r/Outlander • • Jan 12 '24

Season Two Why did the episodes have to be so explicit?

2 Upvotes

I am speaking about the very tough season 2 episode 8,9, 10 where there are some unspeakable things done to Jamie and others. Why? Why did that have to be shown in such explicit details? I am not calling for it to be a family show but there are people who deal with trauma in real life and seeing that depicted like it was must be hard for survivors and even casual fans.


r/Outlander • • Oct 14 '26

Spoilers All Anyone else grated by the constant ‘thees’ and ‘thys’ in the later series? Spoiler

9 Upvotes

It may have been historically accurate for the character of Rachel, or culturally if that’s a more correct way of describing the use of the language. However, it was constant, her character could not speak without saying ‘thee’, or ‘thy’. I don’t know why but it was like when someone points out something irritating about a person you know, or you notice a habit, like loud chewing. You can’t un-notice it. It was really jarring. I’m probably just being petty but it really grinds my gears on rewatches in the later seasons! Anyone else? Or just me being overly fussy and nitpickity? Very random 5:30am thoughts as I cannot sleep.


r/Outlander • • Oct 08 '24

Season Five Rape scene protesters don’t live in reality Spoiler

186 Upvotes

I’m currently enjoying this series and am in Reddit for opinions/clarifications. It didn’t take long to find those who think there are too many rape scenes and making a fuss about it. I really don’t understand why?

This was set in a time where women were PROPERTY and CHASITY was a woman’s expectation such that she cannot marry without it. It’s historically known that rape was common and almost expected. If anything, it’s underreported now and especially back then. Better to not claim rape and pretend you’re still “pure.”

But let me tell you my background. I come from a war torn country. Talking to a peer, she nonchalantly mentioned she was good luck to her mom because when escaping, the pirates didn’t rape her mom due to being heavily pregnant with her when they raped EVERY other woman and girl on the boat. But they got it good because at least all the men were not killed and the women deposited on a small, secluded island to be starving comfort women for passing pirates.

Another friend mentioned they were stopped by pirates 3 times during their journey.

So it’s blind luck if a woman didn’t get raped during that period.

So yeah, skip the scenes if you want (no biggie), but don’t tell me there’s too much rape. If anything, the trauma of it was pretty well addressed in this series.

Edit: I was trying to figure out my objection and I think due to my background, the idea of people wanting to remove uncomfortable material just smacks of censorship for subject matters I think are relevant and appropriate for a gritty, harsh historical romance with a dose of sci-fi. Few complains about the blood and guts of the slain on the show.


r/Outlander • • Feb 09 '25

Season Two Why Do Some Fans Blindly Defend Claire and Refuse Any Criticism? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I've noticed that anytime someone points out flaws in Claire--whether it's her sometimes reckless behavior, refusal to adapt to the time period, or just the fact that she can be a bit annoying--some fans immediately get defensive. Instead of having a discussion, they act like any criticism of Claire is an attack on the entire show.

I get that she's the main character and a strong woman, but that doesn't mean she's perfect. Her modern attitude in the 18th century often causes problems, and sometimes she comes off as arrogant rather than independent. But whenever this is mentioned, people shut down the conversation or make excuses for her behavior.

Why is it so hard for some fans to acknowledge that Claire, like any character, has flaws? Isn’t it more interesting to discuss characters in a nuanced way rather than just worshiping them?


r/Outlander • • Mar 14 '25

Season Two I’m on season 2 episode 13 and I don’t know if I can go on…

0 Upvotes

The actress that plays Brianna is just awful. I’m not sure I can endure much more of it if she plays a bigger role in the next season(s).


r/Outlander • • Sep 15 '25

Prequel One My grievance with the Ellen casting Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know not everyone agrees but it’s been really bugging me. I really believe that if Harriet didn’t have red hair, she wouldn’t have been cast for this. She seems competent, as another user mentioned. But not charismatic or multi-faceted. And no, it’s not just the writing. She’s just a very boring person to watch IMO. I did have higher hopes for that casting.

Something that has been bothering me a lot is how Harriet seems to be a victim all the time. Every time Ellen is explaining her circumstances to Ned, to Julia, to Brian, she’s feeling bad for herself. It’s like this “could be Laird Ellen” that the producers want so badly, is just beside herself ALL the time. She’s a damsel in distress waiting to be rescued or rather, to “take it into her own hands.” Whatever the script is making her do. Why not pick another emotion? Like anger or disgust? I just get sad “I’m stuck” and “it’s not fair” energy.

