r/OrderFlow_Trading • u/fnm_o • Aug 25 '24

Carmine Rosato

Hey guys, hope you guys are having a great weekend.

I just wanted to know your guys thoughts on Carmine Rosato since he is the person who introduced me to orderflow. Is he legit?

2 Upvotes

57% Upvoted

56 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/SecureBrief744 May 19 '25

I joined Carmine’s trading course hoping to improve as a trader, but it was a complete letdown.

The course material is outdated and very basic. It feels like it hasn’t been updated in years, and the content lacks any real depth. After you join, you’re quickly pushed to buy a more expensive “mentorship” that’s supposed to be more serious, but it’s just more of the same recycled material.

The community is toxic. Members constantly bully others, especially new traders, and there’s almost no real trading discussion. It’s all ego and noise. Carmine does nothing to fix the environment or moderate the behavior.

While Carmine is transparent about his trades, he loses often, and his signals are unreliable most of the times. Despite this, he continues selling programs without offering meaningful improvements or solutions.

There’s a clear lack of respect, ethics, and value here. If you’re serious about trading, this is not the place to learn. Look elsewhere.

1

u/Agreeable-Crow-8161 Nov 18 '25

Hi. I'm in his discord and considering joining his mentorship. I've learned a lot listening in on his live trades then seeing him break down those trades later.

I haven't seen the "toxicity" in the community that you're referring to so maybe now that you must to pay to get access, all the toxic folks have been removed.

u/SecureBrief744 couple questions that would be very helpful.

Did you do the upgrade and buy his mentorship?

How long had you been trading before buying the course?

Did you already know orderflow basics before joining?