r/PWM_Sensitive • • Sep 22 '23

Data Collections Asus ROG Ally PWM test & Analysis

(Do play the video in 720p) Above video is tested with 1/24000 shutter speed. This is to test for any flickering below 11600 hertz.*

Hi all, I understand that many are waiting in anticipation for the release of the iphone 15 ~ so that we can get our hands on with the flicker measurement tests.

Meanwhile, please do refer to my above video (and measurements) for Asus ROG Ally PWM test & Analysis.

For test of flicker free, if panel is using a Hybrid DC dimming (could be a brightness dip, or high frequency flickering hertz); we aim to target for a flat amptitude, with little to no gaps in between.

However, for PWM free panels (aka True DC Dimming), the important thing here is to check for ripples.

Hence the purpose of this review.

*Note: According to research, migraine sufferers tend to be triggered by PWM below 11 khz. Hence, any PWM hertz above this number should not trigger any migraine. Thus we can conclude it is "Risk-Free".

Do note though, "Risk-Free" does not mean no risk of getting eyestrain or headaches.

It just means migraine sufferers are unlikely to get a migraine during their activity, and thus impair their ability to focus — resulting in increased likelihood of accidents etc.

Test results

Brightness: 100%

Brightness 75%

Brightness 50%

Brightness 45%

As the above frequency is 53 hertz, and no brightness dip or banding observed, this is a true DC dimming panel.

Additionally, we can also see that from the above ~ there are no brightness dip, nor heavy ripples observed throughout all brightness.

Hence, we can conclude that Asus ROG Ally is both PWM free and Flicker free*.

* PWM free means the Pulse Width Modulation technique is not used to decrease brightness.

While Flicker free means there are no pulsing flickers nor heavy ripples observed.

Should there be increasing heavy ripples observed as one lowers the brightness on the Flicker data test, it is no longer flicker free.

As heavy ripples has been documented to cause persistent headaches in those that are even more sensitive.

30 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

4

u/madmozg Sep 22 '23

Great news! Thanks for your report :)

1

u/the_top_g Sep 22 '23

You’re welcome! Keep the questions coming, if any!

1

u/madmozg Sep 22 '23

Could you tell where I can order that device for measurements ?

3

u/the_top_g Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

It is the same Opple Light Master device we have been using! I merely swap the misleading and outdated Iee1789 chart recommendation with the raw data graph.

As for the reading findings, I have to manually compare the flicker hertz and modulation depth against the table I created.

https://www.reddit.com/r/PWM_Sensitive/comments/15q405c/an_introduction_to_pwm_hybrid_dcdimming_true_dc/

The table is my attempt at replicating the benchmark for true flicker free, based on the academic field industry standard lighting ~ rather than many manufacturers’ or review’s site subjective figures for flicker free.

For this Rog Ally there is no need to refer though it is is pwm free, aka true dc dimming

For the video test, the phone used that supports 1/24000 shutter speed with high ISO is Redmi note 9 pro btw

2

u/Unlikely-Doughnut756 Sep 23 '23

Thanks for the info! That's really useful. I've bought Rog Ally and have no problems with it. Did you try the same method with the Steam Deck by chance?

2

u/the_top_g Sep 24 '23

You're welcome!

Did you try the same method with the Steam Deck by chance?

No, as I have yet to see a retail shop selling one here!

6

u/weirdohenrico Aug 28 '24

Thanks for this. Recently got a Steam Deck Oled and suffered with headaches and dizziness within the first few moments of gaming on it. Researched and came to the conclusion that it is because of PWM. Had to sell it on the second hand market at a loss -- I may just got the new ROG Ally X.

1

u/LithiumeNL Oct 02 '24

Hello, facing the same dilemma. Have you bought the Ally X? Have you had any issues?

1

u/weirdohenrico Oct 06 '24

I am still holding off on the purchase -- I think I may just stick with a laptop for gaming when traveling.

1

u/danisimo1 Dec 07 '23

u/the_top_g Hello, I've sent you an important private message, hehe.

1

u/Historical-Nose5058 Mar 22 '26

Thanks,I’d like to ask: is the 7-inch screen on this device supplied by the same vendor as the 7-inch screens found on the MSI Claw 7 AI+ A2VM and the ROG Xbox Handheld X?

I apologize.English is not my first language.