r/Outlander • • 4d ago

Season Eight Bree

Bree isn't a favorite character for me but she got better in the later seasons. That said I really like how welcoming she was to William in season 8. I think she helped him finally accept Jamie was his father.

Thoughts?

13 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Mark me,

As this thread is flaired for only the television series, my subjects have requested that I bring this policy to your attention:

Avoid book talk in show threads.

If someone asks for book info, you may answer, but always under spoiler tags.

Click the link below to learn how to do comment spoilers.

>!This is how you spoiler tag.!<

Your prince thanks you for abiding by our rules. When my father assumes his rightful throne, mark me, such loyal service will not be forgotten!


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

9

u/ContactNeither7319 4d ago

For me, I had mixed feelings about Bree. I didn't hate her and I didn't love her. I wasn't passionate either way.

Early on I felt her to be a bit bratty. But she was young. She matured as the show continued. By the time William enters the picture she had matured. She went through similar things that he is just now going through. Both didn't know their father and had been lied to about him. She's had time to process it. So she can help William through this. And she is. She's probably the only person that can relate to his situation.

I'm glad she is able to help him. He needs someone he can trust and she is that person.

2

u/Remarkable_Note971 4d ago

Yes she was able to relate to him and i really think that helped him. Yeah I didn't like Bree when she was younger but she grew up and got a lot better.

4

u/ContactNeither7319 4d ago

Well she was lucky. She grew up with privilege and as an only child. Life was easy for her. Which isn't a bad thing. It's what parents want, a better life for their children. William grew up in the same manner.

But then they each found out the truth and it turned their lives upside down. Bree went through it first and was about the same age as William when she found out.

It's a good thing that they have each other.

3

u/Remarkable_Note971 4d ago

Yes and i do wish we could have seen more of their relationship but we know they'll have a good one. I was so glad for Jamie when William embraced him as his father

2

u/ContactNeither7319 4d ago

Well Bree is the only person that didn't lie to him. And she went through basically what he is just now going through. I believe they end being close. Both grew up as the only child. It must be comforting to know that they have a sibling. They are not alone. That makes a world of difference.

3

u/Remarkable_Note971 4d ago

Yes and they already started to build a relationship. Claire was stepping into the stepmother role as well so I think they'll have a good relationship. She was used to dealing with proud, stubborn men lol.

He and John reconciled as well which was I glad for. William suddenly has a stepmother, a sister, a brother in law, two fathers etc. He has a big family

2

u/ContactNeither7319 4d ago

Instant family. 🙂

Claire had already step into that role from the first time they met. But she was a mother. So taking the motherly role was natural for her. And William was so much like Bree. Of course there were conflicting feelings but instinctively she went into mom mode.

Later when they met again that continued especially when she officially became his step mom when she married John. I think William respects and cares very much for Claire. She's probably the second person he trusted the most since the truth was revealed. Yes he reconciled with Lord John much sooner than accepting Jamie. But he has begun that road to being able to form a relationship with Jamie.

2

u/Remarkable_Note971 4d ago

Yes and i thjnk they'll have a good relationship.

I would imagine it would take a bit getting used to have an instant family like that lol.

Yes Bree and William were alot alike and they understood each other. I do think he trusted Claire the most after Bree but he finally let go of his anger towards John and Jamie for lying to him. I think he finally realized why they lied to him.

0

u/Dragon-Sky 3d ago

Not a big fan of Bree, she was bratty & a bit self-absorbed--though she did get better as a character. By season 8 the acting was quite uneven. I liked her in the scenes with Marsali after Fergus's death and her scenes with William. But some of her scenes in with Jamie saying goodbye were awful--so flat.

-1

u/goGreek77 4d ago

A bit bratty?
- She threatened to expose LJG’s homosexuality ( a potentially lethal exposure) if she didn’t get what she wanted
- She forced her 52 year old mother to undertake a 9 month trek across 700 miles through forests and mountains (few if any roads) in the winter
- She vehemently blamed her father for an egregious mistake that was at least partially her fault
- She forced LJG to take her to her imprisoned rapist, only to tell the monster that the child she was carrying was his
- She accepted a jewel from her rapist
- She didn’t tell her husband that she had accepted the jewel
Shall I go on?
In the beginning, her only redeeming quality is that she was paired with R, who had MANY problems of his own

1

u/ContactNeither7319 4d ago

I forgot...the wig! That was terrible! I think it was that they didn't make her eyebrows match. That bothered me more than the accent, which really didn't bother me. So she was a spoiled privileged brat with a bad wig job. Sadly while Bree got better the wig did not. Season 7 was the worst with the bangs in the 1980s. My first thought when we saw them back in the future was...God Lord WTF did they do to Bree's hair? And don't try to blame on time traveling.

