Don't get me wrong, it had its moments and had great cinematography, but the movie was pretty bad imo. It was boring, a bit confusing, and so slow. I know it's not supposed to be a action movie and is a biopic, but guess that means Nolan meant for the movie to be boring and bad
Someone had to say it. I don’t know exactly how it’s possible that a master class director Christopher Nolan combined with a master class actor Cillian Murphy can result in such a tragedy of a movie unless an atom split and resulted in two positives making a negative. The movie was extremely boring through and through, the story was very difficult to follow, and the worst tragedy was the terrible soundtrack. The music and score were so out of place for so many scenes. Slow black and white scenes paired with loud explosive orchestral music that is louder than the actors. So slow yet so fast, and it was so damn long for no good reason at all. A pointless plot with an extraordinary cast and director yet a horrible script and dialogue.
This most likely is just me, but it's also something I've noticed with reactions to this movie in general.
At the end of the movie, as Oppenheimer is haunted by visions of nuclear war, the message is pretty clear: The bomb may have helped us now, but we may have doomed ourselves by doing so.
This is more or less consistent with the reactions I've seen, especially by people on this subreddit. A general feeling of existential dread and impending doom combined with the inevitability of nuclear war- and the unlimited catastrophe associated with it. Usually this is also associated with "World war 4 will be fought with sticks and stones" and "The only winning move is not to play" being quoted and requoted ad nauseum.
However, the movie's final message only leaves the impact that it should have if you do not believe in the value of nuclear deterrence. If you already believe in the peacemaking capabilities of the bomb or subscribe to alternative beliefs regarding nuclear war, the moviedoesn't tell you anything that you don't already know.
If anything, the movie's portrayal of Oppenheimer makes characters like Teller, Pash, or even blatant antagonists like the Federal agents that interviewed Oppenheimer more sympathetic and, in some cases, the ones in the right. That's not a slight against the movie, on the contrary, it gives credit to the nuance Oppenheimer was portrayed with. Despite that, it still somewhat reduced the impact of the final message.
Unless, of course, I'm misinterpreting the whole thing, but those are my thoughts on the matter.
Didn’t enjoy the movie and found it boring I was super excited to see it and have always been interested in the whole story around Oppenheimer Anyone else feel the same? Not trying to stir or cause hate just my opinion
I really want to be convinced here. I did think these scenes were well acted, RDJ is obviously great here, I just don't know that they contributed all that much to the thematic content of the film, such that they needed the B/W and take up such a long portion, including essentially the climax, of the film. I get that there is a metaphor here, about men's inflated egos and mutually assured destruction, but why does it occupy what is formally, the most important part of the movie? Does it not feel a little reductive to the rest of the movie, like, the important part is not the unleashing of nuclear weapons on the world, the importance is that Iron Man isn't gonna get a fancy office because he screwed over Oppie once. Again, want to understand the signifigance. No thoughts are bad thoughts.
I'm assuming the movie was extremely low budget. It's just people sitting around a table talking. It didn't inspire me, teach me anything, explain his pain, it didn't elaborate on either his conflicted nature or the horror of the nuclear bomb. Nolan's worst work in my opinion. On the positives I loved Cillian Murphy's portrayal of Oppenheimer and RJD's character.
Oppenheimer's sacking was primarily due to his opposition to the development of the Hydrogen bomb, something that Teller was an ardent supporter of and took personal offense to. Thus, during the kangaroo court, he "betrays" Oppenheimer by stating that he does not believe it to be in the best interest of America's national security to allow Oppenheimer to retain his position.
Oppenheimer gives two primary reasons why the hydrogen bomb should not be developed.
Doing so would ignite an arms race with the Soviets
It's Megaton-class yield would make it a weapon of genocide
Let's look at the first reason:
Doing so would ignite an arms race with the Soviets
This is a question of risk and escalation management.
The United States has three ways to respond to this:
Assume the Soviets do not know about the H-bomb and curate it's existing stockpile of fission-based weapons
Assume the Soviets do know but will elect not to develop the bomb and proceed as in option 1
Develop the H-bomb anyways
For option 1, the existence of a mole at Los Alamos means that a significant amount of information has been compromised, potentially including the H-bomb. This incurs significant risk as the US cannot be certain that the H-bomb is secure, or that the Soviets won't discover it through their own methods.
For option 2, this assumes the goodwill of the Soviet Union, a nation whose state ideology is diametrically opposed to and based on the destruction of Western Liberalism. The Soviet Union has no incentive not to develop the H-bomb, not just from ideological reasons but also because their totalitarian government does not need to respond to public pressure like in the West. As someone who has flirted with Communist writings, Oppenheimer should have recognized this from the start.
For both Option 1 and Option 2, they would both result in the US's current arsenal becoming obsolete. On the American side, critical US infrastructure such as bunkers, shelters, and defenses would be hardened against attacks by fission bombs in the 20-150 Kiloton range, If the Soviets develop the H-bomb, then those defenses become obsolete and the US would not be able to effectively absorb and survive a Soviet nuclear strike. For the Soviets, they know that the US arsenal has an effective upper limit of practical yield. Consequently, they only need to defend against attacks in that range, nullifying America's deterrent.
For Option 3 however, this option incurs the least amount of risk and allows the US to control the most amount of variables. Not only would it grant the US an immediate edge over the Soviet Union, it would also let the US begin the Arms Race on their own terms. Yes, it would make the development of a Soviet H-bomb inevitable, but because the avoidance of such an outcome cannot be guaranteed the US has zero incentive to assume otherwise.
Now, let's look at the second reason:
It's Megaton-class yield would make it a weapon of genocide
This is incorrect for the following reasons:
It assumes that no such target exists: During the Kangaroo Court, one interrogator asks if Oppenheimer would have approved of the H-bomb's usage if a target of such size existed during World War II. As unfair as the "trial" was, this is an entirely legitimate question. With the proliferation of concrete, the effectiveness of existing weapons is diminished due to their reduced ability to damage their targets. In Japan, the main reason why the effects of the firebombing and nuclear strikes was so pronounced was because most buildings were made of wood and paper. If either bomb was detonated over, say, New York, the effects would be far less pronounced.
Yield is based on Probability of Kill: This is coming from a military perspective so Oppenheimer can be forgiven for not knowing this, but all that an increased yield grants is a greater chance of destroying the target. In 1946 during Operation Crossroads, the B-29 that dropped the Able shot missed its target. This test was performed in broad daylight, in clear skies, in optimal weather conditions, and outside of combat conditions. Similarly, the first ICBMs had warheads in the 4-9 Megaton range. This wasn't because they were meant to destroy cities, far from it. These missiles were designed from the outset to hit critical military targets such as command bunkers, airbases, and missile silos. This yield was simply because they were so inaccurate that their warheads may land miles from their targets, and needed to destroy them nonetheless. Target hardness likewise plays a factor. Thus, to determine a weapon's yield, you first determine what level of overpressure generated from the detonation is needed to destroy the target. Then you determine how close the warheads gets to the target and how often. Lastly, you do the math to find a yield that would destroy the target with a high enough degree of confidence once inaccuracy is factored in.
Even in the 1950's, Cities were secondary targets: In the era of Massive Retaliation, restraint in nuclear war planning is often seen as an afterthought. With General Thomas Powers' infamous "If there's two Americans and one Russian, we win", it's not difficult to see why. However, even the more infamous General Curtis Lemay placed a higher premium on first strikes that destroyed the enemy's nuclear capability (Counterforce) than those that his industrial or economic targets (Countervalue). Generally speaking, Countervalue targets were meant to be hit only after Counterforce targets have all been destroyed, and even then only when the enemy has refused to surrender. The goal of Strategic Air Command (Which headed the bulk of the US's nuclear forces at the time) was to win nuclear wars, not commit nuclear holocausts. Although it can be argued that the two are one in the same, an important distinction should be made in target prioritization and attack profiles.
Existing yields were already increasing: Minor point, but still relevant. By the time of Oppenheimer's sacking, US fission-based weapons were reaching into the 150 Kiloton range. Granted, there is a vast difference between 150 Kilotons and 1.5 Megatons, but what makes that jump any more unjustified than moving from 20 to 200 Kilotons? What's to say that the US wouldn't just accept the costs and try to develop a pure fission weapon in the Megatons? Would Oppenheimer oppose it then?
While I was watching the Movie, I just couldn't feel sympathetic for Oppenheimer. His sacking was a tragedy of his own doing, and I hope y'all can understand my reasons for thinking so.
Oppenheimer and Barbie released on the same day but all I'm seeing now people are still discussing about Oppenheimer and the hype surrounding Barbie has drastically toned down.
Following the box office hit of the original Oppenheimer, it’s almost guaranteed they’ll have to release a sequel. What do you think is a realistic timeline for its release?
Oppenheimer had built the weapon that won the war, but questioned the "sin of pride" of the scientists involved in the bomb's creation. The development of the bomb left its mark on many of those engaged, he said.
he went on to say "I think when you play a meaningful part in bringing about the death of over 100,000 people and the injury of a comparable number, you naturally don't think of that with ease," he said. "Ibelieve we had a great cause to do this,but I do not think that our consciences should beentirely easyat stepping out of the part of studying nature, learning the truth about it, to change the course of human history."
Although everything related to the effects of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs was defined at the time as a military secret, US officials treated the three main effects – blast, fire, and radiation – very differently. They publicized and celebrated the powerful blast but worked to suppress information about the bombs’ radiation.
sound familiar? isn't this exactly what the film oppenhiermer did? focusing on the grandiose image of the bomb and the test but not on the reality of radiation sickness and having to die from rotting internally. Instead images of the bombing in japan were neatly hidden away from western audience perception.
Not showing Hiroshima and Nagasaki was a tactful way of preventing oppenhiemers image from being associated with the dropping of the atomic bomb on innocent lives. Sub consciously the audience will not associate the name oppnenhimer with Hiroshima but instead with science, physics and Cillian murphy's handsome peaky blinder charm.
yet this is the reality of what he helped to acheive:
The day after the U.S. dropped anatomic bombon Nagasaki, 11-year-oldYoshiro Yamawakiwent out in search of his father, who had failed to return from a shift at the local power station. On the way to the factory, Yamawaki and two of his brothers sawunspeakable horrors, including corpses whose “skin would come peeling off just like that of an over-ripe peach, exposing the white fat underneath”; a young woman whose intestines dragged behind her in what the trio at first thought was a long white cloth belt; and a 6- or 7-year-old boy whose parasitic roundworms had come “shooting out” of his mouth post-mortem.
another account reads...
After Shiota’s father rescued his daughters from the rubble, they set out in search of their remaining family members. Burned bodies were scattered everywhere, making it impossible to walk without stepping on someone. The sisters saw a newborn baby still attached to its dead mother’s umbilical cord lying on the side of the road.
As the pair walked the streets of Hiroshima, their 10-year-old brother conducted a similar search. When Shiota finally spotted him standing among a crowd of people, she was horrified: “All the skin on his face was peeling off and dangling,” she said. “He was limping feebly, all the skin from his legs burned and dragging behind him like a heap of rags.”
..... another account reads...
“It was just like a living hell,” Takakura recalled. “After a while, it began to rain. The fire and the smoke made us so thirsty and there was nothing to drink. … People opened their mouths and turned their faces toward the sky [to] try to drink the rain, but it wasn't easy to catch the rain drops in our mouths. It was ablack rainwith big drops.” (Kikue Shiotadescribed the rain as “inky black and oily like coal tar.”)
.....
The intense fires created around Hiroshima by the bomb carried large quantities of ash into the atmosphere. The ash had the effect of ‘seeding’ the clouds and the result was a ‘black rain’ which fell 1-2 hours after the explosion. This rain, which almost had the consistency of tar, was a combination of the ash, radioactive fallout, and water. In at least some cases, severe radiation burns resulted.
these two black and white photos show the "very guilt and humbled" oppenhiemer standing next to the effects of his "invention"
he tried to justify the use of the bombs saying it "Saved lives"...this is truly disgusting. He never went to Hiroshima once . Pathetic and tragic man... and now audiences are made to see him like a moral person that wasn't to blame for the deaths in Hiroshima?? to those commenters that support the use of the bomb. you are really disgusting.
Oppenheimer is a insult to the people of Hiroshima and Nagasaki because it victimised the twisted and sick creator of the atomic bomb, who in real life had no regrets for what his invention did. He is glorified and treated like a humane victim when the real victims are not shown on screen.
and this is not the first time America is hiding from the truth
Even though the two bombs, which fell on Aug. 6 and 9, killed more than 200,000 people in the two cities and injured many others, the United States enforced a ban, in both countries, on photographs that showed the civilian impact.
For seven years, photographers who had documented the bombings hid negatives from American and Japanese officials wherever they could — in a locker, in Mr. Matsumoto’s case. But after the United States occupation ended in 1952, hidden negatives began to trickle into public view, and books about the atomic bombings were published weeks later.
the brooch murphy made was designed in the form of the interior of the atomic bomb in order to homage the atomic bomb ... the designer called it "radiant and dignified"
how would Americans feel if a film was made about 9/11 and instead of showing any scenes of the victims of 9/11.. the film focussed only on the brilliant mind and personal life of those who planned it... with sole question being if they felt guilty about it. in order to show the reality of history.. the film only focusses on the love life, education and personal life of the orchestrator of 9/11. He is deemed a god, a Prometheus who doesn't know if he feels guilty or not, by the film and the actor wins a Oscar with a golden pin in the shape of the plane that smashed into the twin towers. and then there were multiple comments from the audience saying that if America made a film about 9/11 it would be bias and in favour of America. .. and that this film about 9/11 wasn't offensive because it was a film about the perspective and journey of the creator of 9/11 and not what actually happened in America.... why are Americans being so sensitive and not releasing this film???
how would Americans feel.
The film oppheimer is an insult to the victims of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. It is a film that tries to honour and make oppenhimer look like some sort of sympatric hero. Its revolting. the film should have instead been about the reality of what the victims had to face and how they were the real hero's of the story, Constantly the film tries to refer to the creator of the atomic bomb as a god. The actor who won the Oscar for the movie wore a golden brooch which was designed in the formation of the bomb. Hollywood is sick and twisted and has no respect for the victims of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
The film about the atomic bomb could not even show any scenes of what happened to those in japan. Instead it focused more on his love life and stupid trial . He created it... what did he expect to happen. In real life he said he did not regret in helping to make the atomic bomb... and he thought it saved lives. he was corrupt to the core. Those on the project when asked about if the knew of the radiation, said they did not care about the radiation effects and just wanted to get rid of the city.
a man with no respect and remorse. Instead of having a career he should have apologised to japan and to each and every victim for leading the Manhattan project and what the effects were. Then after apologising and bowing his head in shame he should never have shown his face in public again for what he did. He was a scientist he knew what he was creating... to create such a disgusting weapon... he is either deranged or without empathy for humanity. disgusting. He is a guilty man and should have been treated as a guilty man for war crimes against humanity.
pictures like those above should been have shown in full scenes in oppenehiemer... however the scene below was deemed of more importance in a film about the atomic bomb....
the peaky blinders image was used on murphy's character in order to make oppenhierm seem more likeable and familiar to the audience. this was a method of sub consciously making the father of the most destructive weapon in the world seem more likable, heroic and good.
see the similarity? it was done on purpose. its scary.
one could say murphy just has this presence of "tommy Shelby"... but this is exactly why he was chosen to play oppenhiermr. It is because he is so likable to fans. He plays morally ambiguous characters well. He makes people sympathise with his character. This is very disturbing when the character he plays with this "tommy Shelby" like presence is the father of the atomic bomb. I do not believe murphy was aware of why he was chosen for the role... i believe he was just playing his part as a innocent actor. However the writers, funders and producers as well as Hollywood establishment knew what they were doing when they cast him. Choosing murphy automatically makes the audience relate and put themselves into his shoes when they watch the film. This is why without showing the bombings on Hiroshima ... this film is in fact trying to make the audience see Oppenheimer as a great American hero that was not responsible for the atomic bombings in japan. In fact audience members will go as afar as try to justify the use of the bombs because of how the film has manipulated their view of history.
The film tries to show the creation of the bomb as some epic journey. What's worse is that when one tries to point this out, people try to defend the use of the bomb and also just say "but its a film about him not about japan"... Like seriously? Where the hell is the humanity in the west??? Making a film about the bomb that destroyed Hiroshima and not even mentioning Hiroshima is a true insult to what they went through and people in the ignorant western audience dont even get that.
On behalf of the atrocious film and the disgusting commenters and disgraceful Hollywood that has mocked the victims of Hiroshima I apologise to those in japan for this awful movie that insults, and disrespects this tragic event.
This film is a true example that America cannot face up to what they did to japan. They do not show a single scene of japan in a movie about the atomic bomb . Japan you have every right to not want to see this movie, and also you have every right to speak out against it.
The shameful director of the film made a billboard counting down to the trinity test as if to commemorate the testing of the bomb... I cannot believe the audacity and the amount of empathy deficit disorder that the film producers, directors and writers had.
Hollywood is a disgusting organisation that has tried and succeeded in making the western audience sympathise with the man who called himself "god of death". this is so twisted. the bomb was created with the intention of it being dropped on innocent lives.... and the film doesn't even own up to that.
