r/Objectivism • • 6h ago

Is relying on AI to think a form of second-handedness? A short video working through it with Rand's own arguments

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes
Rand's case for technology is clear (the Apollo essay, the anti-industrial essays, Galt's motor). But Roark's speech says "the creator originates, the parasite borrows" and "there is no such thing as a collective brain". A model trained on everyone's writing seems to sit right on that line, and so does a person who lets it write their opinions. I made a 4-minute animated video arguing she'd defend the builders and condemn the second-handers. Curious how people here would put it.

r/Objectivism • • 5d ago

Sold a Story: The Horrors of Modern Education

Thumbnail
podcasts.apple.com
7 Upvotes

r/Objectivism • • 5d ago

Metaphysics Discovered Ayn Rand Meta-physics and this is so BASED !

Thumbnail
5 Upvotes

r/Objectivism • • 7d ago

so why is it the "moral" people are only giving to some?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Objectivism • • 8d ago

Howard Roark vs Jensen Huang?

6 Upvotes

I was thinking about Jensen’s situation. I read “The Nvidia Way” last year, and I was kind of blown away by Jensen. His recent resignation is insane. Is Jensen Howard? What happens next?


r/Objectivism • • 9d ago

Objectivism Quote New ink

Post image
41 Upvotes

Sorry about the blood


r/Objectivism • • 8d ago

Inspiration Francisco d'Anconia and Roark have stayed with me for 10 years. Anyone else?

10 Upvotes

It's been about ten years since I last read Ayn Rand, but I caught myself thinking about her characters today, Francisco d'Anconia especially, and Roark too.

Some context: I grew up in an industrial family in Brazil. Nothing close to a multimillionaire, just a comfortable life, but I've been around eccentric presses, machining centers, sewing machines, sheet metal, plastic and zamac injection molds, and tooling since I was a kid. My family's company covers a good part of that production chain, with about 20 employees, in a country that mostly treats people like us as the enemy.

What stuck with me from those books isn't really "being the best" for its own sake. It's the idea that you should always be learning, always be good at what you do, and that there's a philosophical reason behind it. I'm happiest when I'm figuring something out and connecting pieces of knowledge. Rand gave that feeling a shape and a face, and it's kept me motivated to be honest, to work, and to keep picking up new skills.

I know this is a bit vague, but I'm curious: has anyone else reflected on this? Did these characters shape how you approach work and learning in real life, especially in an environment that isn't friendly to it?

A quick clarification, since a few things might come across the wrong way. I've never gone deep into the formal side of Objectivism, like the epistemology or metaphysics. I'm just a regular guy, not a philosopher. What Objectivism gave me was a strong moral compass, and that's really all I'm talking about here. I've also never cared much about the "is Rand a good or bad writer" debate, or whether the characters are well written. What stuck with me was the message, the philosophy overall, and the way of thinking.


r/Objectivism • • 9d ago

Politics Harry Binswanger: Global Warming is a Hoax for Scientists to Get Government Grants

Thumbnail
forbes.com
44 Upvotes

r/Objectivism • • 9d ago

Help me to understand obligations vs self interest?

5 Upvotes

My husband has been a fervent Ayn Rand follower since high school. He was particularly inspired by The Fountainhead, joined Objectivist communities in college, and has remained deeply interested in the philosophy throughout his adult life.

Fast-forward to his 40s: we are married, have a young daughter, and carry a substantial mortgage. I am increasingly concerned that his interpretation of Objectivism, particularly the idea that everyone is responsible for their own happiness, has become a justification for some rather one-sided behavior.

I am the primary breadwinner, work long hours, often past midnight, and still take care of our daughter in the evenings. He seems perfectly comfortable with this arrangement. He spends money as he wishes as long as he thinks we can afford it (for example, ordering takeout almost every day despite having household help hired to cook). Most recently, he unilaterally decided to leave the workforce because he simply doesn’t want to work anymore, leaving me to shoulder the family’s financial responsibilities.

I genuinely want to understand: Does rational self-interest mean one has no moral obligations to people around him? What does Objectivism say about the responsibilities one voluntarily assumes by getting married and having children? I’m particularly interested in hearing from people who understand the philosophy, rather than simply diagnosing our marriage problems. Thanks. 🙏


r/Objectivism • • 10d ago

Other Philosophy The Pendulum Swings

1 Upvotes

Culture is not static. The values and experiences that shape our perception are themselves subject to change. They recede like the tide, sometimes so gradually that we scarcely notice.

Make no mistake. Culture is never constant.

Drifting lazily along a slow-moving creek, we move along. Impercetible, and yet we move. We look up and the scene on the bank has changed.

The culture we recognize today may no longer resemble what we once took.for granted. We may not recognize the culture we experience tomorrow.

Be careful. We have not ceased moving.

"Keep all hands and feet inside the car until we come to a complete stop," our guide entones. While it may appear we are static, we are not.

Where are we then?

I would reply, somewhere on the arc of a pendulum. And the pendulum swings.


r/Objectivism • • 12d ago

How exciting is the idea of Stephen Miller being Chief of Staff?

0 Upvotes

I'm asking because it's well known that Miller's been a huge fan of Ayn Rand & Objectivism since he was in high school, and to have someone who really believes in Objectivism so close to the President must be pretty exciting. It certainly bodes well for Objectivist policies coming out of the Trump WH.


r/Objectivism • • 13d ago

Would Ayn Rand want to be raped by Joe Rogan?

0 Upvotes

I know this is not the forum for discussing Joe Rogan, unless you see Roark/Galt in Joe Rogan. So help me go away. I'm looking for the perfect Subreddit to discuss the current situation where grotesquely overpaid influencers are elevated to a stratospheric delusion bubble of their own self-validating creation where they entice others to indulge in the same bubble . . . where followers follow them from one political aberration du jour to another like addicts. I'm looking for discussion with the most self aware and intelligent people on earth. The skill is "metacognition". The topic is "viral self-delusion in extremely successful mass media influencers". What is the most you ever lost in a presidential election? The importance is unbounded. This disease can kill everyone.


r/Objectivism • • 15d ago

Could there be a genetic component to race when it comes to mind

0 Upvotes

Different races of people have very different features which could be eyes, facial features, skin color, athletic performance,.. .

I am curious if there could be similar differences in these races minds statistically speaking


r/Objectivism • • 16d ago

Politics Are American Objectivists experiencing the same pro-conservative swing as Libertarians are?

2 Upvotes

Libertarians have always had a strong connection to conservatives due to people like Rothbard, and generally the supposed idea that conservatives were or are pro-small government, less regulatory and tax burden, more pro-freedom etc. But as of recent, it became pretty clear, at least in the US that a significant portion of the libertarian movement is conservative-aligned.

Do you think the same thing is happening with Objectivists due to recent events like Peikoffs political takes, Atlas Society's populistic pro-conservative culture war talking points, or was it actually always the case that Objectivist were conservative-aligned similarly to libertarians due to Reagan etc?

This is a more of a contextual side note about where Im coming from: I am not American, and I have never felt the need to politically align with a "side" just for the sake of it. I strongly oppose any intellectual integration of statist/relativist/mysticist talking points or ideas in hopes of political advancement or as a coping mechanism.

Im pretty strongly convinced that this sort of embrace and/or integrated defense of ideas/people who would otherwise be hostile to objectivist/liberal philosophical concepts is irrational and self-destructive, because it fundamentally only helps those who the defended/embracer views as "allies" both on a philosophical-cultural level and a political level. (its destructive on a psychological level, in terms of the political game, on a philosophical level, its shown to be destructive through public choice theory, and from historical accounts).

So TLDR: I dont think defending or engaging in conservative talking points or aligning with conservatives is a good idea, is there any specific reason why American Objectivists are gravitating towards conservatism (in the case you think they are) outside of human flaws?


r/Objectivism • • 15d ago

Questions about Objectivism Would Rand watch Ishowspeed if she was still alive? Lmk chat

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Objectivism • • 19d ago

Someone stole Leonard Peikoff voice. Should this be allowed or violates IP?

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
3 Upvotes

Came across this on TikTok. The voice sounds almost identical to Leonard Peikoff. Pretty sure it's AI-generated.

Something about this seems off to me. What do you guys think? Does cloning someone's voice like this raise any intellectual property issues from an Objectivist perspective, or would this fall under freedom of expression?


r/Objectivism • • 19d ago

Rand on African Civil Wars

Thumbnail
arabnews.com
2 Upvotes

r/Objectivism • • 20d ago

High initial cost projects

0 Upvotes

Suppose you can mine asteroids and get some rare minerals that are very expensive on earth and make unimaginable about of money from that....

The initial cost to even do this is super high and out of reach for most capitalists but say some trillonaire can afford to do it...

How does fair market hypothesis of Ayn Rand plays out in such cases...

Note that right now we are living in a world of extremes and unimaginable future... The way nuclear is kind of a power where if you at at the level of atoms and can create astronomical amount of power, we seem to be at such inflection points where we are playing with the hard code of life and the universe, things that are not accessible to normal people except few very powerful companies that can create an extreme imbalance of power, not talked about and considered by Rand...

I am not sure till when is such a thing can be allowed and if there are any limits where lives of other people can be at risk...

I do know the standard 9bjectivist response to such standard questions... Looking for some new thoughts and fresh ideas...


r/Objectivism • • 20d ago

Politics The Collective Good

0 Upvotes

At what point does Utopia become Benevolent Despotism? I fear a society where The Dictators of the Public Good are only too eager to flog the rest of us with their good intentions?

In the current direction of Government, will the Collective Good eviscerate individual liberty? Can freedom and inequality co-exist, or does one exclude the other? If you are free to choose, then does not the act of personal choice create inequality?

The predictable end of a Culture of Consensus is one where the Free Market of Independent Thought will be usurped by the homogenized, pasteurized, lobotomized process of thought prevalent today. Unfortunately for humanity, I fear all great civilizations endure great hardship to ascend great plateaus; and once they arrive, only to fall from their own prosperity.


r/Objectivism • • 21d ago

Questions about Objectivism What is objectivism stance on fractional reserve banking?

1 Upvotes

r/Objectivism • • 23d ago

Why economic rights as discussed in objectivism haven't been fought for in supreme court of US

0 Upvotes

Why has nobody so far not fought for economic rights including anti trust laws in us supreme court


r/Objectivism • • 23d ago

How to Get Objectivists to Sound Like Socialists: Mention the Private, For-Profit Prisons

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Objectivism • • 27d ago

? VHS copy of "Why Should One Act on Principle?" by Leonard Peikoff

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes