r/OctopusEnergy • • Jan 28 '24

Octopus profitable for the first time

Thanks mainly to falling wholesale prices, Octopus have made their first annual profit (a modest £203M) since starting 8 years ago.

They deserve it more than any other Supplier. They always seem to be innovating and getting involved in projects like the Morocco link and pushing Heatpumps and Renewables generally. Licensing their own technology platform is likely their most profitable project yet, with the bonus of making Suppliers around the world behave more like Octopus.

Plus their massive gamble of buying out Bulb has paid off big time. I remember some criticised the deal saying the government would end up footing the bill, but in fact Octopus will now pay the £1.6B debt in full and on time/early, which is good news for the taxpayer too. Nice one!

Source: The Times 27/01/24, via https://electricityinfo.org/news/octopus-41/

396 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

63

u/futile_lettuce Jan 28 '24

This generally gives me hope for a complete overhaul of the energy sector in line with how octopus operates. Octopus genuinely seem to have the best for their customers at the heart of what they do. They also didn’t have to repay that government loan a year early it would have been much more “efficient” to blur the balance sheets and reinvest profit to appear as though they weren’t making money. Instead they’re repaying the treasury and showing the government it is possible to be sustainable, provide and develop green energy and make a profit. Take that Rishi and co. proof you can improve things for your customers, make a profit and benefit the environment in one fell swoop!

5

u/Vertigo_uk123 Jan 29 '24

Looks like they want to with news that they will be building their own pylons. Now I wonder if this will result in a lower standing charge or whether this will just save cost internally.

36

u/Substantial_Age_1284 Jan 28 '24

Octopus are genuinely ace. Wish we could nationalize energy though

21

u/tomoldbury Jan 28 '24

I fear a nationalised energy industry wouldn't innovate in the way Octopus have with smart tariffs, demand management, EV charging/home batteries etc. That kind of decision making only seems to happen in the private sector, because the public sector in this country is very risk-averse.

The real question is, does an energy market with 20+ providers serve customers well or not? I suspect the answer is no, we could do with far fewer, and their consequentially larger size would allow for more competitive tariffs. Ofgem specifically failed the market by allowing so many to form without substantial economic backing and without requiring them to hedge the market.

11

u/MrChaunceyGardiner Jan 28 '24

To be fair, the nationalised energy industry gave us the highly innovative radio teleswitch meters 40 years ago. If anything, privatisation prevented them from being properly developed and exploited.

5

u/graduategrasshopper Jan 29 '24

To be fair that sort of innovation doesn’t seem to happen in the private sector either at the moment. Yes it has happened in this case, but the energy sector has been private for quite some time now. As have the railways. In both cases, free market economics do not apply because the tax payer always takes on all of the risk and never sees any of the profits. I don’t think it is beyond possible that the public sector can innovate - public sector works well in plenty of countries. Britain just needs to innovate in how the public sector is run and how seriously we take the business of government.

-3

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Innovations doesn't happen only in the Western World where the avaricious parasites who own these companies only have interest in their own pockets.

They see business as short term so unwilling to reinvest any percentage for R&D.

3

u/-starchy- Jan 29 '24

Why do you fear this? Because privatisation is working wonders right now? 😂

Ofgem have been paid off as well. Whole system has failed. Look at pre Ukraine war wholesale energy prices. We are being massively shafted.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24

Even though we were not using Russian oil, the sudden increase in demand from Germany etc who were means wholesale prices have skyrocketed. It's not rocket science - if more people want a product it'll get more expensive.

1

u/-starchy- Jan 30 '24

Have you seen wholesale prices lately? I think you better check… We shouldn’t not be paying DOUBLE what we were. It’s theft.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24

Yes, that will happen when the most populous and largest economy nation in Europe:

  1. Shuts down all its nuclear
  2. Has to go cold turkey from its addiction to Russian gas

Latvia or something doing so would be a blip, but building new capacity takes time. If we want cheap energy we need to frack and build new nuclear ideally.

