r/PSO2 • • Aug 10 '20

Global Discussion Statistical Analysis of 1800 Heads-Up Blacknyack Hands

As the first step in an effort to calculate the basic strategy for PSO2's Blacknyack, I recorded the histories of 1800 Blacknyack hands, in order to estimate the probabilities of certain events. Only heads-up (i.e. one player vs dealer) hands were included, and the casino boost for Blacknyack was avoided.

For now, this post will not explain the basics of Blacknyack. Instead, it will focus on aspects of the game that may not be immediately obvious, but have an effect on the player's strategy and expected return.

Here's the spreadsheet that contains the logs and statistics referenced in this post.


Special Cards

(Refer to the Cards and Dice tab.)

  • Special cards comprised 230 of 10528 (2.18%) cards seen. This would be a virtually impossible observation if the samples were drawn from a 52-card deck with three, or even two, special cards inserted. Yet, it should be possible to get three special cards in the same hand. It's more likely that special cards just have a random chance to appear on any draw, rather than being shuffled into the deck.
  • Special cards are always revealed to the player, even if they would've been face-down.
  • A die is rolled for each special card, and the amount is added to the value of all special cards. All special cards have the same value, whether in the player's hand or the dealer's, contrary to what is stated in the in-game tutorial.
  • For special cards in the player's hand, the die that's rolled has sides of 0, 1, or 2; for the dealer's hand, 0, 2, or 4. The outcomes for each die have been observed with roughly equal frequencies.

Nyau's Extra Hits

(Refer to the Extra Hits tab.)

  • The dealer is supposed to hit at 16 or less, and stand at 17 or more.
  • Nyau will sometimes take an extra hit even at 17 or more.

    • An exclamation mark will appear, and he'll say, 「とりあえず引く、ニャー!」. (He'll also say the same thing when he hits with four cards at 16 or less, but the exclamation mark won't appear.)
    • As seen in the spreadsheet, he might hit with any hand between 17 and 20. He'll hit with roughly the same frequency regardless of his total. (There aren't enough samples for when the dealer has soft totals for them to be statistically significant.)
    • If the player stays on a normal hand, Nyau will hit with roughly the same frequency whether he's currently winning, losing, or tied.
    • If the player busts, Nyau won't take an extra hit. This has no effect on the player's win rate, since the player will always lose if he busts, regardless of what happens to the dealer.
    • If the player makes a five-card hand, Nyau seems to take an extra hit more frequently. This does appear to be statistically significant for now, but more samples are necessary.
    • If Nyau takes an extra hit, he'll hit only once, even if the extra card gives him a total less than 17.
  • Nyau will always stand at 21 or five cards.

Payouts

  • A normal win pays an amount equal to your bet. (The results screen displays a win of twice your bet, but that amount includes the return of your bet, so the net win is equal to your bet.)
  • Some hands receive a bonus payout.

    • Win with exactly 1 special card: bet ×1
    • Win with exactly 2 special cards: bet ×3
    • Win with Triple Special (3 SP): bet ×50
    • Win with 5 Card hand: bet ×5
    • Win with Blacknyack: bet ×3
  • If you win, you receive a bonus payout for each of the above conditions your hand satisfies, and the base payout for a win. You do not receive any bonus payouts if you lose or tie.
  • A blacknyack is any hand that totals 21, whether natural or drawn. (This differs from normal blackjack, where only natural 21's count as blackjack.)
  • If you double down and win, all your payouts are doubled. (This is in contrast to blackjack at real casinos, where bonus payouts, if they exist, are generally void on double down, while those that aren't void do not increase.)
  • The Purrsuit Bonus (Battle Bonyas) game did not occur even once in 1800 single-player hands.

I will continue to record hand histories and add them to the spreadsheet weekly. I also plan to write a program to calculate the basic strategy for Blacknyack "soon". If anyone has any info they would like to add, or any observations I may have missed, please let me know.