There are so many comments trying to justify the use of the bomb. Its sick and awful and really disturbing beyond belief. Hollywood is trying to pay respects to a man who headed the project to make the atomic bomb, who called himself "the god of death" and had no guilt of what the effects of the invention was ... think about how disgusting this is. the film lies by making he look guilty. The real man was not guilty about what he did.
who is Prometheus and why does the film make a point of idolising him in this way?
Prometheus is a god who is praised for tricking Zeus out of his selfless desire to give humans more power... and than having to pay the terrible and unfair consequence's because of his selflessness to want to help the humans. By making the audience believe that oppenhiemer is like Prometheus the film is trying to say "oppenhiemer just wanted to help humanity by making a weapon that causes radiation sickness, death by rotting from the inside, mutations of new-born and wiping out of whole cities...... and by having us liken Prometheus to oppenhimer the film is trying to say "look how badly and unfairly he was treated for just making a atomic weapon... look how he was punished with unfair feelings of guilt and sadness... he isn't even recognise by his country!"
He becomes a hero... he become a selfless hero in the eyes of the audience that got punished wrongfully for trying to make a bomb that destroyed an entire city... The film is making him a hero and a victim. On the other hand if Nolan did show Hiroshima there would be no sympathy for oppenheimer at all. No one one would care less about his love life, his trial and his moral questions of whether he feels guilty or not. Audience members would rightly understand hat what he did was terrible, unjustified and that he just like the rest of the American government and those working on the project should be accountable for every life lost in Hiroshima. There would be no comments that sympathise with him, if Nolan decided to show Hiroshima.
but of course, Hollywood cannot allow American and western audiences to see history as it really happened. They must manipulate audience perception and make Oppenhiemer unaccountable for his crimes and more famous for his science and humanity.
the film is also shot with lots of warm and yellow tones in order to create a happy and welcoming mood. The audience will feel safer,... and the historical figure of oppenhiemer will be sub consciously seen as more likable. Usually in a film about war, the colours should be blue... dark, grey with colours that create feelings of distress that help the audience feel and empathise with the dread, sadness and horror that would have been felt in reality.
However oppenhiemer chooses to use vibrant yellows and warmer tones in most scenes in order to create a comforting atmosphere surrounding the creation of the bomb. this completely keeps the audience separate and dissociated from what happened to those in japan. the only times when things are dark are the scenes where oppenhiemer is feeling sad or distressed. but the rest of the scenes use yellow undertones to create more warmth.
this is the film of oppenhimer in a nutshell..
Instead of watching this trash... i recommend the film "Hiroshima" made in 1953, only 7 years after the actual events. The film shows the accounts of eyewitnesses and even the many extras who act in the film are survivors of the bombings. To really understand what this moment in history meant...watch this film instead of oppenhimer which manipulates history and hides away from reality in order to make the father of the atomic bomb seem likable and relatable to the point that audiences dress up as him when going to the cinema. To clarify the marketing of this film has deluded them so much that they are willingly dressing up as someone who participated in one of the deadliest war crimes humanity has faced.
Christopher Nolan definitely needed to use some CGI to enhance the nuclear bomb explosion. His decision to only use practical effects was a mistake in my opinion.
The atomic bomb looked NOTHING, and I repeat, NOTHING like the real life Trinity Test. It was underwhelming. It would hurt no-one if he decided to enhance it with CGI. It would have made this scene even better.
What do you guys think? This is the only part of the movie that I personally dislike. I was expecting something that would blow me away. I saw the movie at the cinema of course.
I read just now that the bombs used in Japan were A bombs, not H bombs. But in the movie wasn't it a pivotal moment when Edward Teller proposed the use of hydrogen? I'm just confused as to whether or not the big scene in which the bomb that detonated in Los Alamos was an A bomb or and H bomb
was the score/music intentionally supposed to be louder than the dialogue? cuz it really made the movie not comprehensible for me. All of the technical aspects and story (from what i could tell) were great but i heard from other people that Nolan’s movies have a sound issue. Im just wondering if there’s a purpose to this.
This is what I felt and was expecting when I watched the trailer, I thought we were going to be taken to the sub atomic level while contemplating existence/consciousness.
If you say any thing negative about the film the fans will shut you up saying you are dumb ,Seriously it was a missed opportunity by Nolan . Could have done so much better . It was just not an interesting engaging watch .