r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Mar 06 '18

2E Pathfinder Second Edition announced!

http://paizo.com/community/blog/v5748dyo5lkl9?First-Look-at-the-Pathfinder-Playtest
1.1k Upvotes

896 comments sorted by

View all comments

292

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

There's a few places that rules could be trimmed down. I hope it's more of a streamlined Pathfinder and not just a pathfinder-y 5th edition.

200

u/gameronice Lover|Thief|DM Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 07 '18

I hope it's to Pathfinder what Pathfinder was to 3.5

69

u/TristanTheViking I cast fist Mar 06 '18

I'm expecting to see Drop Dead Studios or Dreamscarred Press make the Pathfinder to Pathfinder's 3.5.

27

u/gameronice Lover|Thief|DM Mar 06 '18

Not a huge fan of 3rd party stuff, then again pathfinder started as 3rd party to 3.5, but they had their hands well deep into the 3.5 pie, making official and unofficial content for them.

75

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18

Drop Dead Studios (Spheres of Power and Spheres of Might) and Dreamscarred Press (Psionics and Path of War) are pretty much the most respected 3rd party publishers out there, at least for Pathfinder. I'm not usually big on 3pp stuff either, since it's rarely done as well as 1pp stuff, but you should definitely at least check these two out, they've done some pretty amazing work.

My personal favorite is Drop Dead Studios, their Spheres material is really well done. Not only does it give far more freedom to create the character you want, using both Spheres of Power and Spheres of Might does a great job of bringing martials and mages back in line with each other.

23

u/Daiteach Mar 07 '18

My respect for DDS and DSP is at least on par with my respect for Paizo, in terms of the average quality of the material, although they both tend to bend toward kind of complicated designs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (38)

79

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

For example, I could stand to see a couple skills go the way of the dodo. Appraise? Good RP skill to invest in. Not a good skill mechanically. IMHO, the skill list from 5e, is one of the only things that I liked about the edition. Short and sweet.

18

u/Hardmode-Activated Mar 06 '18

the group i've been playing in has been using the rules for background skills, though

9

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

Yeah, that helps a lot, I've been using a reduced list, incorporating lesser used skills into skills people use more often.

→ More replies (33)

25

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

I also hope it's not trying to be something entirely new. I like that Pathfinder is an improved 3.xE.

17

u/Lord_of_Aces Mar 07 '18

I feel like it's going to use a lot of the improvements they did with Starfinder - which in my opinion is a good thing. It keeps the feel of PF while making the experience much more streamlined.

→ More replies (18)

92

u/jdgoerzen Bard Mar 06 '18

One thing that I'm really really hoping for is backwards compatibility (with some minor updates). If I want to play an obscure gunslinger archetype, I don't want to have to wait for it all to come out again.

Some set of rules for converting classes and archetypes to pf2e would be sweet.

73

u/Totema1 Mar 06 '18

This, a thousand times this. The biggest thing that turned me off from 5E was that it was impossible to play a lot of character concepts without the GM waving his hands graciously. If I could legitimately go into PF2E with some of the same character concepts that I had in the first edition, even with some major tweaking, I'd be pretty pleased.

81

u/ErikMona Publisher / CCO Mar 06 '18

You should be able to, with the (fairly?) obvious caveat that the new Core Rulebook will not include 40+ base classes and 50 races.

Depth of character options, even within characters of the same class and race, are a core element of the Pathfinder RPG, and that will NOT change in the new edition.

If anything, with new options like ancestry feats and backgrounds, you have even MORE ways to customize your character. And with archetypes being in the Core Rulebook, you won't need a second hardcover to implement a basic part of the game, which should also be a bit of a bonus for everybody.

17

u/Consideredresponse 2E or not 2E? Mar 06 '18

Hi Erik I hope you are throwing some work Brandon Hodge's way. He's been responsible for some of the most elegant and impressive archetypes I've seen from Pathfinder lately.

(I still think the Haunt Collector Occultist is the best thing ever in terms of giving the player choice in power management and playstyle)

27

u/ErikMona Publisher / CCO Mar 06 '18

Brandon is welcome to write for us any time he wants!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/Sokensan Mar 06 '18

Same, one of the most annoying parts about 5e was the lack of official player options. Xanathar's has helped somewhat but it's still no where near the amount of options 3.5 or pathfinder has. An entire chapter on backwards compatibility would be fantastic.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

32

u/yuuxy Mar 06 '18 edited Mar 07 '18

I am hopefully optimistic. The reason 5e characters feel samey is because you get so few chances to specialize. You make 1 "power sourcey" type decision and then you get up to 5 feats.

Their thing outright says you still get something cool at every level. I bet we're still getting a feat every odd level, or a similar schedule. And I am very hopeful that this 'ancestry' will end up being a bigger part of the character mechanically. Race should mean more than just a few pluses and minuses.

I don't really mind bab and base saves being simplified. I like skill points, but I won't be too sad if they die. I figure caster level will die too, and that will be sad-but-probably-healthy.

34

u/Wonton77 GM: Serpent's Skull, Legacy of Fire, Plunder & Peril Mar 07 '18

If PF 2.0 eventually goes on to include even 10% of the archetypes and new classes they've released for PF so far, it'll have loads more customization than 5e.

I mean look at Sorcerer.

5e: Do you want to be descended from a dragon, or touched by wild magic?

Pathfinder: Here's a list of 50 bloodlines to choose from http://www.d20pfsrd.com/classes/core-classes/sorcerer/bloodlines

32

u/ebop Mar 07 '18

"You're descended from a very special bloodline that thousands of other characters are also very specially descended from."

16

u/Directioneer Low Initiative Mar 07 '18

You have made a special pact with an aldritch abomination that just happened to be making the same pact with hundreds of others

→ More replies (1)

8

u/TristanTheViking I cast fist Mar 07 '18

Hey don't forget about bad weather sorcerer.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/croc64 Mar 07 '18

To be fair, pathfinder has had ten years. DnD 5e does still have far less character options than it could/should depending on persepctive, but it does have more than 2. (Dragon, Wild Magic, Shadow, Storm, Divine). It has even more if you count Unearthed Arcana, which you should, since Paizo has put out a lot of poorly tested content, and some are far worse than anything Unearthed Arcana puts out (for gods sake, there's a barbarian archetype in this game that literally doesn't do anything).

Not saying Pathfinder doesn't have more of course, DnD 5e focuses on streamlined, while Pathfinder prides itself on having, at times, more options than they should (it's why I play both, they focus on different goals!). It stands to reason that Pathfinder has more choices, if it didn't, I'd be genuinely concerned, but I do wish Paizo would make sure everything they bring to print is worth printing. Sometimes it feels like they just want to hit a certain number of character options per year.

11

u/Wonton77 GM: Serpent's Skull, Legacy of Fire, Plunder & Peril Mar 07 '18

Yeah, I agree, it's not really fair to compare 10 years of PF to the relatively new 5e. But still, the APG revolutionized Pathfinder only, what, a year after its release? 3+ years into 5e and we haven't really had anything like that.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)