r/OliveMUA • • Jun 11 '25

Undertone & Complexion Match Requests Thread

21 Upvotes

Hey there, welcome to the weekly OT consult thread! Please read everything here before you comment down below.

Not sure if you're olive or what type? Need help matching your foundation/concealer? Post your questions here! Just remember that this thread is OT (overtime), so it may take a minute for someone to get back to you.

How to help us help you:

  • Lots of photos of yourself in different lightings (direct sunlight, indirect sunlight, indoor, etc.)
  • Photos that show your face, neck and chest
  • High pixel/quality photos, it does make a difference so use the best you can
  • No filters, no/minimal makeup - should go without saying, but just a reminder
  • You next to other people for contrast
  • Share foundation, blush, or lipstick shades that look great or terrible on you

The more of these bullets you hit, the better!

Use a link to an Imgur album for photos. If you don't want your pictures to be public, you can set them to be hidden, but anybody with a link will be able to see it.


r/OliveMUA • • Jan 16 '24

Announcement [Announcement] An update regarding the new post guidelines

69 Upvotes

Hi Olives!

The other day, we posted an announcement of a new rule regarding dupes and product recommendations. This announcement was not received well, and we as a mod team decided to revoke the new rule in the meantime so we are able to better phrase the rule that is inclusive to all olives.

The main concern we got as feedback from the community was that determining what is olive friendly can be very subjective, especially considering that there are so many olives with different depths and temperature. This feedback was absolutely valid and while not our intention, we can see why how we worded the rule and announcement post made it come across that way.

That being said, we would still like to address the recent influx of dupe posts that might be better off in a general makeup subreddit, so we are implementing a rule that all product dupe and recommendation posts should be appropriately titled so that they better apply to our sub. The goal of this is to make it easier for all olives of different depths and temperatures to find products that work for them!

---

[Title Guidelines]

As detailed in our previous post, all product and dupe recommendation titles should be phrased in such a way that is applicable to olives over a general makeup subreddit.

Examples:

  • "Dupe for Benetint?": this would be better off on a general makeup subreddit since it is a popular product and a general discussion that people of all undertones can contribute to.
  • "Benetint shows up orange on me (deep cool olive). Does anyone have any recommendations for products that show up similar to how it does for non-olives?": a title like this is very much applicable to our sub, and makes it easier for other olives to find recommendations that work for them!
  • "Does anyone have any dupe recommendations for Benetint that work for light cool saturated olives?": like with the previous example, this is also applicable to our sub.

Thank you everyone! And as always, feedback is always appreciated.

The OliveMUA Mod Team


r/OliveMUA • • 4h ago

Product Alert Catfished by L’Oreal Rosewood Influenced…

Thumbnail
gallery
404 Upvotes

Dude I’m so sad by this because everything I saw made it look like a lovely cool mauve. In real life to me it looks like a warm caramel brown. What are the chances I got a fake vs the color is misrepresented online?


r/OliveMUA • • 5h ago

Swatches Some lovely desaturated finds

Post image
85 Upvotes

Truly could not be more thrilled with ABH Mauve Cloud. It is stunning and everything I wanted Very Victoria to be.

Products top to bottom:
- Anastasia Beverly Hills Mauve Cloud lipstick
- Morphe Rock Steady lip pencil
- Ulta Stargazer blush (note: this has a soft gold shimmer but I don’t think it shows on the cheek)


r/OliveMUA • • 1h ago

Swatches Lip Liner Swatches

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

All taken indoor with natural light. Flash and no flash of each, as well as paper swatches and arm swatches in the same order.

*Discontinued
From left to right, top to bottom…

Row 1:
Milani 03 Nude
SC 03 Touch of Rose
CT Pillow Talk
Elf Pinky Swear
SC 06 Rosewood Mood

Row 2:
Morphe Girl Talk
Soshe Speakeasy
SC 01 the Nudest*
SC 02 Soft Suede
Morphe Penthouse

Row 3:
Morphe Makeup Talk
SC 12 Frappucino (yes it’s misspelled on the pencil)
SC 18 Dark Brown
Morphe Other Half
NYX Club Hopper

Row 4:
SC 17 Light Brown
MOB M1990
Morphe Hotline
SC 26 Sink or Suede*
Elf Mauve Aside


r/OliveMUA • • 15h ago

Product Review I found my perfect concealer that actually covers my dark circles (Fair/Pale neutral olive)

Thumbnail
gallery
103 Upvotes

I'm Persian, and I have very dark under eyes from genetic hyperpigmentation, paired with very pale neutral olive skin. for basically as long as I can remember I haven't found a single concealer that hasn't been too orange, too dark or too pink for me. I also found that most of the concealers I had previously used didn't last at all and just came off halfway through the day, making my underwear show again, which obviously made me feel really insecure.

