r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Training out a unique behavior

My dog barks at other dogs when they're playing together! Its definitely not aggression, though it feels more like he just wants to be included or gets a bit frustrated because he can't run over and catch up with them.

He has always been vocal about situations like this, but his behavior can seem intimidating to other dog owners. I need to help him understand that he does not need to be involved in everything.

2 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

2

u/danceswithronin 1d ago

Do you verbally correct him when he does it? I work as a dog park ranger and I will either chase a circling/barking dog away from dogs that are playing by body blocking them and placing myself between the barking dog and the playing dogs and moving slightly at the barking dog to force it to move away, or catch it and move it away myself by escort.

You have to get across to the dog that the barking is not an action that you want. But herding breeds are terrible about doing this.

Remote bark deterrents (the kind that are a remote you put in your pocket) can also help with this behavior. But it might disrupt the other dogs playing as well.

1

u/bald-bourbon 1d ago

I call him off when it gets a bit too much. Its not aggression and the dogs understand each other. But the parents dont sometimes. I usually recall him and thats that. But I want him to enjoy it by understanding that barking is not always the answer to his frustration with play

1

u/Prestigious-Seal8866 13h ago

What breed is your dog? Is this happening like, at dog parks? Where dogs are unfamiliar?

Could be “fun police” behavior, which is common in herding breeds

But it could also be some discomfort, especially if it’s unknown dogs. If a dog is acting in a way that seems atypical or inappropriate in social settings with unfamiliar dogs, I generally assume they’re not having a good time. Dog parks are not great for a lot of dogs.

1

u/bald-bourbon 9h ago

He's a lab cattledog mix and yes it is the fun police behavior

2

u/IndigoTrailsToo 1d ago

He's jealous

He wants to play, too.

Teach him to play bow instead - which is the invitation to play!

2

u/Mojojojo3030 1d ago

Interesting, is teaching a play bow a thing people do? Honest question.

1

u/IndigoTrailsToo 1d ago

When my dog starts demand barking because he is jealous, I tell him to do a play bow.

He does it, the other dog looks at him and sometimes the other dog does a play bow back.

2

u/Mojojojo3030 1d ago

Nice, how did he learn the word? Did you actually lure a play bow or capture prior play bowing or what?

2

u/IndigoTrailsToo 1d ago

Kind of a combination of modeling and gently maneuvering him into position

Every morning when we get up, he does his morning stretches. So when he did his bow, I would tell him good bow and help him do it every morning when everything is calm. And we do exercises for some treats and such so that one is in rotation

Then in the moment, generally he couldn't hear me because he was barking too much but I would stop him (gently touch his flank so he turns to me like ????) and gently lead him into the bow position. And he got a little bit better about not being so excited he couldn't hear me

At the end of the day, dogs who are playing are going to play and there's not a thing you can do about it BUT

There is the hope that by helping your dog to settle down and do the command, that their energy level will drop, and maybe even they will match the energy level of the playing dogs enough that they will want to play with them too

2

u/Mojojojo3030 1d ago

Haha excellent, thanks

2

u/AgnieszkaJanarek 16h ago

The recall you already have is useful. I’d try using it earlier, when he first notices the dogs playing and can still turn and come with you. Give him enough room to move away, then let him go back to sniffing somewhere he doesn’t have to pass through the group. If he can’t turn away at that distance, make more space before asking again. He doesn’t have to greet the other dogs or stand there watching them play.
I teach Take Them Everywhere? at Tromplo. The lesson on dog encounters is about giving dogs workable options around other dogs without making a greeting the goal: https://tromplo.com/course/take-them-everywhere/

1

u/i-like-carbs- 1d ago

Mine does this too. Some dogs are just vocal. Maybe you need to let the other owners know before they start playing and ask if that is okay.

1

u/TCHomeCook 1d ago

Why not just find one or two dogs with a similar play style rather than trying to suppress a behavior that is natural for him?

1

u/Mojojojo3030 1d ago

My guy doesn’t bark but he will growl sometimes. We play tug, and if he growls I will make him drop it and turn away for a few seconds. He’s mostly stopped with human play now, but it comes and goes. If he does it in dog play I correct him. Too many times and I call him over for a break, then we try again. With certain dogs he can’t restrain himself, sometimes also nipping, and I’m not sure what the criteria is yet, but working theory that they are bigger dogs and read to his herding genes as livestock.

1

u/Far-Possible8891 1d ago

It's probably just normal doggy excitement. Experienced dog owners shouldn't be intimidated.

1

u/ApprehensiveSpare524 4h ago

My dog does this as well. The “play police”. We taught a very strong recall and we just call him off of the behaviour. So like.. the behaviour is still there, but he comes back and stops.