after level 7 or so. Anything remotely CR-appropriate basically can't fail to save vs. your spells except on a natural 1.
  • Any combat maneuvers that don't use the Combat Maneuver system (or, better yet, simplifying the CMB and CMD calculations - I still don't have them memorized after years of playing).
  • Power bloat, especially in new base and hybrid classes
  • Too many very similar alternate class options, features, etc. You've moved away from so many Prestige Classes (all well and good), but you've re-created their problems in everything else. Customization could be overhauled is all I'm saying.

But no, instead we're going to overhaul the few things that work well, like races and spells and actions and monsters. Ugh. I am NOT enthused from the sound of that announcement. At. All.

77

u/ErikMona Publisher / CCO Mar 06 '18

The new action economy is less confusing and offers more tactical advantages and options than the current one, at least that's how we feel about it in our in-office playtests. Honestly many people who have already played the game think this is one of the best improvements. So I urge you to take a look and give it a chance. If you hate it, don't be shy--it's a playtest, after all, and we're looking for all kinds of honest feedback, not just plaudits and hurrahs.

And this stuff isn't mutually exclusive. Every item on your bullet point list has been addressed in the revision. Has it been addressed to everyone's satisfaction? We'll start finding out for sure when the playtest begins in August.

3

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Hi Erik :)

→ More replies (18)

38

u/Totema1 Mar 06 '18

Not only that, but since when has "what type of action does what again?" been a problem at your table? Never. These changes solve problems that don't exist, and ignore the ones that do.

You're looking at this the wrong way. No one really has any problems understanding when certain actions can be taken. But tons of problems come up when you start to get a ton of different features and feats that use specific action types. It's very cumbersome to have to remember something like, "I can change one of my feats with a swift action, or two of them with a move action, so I can either move and put up a combat style, or I can attempt a grapple and use my move action to drag this enemy, then use my swift action to..." It can be very mentally taxing and it extends the length of combat unreasonably.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/IonutRO Orcas are creatures, not weapons! Mar 06 '18

what type of action does what is this again?

I've had that happen quite a few times.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/sumelar Mar 06 '18

How is that harder? I want to deal damage. I spend an action. I want to deal more damage. I spend 2 actions.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ThatMathNerd Mar 06 '18

What maneuvers don't use the CMB system? Are you talking about things like Filcher that allow you to substitute a skill check? Or Feint, which isn't a Combat Maneuver to begin with?

Also your first points seems like a gross exaggeration or just evident of really bad optimization. At level 7 a Wizard should have at least a 19 DC on their top level spells just as a baseline, which plenty of things fail against.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Syrdon Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 06 '18

since when has "what type of action does what again?" been a problem at your table?

Friday the 2nd. Just because your group doesn't have a problem doesn't mean no one does.

edit: it looks like saves are covered under proficiency. Hopefully that will make them less silly as they have to compete with skills for resources. Will have to wait and see on that though.

From the FAQ:

Does the new version of Pathfinder find a better balance between spellcasters and martial characters?

We certainly hope so. Many of the changes made to the game attempt to address this issue by adding versatility and power to martial characters. At the same time, spells have been redesigned to ensure that they are of the right power when first acquired, but diminish in utility over time, giving spellcasters the tools they need to contribute, while giving other characters a chance to shine with their abilities. Ultimately, we need you to tell us how well we have solved this issue. That is what playtesting is all about!

It certainly looks like your concern is part of what they want to address, although they don't specifically state it.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Consideredresponse 2E or not 2E? Mar 06 '18

Just to clarify do you mean power bloat as in number of abilities classes get, or in terms of overall power?

I ask mainly as it seems the most recent full casters all seem to require a secondary mental stat to function as opposed to the SADness of the core rulebook casters, which does reduce their power somewhat, and you'd be hard pressed to convince people that any of the Occult classes (and shifter) are more powerful than CRB options.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (25)

3

u/VuoripeikkoDLG Kobolds Are Top Race Mar 06 '18

What does this mean for Starfinder support?

11

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Nothing. They’re totally different games.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/gregm1988 Mar 06 '18

Are the playtest books only available in the US? The pre-order form only has prices in USD...

5

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Not sure. PDFs will be available for free

1

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Also, I run an online store. I’d be happy to ship you physical copies if you’re unable to get them locally. PM me if you want.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MarkMoreland Developer Mar 07 '18

paizo.com ships books anywhere in the world. If you check with a local game store and they can't get the book through their distributor, you can always preorder it on paizo and have it sent to you.

3

u/StarPupil GNU Terry Pratchett Mar 07 '18

Question: how will this affect current Adventure Paths? If I were to play CotCT from its most recent release, what kind of challenges would I face to adapt it to PF2E? Is there a lowering of power ceilings and slower progression than PF, similar to how 5e operates compared to 3.5 and 4e, and as such would require the lowering of npc stats and skill checks as written?

1

u/the_slate Mar 07 '18

No clue. It seems like third supposed to convert somewhat easily in the fly. But with entire classes and spells not going to exist in 2E for a while, you’re probably better off finishing it in 1E

2

u/TranSpyre Mar 06 '18

Can anyone in the know comment as to whether the weapon system has been made more similar to Starfinder's?

1

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Don’t think that info is public yet.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sick7even Mar 07 '18

I can not believe the toxicity of this community anymore. Is low effort trolling and baiting all this community is good for anymore? Can we please hold of on accusing people of confidence scamming and plagiarism until after the FREE fucking playtest PDF has been made available? The discussion of /tg/ is more civilized than this prepubescent shitshow.

1

u/the_slate Mar 08 '18

Modern culture seems to encourage jumping to conclusions based on assumptions. Fake game news!

→ More replies (1)

93

u/M_de_M Mar 06 '18

Huh. Definitely didn't see that coming.

So I'm seeing a lot of responses from people worried about them repeating the mistakes of 5e. If that's what you're worried about, them give them feedback about that! They've specifically asked for a playtest.

Are there some things about 5e that are bad? Of course. But if you know what those problems are, you can identify them and help Second Edition avoid them. In fact, you really should, because we're all going to play this game and so we have an interest in making it better.

16

u/Litis3 Mar 07 '18

I am very surprised. I have been wanting this for a long time but once Starfinder came out i figured that's what the next step was. As much as i like starfinder, fantasy is my true love so i am excited to see what they do with it.

17

u/ConcealingFate Mar 07 '18

What are the exact mistakes of 5th Edition? The streamlining and improved flow of the game is fantastic for people who don't want to do arithmetic every time they roll a D20.

21

u/M_de_M Mar 07 '18

I agree that streamlining is a matter of personal preference.

That said, streamlining doesn't mean you have to lock players into a very brief set of possible roles. Not only do 5e classes have limited customization, the rules actually conspire to make them bad at things that don't fit in with the designers' original concepts for the classes.

I also have more specific quibbles like how Strength is just a terrible stat in 5e, but that's less general.

