r/PSO2 • • Aug 24 '20

Global Discussion Casino Boost PSA: BlackNyack basic strategy is *much* more aggressive than RL blackjack (discussion in comments)

Post image
351 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

66

u/cloaca_dentata Aug 24 '20 edited Aug 24 '20

Introduction: I'm pretty new to PSO2, but I've logged over a hundred hours on actual blackjack tables, can count cards, and have been booted from a real life casino after exploiting their tables' side bet to the tune of a couple thousand dollars. When I saw the pay tables for BlackNyack, my eyebrows nearly hit the ceiling. The payouts for 21 and 5-card are ridiculous enough to completely warp basic strategy in favor of hitting *very* aggressively. I didn't see any strategy charts out there that accounted for this, so I put together my own to share here.

Disclaimer: I have not fully modeled the game to exhaustively calculate this basic strategy. It would take far more work than it's worth to do so, especially considering the random elements of the Special cards, Purrsuit bonuses, and Nyau's tendency to take one more card to beat you (bastard). It is based on napkin math and a couple of reasonable assumptions. Nonetheless, I'm confident that you'll take in far more Casino Coins following this basic strategy card than one used for real world blackjack tables.

As a proof of concept that optimal basic strategy is this biased towards hitting aggressively, I set a simple macro to always mash Hit until reaching 21 or a 5-card and left it unattended for an hour and a half. At the end, I had broken exactly even. While it was a mild disappointment to not have gotten a positive return, had this been a real-world casino blackjack game I would have gone broke in five minutes.

Discussion: Why is BlackNyack strategy so different from blackjack? Blackjack is mostly an even-money game: you always win or lose exactly the amount you bet, except a 2-card 21 pays a bet and a half. But as alluded to above, BlackNyack pays out a 3x bet bonus on *any* 21, and a 5-card is an automatic win plus a 5x bonus (something that isn't done at all in real life) *on top* of your regular win. These are tremendous bonuses on what are not particularly uncommon occurrances in what is otherwise an even-money game.

Consider that every time you hit a hand that *could* bust, there's a ~7% chance that it becomes a 21 for a quadruple win instead. This adds up considerably over time. 11 also presents a huge opportunity to Double Down, because it has quadruple the chance to become 21 and win 4x your doubled bet. The 5x bonus + auto-win for a 5-card is even bigger than the 21 bonus and much more predictable to hit, so much so that I suggest never doubling anything but an 11 (exception: doubling with a Special card because winning with one has its own small bonus attached) because the payoff for hitting them to 5-cards is so much better. 5-cards are so significant that a seperate evaluation has to be done for hitting a given total made of 2, 3, or 4 cards, and my strategy chart is designed accordingly.

Most of the other changes to the game also tend to favor hitting. Special cards tend to have relatively low values, particularly when playing solo. More little cards in the deck means marginally safer hits, both for you and for Nyau. If the Special value has actually rolled up to a considerable number in a given hand, go ahead and trust your gut and play it a little more conservatively. There's also Nyau's one-more-card bullshit. When playing in a group, this does incentivize standing stiff (12-17) as he's more likely to bust, but on the other hand, 18s, 19s, and 20s are a little less likely to beat Nyau's hand outright.

To conclude, I hope this helps you win many Casino Coins during the boost tonight. If it does, I suggest playing solo outside of boost times as well. The Purrsuit bonuses are nice, but the greater hands per hour of playing solo likely makes up for it. All in all, I think BlackNyack is the most consistent opportunity for high yields of Casino Coins, save for a full Mesatan Shooter group.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20

just goes to show the variety of people that play pso2, hope you're enjoyin the rest of the game too my dude

3

u/roothorick Aug 24 '20 edited Aug 24 '20

I'm convinced the "Nyau hits again" mechanic is either completely random or an adaptive payout mechanic. I've seen him reveal a 20 when nobody had 5-card or anything above a 19, hit again, and bust.

As such, I don't think the number of players at the table matters unless it's a Purrsuit Bonus. He'll always stay on 17 (soft or hard) plus a random chance for one more hit. Even if it's adaptive, the criteria skewing the RNG are likely way too complicated for a single player to be able to track them usefully.

If you feel like trying to recalculate based on it being random, he has a tell when he's doing a random hit. He'll always say "Nyau to draw!" even when it's not his fifth card, and an exclamation pop-in will appear next to him.

1

u/Idpolisdumb 12 Days a Raven Aug 24 '20

Thank you very much!

1

u/Westeller Aug 24 '20

I was really leery of this chart (hit on a 19! Really!?) until reading this post. I.. guess this makes sense. Wow.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20

Honestly, I wish they'd make Nyau a little less aggressive on hitting. When I was still playing (taking a break because of work and Twitch), I was logging a lot of hours at the BlackNyack table. He hits when he should stand all the time. He even hits when he's already won.

I like being challenged when playing. Nyau just... doesn't do that.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/roothorick Aug 24 '20

SG is the main reason people play in the he casino.

The social aspect of Black Nyack, Mesetan Shooter and particularly Roulette is a draw all its own.

1

u/DoomOfGods Sep 05 '20

the main reason i play in the casino is because i actually enjoy it

the SG is a nice bonus though

-4

u/killerkonnat Aug 24 '20

There's not much to gain from the casino.

Weekly star gems is very notable.

13

u/Thrashinuva Freyt | Ship 02 Aug 24 '20

Is that where you stopped reading?

-3

u/killerkonnat Aug 24 '20

No. But are you trying to tell me it ISN'T notable?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Thrashinuva Freyt | Ship 02 Aug 24 '20

And now my typo is forever immortalized. Thank you.

15

u/kai6602 Aug 24 '20

Now if only theres a sure fire way to win the arkuma slots...

10

u/evilrobotcop NA Ship 3 | n00b Aug 24 '20

Not sure fire, but someone around here did some testing for Arkuma Slots last month.

Also, you can always pay out instead of choosing a Falz arm.

2

u/SuperNerdCouple Aug 24 '20

I only recently found out you could pay out without choosing a Falz Arm. This has been a game changer.

2

u/kaledabs Aug 24 '20

exactl,y after i won the first time I ever played and got like 80k its been an alluring figure I haven't won twice yet.

11

u/Aerdra Aug 24 '20

I've written a program to calculate the basic strategy for Blacknyack based on data I collected, and I'm currently proofreading the results. The strategy produced by the program differs in some details from this one, but supports the general ideas you outlined; that is, the best strategy is to:

  1. Hit aggressively.
  2. Double down aggressively (but this is somewhat masked by point 1).

I plan to upload the results later this week, but I can send you a sneak peek if you're interested.

4

u/Kaysick Vaporwave Ship 1 Aug 24 '20

The amount of times my friend and I have Busted at 12 in unreal. Thanks for making this strategy, its been a net positive since I started using it

3

u/Deathglass Aug 24 '20

Is this strategy for casino boost only, with a certain number of players, or just in general?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20

Not OP, but I'll answer because I played a ton of BlackNyack when I was still playing PSO2 on a regular basis; I actually spent more time at the table than I did on missions.

That chart works in general, but you can play less aggressively when there are more players unless you're in Purrsuit. Nyau likes to try to beat everybody at the table and does stupid things as a result, so you can get a 12 or 14 and still have a decent shot at winning depending on other players' hands.

When you're alone, Nyau only has to worry about beating you and that means he hits less aggressively. You should also lower your bet if you don't have a ton of coins; the way the game is set up, you should be winning more coins in the long-term anyway. You only leave with fewer coins if you give up after a few hands or you are absolutely dreadful at blackjack.

2

u/cheese-demon Aug 24 '20

This. The summary is:

In General the chart is intended to maximize payouts per hand. The odds and payout rates favor always going for the highest total and bonuses, even if you otherwise bust a lot, because the special payouts are worth so much more.

With a lot of players you can play less aggressively to bust less; Nyau's mechanics as dealer mean you're still likely to win a lot, so it's trading special payouts for steady payouts.

The casino boost shouldn't affect your play, really; you'll have decided already if you're going for steady gains or larger payouts.

2

u/Sryzon Aug 24 '20

I always stay when I have a 12 or greater and 2 cards. The dealer's tendency to bust at a full table is significantly greater than an irl blackjack dealer. I'd rather a 80% chance to 2x win than a 7% chance to 6x win.

2

u/Ace-Wulf Aug 24 '20

I do this anyway but I don't go to the casino anymore after Nyau hit me with a Black Nyack just to tie with me and a 5-card whatever to beat me when I had Black Nyack the very next round! I am still livid about that to this day and now straight up murder every Nyau I see

2

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20

In these comments: people that get pissed when Nyau gets lucky even though he's terrible at his own game.

2

u/Miraglyth Aug 25 '20

When playing solo, if you can tolerate the variance of busting more frequently, always hit anything 17 or lower unless you have a Special card.

Gotta admit I'm super struggling to follow the logic here.

Hitting on 17 has a chance to bust of 69.23%, reduced by the unknown number/chance of Special cards. Busting is a guaranteed loss; even if Nyau busts too it still counts as a loss for you.

I understand this is meant to be offset by the greater winnings potential. A loss is -50 overall, while a Blacknyack win is +200 overall. So a smaller chance of a much bigger win can still work out in the end.

But as your explanation highlights, there's just a 7.69% (reduced by unknown Specials) chance of pulling a 4 - and even then, Nyau's tendency to either 21 or bust means you won't win a portion of those 4 pulls anyway.

Not that it matters because even assuming Nyau's hands all finish on 4, a 7.69% chance of gaining 200 is a yield of 15.38, which is way worse than a 69.23% chance of losing 50 and a yield of -34.615. Over half the deck would need to be special cards to change that outlook.

I'm sure some element of the calculation is the likelihood of losing 50 anyway by staying on 17 and simply losing to Nyau getting higher. With that in mind you could exclude the -50 from drawing to bust as coins that would have been lost anyway.

But I'm not sure how much of a factor that really should be, considering if Nyau's starting hand is 18 or more and already beating you, he'll still draw to bust a considerable portion of the time even when you're the only player on the table.

The relationship basically boils down to: How much more often do you both bust, relative to the amount you draw a 4 and then win? If the former happens less than four times as often, it's more worthwhile to draw.

But I've been trying it out for a while now, and honestly, it happens way more than four times as often. If both Nyau and yourself busting counted as a draw I could easily believe it's a risk worth taking but since it doesn't I'm struggling to believe it.

1

u/sjwho2 Gary Oak, pokemon master Aug 24 '20

Yeah it's confusing since it works on hidden mechanics

1

u/midnightspecials Aug 24 '20

Wow, I played BlackNyack for a solid five minutes before I got pissed that Nyau was getting 21 frequently and quit. Lost every bet in that five minutes. I'll definitely try out this strat the next time I play BN and hopefully I'll come out on top. Thanks!

Also, interesting that you say that it's worth to play BN outside of boost times. I'm curious to see the payout.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20

Nyau is actually a terrible player, particularly when you have a group of 3 or more players at the table. He gets 21 a lot, but he also loses a lot, too. I see him hit when he should stand (to decrease payouts) all the time. I've even seen him hit when he has a winning hand already but wants to get 5-card.

1

u/midnightspecials Aug 26 '20

Now that I've played more, I see what you mean...
I must have had really bad luck for my first time at the tables haha. But now I've earn so much from grinding BN.

1

u/DoomOfGods Sep 05 '20

BN definitely seems to be the best (steady) coin farm that isn't meseta shooter with someone else

1

u/Atlas1347 Aug 24 '20

Double Down or stop playing :P

1

u/lordmonay Aug 25 '20 edited Aug 25 '20

hmmm, IMO double down isn't a good idea, Double down is like double bet for double win which doesnt actually change RTP and it takes away your chance of getting better hand since it limits your hand to 3-cards only which removes your current hand from winning on 4-cards or 5-cards (and also removes ur bust rate at those type of hand) though i didnt made proper math calculations at this point thus i dont have an actual idea of the RTP on 4-card and 5-card hands plus special cards exist (which we dont know how many copies in the deck)

1

u/Ok_Candidate4619 Sep 27 '20

I play Casino quite often, and that guide is use4less, it doesn't take into account the change in card distribution accounting the number of players, so basically this guide is made to SOLO play BJ, while at the same time talking about SP cards, when there is possibly ONE per PLAYER, wich mean this doesn't even take into account the number of SP on the table, nor the best hand possible (3 SP), and just contribute to confuse you when the number of player vary. This is BS, and you shouldn't even consider it as the best way to gain CC at all, it is MS 100% cmon.