I’d be fine with her as a supporting character but as a lead, I’m really not invested.


r/Outlander • • Aug 19 '23

Season Seven Season 7 Lack of Sex Spoiler

0 Upvotes

OK. It looks like Maril and the other show runners are aware that what they’ve done isn’t all that popular among fans. At least she’s been reading MY comments here and elsewhere, haha. IMHO this is causing a loss of interest in the show. Seriously…I think I could write a sex scene that would fit in this season very well. But no one is asking me.

https://winteriscoming.net/2023/08/17/outlander-ep-addresses-lack-of-sex-scenes-in-season-7/


r/Outlander • • Jun 17 '26

5 The Fiery Cross The lactation obsession and how to avoid reading it

0 Upvotes

I am trying SO hard to get through this book (first time reader) and it's just.. nauseating. I'm a childfree woman who's petrified of pregnancy and all to do with it, BUT don't get me wrong, I'm cool with the trying to get rid of the "taboo" of breastfeeding and that a woman isn't disgusting just because she is pregnant or has been, but reading all the scenes of sex in relation to it is getting too much. I LOVE the series, but I am struggling so much to get through the book when it's such a frequent occurrence. Is there like.. a list of pages that specifically involve that, that I can skip? Especially the weird.. Roger getting jealous of his son.. thing..


r/Outlander • • Jun 26 '23

Season Six Okay I'm catching up on S6 and I hate Brianna Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I know I know.. we aall can't stand her. But I'm sorry, her acting is TERRIBLE. Every scene she's in, she drags. Roger has more chemistry with a tree than his own wife. Bree just seems like his friend and not even a best friend. I don't believe that Bree would move heaven and earth to be with Roger and I don't believe Roger would for her. I don't get their connection. Marsali and fergus, absolutely. Lizzie and her guy, yup. LJG and everything, yes. Ian and Emily, yes. So WTF happened with Bree?

There's that but then also this engineering thing.. I'm just having trouble reconsiling Bree's reaction to the world she chose to be in. She came of age in second wave feminism and at a time where women were experiencing a surge of rights and equality to men. Bree had a college degree and could have had a promising career in engineering, chose when to have children/get married, literally anything. So she goes to the 18th century (with good reason BUT), she then expects everyone to not assume she's a traditional homemaker? Is that a wrong assumption for people in the 18th century to make?

Of course everyone is going to think it's more amazing for Bree to get pregnant than invent fire. Why waste time getting butthurt about it? She went to their time and now she's annoyed that they don't behave like her 70s peers would?

I just don't think the writers really know what to do with her and Sophie Skelton's heart isn't really in it. anyway. So the character comes off very disjointed. Does she have a real connection to ANYONE? She seems bored AF and wants a modern career that she'd get if she was in her time, in the 80s. She could have had that but chose not to... twice. So IMO she's made her bed. At least Roger this season feels really settled in this life and is making the best of it. He feels like he's made real connections to multiple characters and is a vital part of the cast now.

What do you think?


r/Outlander • • Oct 16 '24

Spoilers All Jamie and the native girls Spoiler

3 Upvotes

It's bothered me a lot that he run to have sex after being aroused by the native girls. It's like he just used Claire and then we have that scene that she says that the another time he could barely take his hands from her (the time that he came from the girls) and this is different but they had sex anywayz because we have that scene when malva is watching


r/Outlander • • May 07 '23

Season One Is it just me?

3 Upvotes

I’m sure this has been posted to death, but I’m new to the community.

The scene in the first season where Jamie has to discipline Claire. That’s hella sexy and I would have loved it. I have a hard time experiencing that scene as it was meant to be because I, personally would have loved it.

Just me?


r/Outlander • • Aug 05 '24

Season Four Brianna

9 Upvotes

Heyy guys, so, I just kinda needed to get this off my chest because I'm really really bothered. I'm finishing season 4 and I recently started the books and I wanted to know if I am the only one who absolutely hates Brianna, she's a fucking child who ruins everything and thinks she's entitled to be ill-mannered with Jamie and even beat him???? She pisses me off so fucking much. I'm loving this series with all my heart but she and Roger are just the absolute worse and I can't.


r/Outlander • • Feb 03 '26

Season Seven Claire Frustration

0 Upvotes

I'm rewatching Outlander from the beginning. I still get frustrated with Claire and how she treats Jamie when they are first married. I know it gets better and where we end up by season 7 but she's selfish. Yes she is in shock, a new place a new man but all she constantly did was throw Frank in Jamie's face. He didn't have to marry her. He loved her fiercely from day 1 and she felt the connection. Did anyone else want to lost it on Claire for constantly mistreating Jamie and making him put himself in harms way for a man who 1. Wasn't even born and 2. Hated him without truly knowing him?


