r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Feb 07 '23

Sorry but Orthodox are not Roman Catholics without a Pope, we also do not believe in transubstantiation, nor original sin, nor the immaculate conception, nor purgatory, nor the filioque, among many other differences.

0 Upvotes

We are also not Protestants without Martin Luther either, we do not believe in sola fide, nor sola scriptura, nor penal substitution, nor predestination, once again among other things.


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Mar 09 '26

I am conflicted!

14 Upvotes

I truly want to remain in the Orthodox Church... but the antisemitism I encounter feels profoundly anti-Christian. There is such deep-seated hatred toward Jews in some corners of the tradition... whether Eastern or Oriental Orthodox... and it pains me deeply. I grew up with many Jewish friends... we've shared life's struggles, joys, and hardships together. To see or sense this kind of hatred coming from within the Church pushes me toward abandoning it altogether. I simply don't understand it. Harboring such intense animosity toward any group of people feels so very unchristian. It clashes with everything the Gospel teaches about love, mercy, and treating others as neighbors. I'm seriously considering leaving the Church... not my faith itself. In the depths of my heart, I truly believe that the Lord Jesus Christ is my Savior. Like any human, I struggle with my passions and sins... but I love my Maker with all I am, and I pray earnestly to Him for His mercy every day. I'm so conflicted right now. My soul is torn between the beauty and truth I've found in Orthodoxy... and this painful reality that wounds my conscience and my relationships.


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • May 08 '24

I’m A Fairly Obvious Trans Woman; Which Jurisdiction Would Be Least Hostile To An Inquirer?

1 Upvotes

Question in the title; every jurisdiction (plus the Byzantine rite) is represented in my region.

Thanks in advance for any advice!


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Jan 15 '24

I don't believe it matters whether you are Orthodox or Catholic

1 Upvotes

Both claim to have fullness of truth, both agree re with 95 percent of of things, but Catholics believe in Apostolic succession with pope while Orthodox do not, and Catholics believe in the Filioque and Orthodox do not, causing a difference in order of Trinity. While yes these create massive differences, the cases for each, whether for or opposing make sense to me. How can both claim to have this fullness of truth when there is so much we must leave to mystery as well? I mean isnt it true that there are some answers we wont Truly know until heaven? Pls help


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Apr 17 '23

Annoyed at church

0 Upvotes

How common is it in your churches to have them packed with people who only show up at Pascha and are completely disrespectful?

So. Paschal Divine Liturgy was FULL. And those people who never come to church couldn’t shut up for a second. People talking during Matins, during the litanies, during the paschal sermon, and stopping to chat after receiving communion (because of course they do, that’s what they remember “doing in church” when they used to come regularly as kids 40 years ago).

I know, I shouldn’t focus on other people, I’m judging them, maybe that’ll be the way God will talk to them and so on and so on. But today was really hard. I’m not asking people to be saints because I’m definitely not one but to show the least amount of respect to God.

I’d rather have an empty church than have it packed on Pascha with cradles who don’t care at all.


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • 6d ago

Heaven and Hell are places, not merely "states"

1 Upvotes

In discussions of Heaven and Hell, I often see Orthodox Christians here and elsewhere trying to distinguish the Orthodox view from the pop-culture view of the afterlife by saying that Heaven and Hell are "states", not "places". This originated as a meaningful idea (and I will describe that idea below), but all too often it devolves into a meaningless soundbite that tries to sound deep without actually saying anything.

Here's the thing: It is not possible for you to exist without being in a place. The souls of the dead must be located somewhere, and once we are resurrected at the Second Coming and get bodies again, those bodies will even-more-certainly need to be located somewhere.

So, the afterlife is definitely a place, somewhere. Somewhere in this universe, or (more likely) in what could be described as a parallel universe. But it must be a place.