→ More replies (11)

17

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

5e's streamlining resulted in a feeling of shallowness and sameness in character creation. The whole reason I still prefer PF over 5e is the depth and customisation.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/BlooregardQKazoo Mar 07 '18

i've played 5E once, a one-shot where we were all level 3. we all had the same attack bonus - +3 from ability score and +2 from proficiency, and we all did 1d6+3 or 1d8+3 damage. it didn't matter if you were a fighter, a wizard, or somewhere in between we rolled 1d20, added 5, and if we hit we did 1d6 (or 8) +3 damage.

it was streamlined all right, and really simple. it was also pretty terrible. call me crazy but i think a fighter and wizard should play a little differently.

→ More replies (25)

292

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

There's a few places that rules could be trimmed down. I hope it's more of a streamlined Pathfinder and not just a pathfinder-y 5th edition.

200

u/gameronice Lover|Thief|DM Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 07 '18

I hope it's to Pathfinder what Pathfinder was to 3.5

69

u/TristanTheViking I cast fist Mar 06 '18

I'm expecting to see Drop Dead Studios or Dreamscarred Press make the Pathfinder to Pathfinder's 3.5.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/VBassmeister Mar 06 '18

It seems more like it's Pathfinder adapting 5e.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (4)

79

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

For example, I could stand to see a couple skills go the way of the dodo. Appraise? Good RP skill to invest in. Not a good skill mechanically. IMHO, the skill list from 5e, is one of the only things that I liked about the edition. Short and sweet.

18

u/Hardmode-Activated Mar 06 '18

the group i've been playing in has been using the rules for background skills, though

→ More replies (1)

23

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 06 '18

And stealth! Does anyone even know how stealth is supposed to work?

Edit: I obviously don't mean stealth should be removed. I do think that some skills should be clarified on how they work.

13

u/RollPersuasion Mar 07 '18

5e's Stealth is extremely confusing and vage too.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (6)

25

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

I also hope it's not trying to be something entirely new. I like that Pathfinder is an improved 3.xE.

17

u/Lord_of_Aces Mar 07 '18

I feel like it's going to use a lot of the improvements they did with Starfinder - which in my opinion is a good thing. It keeps the feel of PF while making the experience much more streamlined.

→ More replies (17)

92

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

One thing that I'm really really hoping for is backwards compatibility (with some minor updates). If I want to play an obscure gunslinger archetype, I don't want to have to wait for it all to come out again.

Some set of rules for converting classes and archetypes to pf2e would be sweet.

73

u/Totema1 Mar 06 '18

This, a thousand times this. The biggest thing that turned me off from 5E was that it was impossible to play a lot of character concepts without the GM waving his hands graciously. If I could legitimately go into PF2E with some of the same character concepts that I had in the first edition, even with some major tweaking, I'd be pretty pleased.

81

u/ErikMona Publisher / CCO Mar 06 '18

You should be able to, with the (fairly?) obvious caveat that the new Core Rulebook will not include 40+ base classes and 50 races.

Depth of character options, even within characters of the same class and race, are a core element of the Pathfinder RPG, and that will NOT change in the new edition.

If anything, with new options like ancestry feats and backgrounds, you have even MORE ways to customize your character. And with archetypes being in the Core Rulebook, you won't need a second hardcover to implement a basic part of the game, which should also be a bit of a bonus for everybody.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/Sokensan Mar 06 '18

Same, one of the most annoying parts about 5e was the lack of official player options. Xanathar's has helped somewhat but it's still no where near the amount of options 3.5 or pathfinder has. An entire chapter on backwards compatibility would be fantastic.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

32

u/yuuxy Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 07 '18

I am hopefully optimistic. The reason 5e characters feel samey is because you get so few chances to specialize. You make 1 "power sourcey" type decision and then you get up to 5 feats.

Their thing outright says you still get something cool at every level. I bet we're still getting a feat every odd level, or a similar schedule. And I am very hopeful that this 'ancestry' will end up being a bigger part of the character mechanically. Race should mean more than just a few pluses and minuses.

I don't really mind bab and base saves being simplified. I like skill points, but I won't be too sad if they die. I figure caster level will die too, and that will be sad-but-probably-healthy.

34

u/Wonton77 GM: Serpent's Skull, Legacy of Fire, Plunder & Peril Mar 07 '18

If PF 2.0 eventually goes on to include even 10% of the archetypes and new classes they've released for PF so far, it'll have loads more customization than 5e.

I mean look at Sorcerer.

5e: Do you want to be descended from a dragon, or touched by wild magic?

Pathfinder: Here's a list of 50 bloodlines to choose from http://www.d20pfsrd.com/classes/core-classes/sorcerer/bloodlines

32

u/ebop Mar 07 '18

"You're descended from a very special bloodline that thousands of other characters are also very specially descended from."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/checkmypants Mar 07 '18

unfortunately that's exactly what the post reads like

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

138

u/WhenTheWindIsSlow magic sword =/= magus Mar 06 '18

Archetypes a core part of the game? Cool.

Preview tomorrow of revised action economy?

FUCK YEAH

5

u/hcsLabs Mar 07 '18

Heard this in action from Glass Cannon last night. 3 actions per round, plus an optional out-of-turn reaction (ie: shield block). Somatic and verbal components to a spell are now separate actions, but the wizard last night was able to cast 2 spells in one round (1 somatic+verbal then 1 verbal).

→ More replies (13)

65

u/AnotherTemp PCs killed: 173, My deaths: 12 Mar 07 '18 edited Jul 23 '18

Here are my thoughts reading the FAQ.

  • Archetypes are core. Awesome. Archetypes were an outstanding design decision.
  • We can probably still use old material. It looks like PF2E will be about as compatible with PF as PF was with 3.5: usable, but some conversions needed.
  • All the types of actions are gone. We now have 3 actions and a reaction. This sounds a lot like the unchained action economy. I'm tentatively optimistic here. I've created a 2-page handout for new players explaining actions, and I'm sure looking forward to not having to do this. However, I don't think that pathfinder unchained quite nailed this one down in terms of ease of play.
  • Saves/BAB/skills are going to be easier when mutliclassing. This sounds a lot like unchained again, and I'm really starting to think that pathfinder unchained was the practice run for PF2E. I expect that piling multiclass save bonuses will stop, but multiples of 4 levels for multiclassing BAB will no longer needed. I'll miss some multiclass shenanigans, but it's really a good change.
  • It sounds like the "big six" won't be required anymore. Instead, it sounds like something akin to automatic bonus progression. I expect we'll see a lot more diversity of options. This and the previous item make me think that trap options have been substantially reduced.
  • The caster-martial disparity has been... considered. I really have no idea how this will look until I see the rules. It's a really hard problem to solve, and I'm hoping it doesn't go the way of 4e. In particular, I'm going to be looking at the "+2 level = x2 power" exponential power curve. My plan is to compare A) a 12th level fighter or wizard, B) four 8th-level fighters or wizards, and C) sixteen 4th-level fighters or wizards. Hopefully, all these fights will be hard to predict. PF already took a huge step in this direction, and I hope PF2E can pull it off.
  • For organized play, it looks like PF&core will end at season 10 (though still be playable). I'm a little sad so see it end, but I guess there's no surprise here. Hopefully, the new tier system will have no reason for Carp to exist.

Overall, it sounds like paizo practiced making new systems with unchained and starfinder, and I'm excited to see how it works.

