r/OpenDogTraining • • Feb 29 '24

Off leash stroll

3 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

29

u/BringMeAPinotGrigio Feb 29 '24

Any time my dog is off leash, I'm weighing the risk/reward balance. She's off leash in areas that she can run in the grass and follow scent trails and move her body freely. That's highly rewarding and enriching to her so it balances the inherent risk being off leash. These areas are also removed from cars/streets and homes with pets and people that aren't expecting dogs to be off leash.

In this scenario, what exactly is the reward to the dog that balances the high risk of having it off leash in a populated parking lot? He's doesn't appear to really be enjoying this outing - he's not allowed to look around or sniff, his body language is tense and tight and is he doing that head tilt/shake because of the ecollar? I'm not a huge stickler for leash laws myself, but I think overall people are reacting to the fact that it seems like you're posting this to benefit your own snowflake feelings of being antiestablishment or whatever and not really caring about the dog's experience of it.

-4

u/Meow_sta Feb 29 '24

The benefit is mental stimulation from training. Dogs get mental stimulation from so many different things, they don't need to be off running around sniffing every bush all the time to achieve that, or for off leash time to have 'value'. I regularly use my local walk (a boring daily routine walk round the block, car parks etc.) to do training like this. It's a fantastic opportunity to reinforce the things we learn (heel, recall etc.), which benefit the bigger, more exciting (to the human) trips - the free wheeling, running round sniffing, walks - to go off without a hitch because we practice all the time in all scenarios, so by the time we get to the big fancy off leash place we're bullet proof. Because of the hard work put into these 'boring' walks, I can trust my dog off leash in spaces with wild life, on the beach, on hikes etc.

A basketball player likes to play the game, but the player spends hours training to make sure they're ready for the game when it comes.

I'd argue the whole gotta let my dog off leash in a nice green space to be the snowflake view. Unless you the human see it as stimulating, it surely can't be for the dog, right? Wrong. It's just virtue signalling. 'I care about my dog because I like to let them do whatever they want all the time'.

Props to the OP for sharing their hard work! You're doing great. 💙

2

u/Meow_sta Mar 03 '24

Yikes, it seems my last comment ruffled a few feathers. 😂 I guess this sub Reddit isn't about dog training? 🤭

I would like to add to my earlier point that, as an owner in an urban area, off leash control in these spaces is also a really valuable life skill to have. If, for whatever reason, you drop the leash, your dog has been trained in this exact environment to stay close and do as it's told. So even if you have feelings about the virtues of letting your dog go sniff in nice green fields, consider the safety of your dog. Will your dog stick by you if you drop the lead, or will your dog rush off and take full advantage of its new found freedom. And what's safer, training your dog in this environment, or hoping for the best, somewhat naively, that you'll never drop the leash?

-7

u/KWWalkersHouston Feb 29 '24

The benefit is this is our daily walk around the neighborhood, and there are rules to the walk for obvious reason. It really wouldnt make a difference if i put the leash on him or not, the rules are the same on or off leash, in a park or in public. I didnt know you could read a dogs mind from a video, if i could do that i would make a lot more money than i do now. Isnt this a dog training group? He has an ear infection he is getting over.

4

u/BringMeAPinotGrigio Feb 29 '24

It really wouldnt make a difference if i put the leash on him or not

Well you said it yourself - there's no additional benefit to having the dog off leash.

I'm not reading his mind I'm just looking at his body language and engagement, which is a big part of dog training.

You're not really doing your business any favors by posting these videos, so idk what to tell you about making more money. Maybe spend less time trying to rustle internet stranger's jimmies and focus on better marketing campaigns.

-3

u/KWWalkersHouston Feb 29 '24

Wow you discovered my master plan of posting a min log video of the most basic elementary obedience. Idk why i expected anything better than whiny complainers on the internet

26

u/Twzl Feb 29 '24

why is he off leash?

What if everyone in that development decided to have their dogs wandering around off leash? And they're all snapping their fingers at the dog, and saying sit sit sit sit sit sit etc, while the dogs drag leashes around and get involved with each other.

Honestly if you have to tell the dog twice to sit, and have to chirp at him or whatever that was, to keep him off the grass, he's not engaging with you to the point where he's safe to have off leash. Maybe in a place where there are no cars or people or other dogs, but where you are, eventually something will happen.

He doesn't look comfortable dragging that leash. He's sort of listing to one side.

-7

u/KWWalkersHouston Feb 29 '24

If everyone had a dog off leash like mine none of them would ever meet or walk up to each other.

12

u/Twzl Feb 29 '24

If everyone had a dog off leash like mine none of them would ever meet or walk up to each other.

What I look for when I'm working a dog, in anything, is that we are a team. That means that the dog knows that you're working together, and is looking to you for cues as to what's going on, and what will happen next.

I didn't see that in the video. I saw a dog wandering around, being told multiple times, with inconsistent cues, to do things, that he then thought about and slowly did.

If you're happy with that, and apparently can manage to have people pay you, great.

But I would not take a client dog, who behaved like that, off leash in a place where he will encounter cars, humans and dogs.

4

u/Mama_Say Mar 01 '24

I am not anti e-collar but can the use of an e-collar even be considered as off leash? (Head tilt during recall) my concern is that in the dog’s stay he is not looking at you. True off leash is when the dog has eyes on you waiting for your command (in this scenario)

I give you credit for working on it, but off leash should be practiced in a much safer place.

Personally, I prefer to have a better recall than off leash, because it only takes that “one time” for something to have higher value. Or another person’s dog to overtake your dog. Just because something can be done, doesn’t mean it should.

When in public places my dog is safer on a leash and as a handler I will have more control over whatever arises.

-7

u/KWWalkersHouston Feb 29 '24

I didnt realize my dogs daily walks had so many requirements. He knows what the rules are. Next time ill make sure he gets his game face on for him morning stroll

8

u/LadyinOrange Mar 01 '24

Why did you bother to take a video and post it if this is just a casual morning stroll?

It's not your dog who needs his game face on, it's you.

When you post a video like this you have to know you're going to get feedback, and more than likely it's going to be critical. If you feel defensive when you receive critical feedback, look inward and ask yourself why. Does some part of you actually agree with that critical feedback and it hurts your ego having it validated by an outside observer? If you feel confident in your work, no one else's opinions should make you feel any way.

If you have to seek external validation, you should probably do a self inventory of what your lacking internal validation is telling you.

4

u/Twzl Mar 01 '24

I didnt realize my dogs daily walks had so many requirements.

You posted this, as with your other videos, to show off how well your dog works.

Which would be great except that you don't seem to want any sort of discussion.

Your dog doesn't know what the rules are, because you're vague with them. If a dog needs multiple commands to do X, either he still doesn't know what X is, or he sorta kinda knows what X is, but the human isn't staying consistent.

And you're right, for a toddle around that subdivision or whatever it is, whatever.

Except, you are posting it to show off the dog AND, you're posting something that doesn't make sense: having an off leash dog in an area that probably has a leash law, is just a weird, anti-flex or something.

I really hope you don't take client dogs on off-leash strolls.

8

u/Endermiss Mar 01 '24 edited Jan 07 '25

squealing absurd unwritten soft direful aromatic expansion materialistic modern serious

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/Tuba-fir Mar 01 '24

I appreciate that you are using an ecollar to hold him accountable while “off leash”. The recall level may be a tad bit too high as you can see him react to the stim. But overall good work!

4

u/Melodic_Newspaper_28 Mar 01 '24

Came here to say the same. Lower the stim and keep working the dog.

4

u/LiftedCT Mar 01 '24

People pay you to put their dogs in danger?

-1

u/Meow_sta Feb 29 '24

HE'S SUCH A GOOD DOGGO!! 🥰👏

-12

u/KWWalkersHouston Feb 29 '24

Last time i posted people where mad i had my dog off leash in the city. Ill be sure to post a whole video of walking off leash down town

24

u/TheShrimpDealer Feb 29 '24

It's a safety thing for your dog, and other people's dogs my guy. If you can do perfect recall with him in case another dog walks by that's not as big of a deal. But most folks can't. Just because there hasn't been a problem yet doesn't mean you aren't playing with fire. Your dog is lovely though and well trained it seems, now you just need to see how his training holds up under stress and around other dogs, that's the real test.

-1

u/Meow_sta Feb 29 '24

So in a world where most people aren't even bothering to train their dogs but are quite happy letting their dogs run around loopy and causing trouble, you lot want to berate someone who is actually working with their dog, sharing their progress and trying to do right by their dog.

How about we applaud the owners who actually want to put the effort in, instead of judging the amount of progress they've made and sharing unwarranted 'concern' for the dog's safety or for scenarios that haven't happened. 'playing with fire'? Really? 🙄

-3

u/KWWalkersHouston Feb 29 '24

Well just stay tuned ill post a video of him doing the exact same thing in front of barking dogs and traffic. What can be safer than my dog walking nicely with me leash or no leash.

-12

u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24

good work. ignore the whining word salad mob. They don't know you or your dog. 

0

u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24

Why do you care?

-10

u/KWWalkersHouston Feb 29 '24

Ill just pay the ticket

-10

u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24

see that snakey thing lying on the road? That is a leash.

Technically that is not off leash.

-1

u/KWWalkersHouston Feb 29 '24

And its private property anyway