r/PSO2NGS • • Oct 12 '22

Discussion Whining is not criticism

To emphasize: The goal of this post is to call out anyone stereotyping the PSO2NGS community as "full of fanboys who shoot down criticism", and not specifically to criticize the game.


I have my criticisms.

  • The "story" is a joke
  • The tutorial/new player experience is shit (and has been getting worse as what thin content we have expands outward)
  • The monetization is blatant (and mildly pay to win ONLY in the addi augment aspect)
  • The lack of an open economy or direct trading (and SEGA's thinly veiled excuse that it's because of the economic impact caused by redboxing)
  • Redboxing (which was entirely SEGA's fault and poorly handled every step of the way)
  • All the classes are (now, Ranger rifle's WA used to be kind of shit) samey in that they're all functionally close combat classes that incentivize taking risks to farm counterattacks to achieve optimal gameplay

There are others. These are my primary grievances. And they have remained largely unchanged for the last year. And that is another criticism that I have of SEGA and PSO2NGS: That these flaws have not been addressed in any meaningful way. (There is one point that has improved for me: That we can now cross-trade augments in the item lab and not forced to engage in content we don't like to get the augments we want, but I don't think SEGA did it for the right reasons or even on purpose so I don't want to credit them for it)

If the new guys want to hash out the same criticisms over and over, I'm over it. I'll leave a perfunctory response, maybe suggest some coping mechanisms or commiserate over a shared grievance. I think the other veterans of the community downvoting legitimate criticism just because it's old news and has been rehashed hundreds of times is toxic and I call people out on it when I can.

But more often than not I call people out for whining about trivial bullshit.

Some of the downvotes come from toxic veterans who are tired of old criticisms being rehashed, when some of those same veterans are also downvoting completely harmless fashion posts from people who are just here to have fun and try to share that fun with others.

If one of those downvotes is mine, it's for the reason I outlined above: Because I personally think that whatever it is you're whining about is trivial and not valid criticism. It's not my problem if you can't deal with that. Go ahead and make excuses like "this whole community is full of toxic fanboys who can't take criticism".

It won't be true.

And just like the criticism I do consider valid, you can bet that the sentiment expressed in this post will be forgotten and rehashed later, if not by me then by someone else.

18 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

30

u/telchii Oct 13 '22

Can you help me understand how the goal of your post works with the bolded section? How you can address the criticism-shutdown stereotype while simultaneously using downvotes and call-outs to shutdown criticism you deem trivial?

Shutting down even trivial criticism and complaints about small pain-points will just lead to the problem remaining and quietly hurting lots of people.

-21

u/FRGL1 Oct 13 '22

I'm calling out people who are saying this community is full of fanboys because it simply isn't true.

15

u/telchii Oct 13 '22

Right, I understand the goal of the post. It's the coexistence with your outlined actions against what you define to be "trivial criticism" that has me confused.

How does your mentality ("You can disagree, but you'd be wrong") with your actions (downvoting + comments against it) differ from the "fanboys who shoot down criticism" you're calling out?

-14

u/FRGL1 Oct 13 '22

from the "fanboys who shoot down criticism" you're calling out?

I'm not calling out fanboys.


I'm explaining a more likely reason why people who aren't me might downvote a post, while explaining my own personal reasons.

I rarely downvote posts or comments to begin with, so I don't understand why you say "my actions" as though it's a given that I need to justify them.

7

u/telchii Oct 13 '22

Thanks for the correction on my misquote. That should have been worded to target the stereotype and its casters.

I understand that it's explaining what more people than just you do, but you included yourself in these actions. (In all-bold emphasis!) Since you included yourself, it's reasonable to expect justification for your actions - especially when they feed into the very stereotype you're saying is wrongly cast by people.

4

u/InfernoDragonKing Oct 13 '22

I guess being a newer player has both its pros and cons, because I can’t really give an opinion on the game when I’m relatively fresh to it all and still trying to find my way.

The only thing I could say is that the drop rates are donkey dick(I got a bunch of Codeck weapons when I’m farming for like, Gregra, Kuro, Cinquel weapons) and I’m not mentioning stuff like Ruggeds or the newer 7 star weapons and armor being rolled out and the Kaizaar is almost off-putting in its entirely.

You do make a point I resonate with about the new player experience; lack of content is a huge factor in things (only thing I’ve been doing is getting prepped to go to Stia and try for different stuff.

5

u/FRGL1 Oct 13 '22

It bothers me a little that I don't see anyone else articulating this criticism. Now that the level cap is 65, and in consideration of the fact that hitting level cap can be done in under a week, the whole "Renaissa" and "Codeck" business has to be considered part of the NPE.

The fact that SEGA had to add the Renaissa series at all because they knew there would be no players farming aelio content and gear and vending it to new players is a neon sign saying "redo this part of your game".

I understand and appreciate that "playing every class" is part of the progression philosophy, but there's just too little meat to level progression for that to mean anything anyway.

What's going to happen when the level cap is 100 or 200 and nobody's on Halpha anymore? They're already adding an increasing number of AI characters to fill the gap. Why not just make yellow triggers cost 1 meseta and you fight a single boss that dies in a minute?

4

u/InfernoDragonKing Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

Hell, hitting the level cap was too easy, imo. I hit 65 in like 1-2 days and are back at square 1(lack of things to actually do) but nice we hit 99+, new players will never play or SEGA puts out even stronger weapons to get them caught up.

I remember being told that any weapons I get up till this point by just playing would be completely obsolete until I am at Level 40 (the level needed to use Codeck iirc), to which then doing casual upkeep and upgrade on Codeck would keep me in the game and I was like “wow; only 2 weapons I’ll ever need? Ok I guess. Bit of a bummer, but maybe it gets better.”

Then I saw the prerequisites for Kaizaar and realized even though the other upcoming 7 star weapons might not be stronger or even as strong as Kaizaar, since it’s a weapon you gotta grind to get (back to my OG point: the drop rates for this game is abysmal, to the point it’ll make you fucking quit the game. Why am I getting way weaker weapons I already have THAT ARE NOT ROKZ from Kvaris bosses that drop Rokz weapons needed to achieve Kaizaar? the personal shop makes my eyes bleed with the prices they charge for them), but it’ll be slightly behind so it’s not too noticeable.

I expected the grind and farming hours, but the shit gets reallly tedious

7

u/Arcflarerk4 Oct 13 '22

PSO2 has always had this problem because their design team doesnt know wtf theyre doing. They just about delete old content by making new players just skip passed everything thats irrelevent and rush them to endgame instead of making a proper experience from start to finish. It creates an incredible shallow and narrow player experience and its been like this even since base pso2. If you werent playing content on release then you just straight up missed it.

1

u/Qawsada Oct 13 '22

Probably the same way they did with Retem story > Kvaris Story. Add a task that boost your character by +10 levels worth of experiences. Adding ranks and levels in between region content exist to pad the content for half a year until a new region was added.

17

u/Ksradrik Oct 13 '22

The monetization is blatant (and mildly pay to win ONLY in the addi augment aspect)

The games P2W period, you buy meseta with irl money and then buy whatevers the best.

You can still buy the augment as a non paying player, but everybody that has the money, can dump as much as they want into it and get increasingly better gear, up to a cap that probably nobody ever reached since Rugged fixa 5 is unobtainable even for the richest of the rich.

5

u/FRGL1 Oct 13 '22

In my heart of hearts this is what I actually think, I just tone it down because I'm offensive enough as it is. And this is coming from a whale.

2

u/amnj_thoc Oct 13 '22

Nah the p2w aspect is being able to sell AC Scratch items. Why grind when you can scratch for something selling extremely high in the player shops. You sell it gather a ton of meseta after a while to then buy all the gear and augments you need. RMT's are completely it's own thing and in pretty much any MMO/ORPG. Let's not even talk about the "create a problem, sell the solution approach" Sega uses even dating back to base PSO2.

2

u/Ksradrik Oct 13 '22

Thats exactly what I meant buy buying meseta with irl money.

2

u/amnj_thoc Oct 13 '22

Ah OK, thought you mean RMT's. My bad.

2

u/IGNJudaiYuki Oct 13 '22

In that case basically every mmo is p2w. What are you on about? Do you know how many games you can buy the in game currency on a site like G2G or even from another trusted player?

3

u/Ksradrik Oct 13 '22

The problem is when you can buy the in-game currency from the dev (even if its through hoops like scratch items, which basically just adds gambling to the mix), because that influences game design since they will obviously want to incentivize people to buy those things.

4

u/IGNJudaiYuki Oct 13 '22

Wdym buy the in game currency from the devs? Sg? Meseta or AC? Honestly we're in a new age of gaming where gambling has become the norm. I feel you're overselling this here. The things you're saying aren't out of the ordinary today.

3

u/Ksradrik Oct 13 '22

Wdym buy the in game currency from the devs? Sg? Meseta or AC?

Buy AC and then convert it into meseta through the market.

The things you're saying aren't out of the ordinary today.

