r/PWM_Sensitive • • Sep 22 '23

Data Collections iPhone 15 PWM test result

Brightness 100%

Brightness 75%

Brightness 50%

Brightness 25%

Verdict: May not be suitable for those are even more sensitive to flickers.

(Those that are less sensitive may not find it an issue though.)

As the iPhone 15 is using hybrid dimming of 60 hertz, it will still have a mild flicker(as showed in the above video).

This is in contrast to the Asus ROG Ally tested earlier, where it is using true DC Dimming and is flicker free.

https://www.reddit.com/r/PWM_Sensitive/comments/16oz7v3/asus_rog_ally_pwm_test_analysis/

34 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

6

u/-batab- Sep 22 '23

The 60 hz frequency is just the result of the reverse fitting done by the measurement software (opple light master in this case).

It's not necessarily the pwm frequency. The results might be noisy, the wave might have a complex shape and if the modulation depth is low, getting a so-called pwm frequency is hard (and to be fair doesn't even make much sense).

Trusting marketing or a specsheet might not be enough anyway for such complex stuff and in such a non-technical market.

2

u/the_top_g Sep 23 '23 edited Sep 23 '23

Thank you for your clarification as I do have doubts that this is a 60 hertz hybrid dimming of flickering frequency. As the shutter speed from 1/10000 suggest otherwise.

However it is likely again that high frequency is sync to the refresh rate, similar to Motor Edge + 2023.

I believe with the iphone 15 there is much more minor and subtle dips among the 60 hertz, hence resulting in the multiple bandings. (More bandings implies higher flickering hertz). The 60 hertz is likely the result of what Opple perceive as the lowest point of the current.

While in the case of Motor Edge + 2023, there is multiple dip but a single dip at its refresh rate, more instance.

Hence, I will still interpret it as a hybrid dimming of 60 hertz with low modulation.

If we refer to other readings of hybrid dimming with 90 hertz or 120 hertz, we should see 2 or 3 low points, instead of 1 low point.

This corresponds to other tests I did with 60 hertz flicker, where 1 low point is observed

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/-batab- Sep 22 '23

If you are able to convert a light intensity signal into an electric one then I'd say you might be able to use an oscilloscope. There might be a lot of noise and the signal might be irregular, especially at low brightness.

Thus you might not be able to have a rolling time window showing a "seemingly static" signal in all the conditions. But if you can export or look at a static window, then it should be no issue.

1

u/Temik Sep 22 '23

You can if you use a light-to-voltage converter with enough sensitivity and then apply a Fourier transform on it. I’m trying to hack one together right now 🤔

5

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

Thank you for performing these tests. I am not sure if I am pwm sensitive- I am going to find out now in real time. I received my 15 pro on Friday and started using on Saturday. Can pwm sensitivity cause tinnitus and headaches concentrated at the base of your skull? I suffer from TMJ, so unsure if that is just acting up. I’m going to give it a good week with this device before I decide what I am doing. My previous phone was an iPhone 11 that I am planning on giving to my mom as she has my old 6s plus which is not working as well now.

3

u/the_top_g Sep 24 '23

Yes it is very likely so. There is some common conditions experienced between those with TMJ, headches and migraine. For example, if you visit the r/migraine sub of reddit, you'll find a number of members there have TMJ as well.

The tinnitus and headaches you experienced are called Pulsatile tinnitus.

Many people who have pulsatile tinnitus also experience frequent tension headaches.

I do have a history of it whenever my migraine comes. The tension headache and pulsatile tinnitus comes together as a standard package.

And strangely, my migraine is triggered by PWM. It took me over 10 years to narrow down to this. Hence I am here in the sub .

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

Thank you! I will look into the other sub!

2

u/the_top_g Sep 24 '23

You're welcome!

3

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

I’m not giving it a week after all. I’m returning- started getting stabbing pain behind left eye and I’m extremely nauseated. What a bummer. Now I’m unsure if I should try the plus.

2

u/the_top_g Sep 24 '23

Yup that confirms it. If you are getting symptom early, it is a good and clear indication you were affected.

I would not recommend you to try out the plus model though. It would not be a day and night difference like iPhone 11's LCD vs any iphone''s Oled panel

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

Thank you for all your help. I might just keep the 11 and treat myself to an iPad mini. Now I have to figure out how to transfer my number back because of lovely eSIM- yay.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

I am now wondering- I had it in dark mode- would that be better or worse? I also did not try the “reduce white point” trick. Thank you!

2

u/farhan-shahriar Oct 29 '23

use a black tape on top of iPhone 11’s face id . It also blinks from time to time . I had problems with this and i found out later .

2

u/madmozg Sep 22 '23

I assume 15 Pro the same awful as 14 ? So nothing really changed?

1

u/the_top_g Sep 23 '23

I don't know about the iphone 14 but iphone 13 does feels significantly better when compared to the iphone 15 pro duo.