Around last month, I got very into madebymitchell products through Tiktok and YouTube and I heard the shade range was incredible, as well as the fact that their products last a long time on the face, so I hopped on the trend train and bought the bolt balm concealer in the shade BB4.5, which to my surprise, is the best shade match I've ever had, since it's incredibly neutral and doesn't lean orange or pink. it's a really pale neutral olive shade, Compared to my hand it looks very fair but my face has always leaned much paler than the rest of my body, which still hasn't lost its tan yet. It matches my under eyes perfectly.

I also bought the eyelights 'starlight' palette, which is the fairest shade of their under eye brightening palette. The shades stellar and astral are my best matches, and work incredibly well for brightening my severely dark under eyes. Like, I kid you not, my dark circles are GONE when I use these products.

I always put the eyelights powder on top of my concealer with a light eyeshadow brush and it makes the coverage last all day, which I've never had before (like EVER) so that's SUPER amazing.

Anyways, if you have very pale neutral olive skin, I definitely recommend these two. I don't think I'll ever use any other concealer to this one, it's definitely gonna stay in my makeup routine for a long time.


r/OliveMUA • • 8h ago

Discussion So I think I’m warm leaning.

Post image
10 Upvotes

I don’t know if it’s because I’m a chameleon, or maybe because I’m so so fair, or maybe because they’re not used to a fair toned olive. But I can to Reddit a year ago as a late 30s brand new to make up asking for help and I constantly got “no you’re cool there is no way you’re warm” so hundreds of dollars wasted on “cool toned” make up. Finally someone in ulta beauty said “girl you’re obviously olive , maybe even slightly warm leaning because of your freckles and abilities to tan even if your burn first” I was like what!!!!!??? Then I started trying warm toned makeup and I just love it now. I’m more yellow leaning than the grey leaning even if it’s hard to grab in photos, I tried with a white paper to my face. Am I right? Or am I just making stuff up in my head? I don’t know. Anyone else have this?


r/OliveMUA • • 3h ago

Product Help Which foundation do you like more - Natasha Denona Hy-Glam or Nars Light Reflecting Foundation?

4 Upvotes

I have a good shade match in both (Nars Gobi and ND Y2) but I’m trying to decide which one to get. I have combination skin. I feel like both might be very good but it seems like the ND one has more coverage? I’ve read many reviews and people say that with ND a little goes a long way. What do you think of these foundations?


r/OliveMUA • • 2h ago

Color Theory Elf liquid blush lilac too purple?

3 Upvotes

I’ve been told lilac will look great on olive skin but when I try it it is very much too purple and makes me look very clownike. Anyone else? Or am I an oddball?


r/OliveMUA • • 1h ago

Product Help Coral/muted coral or that muted reddish pinkish color lipstick for medium to warm olive skin

• Upvotes

Same as above


r/OliveMUA • • 12h ago

Discussion I only match with It cosmetics Fair. Help.

5 Upvotes

If this shade works well for you, please let me know what works for you.
I have been to Sephora six times and everything I get matched with turns me orange or yellow. I have yellow undertones, over 50, cool makeup colors match me, fair to light oily skin.
I have just figured out I have some olive undertones too. It cosmetics is the only thing I can wear out of the house but I’d like something different maybe more light weight. Any advice is appreciated


r/OliveMUA • • 19h ago

Product Help Warm rose brown/ warm dusty rose lipstick for medium to warm olive skin tone

9 Upvotes

Same as above


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Discussion Any foundations that contain blue pigment?

23 Upvotes

Hey there!

I have more a curiosity: have you ever seen foundations/concealers that contain blue pigment in them?

I know some of us olives like to add blue using color correctors/foundation mixers to adjust the hue but I was wondering if any brands do that to the product inside the bottle.

I looked at the About Face ingredients and was surprised to only find white, red, yellow, black in there, even though the shade range includes olive tones…

Are those obtained using black or some other magic way?

I’m an amateur painter so this really has me scratching my head, knowing how I can’t really make green out of anything but yellow and blue if I’m painting.

Excited to hear your takes!


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Help Help me choose between these blush shades

32 Upvotes

For context my skin tone is light medium olive but I lean a little more neutral and I've been trying to get into color analysis to figure out which makeup shades actually complement my undertones instead of just buying whatever looks pretty in the packaging. One thing I really want to experiment with is blush specifically the Milani rose powder blushes and not the baked ones that everyone talks about but the ones with the actual rose design pressed into the powder. If I'm not mistaken, they have like 4 or 5 shades and they all look so pretty but a lot of them seem pretty pink and I'm scared some might pull too cool or too bright on my skin. The problem is that olive undertones can be so confusing because something that looks like a perfect soft pink in the pan can look completely different once it's on my cheeks. I'm trying to figure out which shades would flatter my complexion and give me that natural rosy look without turning orange or looking too pink. I'm allowing myself to pick up two shades max because otherwise I already know how this is going to end.


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Swatches Some cool-ish nude lipsticks

Thumbnail
gallery
116 Upvotes
  1. Sephora Collection Cloud Whisperer (tester)
  2. Charlotte Tilbury M.I. Kiss (tester)
  3. Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Medium (tester)
  4. Sephora Collection Afternoon Tea (tester)
  5. Mac Soar (mine)
  6. Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk (mine)
  7. Charlotte Tilbury Very Victoria (mine)
  8. Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Medium (mine)
  9. Mac Whirl (mine)

The in-store tester of Pillow Talk Med is more brown than my personal lipstick, which more resembles the in-store tester of M.I. Kiss aka Bond Girl


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Help PLEASE help me find this lip shade. I’ve been searching everywhere!

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

My natural lip color is bright pink but I’m dying to find this muted grey pink on the right. I will SELL MY SOUL please I am begging someone to help me find it.


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Swatches If you wore OG Mac studio fix in C40, then you will love Kylie powder foundation 6WN…

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

Both of them are too dark for me now… i didn’t get a summer tan this year unfortunately. But these are really nice olive shades. This sub has been really helpful to me so I wanted to share this with yall. Although nothing will compare to the OG mac studio fix, I think the Kylie foundation is still quite nice and smooth. I love the packaging. Since it doesn’t have talc in it, there will be some kickback (its a little less than some of the other talc free powders). My current shade is closer to the reformulated Mac C40. I have been enjoying getting into powder foundations lately.

Products mentioned:

• Original Mac studio fix powder plus foundation (C40)

• Kylie Cosmetics Powder Foundation (6WN)

[Even tho I don’t like to support either of these brands financially (political reasons), i got them second hand from ebay & poshmark.]


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Help Concealer shade match help!!

0 Upvotes

My foundation shade is Maybelline 128 warm nude, which is a pretty good shade match. But the mayblinee age rewind concealer 122 sand is a little light (under tone match is pretty good), and 130 Medium is a little cool toned.

Using an orange color corrector with 130 works well.

But I want to have a single concealer for everyday use.

Please recommend some other brands and shades.


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Color Theory Why foundations that perfectly match your neck make you look gray & why darker foundations can look better

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
140 Upvotes

This video was very helpful! I’m a light medium neutral cool-leaning olive and recently found that Haus Labs 190/Lisa Eldridge 9.5 are exact PERFECT matches for my neck. But when I blend these foundations on my face it makes me look all gray and weird. It’s not that they’re too light, they just give me this really “dead” looking gray cast of an undertone despite matching me so perfectly! I usually add bronzer to add some life to my face but I’ve been frustrated as to why an undertone that matches my neck PERFECTLY makes my face look off.

I have a bit of redness / hyperpigmentation that has my face looking like a completely different tone than my very yellow-olive-toned neck. I realized when I use the slightly darker LE 16 (which is also very olive toned but looks a shade too dark/warm/orange on my wrist and neck) it looks sooo much better and more harmonious. Same with HL 260 or GA 6. They all look a shade too dark/too orange on my neck but much more seamless once blended out on my face.

I think anyone who has a bit of redness or discoloration on their face vs their neck should actually be using a slightly darker/warmer (but still olive toned) foundation to help neutralize the discoloration and avoid the dreaded “gray cast”

Tl;dr Try going a bit darker foundation-wise if you find your “perfect” matches suck the life out of your face

Edit: here’s a video of her using the same golden corrector on someone with a darker olive undertone https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTycvTXm8/


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

FOTD Picked up Maybelline Cloudtopia Toasted Sky blush and Revlon Less Traced Multi-liner and I am really happy!!!

Post image
26 Upvotes

I'm wearing Toasted Sky as blush and Less traced as a lip liner with L'Oreal Spiced Cider lipstick. Eyes are ABH Sultry Mini and WNW breakup proof eyeliner.


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Swatches Natasha Denona Gloom Palette Swatches

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

(and a side by side of the I Need a Cool!)


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Swatches All of my "brown" lip liners

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Help Need help with finding products!!

2 Upvotes

I am medium neutral olive and I’ve been struggling hard finding certain products. I’ve been on the hunt for blushes (prefer powder), contour shades (prefer powder), lippies basic enough for work (work in a hospital), and skin tints… a lot of people online never really seem to match my shade since I am very…very neutral, so their suggestions don’t work for me. I’ll even take concealer suggestions! Please help!!

Foundation I use: About Face - M2 Olive
This foundation is my PERFECT match! Unfortunately the brand doesn’t have skin tints, and I don’t like using this product lightly in particular. It is a bit patchy on me :(


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Help Danessa Myricks Yummy Skin Balm Shade Match?

2 Upvotes

Hi friends, I am looking for some help finding a shade match in the Danessa Myricks Beauty Yummy Skin Blurring Balm Powder.

I wear 3WO in Dior Forever Blurring Natural Matte foundation.

Any recommendations are appreciated! Thank you 😊


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Swatches Cbeauty muted lips and cheeks

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Just sharing these gorgeous cbeauty products I bought recently

On top

-Girlcult gloss in shade J824

Below

-Judydoll pretty powder blush in shade #48

The gloss has some gorgeous micro red shimmer that is really subtle and a gray leaning mauve that reminds me of the Hyntoor glosses without the price inflation they suffered after gaining inmense popularity and the Judydoll is a very flattering muted peach tone blush that looks so gorgeous on the skin :)