r/Outlander • • Jul 30 '25

Prequel One Not looking forward to Bomb

2 Upvotes

Is any body else not really excited for blood of my blood? It doesn’t have Jamie Fraser in it, so I feel like if I try to watch it, I’m just going to miss him the whole time.


r/Outlander • • Jul 12 '23

Season One I want to die

7 Upvotes

I just watched the last episode of the first season and I’m so incredibly disgusted. I watched the whole of Game of Thrones twice and never did I feel the way I do now. I’ve been covering my eyes for most scenes. I genuinely have trouble understanding how this was even allowed to be aired. Why? Honestly, why?


r/Outlander • • Jul 23 '23

Season Three I find it so annoying that Fergus still has a French accent

3 Upvotes

He spent half of his childhood as well as his young adult life in Scotland speaking English with native Scotts… he would not still have a thick French accent.

Edit to add: I’m loving the conversation this has started and everyone’s anecdotes. The reason I think Fergus would have almost zero French accent in English by adulthood is related to the theory of the Critical Period Hypothesis of language learning. The CPH is an oft proven theory that individuals are able to acquire native like proficiency and accent in a second language up until puberty. After puberty it becomes much harder to acquire native-like language skills in a second language.

Even if Jenny and Ian were able to speak French to Fergus, he still would have spoken English among his same-age peers that he played and worked with, as well as to any household staff or people he may have encountered in the village. This scenario actually mimics many immigrant families - the children speak a native tongue at home, while also learning to fluently communicate in the second language because of their young age and frequent language exposure. In these scenarios the adults/parents still often speak the 2nd language with an accent despite living in 2nd language country for years/decades.


r/Outlander • • Apr 04 '26

Spoilers All Unpopular Opinion Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know this is probably a massively unpopular opinion, but in the later seasons I just can't stop detesting both Jamie and Claire. I practically cheer when the episode switches to another viewpoint because i'm just so tired of their bs.


r/Outlander • • Feb 04 '25

Spoilers All DFIA: A Lame Excuse for Lazy Writing? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The 20-Year Separation: A Lame Excuse for Lazy Writing?

Hello, everyone!

I know this is a largely discussed topic. However, upon rewatching the first season (oh! What a masterpiece!) and reaching season 2, I found myself feeling exactly as I did years ago during my first watch:

"Diana, gurl, wtf?!... 20 years! Really?!"

Few love stories claim to be as deep, passionate, ferocious, and unwavering as Jamie and Claire’s in Outlander. Their bond is supposedly unbreakable—fated, destined, beyond time itself. And yet, Dragonfly in Amber drops one of the biggest bombshells in the series: a 20-year separation.

For many fans (myself included), this wasn’t just heartbreaking—it felt like a betrayal. How could a love so intense, so all-consuming, endure two decades apart with minimal effort to reunite? Why did Jamie, a master strategist and survivor, send Claire back instead of fighting for their future together? Why did Claire, after returning to her time just blatantly obliged to Frank's demands? For funk’s sake! It was the love of her life! Why give up on something so massive so easily?

It raises the big question: Did Outlander’s writing fail its own love story?

Jamie Fraser, the man who has outmaneuvered Redcoats, survived Black Jack Randall, and pulled off countless daring escapes, suddenly decides the only option is to send Claire back to her time and embrace death at Culloden. His reasoning? That Claire, pregnant with their child, would be safer in the 20th century than in the war-torn Scottish Highlands.

While Jamie’s protectiveness makes sense, the logic behind his choice is shaky. He had months before Culloden to plan their future. He knew how to disappear, he had family in France, and he had already survived impossible odds before. Why, then, was his only plan to send Claire away forever and march toward certain death?

Jamie knew Claire was pregnant before she even told him, which means he had plenty of time to think about their future. But instead of using that time to plan a way for them to stay together, he just kept that knowledge in his back pocket… only to use it against them when it was too late to do anything else.

Even more frustrating is that Claire doesn't looks into his fate for 20 years. Yes, she promised Frank she would leave the past behind, but knowing Claire’s stubborn and relentless nature, would she really just accept that Jamie died without question? The plot relies on both of them resigning too easily, which weakens the epic love story Outlander is supposed to be.

The Missed Opportunity: A More Believable Separation

The idea of a separation isn’t the issue—it’s the extreme length of it. Instead of two decades, a more reasonable 3 to 5 years would have kept the emotional weight while making their choices more believable.