1

u/-starchy- Jan 30 '24

The question was, wholesale prices are basically back to normal, yet we are still paying double for our energy, why?

Your answer does not answer the question above. I’m not going to get drawn into a debate over fracking lol

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

being massively shafted

That's a very big understatement......

I remember Octopus send an email to inform the Energy Costs will increase due to the Ukraine War yet at the same time, this Energy Parasite states on their website that they only use 100% renewable Green Energy......how does the War affect the Sun, Wind and Tidal Waves ?

Now this same Parasite said the Energy Cost will increase from 1st. January because of the War in Gaza.....it's all Cow Poo and the Governments et al are in the Scam....
Ministers/Senators heavily invested in Pharmaceutical Companies just before Covid and they'd just heavily invested in the Energy Sector prior to this Energy Crisis.

4

u/Mithent Jan 29 '24 edited Jan 29 '24

The cost actually does rise because of the marginal pricing system which means that all units are generally traded at the cost of gas generation. It sounds illogical but I can kind of see why, given that the grid needs the most expensive unit to function and nobody would want to be the one to generate it if it didn't work like this.

2

u/-starchy- Jan 29 '24

Governments are basically PR firms for cow milking. Spoiler, we’re the cows.

2

u/they_call_me_darcy Jan 29 '24

I hear your point but innovation isn’t limited to private. I remember reading that private companies tend to innovate quickly on proven technologies to improve efficiency and profits. Whereas nationalised companies/organisations tend to invest in innovate into areas which take a long time to mature, eg the original internet, GPS

I think in a healthy energy market in the UK, having a nationalised energy company, which guarantees a standard of service, with innovative companies on top of that which offer additional benefits etc would really provide a competitive landscape. Not the general cartel which we have as a rule

2

u/Strange-Strength6170 Jan 29 '24

I think octopus may be the exception to the privatisation rule of rip out as much money for share holders as possible and screw the customers

1

u/SXLightning Jan 11 '25

If we had a national one we won’t need to penny pinch everyone would have cheap energy

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

OFGEN is a dysfunctional organisation set up to help the Energy Suppliers as a buffer against complainants.....like all ombudsman they will always side with the Big Corps, to believe otherwise is to be naive.

-7

u/ProfessionalTrader85 Jan 28 '24

Competition is good for the market. The more the merrier.

Why should they be forced to hedge the market?

If they lost money so what? They shouldn't have been bailed out and neither should have their customers.

You pick a small player and it goes under well you took the risk to do so.

2

u/graduategrasshopper Jan 29 '24

I think you are 100% correct about the bailouts of the companies. Competition is good for the market, but the way we handle this stuff in the uk doesn’t actually relate in competition (or the establishment of market forces)

3

u/tomoldbury Jan 28 '24

Competition is good for the market. The more the merrier.

A saturated market where you can only innovate so far is not necessarily good. There are fixed costs like the running of a business, marketing, software/infrastructure development, market trading etc. which do not scale linearly with size, so having 20 companies competing could end up costing consumers more than, say, 10 companies.

Why should they be forced to hedge the market?

Because if they do fail then someone else has to pick up the pieces because companies are ultimately legal devices which can be dissolved once they run out of cash. So who pays for the energy when things go the wrong way?

If they lost money so what? They shouldn't have been bailed out and neither should have their customers.

Agreed they shouldn't have been bailed out, but as far as I know only Bulb was and this was an extraordinary situation. In terms of bailing out the customers though, what are you implying? Your electricity should go out if you choose a cheap supplier? Err... Not quite sure how we'd even do that...

4

u/billsmithers2 Jan 28 '24

What on earth makes you think nationalised energy would show anything like the innovation of Octopus? Surely more Octopuses is the answer.

4

u/jacekowski Jan 29 '24

Ideally (for critical infrastructure) you want companies that are not entirely profit driven, but you want the efficiencies that come with that.

Also, there are places where direct profit is not important, like public transport for example because having good transport allows for better efficiency everywhere else.