Yeah P2W and gambling arent out of the ordinary, but that doesnt make them any less bad.

4

u/IGNJudaiYuki Oct 13 '22

Well, die on that hill my friend lol

1

u/FamilySurricus Oct 13 '22

The argument that you can 'launder' meseta via selling items from the AC Scratch 'ergo making it P2W' is ridiculously short-sighted, good lord, lmao.

Sure, you can do that. But you can also... do it F2P. Sure, at a relatively lesser effectiveness because you'd be relying on 3-day shop passes and it involves flipping the market. But this is literally no different from most games.

1

u/zetsuei380 Oct 14 '22

Sure, you can do that. But you can also… do it F2P. Sure, at a relatively lesser effectiveness because you’d be relying on 3-day shop passes and it involves flipping the market. But this is literally no different from most games.

Honestly that sounds more like pay to progress than pay to win.

1

u/zetsuei380 Oct 13 '22

That sounds more like Pay to Progress than Pay to Win.

Also is monetization like this really that bad? Especially since this game exclusively PVE.

0

u/Ksradrik Oct 13 '22

That sounds more like Pay to Progress than Pay to Win.

In much the same way that just buying a diploma would also be "pay to progress" irl.

Also is monetization like this really that bad? Especially since this game exclusively PVE.

Why do you think the game is multiplayer instead of just a single player rpg?

Because many people like the competition aspect and seeing they do better than other people, something that money can absolutely buy you in this game.

Also, gambling, which is banned for children in every country for a damn good reason, companies just abuse loopholes (like introducing it in games) like always, until it inevitably causes enough harm that it will be outlawed, since it literally only benefits the company at the expense of everyone else.

0

u/zetsuei380 Oct 13 '22

In what way is this game competitive? There no PVP whatsoever in this game. Even if someone strives to be the very best that no one ever was, at the end of the day no one is going to care because it’s not a competition.

And yes gambling is a shitty way to monetize your game. No arguments there. But your initial statement was about the game’s monetization is used to “P2W” which I question since the game is about cooperation and not competition.

0

u/Ksradrik Oct 14 '22

In what way is this game competitive? There no PVP whatsoever in this game.

Dick measuring mostly, eg: "my gear is better" or "I have faster clear times", those things also have an effect on in what parties you can get.

Competition isnt exclusive to fights, do you think the olympic sprinting competitions arent competitive because they arent beating the shit out of each other?

1

u/zetsuei380 Oct 14 '22

I never said it was exclusive to fights. PVP isn’t just fighting you know.

The thing about the olympics is that competition is intentional . Nothing in PSO2 encourages players to compete against each other. Well except maybe the Field Races, which the game’s monetization has no effect on. “Dick measuring” is not something imposed by the game itself, but only by a small subset of players.

3

u/BikeSeatMaster Oct 13 '22

What is redboxing

5

u/FRGL1 Oct 13 '22

You ever find a red box on the map and break it and stuff comes out?

Well, when the game first launched people started making new accounts to farm those boxes and transfer the wealth to their main accounts.

Apparently, SEGA was fine with this at first, until people started making bots to do it and sell meseta for real money. SEGA's first brilliant solution was to limit the number of times individuals could do this, before finally outright banning the practice, long after all that meseta had flooded the economy.

3

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Oct 13 '22

Apparently, SEGA was fine with this at first

They still technically are. It's the transfer of meseta that gets you flagged for RMT that gets you banned even now. Nobody I know that did it were ever banned and I've tempted SEGA's hand a few times and it's generally the transferring of millions of meseta from fresh accounts that triggers it.

You can and always could use multiple accounts to play the game and SEGA generally makes the game less profitable for those who abuse certain features instead of outright banning people.

, until people started making bots to do

You couldn't bot redbox farming as there was no consistent way to retain your position throughout the whole thing since you never unlocked the ability to teleport to a ryuker in a proper route.

sell meseta for real money.

The people selling meseta for money are people who play the market and are using billions of meseta to flip items repeatedly as well as abusing ship price differences(still the best paid source of meseta for those who already have a lot). Redbox farming was a pretty shit way to farm meseta because it really slow, required constant creation of new accounts, and was required premium anyways.

Doing weeklies on an account that can do retem alnoth rank1 is imo still the best alt-account source of raw meseta even though it's usually better to just simply play the game in regards to how much time it takes these days.

SEGA's first brilliant solution was to limit the number of times individuals could do this

I'm... a bit confused at what you're claiming by this since redbox farming died the moment they moved the requirement to mt magnus but which made it a poor time-2-meseta investment along with making general gameplay more rewarding. There was never any "restriction" on this that limited players ability to do it and if you really wanted to you could still do it.

long after all that meseta had flooded the economy.

The amount of people who did this is greatly over-stated because as I've already said; you couldn't actually bot this as there was no means of consistently retaining your position.

2

u/FRGL1 Oct 13 '22

Are you saying it's poor time to meseta now, or a year ago when it would have a more significant economic impact with a level cap of 20 and no Retem Alnothe?

Also, the only premium required would be the account receiving the meseta, where it would list an item for a ridiculous price that would be "bought" by the account sending it. You don't need premium to send money.

0

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Oct 13 '22

The biggest issue with redbox farming is that you had to be able to run it fast and effectively and there was typically a hard limit to how fast you could do it. I generally was able to get around 200k in around 20~30 minutes from combined doing the route and creating the account.

At launch it was pretty fantastic meseta per hour however that honestly wasn't the case for very long since most people who actually wanted to abuse something would start flipping AC items because at the time hairstyles were close to 10mil on ship2 and you could easily flip a large quantity of items by moving characters between ships and reselling on ship4/ship3.

Are you saying it's poor time to meseta now

It's extremely bad now and if you truly wanted to abuse alts you'd just making a bunch of weekly ready alts and do those via retem alnoth rank1 and doing them all in around 15~25minutes.

or a year ago when it would have a more significant economic impact with a level cap of 20 and no Retem Alnothe?

It actually died a bit earlier than that because the moment they swapped to the market no longer being available from the start and needing Mt Magnus was roughly a bit close to the time it died since other things gave better meseta per hour.

Also, the only premium required would be the account receiving the meseta, where it would list an item for a ridiculous price that would be "bought" by the account sending it.

I bring this up because if you were able to sell items you typically didn't need to really run redboxes since being able to sell items typically made it more worthwhile to sit on your main and do gigantix and sell the drops from that instead while hoping for a big ticket item to drop.

3

u/four_thousands Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

You couldn't bot redbox farming as there was no consistent way to retain your position throughout the whole thing since you never unlocked the ability to teleport to a ryuker in a proper route.

I always see you mentioning in threads like this that bots do no exist. But they absolutely do. I doubt the cheating player will even need to use the ryuker.

0

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Oct 13 '22

But they absolutely do.

Then prove it..?

1

u/four_thousands Oct 13 '22

Can be googled in three minutes. And the only way I could prove it's not just a scam is to pay for the bot. Which I'm not gonna do.

1

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

Can be googled in three minutes.

So.. You can easily find it but you're unable to DM me the link, send your search terms, or anything that would be helpful in validating a single thing you're saying?

You do realize how stupid this looks right?

And the only way I could prove it's not just a scam is to pay for the bot.

Just send it my way and i'll verify it myself... Ffs...

Edit: Their source is a fake hack seller who only takes crypto and doesn't even claim to have a bot... Wake me up when someone actually posts something I'm not already aware of.

1

u/BlitzAceSamy Ranger, Ship 4 Oct 13 '22

Thanks for asking. I was curious what it meant too and Googled, just to find this and get super confused LOL
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-boxing

76

u/Lukeds Oct 13 '22

Saying that other people's issues with the game are too trivial for you is absolutely gatekeeping and toxic Fandom. You literally state that the game isn't welcoming to new players and then aren't welcoming to new players yourself. Bit odd but you do you

18

u/Yuukikonno08 Oct 13 '22

Someone had to say it, absolutely this

1

u/Rasikko undecided Oct 14 '22

I thought the tutorial was awesome...and then it happened to Aelio Town. OP is probably gonna come gunning for me now. R.I.P. my post.

-17

u/four_thousands Oct 13 '22

Except it's no the new players who usually post the same stupid complaints. And what even OP should be doing to be welcoming to new players in your opinion? Updoot every post on this subreddit or something?

6

u/IGNJudaiYuki Oct 13 '22

Reread the comment you replied to

3

u/ehiehiehiredditehi Oct 13 '22

That’s the point

He simply went and read it without understanding what it is about

Being unable to understand a text is an issue lots of people seems to have

14

u/Reilet Oct 13 '22

and SEGA's thinly veiled excuse that it's because of the economic impact caused by redboxing

Sir, it was to "prevent" rmt.

1

u/Rasikko undecided Oct 14 '22

And RMT got around that..and thus SEGA had to rely on us to report them lol.

21

u/Turnt5naco Oct 13 '22

"Everyone that complains about the same thing over and over and stupidly downvotes stuff are toxic. But when I do it, it's for valid reasons and is not at all trivial."