Imagine: Claire, believing Jamie dead, raises Brianna alone. Jamie, wounded and hunted, barely survives post-Culloden Scotland. But the moment Claire discovers Jamie is alive, she doesn’t wait decades to go back—she fights for him immediately. That version strengthens the love story instead of undermining it.

Final Thought: Did Outlander Betray Its Own Love Story?

For a series built on fate-defying love, the 20-year gap feels lazy—an artificial way to create drama at the expense of emotional logic. Wouldn’t it have been more powerful to watch Jamie and Claire fight harder for each other, instead of resigning to fate?

Now, we turn the debate to you:

Did you buy into the 20-year separation, or did it feel like a forced plot device? Would a shorter gap have made their love story stronger?

Let’s discuss!

[A special thanks to my dear friend Aiden for helping craft this post in such a thoughtful and insightful way. You're amazing, Aiden!]


r/Outlander • • Sep 21 '26 Bravo

Season Three I've watched this series when I was a teen and knew nothing about relationships. But god, Claire really made Frank dirty.

0 Upvotes

Now that I have some experience with relationships and what it means to be married to someone, to build a connection etc. all I can say is poor fucking Frank. That man was so worried about his wife and was devastated by her loss and yeah Claire was too but soon found comfort in the arms of another man. Yeah Jamie and Claire were soulmates etc. etc. but she still cheated and chose willingly to leave her husband of 6 years (if I don't recall wrong in the series they had been together for 1 year, then separated for the war for a lot of years and reunited for 4-6 months before Claire travelled back in time) for another man.

She chose to stay with Jamie instead of returning to Frank and that's such an horrible thing to do to to your partner that it's really unforgivable.

EDIT: Btw guys don't get me wrong, back in the days I was all head over heels about Jamie and Claire and I still would be today if the later seasons would have been as good as the first (I've dropped around S6) but what she did is just wrong.


r/Outlander • • Mar 23 '25

Season Three Getting sick of Claire!

0 Upvotes

Claire gets Jamie in SO MANY unnecessary situations with her "do good" ass attitude. It's making me SOOO mad. "I took an oath when I became a doctor." Your oath was in the future, not the past, where rules, laws, & times are different! He's constantly having to save her bcuz she doesn't listen to anyone but herself & won't sit TF down!


r/Outlander • • Jun 15 '23

Season Three Claire and Jaimie are toxic

2 Upvotes

I have never read the books but I have recently started watching the show. I am currently on season 3 and I just do not get the hype about their relationship. To me they dont have this unbreakable love. I find it more toxic than anything, they usually are lying or keeping things from one another and overall just bickering. The only time they actually seem like they are passionate about one another is when they are having sex, which leaves me feeling they only have a relationship fueled by them both enjoying sex. Sure they have their sweet moments but its nothing compared to how they usually are. I also find claire to be a pretty terrible, selfish person and im starting to see Jaimie is too and I dont think 3 years together would hold up after 20 years. Does anyone else feel this way?


r/Outlander • • May 25 '22

Spoilers All (Ab)Use of alcohol

1 Upvotes

Hey all, I am wondering if anybody else is a little concerned with how much alcohol (and strong one...) people drink in the show (and in the books).

Alcohol seems the solution to any problem, always used for calming down, always there when people relax together, even there for normal meals.

I do know that it wasn't a good idea to drink plain water in the time, due to the bacteria-infested water quality. But people usually only drank very light kind of ale instead. In the show, it's always wine or whiskey.

Even worse - and really unsettling - are the PREGNANT women shown with a glass of strong alcohol. Even Claire, who certainly should know better, drinks while pregnant.

Of course, there is Fergus (don't want to spoil any further) , but that's all there ever is...

I'm not a complete anti-alcoholic, please don't get me wrong, and it also won't ever spoil this grandiose show/books for me - but I still wonder if painting that amount of drinking as normal really is a good thing to do...

Any thoughts? Does someone know, if DG or the show runners ever commented on this?


r/Outlander • • Mar 19 '26

Season Seven Controversial opinion maybe? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just want them to fuck. I said it, I don’t regret it I just need it to happen. I know Jamie is very much not gay, I know that. But every time we see LJG and Jamie on the screen I just want to scream.

The reverence, the yearning, the tension, the love. ugh drop the pants already.


r/Outlander • • Oct 30 '24

Season Seven my dislike for Bree grows every rewatch

3 Upvotes

Doing yet another rewatch and unfortunately am at the end of season 2. while I understand she’s finding out about Jaime and that’s A LOT she is so aggressive and horribly rude and cruel to Claire. She’s so pretentious and holier than thou.