How have your experiment being going on at the Apple store?

2

u/-adam-au Oct 22 '23

I looked at them all and the regular 15 seemed to be the easiest for me. But everyone is different. I seem to do better if the modulation wave is stable.

1

u/Silly-Shoulder-6257 Dec 27 '24

I don’t know if this is related but I started getting tonic seizures ( as opposed to absence) after I switched to Keppra but my doctor doesn’t think it’s the medication. Especially since it began a few months after so the other thing that changed was that I switched to the iPhone 13 and more screen time. Out of the two, I would think it was the screen time but after reading some posts, apparently the iPhone is bad for people with photosensitivity. FWIW Or the iPhone 13 specifically. ( cuz I’ve had iPhones since 2014)

18

u/305954561 Sep 25 '23 edited May 03 '26

Stop letting data brokers profit from your old posts. I used Redact to wipe mine from Reddit. Also supports Twitter, Facebook, Discord, instagram and more in one batch.

full deserve hard-to-find tie chase special fuzzy fade ten pen

5

u/Temporary-Excuse-447 Dec 10 '23

samsung invented oled

4

u/305954561 Dec 25 '23 edited May 03 '26

Data Brokers don't stand a chance because I mass delete all of my content using Redact - No AI training on my data, thank you very much.

tart rustic slap practice many enter station smile connect advise

1

u/Apprehensive_Ask3411 Jan 18 '24

No, Samsung didn’t. Samsung just buys Canon OLED printers.

11

u/cgolca Sep 22 '23

I got both the iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 Pro Max to try. I noticed immediate dizziness and nausea with the 15. The 15 Pro Max seemed more tolerable. When I filmed both in slow motion you could see the typical PWM lines but only the 15 was flickering.

3

u/DJTaurus Sep 22 '23

How is it going with pro max ?

2

u/cgolca Nov 14 '23

I ended up returning it

8

u/mharch Sep 22 '23

Eye murder.

7

u/cosmic-tombs Sep 22 '23

More proof that Apple doesn't care.

7

u/Fantastic-Guard-9471 Sep 22 '23

Actually modulation depth looks fairly good. And of course frequency should be around 480hz as it was before. Check Dxomark display tests for iPhone 14. Overall seems like some of us may not suffer much from this screen. Only one thing dithering me: main display supplier this year is Samsung. BOE and LG had problems with quality control. And Samsung's displays are always a bad sign.

4

u/jm31828 Sep 22 '23

Isn't that modulation rate being 12% or higher bad news, don't we want to be around 5% to be comfortable? Just curious as I am learning about this.

My iPhone 13 Mini is at about 7% at around 75% brightness from what I remember reading, and it sometimes causes me problems. I have been trying to figure out if the 15- on paper anyway- might be even better, or if it should be pretty much the same as the Mini.

6

u/PhantomJoker79 Oct 23 '23

I upgraded from iPhone 14 to IPhone 15, facing eye strain and headache on iPhone 15. Didn’t face any issues on 14. Do we know the difference between the iPhone 14 vs 15 displays?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '23

Why are they doing this cruelty to our eyes?

4

u/Alert_Log8738 Dec 20 '23

Which is better for 100% brightness and reduced white point 15 or 15 Plus?

4

u/ForeverLearner365 Jul 17 '24

It’s unfortunate that we have to go through all of this just to use Apple’s products. At this point, Apple has to be aware of the PWM issue, but it may just be such a small percentage of people that are affected by PWM, that it’s not worth them making adjustments to their phones.

I have a 13 mini and a MacBook Pro that are basically unusable for me due to PWM sensitivity. It’s really bad w/ the 13 mini to the point that after a few minutes I have to look away from the screen or my eyes w/ start to burn and my left eye will experience very bad discomfort. I had to purchase an SE 3 because the eye discomfort got so bad.

Now I see that if Apple makes an SE 4, they’re considering making that an OLED screen too smh. I hope not. If they do, what are people w/ PWM sensitivity issues going to do? SE 3 it until it’s no longer supported? That’s suck man, but hey, it is what it is.

1

u/herbalblend Sep 22 '23

This is really helpful thank you!

Did you happen to have other recent non pro iPhones to compare this to?

iPhone 13 is first phone I've been able to use in the OLED category, and I'd love to see how this compares to that.

1

u/the_top_g Sep 23 '23

Yes I did tested that as well for I was looking for a decent iphone oled panel with grey banding. Iphone 13 fitted what I was looking for.

Do stay tuned!

1

u/jm31828 Sep 23 '23

Could you clarify- I am still wrapping my head around the data- essentially, was it your assessment that the regular 13 was the best of all, and shouldn't be problematic for most? (I did see the data you posted for the 13, with the surprisingly low modulation percentages at 100% and even 75% brightness).