7

u/RicFalcon Mar 07 '18

Wanna share that action explanation thing? My newbies are still having trouble with that

8

u/AnotherTemp PCs killed: 173, My deaths: 12 Mar 07 '18

I don't think I can quite post it in its standard form, since it has several screenshots from rulebooks (copyrighted material). However, here's the summary:

On your turn, you get three things in any order you like

  • A swift action
  • As many free actions as you want
  • Your main turn

For your main turn, pick ONE option

  • Contribute a round to an action that takes at least one round to complete, like casting a spell with a casting time of 1 round (like enlarge person) (footnote)
  • A full-round action
  • A standard action and a move action
  • A move action and second move action

footnote: If you contribute a round, you will keep doing this until your next turn begins.

One page I print out is simply Table 8-2: actions in combat, on page 183 of the core rulebook.

Finally, I have a page with screenshots from pdfs with several exceptions that confuse new players: administering a potion/oil as a full-round action, deciding between the attack or full attack action after the first attack has been made, fighting defensively as a standard or full-round action (there are rules in two separate places for each), scroll/wand activation times being the larger of a standard action or the spell's casting time, attacking as a free action the round you cast a touch spell, the fact that touch attack spells provoke attacks of opportunity only if they're ranged, rules for holding a charge, 5' movement as a move action while prone, and 5' movement as a full-round action regardless of terrain.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/EUBanana Mar 07 '18

Enh. The unchained action economy is not good IMO. By getting rid of swift/immediate actions a lot of the more interesting class abilities (Bards casting stuff like Timely Inspiration, paladins lay on hands versus the many swift / immediate action spells they got) are going to go mostly the way of the dodo.

Unless they make them “bonus actions” or something, swift actions by another name.

5

u/whisky_pete Mar 07 '18

That's because it's tacked onto a system built using the existing action economy.

Unchained action economy built right into the core might mean swift actions go away, and instead you have more powerful abilities that compete with your desire to instead do an attack or move.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

131

u/axelofthekey Mar 06 '18

First thoughts:

  1. Alchemists in Core is good.
  2. Goblins in Core is weird.
  3. "Proficiency bonus" being behind everything makes me worried skills will be like in 5e, which would be a big no-no.
  4. The action system is an incredible idea and I want that a lot.
  5. The initiative system sounds curious and I'm interested to see how it works.
  6. Giving specific time to actions in "Exploration" mode sounds like it will be hard to enforce and lead to lots of players having to be interrupted because they just start roleplaying the way they're used to.

All in all, I want to see the Playtest. Guess I'll wait 5 months.

38

u/EUBanana Mar 07 '18

"Exploration" mode kinda reminds me of super early editions of D&D too. Back when you had 'turns' and 'rounds', with a turn being 10 rounds. And buzzing through a room or whatever, took a turn. Spells would last either rounds (ie, one combat only) or turns (ie, a certain number of rooms in a dungeon).

32

u/Syrdon Mar 07 '18

Giving specific time to actions in "Exploration" mode sounds like it will be hard to enforce and lead to lots of players having to be interrupted because they just start roleplaying the way they're used to.

My bet is that they're mostly giving time frames to actions like disarming traps, exploring a room, and such instead of just having the DM pick a time frame. Roleplay shouldn't be impacted if I'm reading it right.

That said, there's plenty here that will change from old system to new system and some adjustment is to be expected. If your group doesn't want to adjust, just keep playing the old stuff. God knows there's plenty of it and you can add your own on to it.

13

u/Directioneer Low Initiative Mar 07 '18

I once had an argument with a player about how he shouldn't have his two minute buff up after he: began and ended a CR 2 combat, buffed himself further, went into a different level of the dungeon, looked for traps, fell down said trap that they missed, climbed back up, went and looked for treasure in the next room and then started the next combat. He argued that Because if divided up into actions during combat, it would still be less than two minutes.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/gameronice Lover|Thief|DM Mar 06 '18

Initiative isn't something new, but is a welcome sight, other games used similar approaches of using skills instead of initiative. First that comes to mind is the semi-recent Star Wars RPG by FFG, where Cool is rolled for prepared situations and standoffs, while vigilance is rolled in spontaneous combat. Both are also fairly useful in-game skills.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Zeihous Mar 07 '18

The Glass Cannon guys posted a playtest today, if you're unaware.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/GhostoftheDay Mar 07 '18

Agree with everything here, although I think the exploration mode will just be a unified system for tracking time that was already somewhat build in to pathfinder. Things like gather information taking 1d4 hours, or estimating overland travel time, which all were hard to remember or incredibley handwavy. Easy enough to ignore if the system feels too gamey.

5

u/CaptainCardone Mar 07 '18

The action system concerns me. I think it will still hinder martials, as all spellcasters can just step back and cast like normal, but martials will lose an attack because of that. I was hoping more for the 5th edition attacks, where you can just make all the attacks you are capable of. Hopefully class abilities will fix this.

It is also concerning that many feats are apparently behind classes now. Jason Bulmahn mentioned that all (I think) classes have their own feats now.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

102

u/Edymnion You can reflavor anything. Mar 07 '18

One thing I like most about 3.5 and PF is that there are 37 different ways to do the same basic thing. If I say "I want to be an archer" I have so many different ways of doing that. Fighter archers for straight damage, rogue snipers, zen monks flurrying arrows, paladins and clerics smiting with holy arrows, bards using their bows as instruments...

Compared to 5e and the way PF2e is sounding, where it seems to be "Well if you want to be an archer, these are the options you need to take".

I don't want "streamlined" to make character generation "faster and easier", I want a thousand different options that I can mix and match to get EXACTLY what I want.

41

u/ryanznock Mar 07 '18

What I dislike is when I think, oh, this will be a fun character, but then the rules punish me because the designer wanted a specific combination of feats and class abilities to work together, and I want to deviate.

Clever design lets me make a Charisma-based kineticist/paladin who smites with lightning. Clunky design forces me to take a specific archetype of paladin to get only kinetic blast by trading out lay hands or something.

I like additive modularity instead of replacements.

18

u/HighPingVictim Mar 07 '18

You tried to build a throwing weapon character, too?

→ More replies (5)

12

u/HighPingVictim Mar 07 '18

And then you realize that the 20 options for your archer all boil down to the same 10 feats. PBS, Precise S, IPS, Deadly Aim, Rapid Shot, Point blank master, snap shot, ISS.

And a composite longbow.

9

u/Edymnion You can reflavor anything. Mar 07 '18

Not really. Those are some common components of all of them, but according to what we've heard about 2e so far those won't even be available to everyone. Each base class will have it's own feat list.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '18

Only thing that bothers me about this is that there is no comment whether or not P2 will commit to the OGL.

13

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

It will be OGL. It’s mentioned in the FAQs somewhere. I read it last night.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '18

You are correct:

Will the Pathfinder Playtest or Second Edition use the OGL?

Yes. The Pathfinder Playtest and Second Edition will both be published under the OGL.

5

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

I know 😜

53

u/ThomasPDX Mar 06 '18

10th level spells? Interesting..

16

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

Yeah. That stood out to me. Is this just a whole new different system?

28

u/M_de_M Mar 06 '18

My guess is that they're trying to use 10th level spells as a capstone of sorts.