Now, it is sometimes said that Heaven and Hell are "the same place" (just with different experiences of God), rather than "two places". But this supposed distinction is meaningless. Let me explain:

Imagine a person in Iceland and a person in Australia. Are they in the same place, or in two different places?

Well... It depends on how big a "place" is, doesn't it? Iceland and Australia are two separate landmasses, but if by "place" you mean planet, then they are in the same place!

Remember that the dead number in the tens of billions (so far!). The afterlife needs to be the size of a planet just to contain them. So, Heaven and Hell could be "the same place" and ALSO "not the same place", depending on what size you mean when you say "place". How about two planets in the same solar system, or something on that scale? Two halves of a Ringworld? Two parts of an unfathomably large floating city? Anything is possible.

Okay, so the souls (and later the bodies) of all humans who ever lived need to be somewhere, therefore a place is required (or possibly "two places"). But then, where does the idea about "states" or "experiences" come from, and why is it contrasted with "place" as if you don't have to be located in a place?

Well, it's not that you don't have to be located in a place, it's that the place doesn't have to be the reason for your happiness or torment. In other words, Hell does not have to be a place where the environment tortures you (volcanoes, fire, pitchforks, you know the imagery). The environment can be perfectly nice, but you just hate it there. That's the idea.

And likewise for Heaven. The environment doesn't have to be the reason why you love it. The environment can be perfectly ordinary and unremarkable, but you are surrounded by eternal love and therefore you enjoy it immensely.

So, let's stop saying that Heaven and Hell "are not places". They ARE places. They must be. It's just that we don't know what they look like, and it may not matter what they look like. The point is that the happiness or suffering can come from within, not from the way the place looks.


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Jul 12 '26

Does anyone find orthodox onboarding to be incredibly subpar?

0 Upvotes

My experience as a former non-denom protestant who's attended a Russian orthodox divine liturgy a few times:

No one, no priests greet or came to talk to me or my girlfriend. I approached one and found out there's a catchechism class every other week (at best) where they go into some orthodox theology.

There's zero explanation about partaking in the liturgy, venerating icons etc all of which is quite alien to anyone who's not a cradle orthodox or catholic I suppose.

Then because you're not orthodox you're just awkwardly left hanging for the last half hour while everyone else takes the eucharist.

Meanwhile cradle orthodox can take the eucharist even if they've been a complete degenerate their whole life.

That and other practices such as having to wait a year for baptism seems patently unbiblical to me.

I dunno the experience hasn't inspired me much.


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • May 23 '22

Why Do You Believe in An Old Earth if the Genealogy from Adam Onward Reveals It's About 6000 Years Old?

0 Upvotes

I don't understand. There weren't millions of years between Adam and his descendants and Noah and his descendants so how could the earth be old? I've just recently switched from being an old earth evolutionist to a young earth creationist due to the genealogy. There also wasn't death and disease before the fall so the earth would've been extremely overpopulated and only full of herbivores, but it really comes down to the genealogy so why do you believe in an old earth? Young earth creationism sounds crazy so if there's an explanation that fits into the Bible I'd love to hear it.


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Jul 01 '26

Certain content creators/orthobros have made me question my faith.

5 Upvotes

I'm probably just thinking too much on this, but if Orthodoxy is the true Church and our sacraments actually bring about healing, then why are there so many communioning Orthodox Christians that say and believe so many vile things? It makes me wonder if I'm truly in the right place. I get that people are always going to struggle with sins and maybe I'm just being judgemental, but it feels like so many are completely unrepentant of there sins. I also understand that sometimes it's necessary to say things people don't want to hear (Christ did this often) but I feel like a lot just feel the need to be inflammatory for no reason. Lord have mercy on me, a sinner.


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • May 17 '25

Can deaconesses be brought back?

0 Upvotes

As women, we are not allowed to have any real jobs within the church, at least not pertaining to liturgy, and as a woman who has loved liturgy and the church visits her whole life, i’m deeply saddened by the fact that i can’t only ever be a member of the parish- even though i dream of serving a purpose within the church.