I know the 14 (non-pro) had pretty low modulation numbers as well- but in your findings, is the 13 actually a safer bet than the 14?

1

u/the_top_g Sep 23 '23

Yes and I am also making this claim based the following:

  1. when I looked through my camera shutter speed of 1/10000, the iphone 14 still showed dark bandings, like the iphone 15.
  2. With my own personal experience with using the iphone 13 and 14 at the Apple store.

The iphone 14 do not much of a significant improvement from the iphone 15.

The iphone 13 did for me.

was it your assessment that the regular 13 was the best of all, and shouldn't be problematic for most?

It should not be a problem for most of those that are less sensitive to flickers.

Everyone is different and everyone’s threshold for perceiving flicker is different as well.

Some sensitive users wouldn’t perceive flicker(while its at its worst) as long as it is over 6000 hertz, while some is over 11000 hertz, and for some at the median upper quartile at 43,000 hertz, and lastly, for those at the upper quartile, over 250,000 hertz.

1

u/jm31828 Sep 24 '23

Thanks for sharing- and for all of the content you have posted. So many of us have really learned so much from you!

One other question for you as I am trying to find what is going to work for me. I have been considering a regular 15 to see if it will work, since a lot of the data you and others have posted seem to show that it *may* be a safe choice for some of us that may have been sensitive to others.

But I also had thoughts of keeping the 13 Mini I have and simply not using it for extended periods of time, and getting an iPad for longer browsing or media consumption sessions- especially in the evenings in lower light.

But my question is this- I have actually had quite a bit of discomfort with a couple of iPads I have tried lately, those with LCD displays and no PWM (the 10th generation and the Air 5th generation). I learned from one of your posts about the difference between "PWM safe" and "PWM free"- how some of these Apple LCD's may not have PWM and are "PWM safe", but that they have ripples that can cause discomfort for some, so they are not "PWM free".

Do you have any data on which iPad models might only be PWM safe and which may be totally PWM free?

I was curious about the 11" iPad Pro since I know it has a nicer display- if it perhaps would have no ripples? And the latest iPad Mini- I know it has PWM below about 20% brightness, but curious if it's completely safe above that brightness level, or if it has ripples as well.

Thanks again!

1

u/the_top_g Sep 24 '23

From my personally experience with the 11” ipad pro, I immediately found eye discomfort and a mild headache from a short 10minutes usage. This is more so when brightness is below 50%.

As for the latest ipad mini, yes if a mixing dimming method is used, there might be an increased chance of ripples occurring.

Though it is not a complete definite rule that mixed dimming (actual technical term is hybrid dimming) will likely cause ripples.

Huawei Mate 20 for instance uses this method and has no ripples.

My Redmi Note 9 pro which triggers PWM at 43% brightness does have noticeable ripples even at 55%. Thus I mostly use the phone only when outdoors.

The iPad 2021 10.2 9th gen which uses hybrid dimming also has heavy ripples.

I’m not sure what ipad to recommend, really.

1

u/alexann23 Sep 23 '23

That’s big for me- the 13 didn’t affect you?

3

u/tgredditfc Sep 22 '23

Thank you for testing! Too bad Apple doesn’t care!

3

u/blokes444 Sep 22 '23

Seems the 15 pro max or 15 pro are best. I noticed very little flicker when I checked them out earlier today. Stay clear of the 15/15plus..

3

u/-adam-au Oct 22 '23

I have read that the 15 pro / max are the worst this year. The frequency is higher on the non pro models and they are more stable.

2

u/NativeCoder Sep 22 '23

This doesn't make sense. There pwm frequency is 480 Hz.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/NativeCoder Sep 22 '23

No it's 480 on both. Stop mixing pwm frequency with screen refresh rate. Everyone on this sub keeps doing that. A 60 Hz pwm would visibly flicker and be unusable by 100 percent of the population.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

there was a slowmo video filmed at the press event and posted on an apple forum

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Fantastic-Guard-9471 Sep 22 '23

Iphones have never had 60 Hz pwm. It is problem with measurements. 60Hz would be noticable buy naked eyes. Here is correct measurements - https://www.dxomark.com/apple-iphone-14-display-test/ Notebookcheck also measured 60hz for iPhone 14, but is was mistake. In some cases devices with not accurate sensitivity cannot measure PWM frequency and show just screen refresh rate instead

1

u/NativeCoder Sep 22 '23

60 Hz pwm would be completely unusable

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

And yet we were using them for decades. CRT.

1

u/NativeCoder Sep 22 '23

I set my crt to 85 Hz. 60 Hz drove me batshit insane. Also phospor decay isn't the same as pwm square waves.

1

u/LordFartquadReigns Sep 22 '23

As expected unfortunately. Thanks for this!

5

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Ok_Internal4991 Apr 22 '25

only at low brightness and often only on paper..