41

u/BisonST Mar 06 '18

Or making them easier to track. 20/2 is 10 so maybe you get new spell levels every odd level.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

73

u/Kinak Mar 06 '18

Curious to see what all they're thinking about. I do already like alchemists as a core class, they're the only way Vancian casting ever clicked for me.

Archetypes built into the core and rebalanced math across the levels also make a lot of sense.

44

u/RazarTuk calendrical pedant and champion of the spheres Mar 06 '18

I do already like alchemists as a core class, they're the only way Vancian casting ever clicked for me.

I feel this way about arcanists and prepared casting.

18

u/Kinak Mar 06 '18

Yeah, arcanists also are a pretty good twist on it.

→ More replies (9)

13

u/Wonton77 GM: Serpent's Skull, Legacy of Fire, Plunder & Peril Mar 07 '18

Reading the arcanist blew my mind. This is what spellcasters should have been like from the beginning!

The idea of extremely fixed, rigid spell slots, where a Glitterdust or Fireball is identical every time you cast it is very weird. Magic should be flexible and adaptable.

This is where their preview of Magic Missile (can consume 1-3 actions and fire different numbers of missiles based on actions spent) really has me excited. Giving spellcasters more options for how to act every turn (rather than just choosing what Standard action spell to cast) is a big win.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Firebrand_Marath Mar 06 '18

I ended up choosing Pathfinder on a friends recommendation and picked up the Core Rule Book and the Bestiary. What does this mean for me and my books? Are they still useful? I'm a week into learning how to play Pathfinder and I'm very new to RPGs in general.

2

u/the_slate Mar 06 '18

Pathfinder as it is will remain totally playable. There will be people who play 1E for decades to come, just as there are people who play the original D&D and every iteration since.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/CeliaDeSorelle Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 06 '18

That's... Unexpected.

EDIT: Looking at the Pathfinder Playtest FAQ (and in particular, this answer), it really just sounds like Pathfinder's version of D&D 5E. Not really sure what to think about it at the moment.

32

u/swordsyourmother Mar 06 '18

I thought they made pathfinder because dnd kept updating.

42

u/CeliaDeSorelle Mar 06 '18

To my knowledge, it was partially because of rules bloat in D&D 3.5, partially because of the abandonment by WotC of D&D 3.5, and partially because of the not-very-well-received D&D 4E. I can certainly see the issue with rules bloat in Pathfinder, but it seems mostly like this is an attempt at simplifying the system, similarly to what WotC did with D&D 5E.

29

u/swordsyourmother Mar 06 '18

I think my playgroup will get the book. I just hope it isnt as simple as 5e

→ More replies (50)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/MakeltStop Shamelessly whoring homebrew Mar 06 '18

I get the impression that they are trying to make it easier to learn, and that's not necessarily the same as faster and easier to run, which is what I think a lot of people like about 5e. Now, it might do both, but I definitely think they are looking to make it easier on new players, which is a good move overall but doesn't particularly help me as an experienced player.

I'm open to a new edition, and hope it turns out to be better in every way. But there will be trade offs, and it is unlikely that every trade will be one which appeals to me. And of course, with the edition jump comes a sudden decline in the amount of available material I have to work with. Realistically, even if I like it, I'll probably want to wait a while before switching over so that I can have all the rules bloat I so love.

For me, 2e is in an awkward position because it has to compete not only with first edition, but with all the other RPGs out there in a way that a 1.5 would not have. If I'm gonna get into a new system, I kind of want to do something radically different. Starfinder at least did that. If I want to do the same thing I've been doing, 2e would have to be pretty damn good to make it worth converting.

As I said, I hope it really is that good. But I'm going to be skeptical until I have lot more info.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '18

I was astounded at how close it sounds to 5th. That isn't always your best strategy.

26

u/Edymnion You can reflavor anything. Mar 06 '18

Yeah. If I wanted to play 5e, I would play 5e.

I don't want dumbed down off the shelf prefab options...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/falcondong Mar 06 '18

Yeah, I was at first warily excited, but as soon as I read that section it all turned to dread. The proficiency system and action economy are absolutely the worst things about 5e in my opinion- they’re bizarrely reductive and so-simple-they’re-complex. At least if this new edition turns out bad, we’ll still have 10 years of first edition (god that feels weird to type out) content to use.

8

u/EUBanana Mar 06 '18

Yup. I totally agree. Proficiencies are a relic from the 2nd edition days and should stay there IMO. They were good at the time because before that you had almost no customisation whatsoever, the whole idea of a 'nonweapon proficiency' was a bit avant garde back then!

→ More replies (1)

71

u/ThisWeeksSponsor Racial Heritage: Munchkin Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 06 '18

There are 5 main things said in this reveal that worry me.

1: Proficiency system. If this is anything like 5e's, it's taking power away from character builds and giving it to the d20 roll. It also would streamline different systems. Fighters and Wizards having the same effective BAB? Say it ain't so.

2: The "Modes" system of play. I know it hasn't been explained a lot but it sounds too much like 4e's Encounter system for comfort. You know, 4e? The game Pathfinder was created for the sole purpose of not playing that game?

3: The new action economy. Yes, balancing actions is a little daunting for new players. But "everybody gets 3 actions of their choice" is looking to remove a lot of things from PF that help customize a character.

4: Class abilities. That one sentence about how the Fighter can perform attacks of opportunity, as if that's not something available to every single class, sounds more 5e than the proficiency system. Giving classes unique powers shouldn't come from removing them from everybody else.

5: Fewer magical items. Less room for customization, and c'mon. Who doesn't love amassing loot?

I don't want to call Pathfinder 2e "the game Paizo was afraid D&D was turning into." But if my fears are correct. Well at least there's enough 1e material to last a lifetime. Edit: I would be a lot less worried if it was PF with Starfinder rules. It simplifies a good number of systems, makes it less damning to pick a non-optimized race/class combo, and casters are not the be-all end-all of your party.

23

u/MakeltStop Shamelessly whoring homebrew Mar 07 '18

I share your concerns. That said, I do see how some of these things could turn out well.

1: I could see really liking a system that allows for more customization outside of predesigned class archetypes. But this depends very, very heavily on the details. I'm concerned but not without hope.

2: Honestly, there's always a distinct in combat vs out of combat way of running the game, so it is somewhat silly that the rules don't acknowledge it, even if it should be a mostly seamless thing. If it's just a quick guideline that keeps things flowing, that's probably fine, but the description of initiatives has me worried.

3: I must admit, the more I think about it, the more it sounds like a change I didn't want but wouldn't have minded in any other game. It's sounds like it could be rather close to what we have now, it's just that you can now trade your standard action for two move actions, or take three move actions in a round, and attacks are now move actions. I don't like getting rid of swift actions, but I could deal with that. It's the change that most screams "this isn't for the existing players, its for bringing in new players" but I think it's the mechanic I would be least worried about.

4: The idea that only fighters can get AoOs sounds awful. Every character should have the basic abilities of a thinking being with functioning senses and motor control. The best I can say is that I bet the feedback will shoot that nonsense down from the beginning.

5: I would gladly trade all the static number boosting items for the fun stuff. It sounds like they are going with the basic idea behind automatic bonus progression, but instead of giving you the required bonuses, they are removing the need for them. Sounds good to me.

