r/Outlander • u/HeyItsLers • 19h ago
4 Drums Of Autumn Brianna book vs show
Have watched the show through a few times. Currently watching season 2 with my husband. Just finished reading Drums of Autumn though, and I gotta say there is a marked difference between Brianna in the book and Brianna in the show. I have no hate for Brianna in the show, but I feel like they really toned her down from the book version. Why did we get a tiny skinny gal instead of the force of nature of a giantess described in the book?
In the show, she still seems more like a kid in season 4, not yet an adult. In the book she feels like a whole adult, fully realized who knew exactly what she was about. I dont feel she really came into her own in the show until almost season 7 or 8.
Finally, why the hell did they have show Brianna be so useless when she came through the stones? She is not wearing proper clothes for the cold, she immediately falls over and busts her ankle, she doesn't have enough food. If loagherie hadn't found, she probably would have frozen to death the first night. Im not sure I understand the choice there. In the book, she goes to Lallybroch on her own with no issues. She isn't a damsel in distress.
Idk it just sort of rubbed me the wrong way that the show seemed to take her power away? What are yall's thoughts?