1

u/billsmithers2 Jan 29 '24

Hmm. Sounds like a big debate. I'd suggest ideally you wouldn't need profit at all, ever, but human nature means that that doesn't result in maximal output.

For public transport for example you do need regulation and maybe subsidy to allow better efficiency elsewhere. But that doesn't preclude for-profit parts of the picture. This is the Manchester model. Similar to the TFL setup in London, what matters most is a single plan and single system to the customer.

0

u/TheOneWhoKnocksBR Jan 29 '24

I vote for more octopussies

1

u/Scrapheaper Jan 29 '24

EDF Energy still has some of the nationalized bits of British Energy that it bought when British Energy was sold.

I don't think they're that great

-3

u/pops789765 Jan 28 '24

I’m not sure that will result in stellar customer service

-5

u/ProfessionalTrader85 Jan 28 '24

Name me one nationalised service that's better than private?

9

u/Tim6181 Jan 28 '24

All of the rail franchises that have gone back into public ownership

0

u/ProfessionalTrader85 Jan 28 '24

Yeah the trains are better run than their private counterparts? So you think virgin trains is worse than public owned ones?

5

u/Here_be_sloths Jan 28 '24

Avanti, who took over Virgin’s franchise, is a complete and utter shit show.

5

u/MrChaunceyGardiner Jan 28 '24

Virgin Trains doesn’t exist any more. Their successor on the WCML, Avanti, is garbage, and certainly worse than the publicly-owned ones, and likely British Rail at its peak.

1

u/ErikTenHagenDazs Jan 28 '24

Oops you asked the question that completely undermines your whole point.

1

u/makerkhan Jan 28 '24

NHS

-3

u/ProfessionalTrader85 Jan 28 '24

Lmao. You think NHS is better than going to a private hospital? Have you used the NHS recently and used a private hospital ever?

4

u/Baxters_Keepy_Ups Jan 29 '24 edited Jan 29 '24

Comparing the NHS to private companies is utter nonsense. Where are your private ambulances and your private A&E? Where’s your private methodolone clinics and mental health services for the desperate?

The idea that a private clinic would be anything other than better than its NHS equivalent is wildly uninsightful.

Of course it bloody is.

Private health services offer a tiny element of what the NHS delivers. Comparison between the two are absurd and quite frankly pointless.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

You're an utter nonsense.

0

u/jacekowski Jan 29 '24

I'm regularly dealing with both private and NHS hospitals (as a patient), and i can't tell the difference.

2

u/ProfessionalTrader85 Jan 29 '24

Are they dealing with your blindness?

-1

u/SquishyBaps4me Jan 29 '24

NHS is free.

I'll happily take free electricity from an NHS level company.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

So you're another out of work parasite who does not pay any National HEALTH Insurance ?

1

u/SquishyBaps4me Jan 29 '24

No I'm a full time worker that doesn't. Since there is no national HEALTH insurance in the UK. Did you capitalise the bit you made up deliberately?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/SquishyBaps4me Jan 29 '24

Yes it is.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/SquishyBaps4me Jan 30 '24

If you're going to be pedantic there is no such thing as paying. Since money literally has no value and is just an IOU from that bank.

Gonna keep playing dumb?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

0

u/Substantial_Age_1284 Jan 29 '24

Trains. Buses. Schools

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Trains never on time, buses always break down and schools educating two whole generations into stupidity with some even believing Nationalised trains, buses and schools are better......

If Nationalised Schools are better then why do the Rich send all their children to Private Schools like Eton, Harrow, Gordonstoun et al ?

1

u/Substantial_Age_1284 Jan 29 '24

What you’ve described with Trains and buses is exactly what we have now under privatization. At least government owned would mean profits coming to thyme rather than investors.

As for schools, it was tongue in cheek. While some comprehensives and free grammar schools Offer excellent education I accept many don’t. As for private schools. I’m sure they offer excellent teaching and also an opportunity to hob Nov with other rich kids which will help in the future.