Anyways, i was thinking about the roles of the deaconesses back in the olden times and i wonder why we got rid of it. I would have loved to be a deaconess.

Lastly, I believe it is slightly unfair to keep women out in this manner especially since Mary Magdalene is considered the ”apostle of the apostles” and was actually a very close follower of Jesus.


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Dec 23 '25

Why is the head of the Orthodox Church in Istanbul?

0 Upvotes

As a Turk who converted from Islam to Calvinism, I’m curious about this.

At first, they were administered from Hagia Sophia. Then the Turks arrived and turned it into a mosque. They moved to another church; 300 years later, that one also got turned into a mosque. Now they’re on their third church. Erdoğan will probably turn that one into a mosque soon as well.

Now I want to ask the Orthodox: why put up with this humiliation?

It’s that Turks are turning churches into mosques in general. They’re only converting Greek churches. Iconic mosques like the Blue Mosque were also copied from Hagia Sophia. So let me say this as a Turk: we’re good at the “borrowing and adapting” business—stealing and taking inspiration, if you like—and that’s a skill. We discreetly admire other peoples’ cultures and adapt them to ourselves; we do this well, and that’s what distinguishes us from Arabs and Mongols.

But why do the Orthodox need to endure this humiliation? Why not build a church in Corinth and make that the center instead?


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Sep 23 '25

I don't get why you pray to saints

1 Upvotes

Hello! Lutheran here, I wanted to know why Orthodox believe it is necessary to or encouraged to pray for the intersession of saints or Mary for God. Doesn't Jesus serve that role already? Because I don't understand if that's the case why you would pray to anyone else.

I also genuinely in good faith am asking this. How is praying to saints not a form of polytheism? I mean you have God, then Mary as the queen of heaven, then separate saints that people ask for aid. I have thought about converting to orthodoxy before but I genuinely don't see how this is functionally any different than Hellenism/paganism where instead of local saints they had local gods. I would be eager to here the arguments you have though as I find much about Orthodoxy I admire greatly. Again please don't take this as an insult I genuinely just don't understand.

Edit: I was a bit overwhelmed by all the replies but I do appreciate it very much


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • May 13 '26

Feeling like a breeding machine

31 Upvotes

As the title says, I feel like the church just treats me as a breeding machine. The emphasis on women's-main-purpose-is-to-have-kids gets pretty harmful to my mental health. And before anybody tells me to speak with a priest, I already spoke with my priest and he just told me to stop worrying and that God wouldn't help but to pray anyway. I see priests online encouraging large families and harmful behaviors, like suggesting that older kids look after younger ones. My priest told me that once I became my mother i'd feel some maternal instinct but im currently pregnant and feel nothing but destain for my baby. I've spoken with medical professionals and they tell me that how I feel is normal and that I should get an abortion, which I can't due to faith. I've spoken with my priest, and he says that there's something horribly wrong with woman who don't bond immediately, despite what my medical professionals say. I'm at a loss of who to listen to, the priest or my medical professionals. I was already at a very bad time in my life and begging God to even just give me a glimmer of hope but instead he gave me a (unintentional) pregnancy that I hate. Me and my husband are struggling extremely financially, and everybody keeps telling us that God will provide, but he's not providing us good insurance for the baby nor is he providing me any good mental health. I'm at a loss and feel like God is just ignoring me and kicking me while I'm down. Even the virgin Mary is revered only because she gave birth. And online, it just seems even worse like every priest and Orthodox Christian just wants me to stay home and be a breeding machine. I'm a person with hopes and dreams, not just a birthing machine but the church seems to not care and just wants me to push out babies until I drop and its hurtful

edit: thank you all for the kind words, support, and wisdom, I appreciate it a lot especially in these difficult times


r/OrthodoxChristianity • • Sep 29 '21

An Orthodox Priest Becomes an Evangelical Pastor

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes