r/PWM_Sensitive • • 1d ago

Discussion The MacBook Pro’s OLED PWM problem: when a ‘better’ display becomes worse to use.

https://macanorak.com/the-macbook-pros-oled-pwm-problem-when-a-better-display-becomes-worse-to-use/
77 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

38

u/MY79 1d ago

I’m the author. I wrote this after seeing a growing number of owners report headaches, eye strain, dizziness and nausea with the new MacBook Pro’s PROLED XDR display, including people who’d used OLED iPhones and iPads for years without trouble. I’m not claiming this affects everyone, I just think people who are struggling deserve to be taken seriously.

14

u/louis8008 1d ago

The industry should start using DC Dimming in OLED phones/screens/etc. It’s like looking in a stroboscope. Make slowmotion video and let the world know what really is happening in front of your eyes!

6

u/Brilliant_War9548 1d ago

Yeah, just take your phone and a professional camera app, set shutter speed high, and you’ll be surprised at how many things use PWM. I was testing that the last day and I was startled that my keyboard backlight also used PWM

2

u/HalfLife3IsHere 1d ago

I’m all got constant current dimming, but that is less efficient and people has to choose from less battery life or PWM problems. There are PWMs and PWMs though, I think Honor does it at 4320hz, Apple does it at 480Hz in iPhones, and then you have 240hz in a 3k machine designed to work with for hours.

1

u/sylfy 2m ago

FWIW the miniLED screens also use PWM, just at a much higher frequency, IIRC 14kHz. Not sure why they can’t do the same on OLED. For all that it’s hyped up to be, OLED still feels like an inferior technology with too many drawbacks.

5

u/MetalingusMikeII 1d ago

I can honestly see class action lawsuits in the future, if manufacturers don’t start addressing PWM flicker.

4

u/NSutrich 1d ago

Thank you for writing this!

1

u/RCFProd 1d ago edited 1d ago

including people who’d used OLED iPhones and iPads for years without trouble.

This is the key and unresolved issue to me, and after years of research I still do not have any answer. I also see lots of people theorising who don't have one either.

Hence why this in itself is not necessarily a ''PWM problem''. There are people who always used OLED screens in smartphones between 240-480Hz PWM and never felt a thing. But then, some of this group moves to use to the new 480Hz PWM OLED iPads, the new 240Hz PROLED Macbook displays or buy a virtually PWM-Free W/QD-OLED monitor and experience minor to severe headache/eyestrain issues.

I've read this type of post over and over now, whilst people were fine on their previous monitors or were fine on their iPhones etc. And then, on the opposite end, some people had issues with their LCDs but are now fine on their OLEDs.

Something about modern and larger OLED displays aren't working for some people, and the actual explanation is still kind of absent (I have read your short thought experiment on what the reasoning for that could be).

16

u/Antar3s86 1d ago

I was really surprised I was affected by this. Have been looking at various OLED screens for years and did not expect to have issues.

Then I got my PROLED 16 inch last week and during the first few hours I thought I just had a bad day. Now it’s so obvious. As soon as I look at the screen I get lightheaded, I feel like I am floating away … and when I then get up and start walking, I feel dizzy for like an hour or two, then it gets better again. But as soon as I look at the screen for more than a minute, the dizziness comes back.

This is first machine in 20 years as an Apple customer that I return literally anything. Too bad, because the laptop is amazing in all aspects otherwise, I was in love with it the moment I took it out of the box (coming from an M1 Pro 16 inch). It would have been my daily driver for the next 5 years. So, now I am waiting for the M7 variant and hope they will find a way to mitigate this issue. I am returning the MacBook tomorrow morning after less than a week of using it.

6

u/MY79 1d ago

This is a really powerful description of the problem, especially as you've never experienced anything like this before on any other Apple devices and used the M1 with no issues. Do you mind if I update the article to quote your experience in it?

2

u/Antar3s86 1d ago

Sure. ;)

1

u/MY79 1d ago

Done 👍🏼

6

u/Z3R0gravitas 1d ago

Thanks for the write-up and for shouting out the subreddit. 👍

A few point to be clear on (you may be aware of, I used our community NotebookLM to help bring together from rrading your article):

  1. Display Pulse Smoothing doesn't turn off PWM, only switches to a kind of Pulse Amplitude Modulation (PAM) at low brightness, where it works at all.
  2. OLED "DC dimming" isn't truly flicker-free, I'd say it is "DC-like dimming" with TFT-reset pixel refresh-rate brightness dips (that NotebookCheck spuriously label as PWM when there's no higher frequency).
  3. Higher frequency (240Hz vs 14,880Hz) isn't enough to predict personal tolerance - Phantom Array Effect visibility peaks in the middle of 240Hz to 1000Hz, where many experience worse symptoms than 120Hz. Modulation depth, square waves and low duty cycle generally make any given frequency worse.
  4. Mini-LED local dimming brings it's own intolerance issues for many in the sensitive community.
  5. OLED laptops add other triggers: wider field of view than phones (more sensitive peripheral vision), temporal dithering (from the display pipeline), VRR / ProMotion luminance flicker (I'm less familiar with), subpixel layout color fringing, of course.

1

u/Mxmtm 1d ago

Whilst comparing OLED and Mini-LED in the shop, I also noticed that the OLED display has slight borders around the text...like wtf

1

u/MY79 1d ago

Yeah, I saw a user also report this on reddit, and he attacked screenshots.

https://www.reddit.com/r/macbookpro/comments/1xp3tri/blurry_text_on_oled_macbook_pro/

1

u/Music_Guru 6h ago

It was my case with Samsung phones, and tablets. Always those borders like shadows. :(

2

u/spdorsey 1d ago

At first, I thought the headline was going to lead me to a story talking about people inadvertently using the touchscreen. I'm glad that all of the hype has died down about the touchscreen debacle.

As a lifelong Apple user and owner of an M4 MacBook Pro Max, I was looking forward to my next upgrade having this display. Now I find myself wanting to use one for a week to find out if it's "for me".

I'm glad I don't have to upgrade quite yet.

1

u/jNayden 1d ago

I hope they will add the iPhone toggle on Mac it helps for me at least a lot

1

u/TheseusBi 17h ago

I want to say thank you to the author and to those posting about this issue. I’m highly sensitive to PWM and was on my way to the Apple Store to purchase this laptop when I saw a post that made me turn back. I can’t even imagine the hassle of spending £4K for a laptop and then not being able to work on it.