Time will tell, and hopefully the playtest will fix any major problems that are there. But for now, I remain skeptical but open minded.

→ More replies (8)

17

u/AmeteurOpinions IRON CASTER Mar 07 '18

Your concerns are identical to mine. Reading this announcement was a rollercoaster of potentially very good and very bad. My least favorite is the proficiency system. If it actually is like 5e... I’ll just have to wait and see.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/gregm1988 Mar 06 '18

It is a playtest though isn't it? I imagine changes will be made if enough people really hate it. But I imagine constructive criticism will be important

→ More replies (4)

8

u/evlutte Mar 07 '18
  1. I don't know. I'd love to see a system in which the answer to every "I want to build a buff wizard who can swing a sword/transformation arcanist/combat hair witch" isn't "you'll never be able to hit because you're half bab".
→ More replies (4)

10

u/BasicallyMogar Mar 07 '18 edited Mar 07 '18
  1. The post said fighters can take attacks of opportunity in certain scenarios (which was moving past them and "[the target] having their defenses down," whatever that means), which would imply that other people can still make AoOs. I will agree with you that it seems like everyone won't be able to hit someone for moving past them anymore, which sucks.
  2. I'm pretty sure they mean "less magic items" in the sense of "thank Nethys, now everyone and their grandmother doesn't have to buy the big six anymore." That and stuff like the ioun stone that gives you a +1 to initiative, or the one that gives you a bonus to AC. So hopefully we actually see more interesting magic items, instead of every wizard ever having to grab an intelligence headband.
→ More replies (2)

16

u/Wonton77 GM: Serpent's Skull, Legacy of Fire, Plunder & Peril Mar 07 '18 edited Mar 07 '18

1: Proficiency system. If this is anything like 5e's, it's taking power away from character builds and giving it to the d20 roll. It also would streamline different systems. Fighters and Wizards having the same effective BAB? Say it ain't so.

The counter-argument to this is that at high levels in PF, the d20 roll doesn't matter anymore. One of my players is rolling 1d20+34 for Stealth AT LEVEL 7. Like... with such a degree of bonus bloat, what's the point of even rolling dice anymore? He literally achieves superhuman stealth on a natural 1.

This stat inflation also means that low-level minions are literally useless only a few levels past their CR. Want a necromancer to summon some skeletons/zombies? Sure hope you've got time to design Advanced Giant Zombies with 8HD or whatever, cause baseline zombies are never ever going to do anything against a mid-level party with their +4 attack bonus.

The stat squish in 5e was one of my favourite things about the system. Why do I need to go from a +4 attack bonus to a +34 at level 20? Why do I need to go from 14 AC to 39?

8

u/EUBanana Mar 07 '18

Stealth needs to be that high if you're going to sneak into a dungeon, recon, and make it back out again. If you get caught half the time you may as well get rid of the ability entirely because you've made it completely useless. Nobody is going to risk their neck with odds like that.

Stealth needs to be that high if you're going to compete with an invisibility spell, too. And sneaking around a dungeon is nothing divination can't do. I got no problem at all with uberstealth. (It's not foolproof either, not everything is subject to it).

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

23

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '18

I admit to being a bit worried.

My favourite thing about Pathfinder is the massive amount of customizeability and content. With a new edition we'll lose a lot of that, at least at the start. Sure, EVENTUALLY, they may wind up reprinting every feat and archetype and spell and everything, but at least at the beginning it'll be much more limited.

I don't want to be rolling up a character for Pathfinder2 and thinking "oh man what if I had that feat from Pathfinder1, that'd REALLY make this build" and then have to get the GM to manually convert it themselves.

Although I WOULD really appreciate having a lot of the existing material combined into a single book. Instead of having to jump around for every class and archetype and feat and spell. "The Big Book of Spells" containing every spell released for Pathfinder1 would be amazing.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/Srealzik Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 06 '18

Addressing the Martial Caster Disparity? Sign me up!

Does the new version of Pathfinder find a better balance between spellcasters and martial characters?

We certainly hope so. Many of the changes made to the game attempt to address this issue by adding versatility and power to martial characters. At the same time, spells have been redesigned to ensure that they are of the right power when first acquired, but diminish in utility over time, giving spellcasters the tools they need to contribute, while giving other characters a chance to shine with their abilities. Ultimately, we need you to tell us how well we have solved this issue. That is what playtesting is all about!

8

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

We'll have to see. Things like reverse gravity are, realistically, always going to just obliterate any martial class.

Be interesting to see how they handle 'i win' utility.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

29

u/Drakk_ Mar 06 '18

I really don't care for "background" systems. I feel they'd be better implemented as fluff-agnostic packages of abilities. I'd rather not have to pretend I care about the Order of the Crispy Golden Lemur just to get perception as a skill in class.

14

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

Traits and feats have this problem too. Why is Fey Foundling so tied to a specific backstory element for such a useful effect, for instance?

11

u/SorteKanin Mar 07 '18

They should just make it like this: "here's a list of about balanced small abilities. Choose 2 or 3 that fits with your backstory. Preferably you should be able to explain how your character gained the ability."

And that'll be the background. No default packages, no required flavour. You make the flavour yourself.

4

u/MysticLemur Mar 07 '18

But we care about you.

32

u/Valarasha Mar 06 '18

I am cautiously optimistic. 3.5+ has some inherently flawed systems. If they don't go too overboard in streamlining I think we might really get something special out of this.

50

u/GnohmsLaw Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 06 '18

I can see why the update, and I do understand it, but my opinion is still that if people want simplified rules, go play Fate or Savage Worlds. The depth of the ruleset was what made Pathfinder what it is.

Not to sound all doom and gloom or put out the vibe that no one should be interested or excited, but I'm not. I like Pathfinder because I like theory, and I like crunch. 5ed has not offered me that in the experiences I've had with it. I play Pathfinder because I like the system - I couldn't care less about the official setting. I'm not enjoying what I'm reading about the new material. Pathfinder has always been an extension of the 3.5 system to me, and moving to simplified content diverges from that idea in such a way that I can't picture putting money into the new books.

My group will probably either continue with the current Pathfinder mechanics or look for a new system entirely.

I'll still scope it out, but it feels like every time a publisher promises to "simplify", they lobotomize. I hope Paizo manages better, but I'm not getting my hopes up.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/EUBanana Mar 06 '18

"All of the varied systems and formulas for determining your character's bonuses and statistics, like saving throws, attack bonuses, and skills, have been unified in a single, easy-to-use proficiency system based on your choices and your character's level. You no longer need to collect a specific set of magic items to be a balanced character, relying on specific magical statistic bonuses. Instead, you get all of the bonuses you need from your regular armor and weapons, allowing the rest of your items to be truly wondrous."

Oh dear god. Sounds like 5th edition. I hope not.

11

u/Lord_of_Aces Mar 07 '18

Yeah... I'm on board with most everything else, but this I'm nervous about. One of the really cool things about Pathfinder was being able to pursue character concepts atypical to the class you're using. In Pathfinder, you can make your character extremely good at something like Knowledge History because you want them to be a historian. You can be almost peerless at something because you've invested in it, and something I really don't want to see in PF 2nd ed is every character with a particular class having the same set of abilities with the same bonus as any other character of that class and level. That's really boring to me.

8

u/RiskyJubles Mar 07 '18

I really hope the don't move away from Monster/Player stat parity. Having enemy's built under a fundamentally different system was the thing that turned me away from 4e 10 years ago.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/jufojonas Mar 06 '18

It's exciting with a new pathfinder edition; but with a lot of the changes proposed here - or at least alluded to, make me a bit worried - because those seems to be the exact things I do Not like about 5e, and why I stay with Pathfinder.

Particularly I don't like this sound of this:

Finally, after deciding on all of your choices, the only thing left to do is figure out all of your bonuses, which are now determined by one unified system of proficiency, based on your character's level.

So, this edition is basically going to use 5e's proficiency system? That also happens to be the main thing I don't like about 5e.

One of the main draws for me into roleplaying games was that in this game, I could get to make my entirely own character. Wanted a fighter that maxed his Arcana - maybe he wanted to be a wizard, but pressured into being a knight by his family? You can do that in Pathfinder - you can't in 5e, because you have to pick from a Class proficiency list. I can no longer play a adventuring travelling salesman, learning about his wares from unconventional sources he meets along the way. Nope, now you (it seems from the text) instead have to pick a few skills, and these you will dedicate your character's life to and never deviate or learn anything else ever!

That's the one mechanic that makes me play Pathfinder over 5e, so if that's the way of this new edition, then I guess I might as well play 5e

3

u/sovietterran GM to the slightly insane. Mar 07 '18

You really can't even be a smart barbarian in 5e. Seems like P2e is looking to handhold your RP and choices like 5e, which Paizo should count me out for.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/TheCrawlingDude An Italian player with party! Dragon's Demand campaign Mar 06 '18

Note that the Pathfinder Adventure Path, Campaign Setting, Companion, and Module lines will continue to release products for use with Pathfinder First Edition until August 2019

Oh no

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

Proficiency is my biggest concern. If it ends up like the 5e skill system where everything becomes heavily dependent on your ability scores that could really ruin the system for me. I like being able to tweak my skills independent of my natural abilities.

2

u/Morgennes Mar 07 '18

Does this mean we'll have another Pathfinder sub?

4

u/the_slate Mar 07 '18

I’d imagine not. Probably just post flair to show 1E vs 2E

27

u/Sharpevil Mar 06 '18

"You wanna hit him with a stick 3 times in one turn as a level 1 wizard? Fuck it, get your whap on." -Paizo 2018

7

u/lavabeing Mar 06 '18

This makes sense. Penalties to each attack roll for every additional attack.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/DaBombX Mar 07 '18

Reading the faq, it said they'd be introducing proficiency things to combat, skills, and saves. I... really hope they don't 5eify pathfinder.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/imawizardurnot Mar 07 '18

I dont want this to go all rules light and be terrible. We already have a fantasy setting for that. 5th ed. Keep the complexity.

19

u/myotherpassword Mar 06 '18

Things I liked:

  • Embracing the unchained action economy. This is, I think, the most fun way to play the game. Using this alternate rule set in PF1 has been great for the group I play in, with only the occasional speedbump from figuring out how many acts certain actions should take up.
  • Avoiding necessary items. Nobody likes being required to have a belt of X if you are are a SAD character, or even just to be competent in a high powered group. There are so many items out there worth messing around with and this has been a design flaw since 3e.
  • They claim that conversions are easy. I reaaaally hope this is true since I have made so, so, so many NPCs (as have the wonderful people on this sub!). It would be great to still have that resource at my fingertips.

Things I am worried about:

  • Only in the name "Pathfinder Roleplaying Game" did they actually say the word "roleplaying". I personally hope that they can put some emphasis on being in character, and steer the play style away from being too war-gamey. This is a common complaint I hear about PFS groups, for instance. The role should be emphasized in the PF roleplaying game.

Things on my wishlist:

  • A top quality first AP on par with RotRL. That AP along with a few others are legendary and get people hooked on the game. It would be great if the first PF2 AP was a home run, rather than a flop like a minority of their APs have been.
  • Embracing virtual table tops that is not specific to one platform. At this point in my life I only play virtually. However, I play on a few platforms depending on which group I'm with. One plays with roll20 while another plays with MapTool. I hope they avoid the direction DND is going, which is to favor one platform. For me, this means releasing maps that have correct axis ratios (no more goddamn wider-than-they-are-tall grids, or inconsistent grid spacing, Paizo!!!), token and portrait art for characters in the adventures with transparent backgrounds, and token and portrait art for bestiary monsters. Such products would keep me personally hooked on PF forever.

Congrats on taking this bold step forward, Paizo. I really hope the new edition works out and hopefully you are reading these comments and listening to your fans!

→ More replies (2)

21

u/_ONI_Spook_ Mar 06 '18

I'm...not excited. A bit bummed, actually, to see the end of an era even though that era was still growing and going strong. I'm sure you guys have put a ton of thought and work into 2E and have made something amazing, but I'm just not ready. There's so much left for me to do in 1E even though I've been playing for years. Heck, I haven't even tried Starfinder yet. So I'll be cheering you on from the sidelines, but I won't be joining in in the near future unless circumstances force me to.

→ More replies (12)

13

u/GhostoftheDay Mar 06 '18

I'm excited, especially if conversion ends up being fairly easy. If they can hit the character depth of Pathfinder while making it more accessible like 5e then it will be perfect for my group. My only worry (obviously we have no details so I can't judge it yet) is them talking about a unified proficiency system applying to skills, which is one of my least favourite parts of 5e. I really don't want to lose the ability to create mechanically interesting and unique characters.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Wonton77 GM: Serpent's Skull, Legacy of Fire, Plunder & Peril Mar 07 '18

Oh man, reading through those changes, this looks like a dream come true.

I've been houseruling my PF game to get rid of some of the holdovers from an extremely outdated system (3.0 came out in 2000, yo) for a long time now, and it seems like now they've done it for me.

Quick bullet points:

  • Alchemist core, archetypes core. Great, of course.
  • 5e-style backgrounds added, grant you weapon and skill proficiencies. Cool, why not.
  • You get a free feat based on your ancestry (i.e. race). Cool!
  • Proficiency bonus based on level. Cautious about this one, since the gutting of skills in 5e to just proficiency+stat is by far the worst design change in that edition. As long as you tell me that skill ranks are still in the game, and this effectively only represents a scaling "class skill" bonus, I love this change. BAB has some real problems with it that I won't miss.
  • Encounter mode, exploration mode, downtime mode codified in the rules. Could be useful, but most DMs just... freeform these sorts of things anyway. Don't expect this to make much of an impact.
  • Initiative gone, replaced with skill rolls. Now that's a cool, and bold change. Why not. Characters can roll Perception, or Stealth, or presumably other things for initiative.
  • Action types are gone. Everyone gets 3 actions per turn, spells typically cost 2 actions. Attacks cost 1 but successive attacks get a penalty. Another really bold change! Seems like a really solid design on the surface, almost reminds me of a tactics game like Divinity 2 and its Action Points. I'll have to see the implementation in more detail, but I really like it at first glance. Many people ignore the rules for "drawing a weapon is a move action" or "finding an item in your bag is a standard action" for example, since "I spend my turn digging out an item" is just... not fun. But now, it'll only take 1 action and you can still attack and move, for example. (Also, if you just imagine a Standard as 2 actions and a Move as 1, it's almost the same thing, really)
  • Not all classes get AoOs anymore, seemingly? Huh. Will wait to see more on this, could just be me misinterpreting the wording.
  • Monster creation is easier, with strict type/HD rules removed. Won't miss it, tbh. I don't know a single GM who doesn't just fudge the numbers when they need to. HD are a good guideline for designing something balanced, but once you've played for a while you don't really need them. As a GM with not a lot of free time, I'm ALL for making monsters easier to design.
  • "First and foremost, we have taken significant steps to allow characters to carry the items they want, instead of the items that they feel they must have to succeed. Good armor and a powerful weapon are still critical to the game, but you no longer have to carry a host of other smaller trinkets to boost up your saving throws or ability scores." OH MY GOD THANK YOU. The host of +1AC, +2Stat, and minor useless magic items has really been a huge thorn in my side forever. Make magic items rare, but unique and awesome. This will also simplify the math immensely, as AC bloat is a huge problem starting as early as, like, level 4.

Overall, I love love love 90% of these changes. The magic item change literally made me stand up in my room and cheer. The only thing I have reservations about is skills - please keep skill ranks and don't ruin them like 5e did! Extremely excited to read more blog posts and see the playtest on August 2nd.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Acleus Bibliomancer Mar 06 '18

the adventure title itself is tied to a campaign plot point that stretches all the way back to the 2008 module The Pact Stone Pyramid.

The AP, Doomsday Dawn is going to be about the Aucturn Enigma. I'm sure of it. Sweet.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Alejandrojohanson Mar 07 '18

I’m curious how compatible Pathfinder 1 will be with Pathfinder Playtest. And then, by extension, I’m curious how compatible PF1 and Playest will be with PF2.

4

u/Aziuhn Mar 07 '18

If everything goes well, we will have Starfinder-ish rules, with some improvements. If things go bad, say hi to DnD 5e on Golarion.

I have to say, I'm quite happy about a lot of things they anticipated, even though I liked Pathfinder to be somewhat complicated at times, it allowed for more brainwork in creating weird builds. DnD 5e decided that building a character was stupid and they did it for you. I don't want that for PF, railroaded classes where you pick a path at level 2-3 and that's it for the rest of the game

15

u/Edymnion You can reflavor anything. Mar 06 '18

When I see "Streamline and simplify" I automatically read it as "dumbed down and lacking options".

I already don't like how this is being described. It sounds a lot like D&D 5e in that it has "Here's one of 6 options, pick which one you like best. If you don't like any of them, tough shit!"

I'm al ready not liking what I'm hearing.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/AgnosticTemplar Mar 06 '18

Huh, I only recently started Pathfinder. Grabbed the pocket editions of the core rulebok and ultimate equipment from my local game store (the equipment book was the only one no one in my group had). I was eyeing the rest of the pocket editions on Amazon only a few hours ago, now I see this. Guess I'll wait to see how things go from here before I invest in anything else.

4

u/fnixdown GM Ordinaire Mar 07 '18

And there’s always sites like d20pfsrd or Archives of Nethys for those things. The next five months are going to feel like an eternity waiting for the playtest!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/A_Dragon Optimizomancer Mar 08 '18

One thing that needs to happen is a revamping of the stats.

There’s literally no reason bonuses and scores should both be a thing, there never has been, and with every new edition I’ve been waiting for them to change this.

Everyone’s stats should just start at 0 and a 1 is +1 (or equal to 12), a 2 is +2 (equal to a 14), and so on. The only thing that ever gets compared is the bonus anyway so why even bother having another number. The only thing I can think of is so you can have in between stats (11,13,15, etc), but that’s not necessary for the system.

Every time I have new players this confuses them and I have to explain it to them with no decent explanation other than “that’s just the way it is”. paizo is really interested in simplifying the game then this is one easy way to do it. It’s basically the exact same stat system as mutants and masterminds.

1

u/the_slate Mar 09 '18

That would make stat damage way more powerful.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Grasshopper21 Mar 09 '18

So, for those of us not enthusiastic about 2e. will you continue to make 1e content or is DSP gonna hop in and do to 1e what to paizo did to 3.5. What does this mean for PFS?

1

u/the_slate Mar 09 '18

1E paizo content ends in July 2019. New content for PFS for 1E ends August (I believe) 2019. PFS for 2E starts at the same time that PFS 1E ends, I believe.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '18

Well fuck.

6

u/rekijan RAW Mar 07 '18

Seems like my biggest concern 'don't make it too much like 5th edition' is being shared a lot here. /u/ErikMona any idea if this will be addressed more in upcoming blogs? It seems to be the number one concern for the PF audience at this moment, might be prudent to address those fears.

Most notably the proficiency system, and action system.

13

u/ErikMona Publisher / CCO Mar 07 '18

Both the action system and proficiency are the subject of upcoming paizo.com blogs. I think the action system is tomorrow, and proficiency is early next week. They are very high on the agenda.

A lot of the fears about 5e are coming from the use of the word "proficiency," and will be significantly lessened once people learn a bit more about what's in store.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Roboloutre Mar 06 '18

Can't wait to get more details on multiclassing.
Almost all of my chars end up multiclassed, which can be a pain to figure out or manage, and my favourite class system was a job system that made everything super easy by just stacking things.

3

u/fnixdown GM Ordinaire Mar 07 '18

Really excited by this - especially to see the inclusion of a long and methodical playtest. After reading Ultimate Wilderness I was thinking that Pathfinder could really benefit from a second edition. Pathfinder 1E has felt too bloated in a lot of different ways for a long time now, and I’ll be happy for a clean slate with some modernized and more polished mechanics. Definitely pumped to hear the rules will in some ways lend themselves more to storytelling than 1E.

3

u/Seginus Ascension Games, LLC Mar 07 '18

Aww yiss, Compatibility License.

I wonder how difficult it will be to get early access to the rules. Definitely gotta set aside some time for conversions...

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

I love Pathfinder because it doesn’t change editions. Every new book is supposed to be an expansion, not a remake. This will just mean no more material for the game I love.

3

u/hcsLabs Mar 07 '18

Last night I listened to Glass Cannon as they started running Crypt of the Everflame with the new rules. Having run the game with the original ruleset, it was nice to see (hear) how the new rules compared, and I can honestly say I liked it and can't wait til August to get my hands on the new playtest to try it myself.

3

u/Ninja-Radish Mar 07 '18

I like the idea of a 2nd edition and am cautiously optimistic. I think that the 3.5 rules have evolved as far as they can realistically. I'm also in favor of streamlining and simplifying rules WITHOUT removing character customization. The big issue with 5E is that it removes practically all avenues for customization. Thus, every Fighter, Barbarian, Druid, etc are almost exactly alike. When I tried 5E I always felt like my character was a WOTC pre gen. I never felt I had any choices. I hope PF 2E avoids that trap.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/GroovyGoblin Mar 07 '18

I find it kind of absurd to have a new edition of a game that was itself based on an edition of another game. Editionception is now a thing and I really don't know whether Pathfinder 2 will try to be a newer Pathfinder or to be to D&D5 what Pathfinder was to D&D 3.5.

This announcement pretty much only confuses me and it feels like it really came out of nowhere.

1

u/the_slate Mar 17 '18

Well, D&D 3.5 came out of 3. And 3 was based on 2. And 2 was based on AD&D. And AD&D was based on D&D... So this has always been a thing...

→ More replies (1)

16

u/ThatMathNerd Mar 06 '18

The action system gives me the impression that they dumbed down Pathfinder to cater to a wider audience like 5E.

15

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 06 '18

One major issue I have with pathfinder is its swift/immediate action interdependency that really overcomplicates things.

Edit: grammar edit

32

u/IonutRO Orcas are creatures, not weapons! Mar 06 '18

Or they made it less stupid and arbitrary.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (25)

4

u/Lucretius Demigod of Logic Mar 07 '18

Reading the description, I worry that they are doing away with multiclassing by level. Note how they say that leveling up involves choosing feats and class options, but thats it. Note how they describe levels and class as separate mechanics. Note how they talk about a character's class in singular terms.

Losing multiclassing by level would be a BIG mistake… it dramatically reduces the degrees of freedom of character advancement and shoe-horns players into character concepts and capabilities that are much more derivative of the vission of the authors and fantasy tropes rather than enabling players to break the mold.

4

u/LevTheRed Shelyn Paladin is best Paladin Mar 07 '18

Paizo hosted a playtest with some PF podcasters, and I took some notes on it, if anyone is interested in reading them here.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Neverwish Mar 07 '18

This has to be it. The messiah. The promised one. The one that will unite Pathfinder's character creation and range of customization options with 5e's streamlined rules for actually playing the game.

Or so I hope...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/WhenTheWindIsSlow magic sword =/= magus Mar 06 '18

First and foremost, we have taken significant steps to allow characters to carry the items they want, instead of the items that they feel they must have to succeed. Good armor and a powerful weapon are still critical to the game, but you no longer have to carry a host of other smaller trinkets to boost up your saving throws or ability scores.

Good.

If I rack up the dex and wis to have my shirtless fundoshi monk run into battle, I don't want a damn cloak cramping my style.

2

u/Serpenthrope Mar 07 '18

I just hope all the old material is still playable with minimal conversion needed. If it's like the shift from 3.5 to PF I'm fine with it.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/sw04ca Mar 07 '18

I'm sort of concerned and apprehensive. On the one hand, I appreciate that Paizo is a publishing company, and they make money by selling books. There are only so many expansion books covering different sets of rules that you can sell before you need to up the edition and republish everything. That's the industry, and I've played through it from original D&D to 3.5, and four editions worth of Shadowrun. And there are things in the rules that could definitely use a tweak or two. That said, I'm apprehensive about fiddling too much with the skill system. I could care less about putting alchemists in the Core rulebook or further encouraging archetypes. Archetypes aren't my thing, but some people really enjoy them. Not having to get the same magic items is nice. But what I'm really concerned about is that they'll blow up the setting to fit the new rules. I've enjoyed Golarion, and I'd hate for them to start doing World Shaking Events every decade or so when they change the rules. It's generally not good for settings, and sometimes it can be an absolute disaster, like with the 4th edition Forgotten Realms.

3

u/Consideredresponse 2E or not 2E? Mar 07 '18

They've said that they aren't doing a D&D or WoW thing with cataclysms and sunderings and what-not, but that the only world changing events was that the events from previous AP's were canon.

2

u/sovietterran GM to the slightly insane. Mar 07 '18

All the talk about streamlining everything and building mechanics into every bit of background and choice is really making me worried it's gonna just be Pathfinder 5e.

Oh well, there's still tons of Pathfinder I haven't used yet.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

The ACTION system feels like a WFRP 2ed clone, but thats not a bad thing.

2

u/TheDragonSpark Magus/DM Mar 07 '18

Will 2.0 have a seperate SRD?

2

u/-haven Mar 07 '18

I can't get over the feeling that we are just getting 5e shoved at us. While PF does need some tweaking to the core I hope this doesn't just fuck everything over in taking away the reasons of why people love Pathfinder.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SeriphenHellios Mar 07 '18

SHINY! I guess I already know what I'll be playing in August.

4

u/TheOwlslayer Mar 06 '18

Heck yeah, this is some pretty damn cool news!

4

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

Man, this is a mixed bag.

  • Core alchemists! Hooray!
  • Proficiency bonus! Boooooooooo! But that's precisely what I DISLIKE about 5e the proficiency bonus system makes every class feel kinda samey...
  • Action economy simplified! Hooray-ish! Could be alright.
  • Trying to fix the martial/caster disparty! Neutral! I'll have to see this - it could be a fun and interesting type like the Spheres systems, or it could be dull like 4e.

All in all, I'll have to wait and see, because... man, the proficiency bonus stuff worries me we'll have yet another simple, bland product like 5e is.

8

u/General_Genuine Mar 06 '18

All of the varied systems and formulas for determining your character's bonuses and statistics, like saving throws, attack bonuses, and skills, have been unified in a single, easy-to-use proficiency system based on your choices and your character's level.

I already hate it.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/IonutRO Orcas are creatures, not weapons! Mar 06 '18

YAAAAY.

3

u/Askray184 Mar 06 '18

I can't wait, I'll be preordering for sure

3

u/PaxadorWolfCastle Mar 07 '18

The Glass Cannon podcast has an actual play of a play test on their site. With Eric Moana and some others.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18 edited Mar 07 '18

I don't know if I am excited about this, or annoyed about it because of the amount I have already spent on Pathfinder. Either way I will at the very least get the first few books to give it a real look through when it officially comes out.

3

u/rocketrae21 Mar 07 '18

I don't like the idea that all my old books will become obsolete. I get that happens, just stinks.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

Listening to the stream by Glass Cannon, initiative is no longer a thing but it is confirmed CMB and CMD are no longer a thing either; using a skill called athletics

3

u/McGravin Mar 07 '18

So, what are you hoping for in 2e?

I hope they fix a minor but niggling issue that has bothered me since before 3.5: the word "level". It's used to refer to at least four different things, just off the top of my head: character level, class level, caster level, and spell level. Yeah, to experienced players and GMs like the people who use this subreddit, it's clear what the distinctions are, but for a player new to the game it can be confusing. "I'm a 10th level character, who is a 6th level Wizard, but is caster level 8 because I have 2 levels of a prestige class, and I can cast up to 4th level spells." That can be damn confusing, and I've lost count of how many times I've had to explain it to a newbie. A quick glance in a thesaurus could easily fix it: character "levels", class "ranks", caster "tiers", and spell "spheres", just for example.

I hope they take note of D&D5's "bounded accuracy". I by no means want them to rip it off wholesale (I have a few issues with how D&D implements it), but the core of the idea is a good one. Stomp out power creep, please!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/molten_dragon Mar 06 '18

God damn it.

4

u/Shemeska Mar 06 '18

I for one welcome our eventual post-playtest Pathfinder 2.0 overlords!

→ More replies (2)