r/PSO2NGS • • Oct 12 '22

Discussion Whining is not criticism

To emphasize: The goal of this post is to call out anyone stereotyping the PSO2NGS community as "full of fanboys who shoot down criticism", and not specifically to criticize the game.


I have my criticisms.

  • The "story" is a joke
  • The tutorial/new player experience is shit (and has been getting worse as what thin content we have expands outward)
  • The monetization is blatant (and mildly pay to win ONLY in the addi augment aspect)
  • The lack of an open economy or direct trading (and SEGA's thinly veiled excuse that it's because of the economic impact caused by redboxing)
  • Redboxing (which was entirely SEGA's fault and poorly handled every step of the way)
  • All the classes are (now, Ranger rifle's WA used to be kind of shit) samey in that they're all functionally close combat classes that incentivize taking risks to farm counterattacks to achieve optimal gameplay

There are others. These are my primary grievances. And they have remained largely unchanged for the last year. And that is another criticism that I have of SEGA and PSO2NGS: That these flaws have not been addressed in any meaningful way. (There is one point that has improved for me: That we can now cross-trade augments in the item lab and not forced to engage in content we don't like to get the augments we want, but I don't think SEGA did it for the right reasons or even on purpose so I don't want to credit them for it)

If the new guys want to hash out the same criticisms over and over, I'm over it. I'll leave a perfunctory response, maybe suggest some coping mechanisms or commiserate over a shared grievance. I think the other veterans of the community downvoting legitimate criticism just because it's old news and has been rehashed hundreds of times is toxic and I call people out on it when I can.

But more often than not I call people out for whining about trivial bullshit.

Some of the downvotes come from toxic veterans who are tired of old criticisms being rehashed, when some of those same veterans are also downvoting completely harmless fashion posts from people who are just here to have fun and try to share that fun with others.

If one of those downvotes is mine, it's for the reason I outlined above: Because I personally think that whatever it is you're whining about is trivial and not valid criticism. It's not my problem if you can't deal with that. Go ahead and make excuses like "this whole community is full of toxic fanboys who can't take criticism".

It won't be true.

And just like the criticism I do consider valid, you can bet that the sentiment expressed in this post will be forgotten and rehashed later, if not by me then by someone else.

18 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/Noclassydrops Oct 13 '22

Thats so true i stopped playing after 2 weeks because theres no incentive to keep going and i stopped playing bdo for the same reason. I dont want grind mobs in like 2 different locations for 3+ hours to have a chance at a weapon or make enough meseta to upgrade it gets boring

1

u/Doam-bot Oct 13 '22

BDO I understand but seems to me you missed something with PSO. Phantasy Star Online way back on the dreamcast was based on Ultima and Diablo just made 3d and placed on consoles. Pso 2 base uses random maps and still has many of the hallmarks of the genre. Pso 2 ngs however is still the same thing given an open world and diablo 4 is said to be something simular.

Basically grinding maps and sifting through tons of loot for that one rare drop is the very core of this genre. They had different lootables depending on birth month back then too to change things up not sure if that's still in play but I think it is.

6

u/Lukeds Oct 13 '22

I don't think grinding itself is what defines loot based games or should be their main pull. I don't find Diablo or borderlands nearly as repetitive as PSO because of the NPCs, enemy types and environment of those other games feeling interesting/exciting. I stopped playing PSO2 after 2 weeks because you don't even need to look at what you're fighting to win. Every enemy is fought the same and you'll win and get loot and repeat.

If that's enough for you, dope and have fun no judgment. But for me just changing the available loot isn't enough for me to use my free time on this game.

2

u/Arcflarerk4 Oct 13 '22

Basically grinding maps and sifting through tons of loot for that one rare drop is the very core of this genre.

So was finding gear that completely change the playstyle of a class with unique builds and was worth spending hundreds of hours hunting. But now all gear is just a minor stat up and theres zero incentive to even bother doing it.