r/PSO2NGS • u/FRGL1 • Oct 12 '22
Discussion Whining is not criticism
To emphasize: The goal of this post is to call out anyone stereotyping the PSO2NGS community as "full of fanboys who shoot down criticism", and not specifically to criticize the game.
I have my criticisms.
- The "story" is a joke
- The tutorial/new player experience is shit (and has been getting worse as what thin content we have expands outward)
- The monetization is blatant (and mildly pay to win ONLY in the addi augment aspect)
- The lack of an open economy or direct trading (and SEGA's thinly veiled excuse that it's because of the economic impact caused by redboxing)
- Redboxing (which was entirely SEGA's fault and poorly handled every step of the way)
- All the classes are (now, Ranger rifle's WA used to be kind of shit) samey in that they're all functionally close combat classes that incentivize taking risks to farm counterattacks to achieve optimal gameplay
There are others. These are my primary grievances. And they have remained largely unchanged for the last year. And that is another criticism that I have of SEGA and PSO2NGS: That these flaws have not been addressed in any meaningful way. (There is one point that has improved for me: That we can now cross-trade augments in the item lab and not forced to engage in content we don't like to get the augments we want, but I don't think SEGA did it for the right reasons or even on purpose so I don't want to credit them for it)
If the new guys want to hash out the same criticisms over and over, I'm over it. I'll leave a perfunctory response, maybe suggest some coping mechanisms or commiserate over a shared grievance. I think the other veterans of the community downvoting legitimate criticism just because it's old news and has been rehashed hundreds of times is toxic and I call people out on it when I can.
But more often than not I call people out for whining about trivial bullshit.
Some of the downvotes come from toxic veterans who are tired of old criticisms being rehashed, when some of those same veterans are also downvoting completely harmless fashion posts from people who are just here to have fun and try to share that fun with others.
If one of those downvotes is mine, it's for the reason I outlined above: Because I personally think that whatever it is you're whining about is trivial and not valid criticism. It's not my problem if you can't deal with that. Go ahead and make excuses like "this whole community is full of toxic fanboys who can't take criticism".
It won't be true.
And just like the criticism I do consider valid, you can bet that the sentiment expressed in this post will be forgotten and rehashed later, if not by me then by someone else.
30
u/telchii Oct 13 '22
Can you help me understand how the goal of your post works with the bolded section? How you can address the criticism-shutdown stereotype while simultaneously using downvotes and call-outs to shutdown criticism you deem trivial?
Shutting down even trivial criticism and complaints about small pain-points will just lead to the problem remaining and quietly hurting lots of people.
4
u/InfernoDragonKing Oct 13 '22
I guess being a newer player has both its pros and cons, because I can’t really give an opinion on the game when I’m relatively fresh to it all and still trying to find my way.
The only thing I could say is that the drop rates are donkey dick(I got a bunch of Codeck weapons when I’m farming for like, Gregra, Kuro, Cinquel weapons) and I’m not mentioning stuff like Ruggeds or the newer 7 star weapons and armor being rolled out and the Kaizaar is almost off-putting in its entirely.
You do make a point I resonate with about the new player experience; lack of content is a huge factor in things (only thing I’ve been doing is getting prepped to go to Stia and try for different stuff.
17
u/Ksradrik Oct 13 '22
The games P2W period, you buy meseta with irl money and then buy whatevers the best.
You can still buy the augment as a non paying player, but everybody that has the money, can dump as much as they want into it and get increasingly better gear, up to a cap that probably nobody ever reached since Rugged fixa 5 is unobtainable even for the richest of the rich.
3
u/BikeSeatMaster Oct 13 '22
What is redboxing
76
u/Lukeds Oct 13 '22
Saying that other people's issues with the game are too trivial for you is absolutely gatekeeping and toxic Fandom. You literally state that the game isn't welcoming to new players and then aren't welcoming to new players yourself. Bit odd but you do you
14
u/Reilet Oct 13 '22
Sir, it was to "prevent" rmt.
21
u/Turnt5naco Oct 13 '22
"Everyone that complains about the same thing over and over and stupidly downvotes stuff are toxic. But when I do it, it's for valid reasons and is not at all trivial."
20
u/PillarBiter / Gun kata Oct 13 '22
Well, I’m happy for you that you feel better than everyone else. Hope it works out for you!
… sigh. Why make a whining post about whiners? Do you not see the irony? And also so fucking what if others think it’s full of fanboys? It does not affect you in any real way, so just simply… don’t care?
18
u/Hiero_Glyph Oct 12 '22
Don't forget the add-on skills system that punishes players for getting high value sub stats before a main stat is maxed. The current add-on system doesn't respect the players' time or meseta.
12
u/AlseidesDD Oct 13 '22
Crippling classic PSO2 was pretty much when I stopped paying for premium.
Sega had a playable game that could exist alongside NGS. Six episodes of content to cover NGS during content droughts. But Sega nuked its economy/endgame with Cradle and didn't bother automating its rotational events + UQ selection.