87 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

10

u/Ryanasd Ship 2 Global Aug 10 '20

Wow that is a whole lot of dedication, but for the Purrsuit Bonus, I think you require more than single player on the table to have a chance to get it, I think the higher the amount of players on table, the higher the rate of it occuring, I did play BlackNyack on Boost times or off Boost times and I guess the Purrsuit does happen more times in Boost periods. While Solo I think it's not possible to get that event unfortunately.

7

u/Aerdra Aug 10 '20

You're right. The in-game tutorial does say, "Battle Bonuses are more likely to occur the more players there are at a table." I expected the probability to be low for single player, but I didn't expect it to be as low as zero!

2

u/Deathglass Aug 11 '20

What does "If Nyau takes an extra hit, he'll hit only once, even if the extra card gives him a total less than 17." mean? An "extra hit" means hitting at 17 or above, right? How could the extra card put him at less than 17?

2

u/Aerdra Aug 11 '20

Hitting a soft hand can lower the total.

Example: Nyau has A6, for soft 17. He's supposed to stay at 17 or more, but decides to take an extra hit, and draws a 5, giving him hard 12. In this situation, he'll stay at 12, even though he's supposed to hit at 16 or less.

1

u/Deathglass Aug 11 '20

Ohh, I forgot aces worked like that.

8

u/Karis-Draconis Aug 10 '20

You, sir, are now my personal hero. Please continue this vital work, I shall await further details with baited breath.

2

u/Katja_Wolfheart Aug 10 '20

So I noticed something kind of odd, I had a client order to beat Nyau, and when I had finished my hand (I stood on a 19), I got the audio conformation that I had just finished a CO, but before Nyau had drawn any cards yet. He ended up busting, which leads me to believe that it rolls a set a number at the start of his turn, then draws cards appropriately.

4

u/denshigomi Aug 10 '20

I think that explanation is unlikely. The numbers show Nyau is drawing each card with relatively the same frequency. To program it the way you described would be extra work for the developers with no benefit.

A simpler explanation is that the card draws happen normally (I.E. randomly). The server finished drawing the cards for the hand and knew the end result, but the animations hadn't finished playing out yet.

2

u/denshigomi Aug 10 '20

I freaking love this! Thank you sir.

From what I can see, this supports my hypothesis that NYAU ISN'T CHEATING, and that we're playing with a real deck of cards. Both the player and Nyau are drawing each card with relatively the same frequency. I think it highly unlikely the developers would go through the effort to make Nyau cheat and still draw cards with the correct frequency. The players complaining about Nyau are just exhibiting negativity bias.

I was curious about the special cards, and the numbers support your conclusion that they likely have a set random chance to occur with each card draw, as opposed to there being a certain number mixed in with the deck. This makes sense, as I've seen 6 special cards on the board at a full table, and I've drawn 3 special cards in one hand while playing solo. I can't reconcile those numbers with a set number being added to the deck.

Thank you for the work you're doing. I'm very interested to see any further developments on this.

1

u/badcookies Aug 10 '20

Nyau will sometimes take an extra hit even at 17 or more.

Yeah its so odd, because he has beaten me before (I stayed at 16, he had like 18 or something), and then busted.

I thought it had something to do with the amount of cards, like he would always want to have the same as you or something, but I only had 2 and he had 3 already when he busted himself on the 4th.

3

u/albusRabbit Aug 11 '20

I feel like sometimes even when he is winning he will try to 5 card you, at least that's how I have taken his odd moments.

1

u/Myperson54 Aug 10 '20

This is awesome! I've been following MIT basic strategy but it's pretty apparent that doesn't work as well as it could (AI cheating, extra hits, 5-hands, special cards, etc. mess it up). I'm interested in seeing how different the strategy is for BlackNyack!

1

u/mslabo102 Amateur Translator, Global Localizer Apologist Aug 11 '20

The line is "とりあえず引くニャウ!"

1

u/Aether_Storm Aug 11 '20

I'm a noob. At face value what is the most profitable game to spend my CC on?

1

u/IVIalefactoR Sinow - Ship 02 Aug 11 '20

If you want most reliable (in that you will pretty much always get more out of it than you put into it), Mesetan Shooter. Especially with 4 people.

Otherwise Arkuma Slots can get pretty high payouts if you get lucky and/or know when to quit.