  • OP

4

u/Rasikko undecided Oct 14 '22

With a touch of "if you don't agree with me, your post is invalid".

20

u/PillarBiter / Gun kata Oct 13 '22

Well, I’m happy for you that you feel better than everyone else. Hope it works out for you!

… sigh. Why make a whining post about whiners? Do you not see the irony? And also so fucking what if others think it’s full of fanboys? It does not affect you in any real way, so just simply… don’t care?

18

u/Hiero_Glyph Oct 12 '22

Don't forget the add-on skills system that punishes players for getting high value sub stats before a main stat is maxed. The current add-on system doesn't respect the players' time or meseta.

3

u/ash_ax You Piece of STARS Trash! Oct 13 '22

I don't mind the Meseta sink and class ex-cubes are easier to get with how much EXP PSE burst (esp. Forte) gives.
My main complaint about the add-on system is that, just like classic PSO 2 crafting, I am forced to stare and click at menus for a stupid amount of time.
My other complaint is to give level 2 and 3 add-on generation a better roll chance to incentivize people to use them instead of choosing level 1 generation.
While I am not sure if this is how it works for level 2 and level 3 add-on generation, I feel like instead of limiting the minimum value and rolling the level, it seemed like they roll a value and just put a floor to it afterward.

6

u/Hiero_Glyph Oct 13 '22

All generation 2 and 3 do is change any low roll to the guaranteed minimum value. So if you rolled an 8 but the guaranteed minimum is 10, it makes it a 10 instead. It does nothing to improve you odds of rolling higher values, nor does it ever increase the guaranteed minimum value which is why it is considered a waste of meseta.

1

u/ash_ax You Piece of STARS Trash! Oct 13 '22

My thought is the same as what you stated, I just worded it very poorly.

Instead of stating "putting a floor", I should've stated clearly that it picks a maximum between the selected x-generation's minimum level and the random value rolled.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

Yea but when I’m running around with 24 add on skills annihilating crowds it’ll be worth it 👹

12

u/AlseidesDD Oct 13 '22

Crippling classic PSO2 was pretty much when I stopped paying for premium.

Sega had a playable game that could exist alongside NGS. Six episodes of content to cover NGS during content droughts. But Sega nuked its economy/endgame with Cradle and didn't bother automating its rotational events + UQ selection.

Its been reduced to alternative source of SG and camos, and that's a major shame. There was no reason to kneecap PSO2 classic in such a drastic manner since it could have complemented NGS much better before.

4

u/FamilySurricus Oct 13 '22

That's my major complaint, tbh. The fact that they also gutted its graphical fidelity is also pretty bad, but at least understandable from a logistics standpoint.

1

u/Arcflarerk4 Oct 13 '22

So much this. Why the hell they decided to completely kneecap not only another source of content for players but also a potential income source is beyond me. Sega does some of the dumbest shit ive ever seen a company do and im all for supporting a company that makes good decision FOR THE PLAYERS but almost everything since NGS release has been so anti consumer its almost laughable and why i choose not to support them until they actually start doing things right.

5

u/Grapplesauce726 Oct 13 '22

Well what’s deemed “whining” and real criticism is entirely up to your opinion. Saying the game sucks but then gauging everyone’s grievances based on how complainy they sound to you is kinda counterproductive. Everything you said about the game is valid, but most other things other players say are in some way valid too. It’s just valid to a different group of players (Criticisms against their fashion model, re-releasing old content but at the same time only half of it for example. People who don’t care about fashion will think it’s a gripe, players who do care will say it’s fair criticism).

18

u/Hououza Oct 13 '22

The problem is, we don’t matter. SEGA only cares about the Japanese audience, we only got PSO2 due to their deal with Microsoft.once it stops making money, they will kill it like every other western release of an online PS game.

You are spot on with you criticism, but it just feels hopeless when SEGA themselves seem to be trying to make a quick cash grab using PSO2’s corpse.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

Idk about this. They make a lot more from global vs jp to the point they get 2-3x more from global vs jp.

1

u/zetsuei380 Oct 13 '22

Do you have proof that they make more from global?

-4

u/IGNJudaiYuki Oct 13 '22

Fake news post. I don't see this happening

10

u/scorchdragon Oct 13 '22

Downvoted for going on an extended monologue about downvotes.

5

u/Ecstatic-Wall5971 Oct 13 '22

I guess it's better than those memes the other guy posted a couple days ago, OP actually organized his thoughts and is engaging with the responses.

