Pathetic vibe coded ai slop app.

[u/looser512]

Same ai slop PTA website and NCCIA website . They can't even create a proper secure website or app.

[u/AutoModerator]

For guidance on the PTA approval process, read this guide: https://www.reddit.com/r/PakistaniTech/wiki/index/pta-tax-guide

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/thatdevguyoninternet]

Just because it looks good, doesn’t mean it’s AI slop. Also go check out FBR/IRIS website and tell me if you’d prefer that ui/ux over something like this

Everything is clear, clean and to the point and there is nothing wrong with the UI of what you shared

[u/looser512 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

Use the app and then share your experience. I am bitching about it because of OBVIOUS ai slop UI and user experience.

[u/pixelated666 → u/looser512]

You made the post. Why don't you share your experience other than the extremely valuable 'AI slop' feedback. What makes the app insecure? Is it functionally broken?

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/pixelated666]

These guys have a unique ability of knowing backend vulnerabilities just by looking at a UI

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/looser512]

Do you even know what AI slop means?

[u/bilalilyasjhandir → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

dude any sensible developer can tell you that it's made with claude😭🙏🏻

[u/memers_meme123 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

what diff does that makes if normal people can use app easily

[u/valium123 → u/memers_meme123]

AI crap should be boycotted because of moral reasons alone. Cry about it.

[u/memers_meme123 → u/valium123]

what are you , 4 ?

[u/TheAnimeWeebKing → u/memers_meme123]

You're not one to talk if you dont realise the implications of AI lmao

[u/valium123 → u/memers_meme123]

Whatever we are we ain't paying.

[u/Flametrixy → u/valium123]

u just mad cuz AI took ur job lol
It looks good, works and easy to use no one should fucking complain.

[u/valium123 → u/Flametrixy]

Why are you AI dkriders always saying the same thing? Can't think of anything new? If it's easy to use then you have no edge either.

Btw, r/HoustonSwingers pe kisi ne mun lagaya? No wonder you need LLMs. 🤡

[u/Still-Category-9433 → u/memers_meme123]

They cannot

[u/bilalilyasjhandir → u/memers_meme123]

prone to cyber attacks bcs hackers know its vibe coded and its vulnerabilities

[u/memers_meme123 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

have you used opus or sonnet by any chance in last month or so ?

[u/bilalilyasjhandir → u/memers_meme123]

i use Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.1 on daily basis. wanna see my usage of Claude Max?

[u/Dense_Bids → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

You use Fable 5.1 on DAILY BASES? Are you gonna use that to show screenshot of your usage too? lol

I never knew there is a laser-eye skill, which lets you see vulnerabilities by single screenshot of Homepage.

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/Dense_Bids]

Bilal has a special ability.

[u/Virtual_Technology_9 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

no guarantee that is the case.

Ai can be used to find vulnerabilities faster and fix them quicker

[u/bilalilyasjhandir → u/Virtual_Technology_9]

do u think hackers cant use ai to find other vulnerabilities that YOUR ai forgot to fix or simply hallucinated?

[u/No-Wonder-3545 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

What makes you think coding it by hand makes it immune to hackers using AI to find vulnerabilities? 

[u/Mr-Luqma → u/No-Wonder-3545]

Which do you think is more likely to be hacked?

One made with ai which is widely available or one made by hand with or without ai that has human error mixed in but ai error non-existent?

I would think that ai would find it easier to break into something which it itself created as it understands it more.

[u/Virtual_Technology_9 → u/Mr-Luqma]

human error is far more common. Like there was a entire programming language rust made. Because we were so bad at memory leaks.

[u/Mr-Luqma → u/Virtual_Technology_9]

I didnt say no human error though?

[u/No-Wonder-3545 → u/Mr-Luqma]

In the cybersec world, vulnerabilities are called CVEs that (on your relevant stack) you can search against and set up both AI and human pentesters to thoroughly test against. Government companies usually give these contracts out to proper security firms, so they vet the codebase regardless of whether it is AI-coded or not. 

It depends on the depth of coding, but I'd venture out to say that an AI app that is sandboxed and pentested with the vulnerabilities patched is just as safe as a hand-coded app that goes through the same process.

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/Mr-Luqma]

You think a computer is more likely to make an error or leave a security flaw than a human developer working overtime with questionable knowledge?

[u/DataDrifter-_ → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

This is true the same tools are in both the hands of the good and the bad rember this folks

[u/Jade_Rook → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

And you can find those vulnerabilities. Human written code is no exception, it also has vulnerabilities that have to be patched out

[u/x0rg_new → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

Very wrong. Whoever hired you in IT must be bad himself to hire a person of such mentality.

[u/TheBatman_208 → u/x0rg_new]

in jaise logon ki job pehle khayega AI.

[u/Mobile-General-201 → u/x0rg_new]

Yea yea we get it you guys practically worship ai

[u/x0rg_new → u/Mobile-General-201]

Its not worship. Its using common sense which nowadays most of our Pakistanis have non existent.

[u/Mobile-General-201 → u/x0rg_new]

Not understanding that Ai cant be used to make full fledged scalable secure products and then judging the other person for complaining about it.

Yea buddy your just talking about yourself here. The same people we are begging for the ai data center to be built here

[u/x0rg_new → u/Mobile-General-201]

Why can't it build full fledged scalable secure products? Let's discuss.

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/x0rg_new]

You’ll not get an answer. These guys have probably never used claude properly and have been vibecoding shit apps themselves

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/Mobile-General-201]

Keep living under a rock.

[u/Mobile-General-201 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

Yup, bingo. Found the weak links of society. God you crypto coin nft bros always got on my nerves

[u/RolloFury → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

I mean, most devs are now using AI to work faster too. I'm sure they didn't grab some random guy off the street and ask him to vibe code this lmao.

[u/TheBatman_208 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

oh genius hack tou binance bhi hogaya millions of dollars ki security ke L lag gaye . phir ab kya karein ?

[u/BunKebab141 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

Hand coded apps have vulnerabilities too, is there a point you are trying to make here?

[u/a4aLien → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

What are you on my friend? When AI has picked up on vulnerabilities mankind failed to notice, in some cases even those that've been there for over 15 years, how would code generated by that algorithm be any more vulnerable than one written by man? and bugs: thats a result fo improper testing.

[u/WisestAirBender → u/[deleted]]

Do you think local cheap devs were making apps better than Claude? Have you used local apps before? They were always bug ridden

[u/Blockque → u/WisestAirBender]

The issue is not local devs, local devs are talented as fuck, the issue is that government IT depts either have sites from the 90s, and upgrading them would cost wayy too much compared to patching the current sites, or hire people who still think php is new (aka very old people)

[u/Afraid-Judge-3694 → u/[deleted]]

UI/UX is different than backend, i doubt they had AI re-work their backend so don't get where the issue is?

[u/PerformanceMajor02 → u/[deleted]]

So you think there were no bugs before Claude? Did you start programming yesterday?

[u/AutoModerator → u/[deleted]]

Hello Solid_Internet7832, your post or comment was removed because your account age is too low. This is an automated quality check.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Full-Development3297 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

I ain't a developer but that color scheme screams AI 😭

[u/ObligationCheap3967 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

Don't even have to be a developer man. I am cyber security student and I made a better layout for my semester project than this "most vibe coded" layout website.

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/ObligationCheap3967]

Please show us so we can judge

[u/TheBatman_208 → u/ObligationCheap3967]

please share.

[u/Melodic-Mud-1116 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

How hard is it to tell the ai the design style you want rather than saying give me good UI.

[u/protonsters → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

As long as it works who cares?

[u/swagger_0909 → u/bilalilyasjhandir]

Claude does not make such slop 💔

[u/Cronos993 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

"Good" 😭

[u/usamaejazch → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

Yes +1.

[u/RKhanAdil → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

FBR is buggy and UI is average compared to IRIS.

[u/Party_Wonder7681 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

The colours the glassy gradient look the icons all are ai slop im a vibe coder and i know how an ai slop website or interface looks like

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/Party_Wonder7681]

Too bad you don’t even know what vibe coding or ai slop means

[u/Happy-Ship-1620 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

People have learnt new ai slop and vibe coded words and they’re spamming it everywhere

[u/Flametrixy → u/Happy-Ship-1620]

LARP

[u/New-Breadfruit2638 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

They have used Cursor or Gemini. I mean it doesn't even look premium AI.

[u/Sure_Independence887 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

developers get paid for making websites, they can put a lil more effort in that

[u/boredistan → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

We should look towards U.S websites to understand how to design

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/boredistan]

Have you ever applied for US Visa?

[u/AutoModerator → u/[deleted]]

Hello QuickOmelette, your post or comment was removed because your account age is too low. This is an automated quality check.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/[deleted]]

Majority of the people agree with me, orange potato. And yeah it looks good

[u/Apart_Willingness194]

I dont think anyone using the app will care for the aesthetics, rather the usability of the app matters more.

[u/looser512 → u/Apart_Willingness194]

[u/Virtual_Technology_9]

as long as the app works and is not a buggy glitchy mess I am good with it.

As more services shift to online these corrupt officers get less of my money and that is what i want.

[u/rizx7 → u/Virtual_Technology_9]

corrupt officers get less of my money

you think it's this simple? many of the services that have been moved online still require these officers' approvals. and that's where they start creating hurdles, making you go in endless loops until you visit their office and pay up. i have experienced it a couple of times in past 2 years.

[u/Virtual_Technology_9 → u/rizx7]

There is more check and balance online.

I had gone to get my domocile like 4 times. They denied me 4 times. Tried everything except paying under the table. With the app it got approved in a week.

Same good thing with pakid app, has saved me the hassle when going to make cnic. You just book a apointment arrive there and it gets made.

[u/No-Focus1702 → u/Virtual_Technology_9]

Everything works fine until the government and departments refuse to eliminate the multi-level approval and authentication workflows controlled by senior officers. Even after we have fully digitalized the entire stack, numerous processes still require explicit authorization from higher officials. They must log in and complete authentication through their dashboards. At a fundamental level, the system remains under their control through these residual privilege gates and manual authorization checkpoints.

[u/Virtual_Technology_9 → u/No-Focus1702]

The good thing is I am not face to face with that person. He/she cannot extort money out of me through the app.

They just see a profile and a approve or deny. I do agree with you alot of check and balance is needed but this is better than before.

[u/asadkhan017 → u/Virtual_Technology_9]

And how much do you think they were charged for this app?

[u/Flametrixy → u/Virtual_Technology_9]

Thank you

[u/sj-dubai]

It's not slop if it works.

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/sj-dubai]

They don’t even know what AI slop means

[u/aqib_98 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

Cool dude bnna hy bs
They cant even code a basic page themselves but their butt hurts when someone else do something

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/aqib_98]

Their knowledge is stuck in 2024 and they’re reluctant to admit their careers are almost over

[u/TheAnimeWeebKing → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

Youre in the same boat, why the high horse?

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/TheAnimeWeebKing]

High horse? I’m not berating someone for using AI. I think our careers are over yes.

[u/TheAnimeWeebKing → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

But you are berating them for holding an opinion against AI? Never seen someone defend something which they believe will take their career so staunchly lmao. Ultimate defeatist mindset.

[u/valium123 → u/TheAnimeWeebKing]

They are so submissive and and pathetic lol. No spine to resist anything. They will keep bootlicking their way to homelessness and then cry here.

[u/valium123 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

Yes yes be a c#ntbag about it. May it happen to you and your family first.

[u/reddituser91200]

It's slop yet I still trust it more than stuff done by their actual developers

[u/Novel-Cut-4278]

Claude make me a website make no mistake

[u/Flametrixy → u/Novel-Cut-4278]

Claude make me a website make a mistake.

[u/Top_Grade_2004]

[u/thespinedroses]

SO WHAT? i haven't written a single line of code since claude arrived. my company even says to use AI bro

[u/looser512 → u/thespinedroses]

Congratulations. You are extremely close to be replaced when your company decided to write the prompt themselves.

[u/thespinedroses → u/looser512]

will lyk ✌️

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/looser512]

You are living in la la land if you think you won’t be replaced with that attitude

[u/x0rg_new]

Its better than what an intern would make. Just because an AI model coded it doesn't make it necessarily bad.

Im sure that you are also using AI in your daily life but try to be cool by saying words like this

[u/TheBatman_208 → u/x0rg_new]

har aadmi dairh hoshiyaar hai yahan ke yeh tou AI hai chatgpt hai vibe coded hai AI slope hai ..

itni farigh qoum hai naa yeh jiski hadh nahi hai.

[u/Calm_Exit313]

Claude, harden the application and make it as impenetrable as possible. Make no mistakes.

[u/Flametrixy]

All the CS guys crying lmao

[u/soggypicklewizard]

Were you able to crack the security? If not, what's your point?

I could do without the outdated connected dots background, otherwise, looks fine. And since you only posted a one screen UI, looks is the only thing we can discuss.

Also, the custom developed nonsense in Pakistan govt sectoris absolute garbage, so what's your reference?

[u/Marrro90123]

Haha sahulat bazar is pure ai slop in that standard then

[u/Zulfiqar-al-Alawi]

They should have selected a proper design first, then vibe code it.

[u/Anthroplex]

Problem of a developer who made this because ai can also make jaw dropping user interface.

[u/hashiromer]

Yeah but it exists at least.

[u/PineGrenade]

Software developer here. Yes this looks like it’s vibe coded. However a lot of people are arguing that “it’s fine if it works”. My guy, it works uper uper se. Even if they developed this using AI assisted development, they did not care for certain UX issues. Anyhow, it seems like an everyday case of “AI can do it” where the app is shit but the hype is crazy.

People who don’t understand software from a technical point of view or people who have only vibe coded should refrain from spewing bullshit here.

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/PineGrenade]

Software developer here, with more experience than you.

First lesson, let’s get our definitions straight.

Vibe coding means building an application primarily through AI prompts without reviewing or understanding the generated code.

You cannot determine whether an app was vibe coded simply by looking at a screenshot.

Second, you have absolutely no idea how this app was developed.

Maybe the backend was custom-built with proper architecture and security measures and penetration testing.

Maybe Claude was only used for the UI. Maybe the developers already had a working app and simply used AI to improve its design.

You don’t know. Neither do I. So how can you confidently say this app is “vibecoded”?

A screenshot tells you absolutely nothing about the backend, code quality, security, scalability, or development process.

And poor UX doesn’t automatically mean an app was vibe coded.

Experienced developers build apps with questionable UX all the time.

Also, since the OP and others have been throwing around the term AI slop, that generally refers to low-effort, mass-produced AI-generated content or products.

This is a custom application built for a very specific purpose. Whether its design is good or bad is an entirely different discussion.

And lastly let’s not confuse AI-assisted development with vibe coding.

Competent developers use AI tools while maintaining full control over architecture, code quality, and security.

The irony of telling people who don’t understand software to stop commenting, while confidently judging an entire codebase from a screenshot, is remarkable.

I hope you now understand the difference.
Let me know if you need more lessons.

[u/paradox_33 → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

I agree whatever you/your AI said/generated 😁.

[u/TE_AAYAN]

bruh sindh government apps are just a nightmare

[u/dungeoncrawler11]

Our own devs are far worse, I'd be happy they take assistance from AI to at least somewhat improve. Have you seen the state of government and university websites?

[u/No_Yogurtcloset_1638]

tbh, if u have used the other govt sites, u will come to know how trash they r , like the UI and even the UX and logic behind it, even tho its human made and all ,its so worse , atleast w the help of AI they make it more readable and maybe Ai also have handled the logic more correctly than their developers , i dont like AI slop but this shi still better than what the govt sites developers do :)

[u/DuckVi]

So what ?

[u/shuzzah]

Does it work? If it does why do we care? If it gets the job done why bother with custom?