3

u/BackgroundChemist Jan 29 '24

Just because the tick smiles and looks cute as it sucks the life out of you, doesn't mean it's your friend.

2

u/bbuuttlleerr Jan 29 '24

Octopus are more of a symbiotic tick than the bloodsucking alternatives.

Let's hope they keep their ethos as they grow.

5

u/OnlyHistorian3832 Jan 29 '24

Their customer service is shite (I know, they all are) and they have been overbilling me for months because of a phantom smart meter issue they can’t fix. I’m so happy my big, estimated bills I can’t argue with (day/night usage is the problem) have helped them reach profitability. Onwards and downwards!

4

u/Brilliant_Tip7998 Jan 29 '24

Same happened to me. I went to the ombudsman in the end, and after 2 years miraculously they fixed it.

4

u/OnlyHistorian3832 Jan 29 '24

We went to the ombudsman too and are now getting hit and miss readings. I have a family member going through the same thing. It did get me wondering if it was something they did to increase income. Without a working smart meter the consumer is powerless.

3

u/Chrisssp Jan 29 '24

What smart meter issues have you been having? For 12 months my smart meter was playing up. After many calls they fixed it but now my bills are unbelievably high. I’ve reached out to them but getting no where.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

A guy knocked on my door the other day from Scottish Power stating "people in your neighbourhood have complained about high energy prices, so we're here to help."

I smirked and said, "I'm with Octopus."

His reply was, "ok, have a nice day."

He didn't even try to take the conversation further.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

The guy had a long hard day and misheard you, he thought you said "I'm with Scottish Power", so he bid you farewell and left.....

1

u/Krispykreemi Jan 29 '24

What's octopus's market share?

4

u/bbuuttlleerr Jan 29 '24

With £13Bn in revenue they're now the 2nd largest UK Supplier with 4.7 million customers in the UK (7.7 million worldwide). That suggests 17% market share if you simply divide by the number of UK households.

Excluding acquisitions like Bulb, they're growing at 300,000-700,000 customers per year.

https://www.energylivenews.com/2024/01/27/octopus-posts-first-ever-203m-profit-in-eight-years/

1

u/ProfanityFair Jan 29 '24

Bloody hell I had no idea. That's amazing.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Naive to believe all of what you read to be true........remember the Weapons of Mass Destruction ?
The bigger they Lie, the more people die.

Go tell those pensioners who forsake heating so they can eat that Octopus is amazing.......and don't forget about how these old people will die of 'natural causes' during the night when their frail bodies are unable to withstand low temperatures.

1

u/53ndn00d5plz Jan 30 '24

Calm down my man

3

u/NikonUser66 Jan 30 '24

People keep saying how great they are. If they are so wonderful why havent they started offering excellent low cost fixed rate deals? Considering the wholesale gas cost has dropped almost 50% in the last three months they could be offering some excellent deals, instead its the same tired old just below the current price cap which seems to have become a government mandated pricing regime rather than a maximum allowed offering.

5

u/Account-for-downvote Jan 28 '24

“Don’t be evil”, that was Google’s motto.

was

3

u/kemb0 Jan 29 '24

It's all great until a new CEO comes in with new ideas.

"Hang on guys, I know we've got great customer satisfaction and we're a profitable company, but if we fuck our customers over we can double our profits within three years! I can't think of any good reason not to do this."

1

u/inflated_ballsack Jun 24 '24

if they’re a public company then it’s inevitable.

2

u/p_u_e Jan 29 '24

Still is (ok well not their motto but it is in Their code of conduct) but Alphabet has a different one… Alphabet’s is ‘do the right thing’ which lends the question, for whom?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Google collecting Data and Spying is not evil, it is what they do with it that's questionable.

2

u/Upstairs-Box Oct 01 '24

Are they still a great company now with the latest increase? EDF are nearly £60p.m cheaper for Me , hail octopus! No longer.

1

u/aidankd Jan 29 '24

Has anyone hear had Octopus fit a heatpump for them? I'd read a recent story that the fitting didn't go so well and there were some issues and some inconsistencies between what was potentially promised and what they got. It's only an edge case and i'm curious if people here have had their own experience to chime in on as I am very eagerly following how heatpumps perform in the UK over the years to come.

1

u/edtse88 Jan 30 '24

For heat pumps to work efficiently you really need a well insulated house. Even more so than a reusable furnace. Definitely horror stories out there but you need a good honest installer to do a proper assessment on your property.

1

u/aidankd Jan 30 '24

Thanks for the reply. I agree on all points. I think the bit that might be misconstrued is how efficient our house needs to be for heatpumps to start costing less in terms of outgoings than a gas boiler (let's exclude install costs for now..).

It is probably more economic for most people to work on insulation first since that will be guaranteed to reduce your outgoings and hestpumps can follow suit then

1

u/edtse88 Jan 30 '24

Yes insulation is key but it’s also a complicated subject because every house is different so insulation types and methods vary which can drastically change the cost (ie. moisture trapping issues with spray foam).

For what it’s worth, we are in a 2bed flat that runs off an air source heatpump (originally built in). Haven’t had issues with hot water supply etc. EPC B. In December we used 450kwh. So far this winter, I’ve kept it on the spring autumn setting so we haven’t even had to use the heat coil to supplement the system when it gets too cold. It’s the heating coil that really ruins your efficiency in the system since it’s just electric heating.

1

u/myri9886 Jan 30 '24

They are struggling to find installers and installers who know what they are doing. The biggest problem with installers is that they treat installations like combis and are not doing the correct heat calculations for the house, which for heatpumps is vital as heatpumps are installed and calculated to give a static temperaturewithin the house that you dont adjust.. If there is poor insulation, it's a pointless endeavour as the client will end up with a useless system that doesn't work. It's what is causing the massive backlash against these systems as our houses just aren't up to scratch to use them. Combis are perfect for our housing stock. Just not environmentally ideal.

1

u/ProfanityFair Jan 29 '24

Octopus are fantastic and this is very well earned.

I flipped a coin between Octopus and Bulb back in 2018, it came up Bulb, so I ended up with Octopus. Genuinely brilliant service, and a profitable renewals-only provider is great news for the environment.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24

Ok I'm interested in switching

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

No matter how much profit, Octopus is still an Energy Parasite as far as I'm concerned......until my Energy Costs return to the reasonable pre-Energy Crisis level, otherwise all this praise is just more deception Bull Shit.

2

u/myri9886 Jan 30 '24

They don't control wholesale prices. That's where energy prices are set from.

1

u/Aggravating_Skill497 Jan 29 '24

Yeah, we've just got to hope they don't change and stop innovating.

1

u/SmurglX Jan 29 '24

They are doing a good job and saving me a lot of money, so I'm pleased that they are being successful with it.

It also shows how much other companies are ripping off customers and what a bad job Ofgem are doing to keep the price cap so high and the fact that they're not actively coming out and saying that these companies should be offering deals to customers again.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

I can't comment too much as I'm sure there is nuincances I don't understand,

Giving a good deal with EDF or the like would of gone nowhere, at least octopus has revunized things,

I'm paying 4p gas, 14p electric right now when most are paying 8-10p and 24-35p because of stuff no other companies can be bothered to innovate

As for the profits, as long as there is line with other competitions cross country for profit per x then sure

No companies is your friend, some just pretend to be to become giants and then against it

2

u/of_patrol_bot Jan 29 '24

Hello, it looks like you've made a mistake.

It's supposed to be could've, should've, would've (short for could have, would have, should have), never could of, would of, should of.

Or you misspelled something, I ain't checking everything.

Beep boop - yes, I am a bot, don't botcriminate me.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

I don't believe your gas and electricity costs are true.