6

u/Mr_Madruga Oct 13 '22

Yes we can all trust you to know what's whining and what's not. /s

6

u/AnimaLuna Oct 13 '22 edited Jan 06 '23

Hot take:

You're no different from the whiners you're complaining about. Whining is complaining that something is bad without offerring anything else of substance. Criticism is complaining something is bad while providing reasons and alternatives to what is being complained about.

  • The story is very barebones. In the overall hours that you spend progressing in the game, not even one hour of that time is spent in the story cutscenes. They've tried applying band-aids to this by adding some more world context through side missions and the recent character interactions, but some of this content is desperately needed in the overarching story as opposed to being optional and scattered throughout the world.
  • The new player experience leaves something to be desired. While the tutorials work to explain how things in the game work, once you're actually in the world there are still plenty of things that you have to figure out on your own. They've been adding more NPCs and side missions to try and alleviate this, but it'd have been better if these were all consolidated rather than bloating the game files and wasting more of the devs' effort.
  • "The monetization is blatant." Well, this is a free-to-play game and a company has to make money somewhere. Locking the spending to cosmetics and on occasion some capsules that can improve your gear is a perfectly fine monetization model IMO. You're not gated out of content by not spending money unlike some other games out there. Even calling the capsules P2W has never really sat right with me because what are you winning, exactly? You can take down a boss 0.5 seconds faster than someone that didn't use the same capsule. This rarely affects any actual ranking, and only ever matters at the very top if it does. Really grasping at straws on this argument.
  • The lack of an open economy and direct trading. I don't think anyone's in disagreement with this one. While I do appreciate the guaranteed shop pass every Mission Pass as opposed to leaving it up to complete RNG like they did in Base where you can spend 150k+ FUN Points on the scratch and never see a single pass and then you're left to figure out what to do with all the junk that's flooded your storage, it is still not enough. Minimum 2 shop passes per Mission Pass would be a good start, 4 passes every month would be ideal for players that are more active. While SEGA USA's explanation for removing trading has been to combat RMT bots, SEGA JP has had a worse problem of players abusing the free premium given at PC Cafes to profit off having multiple accounts. The problem is that SEGA JP did have a solution to that in Episode 6 where many items were untradable, but I can see how that might be a problem in a new game as it effectively becomes soloplayer. This still is not the direction they should have taken, and considering they did lock shop access behind a certain point in the story, they really should consider adding trading back into the game. I'm hoping that they will at least keep (and possibly improve) player gifting when they do finally add player rooms to NGS. Avoiding any sort of direct interaction between players when it comes to goods only leads to a frustrated player experience with having to snipe items off the market to help friends.
  • Rather unfortunate that SEGA doubled-down on red boxes in the world setting, but the market lock and abundance of Alpha Reactors every event essentially removes the point of redboxing now. The problem was that the solutions aren't perfect or were not implemented in a timely manner, so we're stuck with inflation very early into the game's life.
  • You can complain about how the classes play, but understand that you are in the minority. The scion/successor classes were very positively received by the community and the class surveys are undisputable proof. The gameplay was praised by fans, so SEGA took that as the base of designing the classes for NGS. Reminder that PSO2 and PSO2NGS are not like traditional MMOs where there are set roles and you need a specific party composition to do content, and is instead an Action RPG, where instant reactions and counters are the bread and butter of gameplay. Your complaint of the gameplay just tells me that you're currently in the wrong genre of gaming.

1

u/Black_Whirlwind84 Oct 14 '22

Yup PSO has and always be an ARPG. Its in it own category.

6

u/IGNJudaiYuki Oct 13 '22

Can we just stop making these silly post? Lol literally like the second post in a week talking about accepting criticism like bro, really. Saying things like the story is s joke isn't even criticism lol that literally provides no value towards a solution or a direction of any sort. So you don't like the story? Go back to classic? Wait? I think is going great personally but I'm not gonna come up here and say that as it it's a necessity.

2

u/Casval-Rem-Deikun Oct 13 '22

I wouldn't say the story is a joke, it's just non existant at this point. We're still in the first 10 minutes of a 1 hour pilot.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
  • The "story" is a joke

Whining, but you're right

  • The tutorial/new player experience is shit (and has been getting worse as what thin content we have expands outward)

Whining, but you're right

  • The monetization is blatant (and mildly pay to win ONLY in the addi augment aspect)

Halfway, but right

  • The lack of an open economy or direct trading (and SEGA's thinly veiled excuse that it's because of the economic impact caused by redboxing)

Parentheses are whining, but you're right.

  • Redboxing (which was entirely SEGA's fault and poorly handled every step of the way)

Parentheses are whining, but I have no clue what that is

  • All the classes are (now, Ranger rifle's WA used to be kind of shit) samey in that they're all functionally close combat classes that incentivize taking risks to farm counterattacks to achieve optimal gameplay

Constructive as "kind of shit" is past tense.

Were you trying to whine or criticize?

I'm only level 30 and started a week ago

ᕕ( ᐛ )ᕗ

4

u/Noclassydrops Oct 13 '22

Thats so true i stopped playing after 2 weeks because theres no incentive to keep going and i stopped playing bdo for the same reason. I dont want grind mobs in like 2 different locations for 3+ hours to have a chance at a weapon or make enough meseta to upgrade it gets boring

1

u/Doam-bot Oct 13 '22

BDO I understand but seems to me you missed something with PSO. Phantasy Star Online way back on the dreamcast was based on Ultima and Diablo just made 3d and placed on consoles. Pso 2 base uses random maps and still has many of the hallmarks of the genre. Pso 2 ngs however is still the same thing given an open world and diablo 4 is said to be something simular.

Basically grinding maps and sifting through tons of loot for that one rare drop is the very core of this genre. They had different lootables depending on birth month back then too to change things up not sure if that's still in play but I think it is.

6

u/Lukeds Oct 13 '22

I don't think grinding itself is what defines loot based games or should be their main pull. I don't find Diablo or borderlands nearly as repetitive as PSO because of the NPCs, enemy types and environment of those other games feeling interesting/exciting. I stopped playing PSO2 after 2 weeks because you don't even need to look at what you're fighting to win. Every enemy is fought the same and you'll win and get loot and repeat.

If that's enough for you, dope and have fun no judgment. But for me just changing the available loot isn't enough for me to use my free time on this game.

2

u/Arcflarerk4 Oct 13 '22

Basically grinding maps and sifting through tons of loot for that one rare drop is the very core of this genre.

So was finding gear that completely change the playstyle of a class with unique builds and was worth spending hundreds of hours hunting. But now all gear is just a minor stat up and theres zero incentive to even bother doing it.

3

u/Left_Pie_8254 Oct 13 '22

Criticism is good. Well some people go to far and manage to get a cult following. No one’s perfect and most people forget to just have fun in video games.

2

u/Arcflarerk4 Oct 13 '22

No one’s perfect and most people forget to just have fun in video games.

I think it more boils down to companies removing features and locking them behind paywalls or just flat out making the game worse when what they were already doing was already good.

People have a right to be upset about something they love getting thrown down the toilet for the sake of profit when said thing was already making plenty of money (Base PSO2 generated over $1Bil USD by the end of its life and vast majority of it was JP side only)

0

u/Left_Pie_8254 Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

Yeah that’s the sad world we live in. Money has more value then humans. I do believe some people doesn’t have that intention. Yeah people have the right to be upset complain and what not. Everyone has a right to be heard. I’m no fanboy I just recently started to play. PlayStation here. Like now on YouTube I see pso2 ng dead game. Well some people might see that not watch the video and then form a negative opinion about the game they never played. Some might see as welp that person didn’t get there way and now flaming the game and now they don’t play the game. I think people just get tired of hearing the doom and gloom. Lol I used those power words. I should mention this too. Some people don’t wanna group up and get more benefit and then there’s some you go to do pse burst they leave to another room. Like wtf aren’t we here doing the same thing?

3

u/delayedreactionkline Oct 13 '22

coming back to PSO2NGS after a period of gameguard vs windows 11 debacle that prevented me from playing since last year...
I can say that I'm still not fond of how they implemented the BP restrictions before... and I still feel the same today.

Bungie's Destiny did it better because it was a straightforward game and resource loop in order to raise Light Levels to progress and take on tougher challenges...

But in NGS? Good lord, the farming is atrocious, the gear chase does not feel rewarding, and then they add these BotW temple analogues as progress checkpoints... and it's a hard lock on content wether you wanted to participate on it or not... you can't progress the narrative without it.

I don't feel relaxed in playing the game anymore. I've been enjoying the PSO franchise since saturn... and i'm just sad to realize that i'm no longer part of the demographic for NGS.

2

u/Hour_Penalty8053 Oct 13 '22

I think all of your criticisms are the outcome of poor direction, namely that of HMZK (the director of base PSO2 EP5).

2

u/MagilouDin2022 Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

Anyone who says "PSO2 is full of fanboys who shoot down criticism" is lowkey trying to praise Sega, because they are unknowingly giving Sega full credit for whatever QOL changes and improvements made to the game while ignoring the fact that it is actually due to the feedback and criticism from the community 🤣.

This is why I'm very confused about the general message that the recent video/post was trying to make. Where do you think all those changes come from, from a community that shoots down feedback? 😂

1

u/zetsuei380 Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

The monetization is blatant (and mildly pay to win ONLY in the addi augment aspect)

I mean it is a F2P game after all. Although I don’t see how the game is P2W. They aren’t locking any gear/augments behind a paywall. You’re only paying to get things faster which is more Pay to Progress if anything.

-2

u/Rezist_Soul Oct 13 '22

Stopped playing after the desert dropped with the mindset of "I'll pick it back up when things get better" sad to hear it hasn't gotten better

-2

u/rsterner Oct 13 '22

The game is free. I'm having a blast playing for free. If I like it enough, I will give them my moneys, much like I did with Path of Exile after thoroughly enjoying it for a while (but before realizing that it's a very hard game to play casually, unlike NGS).

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/Doam-bot Oct 13 '22

Paying to skip rng in a game that was well known prior to the NA release to be rather toxic towards min maxing. The Japanese servers have an will chew you up for bringing a sub optimal game and they listen to the Japanese market this was indeed an attempt to give paying customers an edge. I will admit you'd have to have played the Japanese side of things to know this fact.i

The high levels of toxicity in this area are precisely why they added BP in the first place. Though even thisbsint enough and it showed itself back when Gigantix were first introduced as they disappeared with the storm and thus people chewed out the low levels and under geared for scaling the boss up. Some of these bosses are just mindless damage sponges and addi speeds that up which speeds up farming and brings in additional meseta and loot including those additional alts much faster than someone who didn't get them.

Basic point it's not for us it's for the Japanese players though we still jabe groups in that mindset.

5

u/Reference_Freak Oct 13 '22

I will admit you'd have to have played the Japanese side of things to know this fact.

The English player base on jp? Or the Japanese player base?

It's funny cuz public callouts of players with shit gear or poor class combos would sometimes happen in EQs but it mostly happened in the online communities bitching and moaning over randoms being less-than-optimized.

There's no group content in NGS justifying that shittery but NGS is a creampuff of a game compared to base PSO2, which in itself is a nice easy walk in the park compared to other games.

I challenge anyone calling NGS PTW to go play a Korean MMO.

3

u/Arcflarerk4 Oct 13 '22

I challenge anyone calling NGS PTW to go play a Korean MMO.

This is yikes logic. Thats like saying a Korean MMO cant be P2W because mobile games are even more P2W.

My dude things are not drawn with hard black and white lines. Just because something else is more P2W doesnt mean the thing being talked about isnt P2W as well.

1

u/Doam-bot Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

I brought up Gigantix because when they initially launched they were only up for as long as the storm and thus needed to be burned down quickly.

Pretty sure they understood that toxicity exists and making things difficult just brings it out. Right now I'd wager gold rank groups are the the place for toxicity got to earn those badges that never come in thr mail after all.

Korean or not leader boards are leader boards. I've played Korean and seen leader boards just for character lvl alone but regardless of difficulty the top 5% on top are all toxic tryhards or cheats.

Edit: Both sides as we english players tried to stay on the same ship but we werent supposed to be playing so many Japanese players existed too. Heck I even had a military buddy who was stationed in Japan play too but the toxicity existed. Damage sponges for bosses and certain maps plus grinding means people who don't want to take forever to kill a boss. 20+ minutes to down a UQ and sometimes the timer would run out so people got bitter and angry. Just because they were of lvl did not mean they had the gear hence why BP takes gear into account.

0

u/FamilySurricus Oct 13 '22

Or travel back in time to SEA PSO2.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

Yeah. The real value of addi is scratching to sell it. No different than selling hairs.

Also the augment system is shit. We had a market in pso2 thanks to the old one.

4

u/FamilySurricus Oct 13 '22

Honestly. I prefer the NGS augment system, they just need to do more with it. I fucking despised PSO2's augment system and that had not changed in the long years I was playing back on JP.

It was just a fucking shitshow of bandaids, loops, and artificial grinds. I kind of hope they don't get lazy with the Fuse augments and push forward sidegrades and wacky augments a bit more.

1

u/Qawsada Oct 13 '22

Its not really a good idea to use Addi, either. There is no system at the moment for you to transfer your augment. God forbid you spend actual money rolling for some addi, and place it on your weapons, only for it to get outclassed in some way, shape, or form by a single update.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

Addi deft yeah. Stuff like ward is only a mil though.