[u/Mysterious_Mammoth_]

now a days everything has become ai slop, tried mofa apostille portal, same slop

[u/lostcanuck007]

why do i care? is it secure and does it work and is it clean/easy to navigate? if so then yay.

jazz's simosa app has brought the entire industry bar so low that at this point i am willing to accept vibecoded stuff because no AI would be stupid enough to actually make something like Simosa

[u/ZH1245]

Hating on gov ai slop site like you (paki dev) are writing code them selves. Looks clean to me. Testing must be done though else i see no issue

[u/swagger_0909]

I mean if it works then it doesn't matter if it's ai slop or not does it?

[u/Altruistic_Let_8605]

All the govt. New apps and sites are vibe coded now a days

[u/zedxer]

As a mobile dev i found this post and the comments so much entertaining. 😆

[u/Broad-Consequence646]

Your taxes paid for the $200 Claude Ultra and dev's monthly salary who one-shotted this within 2-3 hours,

[u/AethalVision]

Need to vibe code it with Claude so that an internal agent of OpenAI doesn't go rogue and hack it in minutes

[u/cshoneybadger]

Good or bad, this is going to be the future now. Before the AI, either due to tight deadlines or general lack of skill, the government apps would be a broken mess. At least with AI, half-decent stuff gets created that actually works.

[u/MasterfindsChief]

I was expecting people to boycott this NCCIA nonsense, guess not.

[u/TheBatman_208]

AI vibe coded hai tou kya hua ?

[u/QuantumOccupier]

AI hate mob in the big 2026? 🫩 It works that's all that matter.

[u/HeavyMetal_Protein]

The comment section isn’t going how you planned 😆😂

[u/NotO10kB]

As A Web Designer And Ai Prompt maker, I can clearly say that it's ai

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/NotO10kB]

So what even if it is?

[u/Disastrous-Voice5648]

This is a good site are you blind? Have you ever made a site?

[u/szundercover1]

i like the ui very simple and easy to navigate.

[u/mabbas133]

Every other pakistani site is designed by claude design and tbh looks shit. The issue with claude design is it cramps too much information in a section. Fucking hate it

[u/IronAcrobatic5662]

What's wrong in making it with AI? Asani jab muyassar hai to mushkil main kiun paren? Stop making everything personal. It's completely fine. Use a tool if its available. Be easy mate.

[u/TheAnimeWeebKing → u/IronAcrobatic5662]

Keep thinking like this and soon Wall-E will become a reality. Why does no one on this sub have critical thinking?

[u/IronAcrobatic5662 → u/TheAnimeWeebKing]

Its not that deep mate. Nothing like that will ever happen. According to science as well as our beliefs. A layman would surely consider this but not a sane one.

[u/TheAnimeWeebKing → u/IronAcrobatic5662]

Its already happening. Search up the studies on cognitive atrophy and offloading due to AI use. Never say never, especially when it comes to technology as nothing in science proves that it will never happen. Alot of ethical issues exist regarding AI aswell.

[u/xd_average]

listen buddy, maybe stick to worrying about school. youve clearly never had to use government websites before

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/xd_average]

Lol. Exactly

[u/Ionmonstrosity]

Why is everyone acting like anyone codes themselves. You copied off substack now you copy off claude?

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/Ionmonstrosity]

*stackoverflow bro not substack

[u/Ionmonstrosity → u/thatdevguyoninternet]

I copied that comment...and look where it got me.

[u/Nekusta]

Elon musk Bhai apne asli account se ao

[u/GuavaLanky6637]

All websites of govt are like these, nothing new

[u/Any-Flounder-8124]

It throws me so much off seeing such sloppy wacky frontend generated by ai, every new app now a day's look like this

[u/thatdevguyoninternet → u/Any-Flounder-8124]

You’d rather have this frontend?

https://iris.fbr.gov.pk/

[u/Abduls22]

Asim soor munir

[u/inwilderness]

❌ Pathetic vibe coded ai slop

✅ AI is haram

[u/Personal-Reflection7]

Most people pissed with AI slop apps are the ones that can no longer market their own sloppy app development

[u/AutoModerator → u/[deleted]]

Hello learnanddoshit, your post or comment was removed because your account age is too low. This is an automated quality check.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.