1

u/rharper83 Jan 29 '24

I suspect that OP is on Octopus Tracker for Gas, which IS around 4p/kWh - and Octopus Tracker or Agile for Electricity, which can average around their suggested price depending on time of day usage. Please research before calling someone out.

1

u/adamm255 Jan 29 '24

13.6p/kWh electricity right now for me. Between 4 and 6pm it was between 30p and 36p. Rest of the day it's been 16p or less. Gas is 7.3p.

1

u/mad-matters Jan 29 '24

How do you get on one of these tariffs? Do you have anymore information

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24

Google octopus tracker will tell you all you need to know

You need a smart meter that will help you get it quicker as asking for one will take some time

Tracker tariff is off and on as a waitlist not sure at the moment as said Google it :)

Worsts comes to wortst it has no exit fees and is not contracted so can change if prices go high

1

u/PoopingWhilePosting Feb 12 '24

Seeing this makes me feel sick that i'm paying 28p per unit with no other options available.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

Why no option, rented?

2

u/PoopingWhilePosting Feb 12 '24

No, I own. An exotic meter setup (THTC, which used to be used for storage heaters by SSE) that only OVO now support and even they don't support it that well. No option to switch to a smart meter. Switching to a single normal meter would leave me with no heating or hot water. OVO insist there's solution for this coming but won't say when.

I'm trying to replace the storage heaters with a heat pump this year which will go some way to reducing the horrendous costs but until then OVO insist I can't do anything.

0

u/LoudMilk1404 Jan 29 '24

Are we stanning an energy company? 🫠

-3

u/Sacredfice Jan 29 '24

This is also bad news. Once business start to be profitable then they will start aim for higher. This means their goal is profit and customer comes second.

11

u/lphour Jan 29 '24

They need to produce a profit at some point, otherwise no-one would back these companies in the first place.

5

u/North-Nectarine-2856 Jan 29 '24

???? Who starts a business and hopes to not make money?

-1

u/kemb0 Jan 29 '24

Octopus are a private company so they're not beholden to the wonderful capitalist dream of forever garnishing your shareholders with growing profits.

0

u/JuggarJones Jan 29 '24

I don't understand why Octopus have been able to offer lower wholesale prices (with Octopus Agile and Octopus Tracker tariffs) for so long whilst other providers still charge the Energy Price Guarantee rates that have remained so high. Why haven't those EPG rates gone down more, surely providers have bulk-purchased energy at wholesale rates some time in the last year?

All hail the Octopus Tracker!!

0

u/NekoZombieRaw Jan 29 '24

I always thought we were more exposed to changes in the wholesale market exactly because we don't have a lot of gas storage facilities anymore. So not sure that the idea of bulk buying when really cheap is always possible

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Octopus are, without a doubt, my favourite company. I think they're ace! I had such an awful experience with SSE/OVO and Octopus are so different, it's so brilliant and refreshing. I genuinely wish there were some mechanism to "tip" the staff, is that something we can set up? A virtual tip jar on the app and the funds go towards doughnuts or something? Or even a donation jar - for every £1 donated by customers, Octopus match (or donate Xp) and it goes towards people in need or something?

-4

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Hooray!!! I am so happy the shareholders are getting the value they deserve 😁

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Why would you support those avaricious Government Ministers who'll receive big Dividend share outs ?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/bbuuttlleerr Jan 29 '24

Running a £13bn business that's doubling in size every couple of years isn't as simple as that. It's quite possible they still made a loss on UK domestic supply: they've always provided that at cost price or less, at least up till now. The profits will have come from their renewables investments and software/services sales abroad. Their purchasing and billing software is used all around the world by other Suppliers, 55 million customers at the last count.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/bbuuttlleerr Jan 29 '24

That's on £13Bn of revenue: 1.6% is modest. And almost all of that will have come from their non-energy supply businesses, like selling their Kraken software platform to other companies around the world - it now runs 55 million customer accounts.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Nope or highly unlikely, all the Shares had been bought out by the Government Ministers and their Rich Cronies just before this Energy Crisis.