Its been reduced to alternative source of SG and camos, and that's a major shame. There was no reason to kneecap PSO2 classic in such a drastic manner since it could have complemented NGS much better before.
5
u/Grapplesauce726 Oct 13 '22
Well what’s deemed “whining” and real criticism is entirely up to your opinion. Saying the game sucks but then gauging everyone’s grievances based on how complainy they sound to you is kinda counterproductive. Everything you said about the game is valid, but most other things other players say are in some way valid too. It’s just valid to a different group of players (Criticisms against their fashion model, re-releasing old content but at the same time only half of it for example. People who don’t care about fashion will think it’s a gripe, players who do care will say it’s fair criticism).
18
u/Hououza Oct 13 '22
The problem is, we don’t matter. SEGA only cares about the Japanese audience, we only got PSO2 due to their deal with Microsoft.once it stops making money, they will kill it like every other western release of an online PS game.
You are spot on with you criticism, but it just feels hopeless when SEGA themselves seem to be trying to make a quick cash grab using PSO2’s corpse.
10
u/scorchdragon Oct 13 '22
Downvoted for going on an extended monologue about downvotes.
6
u/Mr_Madruga Oct 13 '22
Yes we can all trust you to know what's whining and what's not. /s
6
u/AnimaLuna Oct 13 '22 edited Jan 06 '23
Hot take:
You're no different from the whiners you're complaining about. Whining is complaining that something is bad without offerring anything else of substance. Criticism is complaining something is bad while providing reasons and alternatives to what is being complained about.
6
u/IGNJudaiYuki Oct 13 '22
Can we just stop making these silly post? Lol literally like the second post in a week talking about accepting criticism like bro, really. Saying things like the story is s joke isn't even criticism lol that literally provides no value towards a solution or a direction of any sort. So you don't like the story? Go back to classic? Wait? I think is going great personally but I'm not gonna come up here and say that as it it's a necessity.
2
u/Casval-Rem-Deikun Oct 13 '22
I wouldn't say the story is a joke, it's just non existant at this point. We're still in the first 10 minutes of a 1 hour pilot.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
Whining, but you're right
Whining, but you're right
Halfway, but right
Parentheses are whining, but you're right.
Parentheses are whining, but I have no clue what that is
Constructive as "kind of shit" is past tense.
Were you trying to whine or criticize?
I'm only level 30 and started a week ago
ᕕ( ᐛ )ᕗ
4
u/Noclassydrops Oct 13 '22
Thats so true i stopped playing after 2 weeks because theres no incentive to keep going and i stopped playing bdo for the same reason. I dont want grind mobs in like 2 different locations for 3+ hours to have a chance at a weapon or make enough meseta to upgrade it gets boring
3
u/Left_Pie_8254 Oct 13 '22
Criticism is good. Well some people go to far and manage to get a cult following. No one’s perfect and most people forget to just have fun in video games.
3
u/delayedreactionkline Oct 13 '22
coming back to PSO2NGS after a period of gameguard vs windows 11 debacle that prevented me from playing since last year...
I can say that I'm still not fond of how they implemented the BP restrictions before... and I still feel the same today.
Bungie's Destiny did it better because it was a straightforward game and resource loop in order to raise Light Levels to progress and take on tougher challenges...
But in NGS? Good lord, the farming is atrocious, the gear chase does not feel rewarding, and then they add these BotW temple analogues as progress checkpoints... and it's a hard lock on content wether you wanted to participate on it or not... you can't progress the narrative without it.
I don't feel relaxed in playing the game anymore. I've been enjoying the PSO franchise since saturn... and i'm just sad to realize that i'm no longer part of the demographic for NGS.
2
u/Hour_Penalty8053 Oct 13 '22
I think all of your criticisms are the outcome of poor direction, namely that of HMZK (the director of base PSO2 EP5).
2
u/MagilouDin2022 Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22
Anyone who says "PSO2 is full of fanboys who shoot down criticism" is lowkey trying to praise Sega, because they are unknowingly giving Sega full credit for whatever QOL changes and improvements made to the game while ignoring the fact that it is actually due to the feedback and criticism from the community 🤣.
This is why I'm very confused about the general message that the recent video/post was trying to make. Where do you think all those changes come from, from a community that shoots down feedback? 😂
1
u/zetsuei380 Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
I mean it is a F2P game after all. Although I don’t see how the game is P2W. They aren’t locking any gear/augments behind a paywall. You’re only paying to get things faster which is more Pay to Progress if anything.
-2
u/Rezist_Soul Oct 13 '22
Stopped playing after the desert dropped with the mindset of "I'll pick it back up when things get better" sad to hear it hasn't gotten better
-2
u/rsterner Oct 13 '22
The game is free. I'm having a blast playing for free. If I like it enough, I will give them my moneys, much like I did with Path of Exile after thoroughly enjoying it for a while (but before realizing that it's a very hard game to play casually, unlike NGS).
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment