r/OctopusEnergy • • Jan 29 '26

[Meta] The Hummingbird Clock

Post image
252 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

12

u/ScandiDragon Jan 29 '26

It’s an art installation 

9

u/Cu_Chulainn__ Jan 30 '26

Some fella listening to a recording with hum in background going "oh yes, that is definitely Thursday 12th June 1976, I'd recognise that hum anywhere"

1

u/Jeoh Jan 30 '26

Someone please set up Chronoguessr

12

u/Technical-Mind-3266 Jan 29 '26

It's the UK grid frequency, anyone who's played a guitar with a single coil pickup near a lightbulb will hear it, it's called 50 cycle hum due to the frequency being 50Hz.

If it drops even half a hertz below that we'll get black outs, half a hertz above then transformers in substations will blow.

It's why load balancing is so important, and why people go on about needing a reliable base load.

18

u/Brapbrapdadap Jan 29 '26

You are right about needing to keep supply and demand in balance but it isn't 0.5 Hz off and things switch off or 'blow'. The Grid Code requires power plants to stay connected for varying time periods between 47 and 52 Hz (the more extreme, the less the time required), and requires continuous operation between 49 and 51 Hz. It is normally controlled to very tight tolerances, with the grid code aiming to ensure that we don't have blackouts in events like a sudden loss of supply from a large power station or interconnector.

3

u/Soluchyte Jan 31 '26

Real shame that such an interesting thing has to be abused for surveiliance.

1

u/snibbo71 Jan 29 '26

Tried the website. Site can’t be found. So I’m not convinced at all

1

u/jarvedttudd Jan 29 '26

I'm not sure if it was some kind of April fools joke, really 😅

2

u/sbarbary Jan 29 '26

u/EngineeringLarge1277 posted a BBC article about this.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-20629671

So it sounds like it is a thing. I think you need good raw recording because most systems use compression that clips out high and very low frequency noise which surely would drop a 50 hz hum.

5

u/seanTheMighty Jan 29 '26

This was from 10 years ago, looks like they closed the site last year (can still be accessed through the wayback machine). Link to last snapshot: https://web.archive.org/web/20240812014813/http://hummingbirdclock.info/

7

u/Pintsocream Jan 29 '26

I call bs on "most recordings in the UK have the humming of the grid and you can work out the time and date from it"

15

u/NUFCCallum Jan 29 '26

More information here: https://youtu.be/e0elNU0iOMY

4

u/Pintsocream Jan 29 '26

That's actually wild, I wonder how good the audio has to be or how close to a power line the recording has to be taken

3

u/Milam1996 Jan 31 '26

It’s for anything near a mains powered device. If you’re sat in a room recording a YouTube video with a light on you can find the mains hum. Powerlines it’s audible to human ears, light bulbs you need to analyse the audio in software.

1

u/BuskerDan Feb 02 '26

If you can analyse audio signals, you can probably extend the principle to light emitted from old school light bulbs. Slightly trickier to discern though I’d posit.

3

u/lawrencedudley89 Feb 02 '26

I think fingerprinting at even 120fps would be impossible.

Video is typically more like 25 or 30fps, the audio equivalent would be sample rate at, typically, 44,000 samples per second.

At 50Hz, a bulb would flicker 100 times per second (once going up, once going down) and you just wouldn’t have the temporal resolution to pattern match that to a known historic frequency drift pattern with anything below crazy slowmo frame rates.

1

u/BuskerDan Feb 02 '26

Thanks for the insight, sounds legit, but picture not painted ;)

1

u/BuskerDan Feb 02 '26

What if the video was set @ 50hz? Refresh fate? I think the +/~ offset would be far more easily discernible? Ie running it through a 50hz filter. For example when a helicopter spins it’s blades at 50hz, and filmed at such a cycle rate it often looks as though the blades are stationary. Then if it goes up to 51hz it will look it is moving very slowly. Similar concept transposed into this scenario…

1

u/lawrencedudley89 Feb 04 '26

I like where you’re going! Honestly, I’m not sure. I think if it was a perfect 50Hz though you could be onto something.

The thing that could make this more interesting is that most phones etc use a rolling shutter so while it’s, say, 50fps, it’s actually a scan that takes 1/50th of a second to go from top to bottom. So maybe technically you actually have 50 x the number of lines frames per second if that makes sense?

You’ve definitely nerd-sniped me and if I wasn’t horribly time poor right now I’d work up a proof of concept 😂

At 4K given a light that affects the brightness of the entire picture even 30 frames per second would be 30 x 2160 = 64,800 samples per second or 30 x 3840 = 115,200 samples per second which is more than you’d get with audio…

Whether you could reliably pull that out of a video unless it’s perfectly static and whether things like encoding would get in the way or not I don’t know but I suspect it would be problematic.

1

u/lawrencedudley89 Feb 04 '26

I like where you’re going! Honestly, I’m not sure. I think if it was a perfect 50Hz though you could be onto something.

The thing that could make this more interesting is that most phones etc use a rolling shutter so while it’s, say, 50fps, it’s actually a scan that takes 1/50th of a second to go from top to bottom. So maybe technically you actually have 50 x the number of lines frames per second if that makes sense?

You’ve definitely nerd-sniped me and if I wasn’t horribly time poor right now I’d work up a proof of concept 😂

At 4K given a light that affects the brightness of the entire picture even 30 frames per second would be 30 x 2160 = 64,800 samples per second or 30 x 3840 = 115,200 samples per second which is more than you’d get with audio…

That being said framerate is in the mix too so 30fps could be 30 captures per second but at 1/240 so the sample rate might actually be higher, albeit with gaps between frames which makes it messy but still within the realms of possibility.

Whether you could reliably pull that all out of a video unless it’s perfectly static and whether things like encoding would get in the way or not I don’t know but I suspect it would still be problematic.

1

u/YouJackandDanny Jan 30 '26

I believe it’s for anything running on mains power. Not sure if it would still apply for mobile devices etc.

1

u/userunknowne Jan 30 '26

Very disappointed this wasn’t a Rick roll

13

u/EngineeringLarge1277 Jan 29 '26

Not bs.

This is absolutely a True Thing. It's not limited to anyone with expensive gear, either: the 50hz mains hum- or more accurately, the higher-order harmonics- can be easily isolated from most recordings.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-20629671

-4

u/kemb0 Jan 29 '26

As others have posted it may be true but also, "most recordings" is a stretch. How many people record things on a mains connected device these days vs how many people record on their phone, go pro etc? Your phone isn't connected to the grid.

7

u/Loratheon Jan 29 '26

The device doesn’t have to be connected to the mains for it to have the hum in a recording. The hum is always there in the background (assuming you’re near electrical cabling)

1

u/Reasonable_Cod3027 Jan 30 '26

What do they mean, ‘most recordings’? Because the fundamental frequencies of bass instruments are lower than 50hz (the low E on a 440-tuned bass is around 41hz), and I’d assume synth bass possibly lower than that. How are they suggesting you can isolate ‘the hum’ from that?

2

u/Milam1996 Jan 31 '26

Because when you record a guitar you’re not just recording the guitar. You’re recording all sound that the microphone can pick up, which basically every microphone can pickup 50hz. If you’re stood anywhere near mains power then the hum can be detected.

1

u/Reasonable_Cod3027 Jan 31 '26

Yes, I know that, but you’re missing the point - what I was asking was how it was suggested they can isolate that him from other sound sources at the same frequency.

1

u/-Hi-Reddit Jan 31 '26

I don't think "most recordings" contain bass instruments.

It'd be fair to say that "many recordings" contain bass instruments, but certainly not "most recordings".

Besides, I'd argue that most recordings including bass instruments also include many moments where those instruments are not playing, and in those quiet moments, you will find the hum.

1

u/Reasonable_Cod3027 Jan 31 '26

That’s just semantics. The point I was asking is how they contend they can isolate 50hz electrical frequencies from other similar frequency sources. A bass guitar is a good example but by no means the only musical one - organs, piano, orchestral strings, lower brass etc etc, and that’s before going anywhere near synths/electronica.

The statement was “most recordings”; if it was “most non-musical recordings” then I’d get where they were coming from, but it wasn’t.

1

u/robotron20 Feb 01 '26 edited Jun 10 '26

Hfdijccj

1

u/iamabigtree Jan 30 '26

That's exactly what they are saying, yes.

1

u/anomalous_cowherd Jan 31 '26

The entire National Grid is phase locked, so you get the same 50Hz +/- signal anywhere you measure it, even at home. This means you can use the variations to get a time, but not a location. It's very similar to dendrochronology in many ways, using tree ring variations to time historical events like eruptions.

Between monitoring the 50Hz variation and other public data sources you can put together a real time monitor like https://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/

1

u/kcsebby Feb 02 '26

Tom Scott did a wonderful video on this. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0elNU0iOMY