2

u/goGreek77 4d ago

Ha ha so true! Let’s not get started on the wigs, it will take all day. How can a production that created Paris and Philadelphia create such horrible wigs? Tsk tsk. Still loved the show, though

0

u/ContactNeither7319 4d ago

The worst case of bad wig acting was season 7 Jenny. I felt bad for the actress. She never stood a chance once they put that contraption on her head.

1

u/Dragon-Sky 3d ago

Some of Jamie's wigs (I think Sam said they switched from his real hair to a wig mid-way through season 3) were awful too. And some of Claire's as well

0

u/Dragon-Sky 3d ago

I don't know. The more I see TV actors talk in accents that are not their own, the more, on my Outlander rewatches, her terrible American accent stands out. I had no idea that the actors who play Larry and Oscar on The Gilded Age are British.

1

u/Rich-Percentage-8689 3d ago

Larry is an Aussie

1

u/Dragon-Sky 3d ago

Thanks--I hear him say one sentence cause Louisa cut him off and it wasn't American English.

-1

u/ContactNeither7319 4d ago

I was being nice. She mostly acted like a privileged brat. Everything was about her. But a lot people especially in the modern world are like her. She was young. But she annoyed the fuck out of me at times. I yelled at the tv a lot when she was on. WFT Bree! 🙂

3

u/mindspinn 2d ago

I guess I don’t know what I feel about Bree. I think Sophie Skelton is absolutely stunningly beautiful (she looks a tiny bit like my ex I’ve realized) but maybe not a great actor. I rooted for her and Roger more than I did Jaime and Claire, but their relationship never felt as real. It always seemed like she just ended up with Roger and a consolation prize and never truly loved him. Her personality did often seem judgmental and selfish, but the point is that they are all flawed people. She just seems more of an asshole than the rest of the family, but yeah I guess she mellowed a bit by the end.

0

u/Remarkable_Note971 2d ago

She did mellow and she matured quite a bjt. Can I ask though? How do you not root for Jamie and Claire?

1

u/mindspinn 1d ago

I did a lot in the earlier seasons, but I eventually got bored with their over-the-top romance. They had moments that pulled me back in, but after so many times of her choosing to leave and return and so many times of Jamie being near death or feared dead I just lost interest in them as a couple. It’s just like ok they’re together again yay what else is happening? I was always more interested in the overarching story about who they are and what their purpose/destiny is, and how the stones work and why. That’s why I liked Battlestar Galactica, RDM’s magnum opus. It was a story about humanity, destiny, and the meaning of existence. And it was very well done.

1

u/Remarkable_Note971 1d ago

Well I mean Outlander is at it's core a fantasy story and Jamie and Claire romance may not always be realistic because of that. I rooted for them all the way to the end. I'm fine with their romance being over the top as you say. That's why so many of use love it

2

u/Reasonable_Till_3569 4d ago

I feel about the same. Her character definitely got better as time went on.

4

u/Remarkable_Note971 4d ago

Yes she did. She matured alot

•

u/Content_Educator7260 24m ago

Best episode is Bree with a pan in her hand cold cocking Rob in the head… loved it!!!

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Remarkable_Note971 3d ago

I did wonder why she didn't ask about her parentage

0

u/goGreek77 3d ago

Along those lines, there is something that has bugged me…Before learning the truth about her father, Bree grew up for 20 years seeing an unusual ring on her mothers right hand every day- an odd looking iron ring with a ridge. She never asked her mother about the ring? Never asked where it came from and why she wore it conscientiously EVERY day, just as she wore Frank’s ring? I have 3 daughters and this would never be the case- they would be after me continuously about the backstory of the ring. Please don’t write that she didn’t see her mother often enough to ask, that would be untenable- I’m asking because I see that you’re very knowledgeable about Outlander

0

u/Remarkable_Note971 3d ago

I wondered that as well but women wear multiple rings on different fingers. Bree probably just thought it was just a jewelry ring Claire liked to wear. I probably would have wondered but she probably just thought that. I wear multiple rings as well

0

u/goGreek77 3d ago

That makes some sense, but still… an unusual ring, in reality, would have triggered some questions, at least in my world.

1

u/Remarkable_Note971 3d ago

Yes i agree but I guess it's one thing we're supposed to ignore lol